skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: The Global Flow of Hard Disk Drives: Quantifying the Concept of Value Leakage in E‐waste Recovery Systems
Summary The remaining value within end‐of‐use/life hard disk drives (EoU/L HDDs) is often not optimally recovered. The improper collection and recovery of HDDs contribute not only to rising environmental and social concerns worldwide, but also to the transformation of the economy and a significant loss of value. Currently, the most preferred treatment option for used hard drives is to recover the metals with the highest recycling effectiveness, such as steel and aluminum, via a shredding‐based recycling process that results in both value and material leakages. The complexity of retrieving the remaining values within EoU/L HDDs demands a larger view of the global supply of HDDs available for recovery. The aim of this paper is to first identify the geographical patterns of transboundary global shipments of new and used HDDs between developing and developed regions, and then capture and quantify the value leakage by bringing several unique perspectives. Two analyses have been conducted. First, the loss of value due to the insufficient recovery of neodymium (Nd) at the global level is quantified. Second, the value leakage as a result of the delay on on‐time reuse of HDDs is captured. Furthermore, the central challenges toward proper recovery of HDDs, where consumer electronic industry can make significant contributions, have been identified. HDDs are well positioned to contribute important insights to the recovery of other electronic devices, so the findings from HDDs can be adopted for other types of electronics.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1705621 1435908
PAR ID:
10056665
Author(s) / Creator(s):
 ;  ;  ;  
Publisher / Repository:
Springer Science + Business Media
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Journal of Industrial Ecology
Volume:
23
Issue:
3
ISSN:
1088-1980
Format(s):
Medium: X Size: p. 560-573
Size(s):
p. 560-573
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. The value of electronic waste at present is estimated to increase rapidly year after year, and with rapid advances in electronics, shows no signs of slowing down. Storage devices such as SATA Hard Disks and Solid State Devices are electronic devices with high value recyclable raw materials which often goes unrecovered. Most of the e-waste currently generated, including HDDs, is either managed by the informal recycling sector, or is improperly landfilled with the municipal solid waste, primarily due to insufficient recovery infrastructure and labor shortage in the recycling industry. This emphasizes the importance of developing modern advanced recycling technologies such as robotic disassembly. Performing smooth robotic disassembly operations of precision electronics necessitates fast and accurate geometric 3D profiling to provide a quick and precise location of key components. Fringe Projection Profilometry (FPP), as a variation of the well-known structured light technology, provides both the high speed and high accuracy needed to accomplish this. However, Using FPP for disassembly of high-precision electronics such as hard disks can be especially challenging, given that the hard disk platter is almost completely reflective. Furthermore, the metallic nature of its various components make it difficult to render an accurate 3D reconstruction. To address this challenge, We have developed a single-shot approach to predict the 3D point cloud of these devices using a combination of computer graphics, fringe projection, and deep learning. We calibrate a physical FPP-based 3D shape measurement system and set up its digital twin using computer graphics. We capture HDD and SSD CAD models at various orientations to generate virtual training datasets consisting of fringe images and their point cloud reconstructions. This is used to train the U-NET which is then found efficient to predict the depth of the parts to a high accuracy with only a single shot fringe image. This proposed technology has the potential to serve as a valuable fast 3D vision tool for robotic re-manufacturing and is a stepping stone for building a completely automated assembly system. 
    more » « less
  2. Efficient disassembly operation is considered a promising approach toward waste reduction and End-of-Use (EOU) product recovery. However, many kinds of uncertainty exist during the product lifecycle which make disassembly decision a complicated process. The optimum disassembly sequence may vary at different milestones depending on the purpose of disassembly (repair, maintenance, reuse and recovery), product quality conditions and external factors such as consumer preference, and the market value of EOU components. A disassembly sequence which is optimum for one purpose may not be optimum in future life cycles or other purposes. Therefore, there is a need for incorporating the requirements of the entire product life-cycle when obtaining the optimum disassembly sequence. This paper applies a fuzzy method to quantify the probability that each feasible disassembly transition will be needed during the entire product lifecycle. Further, the probability values have been used in an optimization model to find the disassembly sequence with maximum likelihood. An example of vacuum cleaner is used to show how the proposed method can be applied to quantify different users’ evaluation on the relative importance of disassembly selection criteria as well as the probability of each disassembly operation. 
    more » « less
  3. Data center downtime typically centers around IT equipment failure. Storage devices are the most frequently failing components in data centers. We present a comparative study of hard disk drives (HDDs) and solid state drives (SSDs) that constitute the typical storage in data centers. Using six-year field data of 100,000 HDDs of different models from the same manufacturer from the Backblaze dataset and six-year field data of 30,000 SSDs of three models from a Google data center, we characterize the workload conditions that lead to failures. We illustrate that their root failure causes differ from common expectations and that they remain difficult to discern. For the case of HDDs we observe that young and old drives do not present many differences in their failures. Instead, failures may be distinguished by discriminating drives based on the time spent for head positioning. For SSDs, we observe high levels of infant mortality and characterize the differences between infant and non-infant failures. We develop several machine learning failure prediction models that are shown to be surprisingly accurate, achieving high recall and low false positive rates. These models are used beyond simple prediction as they aid us to untangle the complex interaction of workload characteristics that lead to failures and identify failure root causes from monitored symptoms. 
    more » « less
  4. Worldwide wind energy generation capacity has grown rapidly over the past several decades, and wind turbines installed at the beginning of this wave of growth are approaching the end of their design lifetimes. As an increasing number of wind power plants reach their end of life, both decommissioning and repowering (i.e., dismantling or refurbishing existing turbines and commissioning new ones) will produce waste material from the retired wind turbines, foundations, and balance of plant. However, the amount and type of waste, particularly for wind blades, is often mischaracterized. Although wind turbine components are largely recyclable, the blades are typically made of fiberglass composites, which can present challenges for material recovery and reuse. Within the USA, the accumulation of wind turbine blades in landfills has raised questions about whether the continued expansion of wind energy is sustainable if it results in substantial future waste. This study compares the mass and volume of potential global wind blade waste to other waste streams. It also discusses the materials used to manufacture wind turbine blades and summarizes current options for material redesign, recycling (recovery and reuse), repurposing, and disposal of used blades. The analysis indicates that, although wind turbine blades could represent 14% of the composite market by 2027, the potential future mass and volume of wind turbine blade waste is relatively small compared to other industries. These findings suggest that although the development of scalable, economically viable, and environmentally sustainable methods for wind turbine manufacturing, repurposing, and recycling is important, it may make sense to take advantage of synergies among multiple industries in recycling composite waste, rather than focusing solely on wind turbine blades. From a global perspective, larger sustainability, recycling, and waste stream reduction impacts can be made in other industries, such as transportation and construction. 
    more » « less
  5. As electronic waste (e-waste) becomes one of the fastest growing environmental concerns, remanufacturing is considered as a promising solution. However, the profitability of take back systems is hampered by several factors including the lack of information on the quantity and timing of to-be-returned used products to a remanufacturing facility. Product design features, consumers’ awareness of recycling opportunities, socio-demographic information, peer pressure, and the tendency of customer to keep used items in storage are among contributing factors in increasing uncertainties in the waste stream. Predicting customer choice decisions on returning back used products, including both the time in which the customer will stop using the product and the end-of-use decisions (e.g. storage, resell, through away, and return to the waste stream) could help manufacturers have a better estimation of the return trend. The objective of this paper is to develop an Agent Based Simulation (ABS) model integrated with Discrete Choice Analysis (DCA) technique to predict consumer decisions on the End-of-Use (EOU) products. The proposed simulation tool aims at investigating the impact of design features, interaction among individual consumers and socio-demographic characteristics of end users on the number of returns. A numerical example of cellphone take-back system has been provided to show the application of the model. 
    more » « less