Thousands of species worldwide are threatened with extinction due to human activities. For some animals, such as elephants, totoaba, and bluefin tuna, population declines are largely driven by hunting. High prices and large profits create a strong incentive for illegal hunting, even in the face of penalties and strict international restrictions against trade. One innovative solution to help reverse the declines of such species is to farm them to increase supply, thereby reducing prices and decreasing hunting incentives. However, this idea has been criticized as impractical, though some examples exist of successful implementation. Here, we evaluate the hurdles facing endangered species farming as a market‐based mechanism to reduce illegal harvest of wild populations and provide guidance on when it is most likely to be effective. Using a simple model, we show how farming costs and enforcement of anti‐poaching measures are key drivers of success for this solution. We also argue that many of the most promising candidates are aquatic species that have been largely overlooked. Thus, while conservation farming may not be a solution for all endangered species, it should be more seriously considered for species that could be produced quickly and cost‐effectively.
- NSF-PAR ID:
- 10058934
- Publisher / Repository:
- Wiley-Blackwell
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Conservation Biology
- Volume:
- 32
- Issue:
- 5
- ISSN:
- 0888-8892
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 1128 to 1138
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
more » « less
Abstract -
Petrochelidon pyrrhonota (Cliff Swallow) is experiencing significant population declines in parts of its breeding range, particularly in northeastern North America. At 12 active Cliff Swallow colonies in western Massachusetts in 2019–2020, we examined the extent to which installation of artificial nests, providing of mud sources, and control of Passer domesticus (House Sparrow) affected colony size and reproductive success of Cliff Swallows. While there was a trend for colony size to increase at sites with artificial nests, there was not a significant size increase at these sites from 2019–2020. Cliff Swallow nesting success was significantly lower at colony sites where House Sparrows were present, compared to those at which they were absent. The number of nesting Cliff Swallows at 2 sites where mud sources were enhanced increased from 2019 to 2020. Efforts to control House Sparrows by shooting at 1 site were unsuccessful. Our study suggests that without effective control of House Sparrows, Cliff Swallows are likely to keep declining in Massachusetts, regardless of other management techniques used.more » « less
-
more » « less
Abstract Parks are essential for protecting biodiversity and finding ways to improve park effectiveness is an important topic. We contributed to this debate by examining spatial and temporal changes in illegal activities in Kibale National Park, Uganda between 2006 and 2016 and used existing data to evaluate how the changes were correlated with the living conditions of people in neighboring communities, as well as patrolling effort. We explore the effectiveness of conservation strategies implemented in Kibale, by quantifying changes in the abundance of nine animal species over two to five decades. While uncertainty in such animal survey data are inherently large and it is hard to generalize across a 795‐km2area that encompasses diverse habitat types, data suggest an increase in animal abundance in the National Park. An increase in patrolling effort by park guards over the decade was correlated with a decline in the number of traps and snares found, which suggests patrolling helped limit resource extraction from the park. The park’s edge was extensively used for illegal forest product extraction, while the setting of snares occurred more often deeper in the forest. Perhaps counter‐intuitively, increased community wealth or park‐related employment in a village next to the park were positively correlated with increased illegal forest product extraction. Overall, our results suggest that the portfolio of conservation strategies used over the last two to five decades were effective for protecting the park and its animals, although understanding the impact of these efforts on local human populations and how to mitigate any losses and suffering they sustain remains an important area of research and action. It is evident that complex social, political and economic drivers impact conservation success and more interdisciplinary studies are required to quantify and qualify these dimensions.
