skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: Frost Resilience of Stabilized Earth Building Materials
Earth-based building materials are increasingly valued in green design for their low embodied energy, humidity-buffering ability, and thermal stability. These materials perform well in warm dry climates, but greater understanding of long-term durability is needed for successful adoption in colder and/or wetter climates. The presence of stabilizers dramatically improves resistance to surface erosion from wind and rain, compared to unstabilized adobe and cob counterparts, and the influences of soil composition, fiber type, and diverse binders, on rain and wind surface erosion have been investigated in detail. Frost and freeze-thaw resistance, however, have been less well-studied, despite strong interest in stabilized earth materials in northern North America, Europe, and Asia. In particular, recent studies have relied on a widespread misunderstanding of the mechanism by which frost damage occurs in porous materials that will impede efforts to create valid models for material design and improvement. In addition, the influence of radiative thermal stresses on wall surfaces has been overlooked in favor of focus on ambient air temperatures. Here, we apply contemporary understanding of cracking by segregated ice growth to develop a macroscopic damage index that enables comparison between performance of different materials subject to different weather patterns. An examination of predicted damage patterns for two stabilized earth building materials and two conventional materials in twelve cities over two time periods reveals the dominant factors that govern frost vulnerability. We find that the frost resilience of earth building materials is comparable to that of the conventional materials we examined, and that assessments that neglect expected variations in water content by assuming full saturation are likely to yield misleading results. Over recent years, increased winter temperatures in several cities we examined predict reduced material vulnerability to frost damage, but we also find that accompanying increases in humidity levels have made some cities much more vulnerable.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1804218
PAR ID:
10112193
Author(s) / Creator(s):
;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Geosciences
Volume:
9
Issue:
8
ISSN:
2076-3263
Page Range / eLocation ID:
328
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. The ground thermal regime has a profound impact on geomorphological processes and has been suggested to be particularly important for weathering processes in periglacial environments. Several frost-related damage indices have hitherto been developed to link climate and frost weathering potential in bedrock, although only for individual points or grid cells. Here, we model ground temperature and frost weathering potential in steep rock walls in the Jotunheimen Mountains, southern Norway, along a two-dimensional profile line for the Younger Dryas Stadial-Preboreal transition (c. 11.5 ka), the Holocene Thermal Maximum (c. 7.5 ka), the Little Ice Age (1750), and the 2010s. We use an established heat flow model and frost-cracking index based on the ice segregation theory. A central innovation of our model treatment is the implementation of ensemble simulations using distributions of automatically mapped crack radii in a rock wall, whereas previous frost damage models considered only a single characteristic crack radius. Our results allowed for the identification of sites with enhanced frost weathering. Such sites are typically found between rock walls and retreating glaciers, as well as in areas where snow depth changes abruptly, resulting in large thermal gradients. Hence, frost weathering may be highly active during glacier retreat, enhancing the damage to rock walls during deglaciation by adding to the damage from stress release. The coldest climates of the Younger Dryas Stadial-Preboreal transition and the Little Ice Age were generally most favorable for frost cracking. Such timing compares well with the knowledge about the timing of rockfall accumulations in Norway. 
    more » « less
  2. Severe natural multi-hazard events can cause damage to infrastructure and economic losses of billions of dollars. The challenges of modeling these losses include dependency between hazards, cause and sequence of loss, and lack of available data. This paper presents and explores multi-hazard loss modeling in the context of the combined wind and rain vulnerability of mid/high-rise buildings during hurricane events. A component-based probabilistic vulnerability model provides the framework to test and contrast two different approaches to treat the multi-hazards: In one, the wind and rain hazard models are both decoupled from the vulnerability model. In the other, only the wind hazard is decoupled, while the rain hazard model is embedded into the vulnerability model. The paper presents the mathematical and conceptual development of each approach, example outputs from each for the same scenario, and a discussion of weaknesses and strengths of each approach. 
    more » « less
  3. Over the past decade, significant research efforts have been dedicated to the development of performance-based wind engineering (PBWE). Notwithstanding these efforts, frameworks that integrate the damage assessment of the structural and envelope system are still lacking. In response to this need, the authors have recently proposed a PBWE framework that holistically treats envelope and structural damages through progressive multi-demand fragility models that capture the inherent coupling in the demands and damages. Similar to other PBWE methodologies, this framework is based on describing the hurricane hazard through a nominal straight and stationary wind event with constant rainfall and one-hour duration. This study aims to develop a PBWE framework based on a full description of the hurricane hazard in which the entire evolution of the storm track and time-dependent wind/rain fields is simulated. Hurricane-induced pressures impacting the building envelope are captured through the introduction of a non-stationary/-straight/-Gaussian wind pressure model. Time-dependent wind-driven rain is modeled through a computational fluid dynamics Eulerian multiphase framework with interpolation schemes for the rapid computation of wind-driven rain intensities over the building surface. Through the development of a conditional stochastic simulation algorithm, the envelope performance is efficiently characterized through probabilistic metrics associated with rare events of design interest. The framework is demonstrated through analyzing a 45-story archetype building located in Miami, FL, for which the envelope performance is estimated in terms of a suite of probabilistic damage and loss metrics. A comparative study is carried out in order to provide insights into the differences that can occur due to the use of nominal hurricane models. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract Radiative cooling has been recently intensively explored for thermal management and enhancing energy efficiency. Yet, traditional materials with singular emissivity fall short in dynamic thermal management, highlighting the need for materials that can adjust their thermal radiation in real time. Active modulation methods, requiring external stimuli such as mechanical stretch, electric potential, or humidity change, offer adaptability but can increase energy use and complexity. Passive approaches, using materials' inherent thermal‐responsive properties, face manufacturing and scalability challenges. Here, a scalable yet effective passive approach is introduced for adaptive thermal modulation based on gold (Au) and liquid crystal elastomer (LCE) with a reversible response to environmental temperature changes. This modulator enables a “low thermal resistance” state through actuation‐induced microcracks that expose a high‐emissivity polymer substrate, and a “high thermal resistance” state by closing these microcracks and forming a high thermal resistance air gap between the modulator and the target object. The flexible design and fixed external dimensions of the Au‐LCE thermal modulator make it adaptable to various surface geometries. Furthermore, by adjusting the LCE's chemical composition, the modulator's transition temperature can be tailored, broadening its applications from enhancing building energy efficiency to improving clothing thermal comfort. 
    more » « less
  5. Abstract Urban heat islands (UHIs) may increase the likelihood that frost sensitive plants will escape freezing nighttime temperatures in late spring and early fall. Using data from 151 temperature sensors in the Madison, Wisconsin, region during March 2012–October 2016, we found that during time periods when the National Weather Service (NWS) issued freeze warnings (threshold of 0.0°C) or frost advisories (threshold of 2.22°C) were valid, temperatures in Madison’s most densely populated, built-up areas often did not fall below the respective temperature thresholds. Urban locations had a mean minimum temperature of 0.72° and 1.39°C for spring and fall freeze warnings, respectively, compared to −0.52° and −0.53°C for rural locations. On average, 31% of the region’s land area experienced minimum temperatures above the respective temperature thresholds during freeze warnings and frost advisories, and the likelihood of temperatures falling below critical temperature thresholds increased as the distance away from core urban centers increased. The urban–rural temperature differences were greatest in fall compared to spring, and when sensor temperatures did drop below thresholds, the maximum time spent at or below thresholds was highest for rural locations during fall freeze warnings (6.2 h) compared to urban locations (4.8 h). These findings potentially have widely varying implications for the general public and industry. UHIs create localized, positive perturbations to nighttime temperatures that are difficult to account for in forecasts; therefore, freeze warnings and frost advisories may have varying degrees of verification in medium-sized cities like Madison, Wisconsin, that are surrounded by cropland and natural vegetation. Significance StatementThe purpose of this study was to understand whether the urban heat island effect in Madison, Wisconsin, creates localized temperature patterns where county-scale frost advisories and freeze warnings may not verify. Approximately one-third of Madison’s urban core area and most densely populated region experienced temperatures that were consistently above critical low temperature thresholds. This is important because gardening and crop management decisions are responsive to the perceived risk of cold temperatures in spring and fall that can damage or kill plants. These results suggest that urban warming presents forecast challenges to the issuance of frost advisories and freeze warnings, supporting the need for improved numerical weather prediction at higher spatial resolution to account for complex urban meteorology. 
    more » « less