skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: Modeling Knowledge Acquisition from Multiple Learning Resource Types
Students acquire knowledge as they interact with a variety of learning materials, such as video lectures, problems, and discussions. Modeling student knowledge at each point during their learning period and understanding the contribution of each learning material to student knowledge are essential for detecting students’ knowledge gaps and recommending learning materials to them. Current student knowledge modeling techniques mostly rely on one type of learning material, mainly problems, to model student knowledge growth. These approaches ignore the fact that students also learn from other types of material. In this paper, we propose a student knowledge model that can capture knowledge growth as a result of learning from a diverse set of learning resource types while unveiling the association between the learning materials of different types. Our multi-view knowledge model (MVKM) incorporates a flexible knowledge increase objective on top of a multi-view tensor factorization to capture occasional forgetting while representing student knowledge and learning material concepts in a lower-dimensional latent space. We evaluate our model in different experiments to show that it can accurately predict students’ future performance, differentiate between knowledge gain in different student groups and concepts, and unveil hidden similarities across learning materials of different types.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1755910
PAR ID:
10185069
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Proceedings of The 13th International Conference on Educational Data Mining (EDM 2020)
Page Range / eLocation ID:
313 - 324
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Benjamin, Paaßen; Carrie, Demmans Epp (Ed.)
    Knowledge Tracing (KT) focuses on quantifying student knowledge according to the student's past performance. While KT models focus on modeling student knowledge, they miss the behavioral aspect of learning, such as the types of learning materials that the students choose to learn from. This is mainly because traditional knowledge tracing (KT) models only consider assessed activities, like solving questions. Recently, there has been a growing interest in multi-type KT which considers both assessed and non-assessed activities (like video lectures). Since multi-type KT models include different learning material types, they present a new opportunity to investigate student behavior, as in the choice of the learning material type, along with student knowledge. We argue that student knowledge can affect their behavior, and student interest in learning materials may affect their knowledge. In this paper, we model the relationship between students' knowledge states and their choice of learning activities. To this end, we propose Pareto-TAMKOT which frames the simultaneous learning of student knowledge and behavior as a multi-task learning problem. It employs a transition-aware multi-activity KT method for two objectives: modeling student knowledge and student behavior. Pareto-TAMKOT uses the Pareto Multi-task learning algorithm (Pareto MTL) to solve this multi-objective optimization problem. We evaluate Pareto-TAMKOT on one real-world dataset, demonstrating the benefit of approaching student knowledge and behavior modeling as a multi-task learning problem. 
    more » « less
  2. Accurate modeling of student knowledge is essential for large-scale online learning systems that are increasingly used for student training. Knowledge tracing aims to model student knowledge state given the student's sequence of learning activities. Modern Knowledge tracing (KT) is usually formulated as a supervised sequence learning problem to predict students' future practice performance according to their past observed practice scores by summarizing student knowledge state as a set of evolving hidden variables. Because of this formulation, many current KT solutions are not fit for modeling student learning from non-assessed learning activities with no explicit feedback or score observation (e.g., watching video lectures that are not graded). Additionally, these models cannot explicitly represent the dynamics of knowledge transfer among different learning activities, particularly between the assessed (e.g., quizzes) and non-assessed (e.g., video lectures) learning activities. In this paper, we propose Transition-Aware Multi-activity Knowledge Tracing (TAMKOT), which models knowledge transfer between learning materials, in addition to student knowledge, when students transition between and within assessed and non-assessed learning materials. TAMKOT is formulated as a deep recurrent multi-activity learning model that explicitly learns knowledge transfer by activating and learning a set of knowledge transfer matrices, one for each transition type between student activities. Accordingly, our model allows for representing each material type in a different yet transferrable latent space while maintaining student knowledge in a shared space. We evaluate our model on three real-world publicly available datasets and demonstrate TAMKOT's capability in predicting student performance and modeling knowledge transfer. 
    more » « less
  3. Knowledge tracing (KT), or modeling student knowledge state given their past activity sequence, is one of the essential tasks in online education systems. Research has demonstrated that students benefit from both assessed (e.g., solving problems, which can be graded) and non-assessed learning activities (e.g., watching video lectures, which cannot be graded), and thus, modeling student knowledge from multiple types of activities with knowledge transfer between them is crucial. However, current approaches to multi-activity knowledge tracing cannot capture coarse-grained between-type associations and are primarily evaluated by predicting student performance on upcoming assessed activities (labeled data). Therefore, they are inadequate in incorporating signals from non-assessed activities (unlabeled data). We propose Graph-enhanced Multi-activity Knowledge Tracing (GMKT) that addresses these challenges by jointly learning a fine-grained recurrent memory-augmented student knowledge model and a coarse-grained graph neural network. In GMKT, we formulate multi-activity knowledge tracing as a semi-supervised sequence learning problem and optimize for accurate student performance and activity type at each time step. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed model by experimenting on three real-world datasets. 
    more » « less
  4. One of the essential problems, in educational data mining, is to predict students' performance on future learning materials, such as problems, assignments, and quizzes. Pioneer algorithms for predicting student performance mostly rely on two sources of information: students' past performance, and learning materials' domain knowledge model. The domain knowledge model, traditionally curated by domain experts maps learning materials to concepts, topics, or knowledge components that are presented in them. However, creating a domain model by manually labeling the learning material can be a difficult and time-consuming task. In this paper, we propose a tensor factorization model for student performance prediction that does not rely on a predefined domain model. Our proposed algorithm models student knowledge as a soft membership of latent concepts. It also represents the knowledge acquisition process with an added rank-based constraint in the tensor factorization objective function. Our experiments show that the proposed model outperforms state-of-the-art algorithms in predicting student performance in two real-world datasets, and is robust to hyper-parameters. 
    more » « less
  5. Personalized learning and educational recommender systems are integral parts of modern online education systems. In this context, the problem of recommending the best learning material to students is a perfect example of sequential multi-objective recommendation. Learning material recommenders need to optimize for and balance between multiple goals, such as adapting to student ability, adjusting the learning material difficulty, increasing student knowledge, and serving student interest, at every step of the student learning sequence. However, the obscurity and incompatibility of these objectives pose additional challenges for learning material recommenders. To address these challenges, we propose Proximity-based Educational Recommendation (PEAR), a recommendation framework that suggests a ranked list of problems by approximating and balancing between problem difficulty and student ability. To achieve an accurate approximation of these objectives, PEAR can integrate with any state-of-the-art student and domain knowledge model. As an example of such student and domain knowledge model, we introduce Deep Q-matrix based Knowledge Tracing model (DQKT), and integrate PEAR with it. Rather than static recommendations, this framework dynamically suggests new problems at each step by tracking student knowledge level over time. We use an offline evaluation framework, Robust Evaluation Matrix (REM), to compare PEAR with various baseline recommendation policies under three different student simulators and demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed model. We experiment with different student trajectory lengths and show that while PEAR can perform better than the baseline policies with fewer data, it is also robust with longer sequence lengths. 
    more » « less