An official website of the United States government
Software developers create and share code online to demonstrate programming language concepts and programming tasks. Code snippets can be a useful way to explain and demonstrate a programming concept, but may not always be directly executable. A code snippet can contain parse errors, or fail to execute if the environment contains unmet dependencies. This paper presents an empirical analysis of the executable status of Python code snippets shared through the GitHub gist system, and the ability of developers familiar with software configuration to correctly configure and run them. We find that 75.6% of gists require non-trivial configuration to overcome missing dependencies, configuration files, reliance on a specific operating system, or some other environment configuration. Our study also suggests the natural assumption developers make about resource names when resolving configuration errors is correct less than half the time. We also present Gistable, a database and extensible framework built on GitHub's gist system, which provides executable code snippets to enable reproducible studies in software engineering. Gistable contains 10,259 code snippets, approximately 5,000 with a Dockerfile to configure and execute them without import error. Gistable is publicly available at https://github.com/gistable/gistable.
more »
« less
DockerizeMe: Automatic Inference of Environment Dependencies for Python Code Snippets
Platforms like Stack Overflow and GitHub's gist system promote the sharing of ideas and programming techniques via the distribution of code snippets designed to illustrate particular tasks. Python, a popular and fast-growing programming language, sees heavy use on both sites, with nearly one million questions asked on Stack Overflow and 400 thousand public gists on GitHub. Unfortunately, around 75% of the Python example code shared through these sites cannot be directly executed. When run in a clean environment, over 50% of public Python gists fail due to an import error for a missing library. We present DockerizeMe, a technique for inferring the dependencies needed to execute a Python code snippet without import error. DockerizeMe starts with offline knowledge acquisition of the resources and dependencies for popular Python packages from the Python Package Index (PyPI). It then builds Docker specifications using a graph-based inference procedure. Our inference procedure resolves import errors in 892 out of nearly 3,000 gists from the Gistable dataset for which Gistable's baseline approach could not find and install all dependencies.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1814798
- PAR ID:
- 10084519
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- 41st ACM/IEEE International Conference on Software Engineering (ICSE)
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Modern software development communities are increasingly social. Popular chat platforms such as Slack host public chat communities that focus on specific development topics such as Python or Ruby-on-Rails. Conversations in these public chats often follow a Q&A format, with someone seeking information and others providing answers in chat form. In this paper, we describe an exploratory study into the potential usefulness and challenges of mining developer Q&A conversations for supporting software maintenance and evolution tools. We designed the study to investigate the availability of information that has been successfully mined from other developer communications, particularly Stack Overflow. We also analyze characteristics of chat conversations that might inhibit accurate automated analysis. Our results indicate the prevalence of useful information, including API mentions and code snippets with descriptions, and several hurdles that need to be overcome to automate mining that information.more » « less
-
Modern software development communities are increasingly social. Popular chat platforms such as Slack host public chat communities that focus on specific development topics such as Python or Ruby-on-Rails. Conversations in these public chats often follow a Q&A format, with someone seeking information and others providing answers in chat form. In this paper, we describe an exploratory study into the potential usefulness and challenges of mining developer Q&A conversations for supporting software maintenance and evolution tools. We designed the study to investigate the availability of information that has been successfully mined from other developer communications, particularly Stack Overflow. We also analyze characteristics of chat conversations that might inhibit accurate automated analysis. Our results indicate the prevalence of useful information, including API mentions and code snippets with descriptions, and several hurdles that need to be overcome to automate mining that information.more » « less
-
Identifying, localizing, and resolving bugs in software engineering is challenging and costly. Approaches to resolve software bugs range from Large Language Model (LLM) code analysis and repair, and automated code repair technology that aims to alleviate the technical burden of difficult to solve bugs. We propose RAGFix, which enhances LLM’s capabilities for bug localization and code repair using Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) based on dynamically collected Stack Overflow posts. These posts are searchable via a Question and Answer Knowledge Graph (KGQA). We evaluate our method on the HumanEvalFix benchmark for Python using relevant closed and open-source models. Our approach facilitates error resolution in Python coding problems by creating a searchable, embedded knowledge graph representation of bug and solution information from Stack Overflow, interlinking bugs, and solutions through semi-supervised graph construction methods. We use cosine similarity on embeddings based on LLM-synthesized summaries and algorithmic features describing the coding problem and potential solution to find relevant results that improve LLM in-context performance. Our results indicate that our system enhances small open-source models’ ability to effectively repair code, particularly where these models have less parametric knowledge about relevant coding problems and can leverage nonparametric knowledge to provide accurate, actionable fixes.more » « less
-
Identifying, localizing, and resolving bugs in software engineering is challenging and costly. Approaches to resolve software bugs range from Large Language Model (LLM) code analysis and repair, and automated code repair technology that aims to alleviate the technical burden of difficult to solve bugs. We propose RAGFix, which enhances LLM’s capabilities for bug localization and code repair using Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) based on dynamically collected Stack Overflow posts. These posts are searchable via a Question and Answer Knowledge Graph (KGQA). We evaluate our method on the HumanEvalFix benchmark for Python using relevant closed and open-source models. Our approach facilitates error resolution in Python coding problems by creating a searchable, embedded knowledge graph representation of bug and solution information from Stack Overflow, interlinking bugs, and solutions through semi-supervised graph construction methods. We use cosine similarity on embeddings based on LLM-synthesized summaries and algorithmic features describing the coding problem and potential solution to find relevant results that improve LLM in-context performance. Our results indicate that our system enhances small open-source models’ ability to effectively repair code, particularly where these models have less parametric knowledge about relevant coding problems and can leverage nonparametric knowledge to provide accurate, actionable fixes.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Conference Paper:
- The DOI is not currently available.
