skip to main content


Title: Sensitivity analysis of effective transverse shear viscoelastic and diffusional properties of myelinated white matter
Abstract

Motivated by the need to interpret the results from a combined use ofin vivobrain Magnetic Resonance Elastography (MRE) and Diffusion Tensor Imaging (DTI), we developed a computational framework to study the sensitivity of single-frequency MRE and DTI metrics to white matter microstructure and cell-level mechanical and diffusional properties. White matter was modeled as a triphasic unidirectional composite, consisting of parallel cylindrical inclusions (axons) surrounded by sheaths (myelin), and embedded in a matrix (glial cells plus extracellular matrix). Only 2D mechanics and diffusion in the transverse plane (perpendicular to the axon direction) was considered, and homogenized (effective) properties were derived for a periodic domain containing a single axon. The numerical solutions of the MRE problem were performed with ABAQUS and by employing a sophisticated boundary-conforming grid generation scheme. Based on the linear viscoelastic response to harmonic shear excitation and steady-state diffusion in the transverse plane, a systematic sensitivity analysis of MRE metrics (effective transverse shear storage and loss moduli) and DTI metric (effective radial diffusivity) was performed for a wide range of microstructural and intrinsic (phase-based) physical properties. The microstructural properties considered were fiber volume fraction, and the myelin sheath/axon diameter ratio. The MRE and DTI metrics are very sensitive to the fiber volume fraction, and the intrinsic viscoelastic moduli of the glial phase. The MRE metrics are nonlinear functions of the fiber volume fraction, but the effective diffusion coefficient varies linearly with it. Finally, the transverse metrics of both MRE and DTI are insensitive to the axon diameter in steady state. Our results are consistent with the limited anisotropic MRE and co-registered DTI measurements, mainly in thecorpus callosum, available in the literature. We conclude that isotropic MRE and DTI constitutive models are good approximations for myelinated white matter in the transverse plane. The unidirectional composite model presented here is used for the first time to model harmonic shear stress under MRE-relevant frequency on the cell level. This model can be extended to 3D in order to inform the solution of the inverse problem in MRE, establish the biological basis of MRE metrics, and integrate MRE/DTI with other modalities towards increasing the specificity of neuroimaging.

 
more » « less
Award ID(s):
1763005 1437113 1762774
NSF-PAR ID:
10361319
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
IOP Publishing
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Physics in Medicine & Biology
Volume:
66
Issue:
3
ISSN:
0031-9155
Page Range / eLocation ID:
Article No. 035027
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract

    White matter (WM) characterization is challenging due to its anisotropic and inhomogeneous microstructure that necessitates multiscale and multi-modality measurements. Shear elastography is one such modality that requires the accurate interpretation of 3D shear strain measurements, which hinge on developing appropriate constitutive tissue models. Finite element methods enable the development of such models by simulating the shear response of representative elemental volumes (REV). We have developed triphasic (axon, myelin, glia), 2D REVs to simulate the influence of the intrinsic viscoelastic property and volume fraction of each phase. This work constitutes the extension of 2D- to 3D-REVs, focusing on the effect of the intrinsic material properties and their 3D representation on the viscoelastic response of the tissue. By lumping the axon and myelin phases, a flexible 3D REV generation and analysis routine is then developed to allow for shear homogenization in both the axial and transverse directions. The 2D and 3D models agree on stress distribution and total deformation when 2D cross-sectional snapshots are compared. We also conclude that the ratio of transverse to axial transverse modulus is larger than one when axon fibers are stiffer than the glial phase.

     
    more » « less
  2. A new finite element approach is proposed to study the propagation of stress in axons in the central nervous system (CNS) white matter. The axons are embedded in an extra cellular matrix (ECM) and are subjected to tensile loads under purely non-affine kinematic boundary conditions. The axons and the ECM are described by the Ogden hyperelastic material model. The effect of tethering of the axons by oligodendrocytes is investigated using the finite element model. Glial cells are often thought of as the “glue” that hold the axons together. More specifically, oligodendrocytes bond multiple axons to each other and create a myelin sheath that insulates and supports axons in the brainstem. The glial cells create a scaffold that supports the axons and can potentially bind 80 axons to a single oligodendrocyte.

    In this study, the microstructure of the oligodendrocyte connections to axons is modeled using a spring-dashpot approximation. The model allows for the oligodendrocytes to wrap around the outer diameter of the axons at various locations, parameterizing the number of connections, distance between connection points, and the stiffness of the connection hubs. The parameterization followed the distribution of axon-oligodendrocyte connections provided by literature data in which the values were acquired through microtome of CNS white matter. We develop two models: 1) multiple oligodendrocytes arbitrarily tethered to the nearest axons, and 2) a single oligodendrocyte tethered to all the axons at various locations. The results depict stiffening of the axons, which indicates that the oligodendrocytes do aid in the redistribution of stress. We also observe the appearance of bending stresses at inflections points along the tortuous path of the axons when subjected to tensile loading. The bending stresses appear to exhibit a cyclic variation along the length of the undulated axons. This makes the axons more susceptible to damage accumulation and fatigue. Finally, the effect of multiple axon-myelin connections in the central nervous system and the effect of the distribution of these connections in the brain tissue is further investigated at present. 

    more » « less
  3. Material properties of brain white matter (BWM) show high anisotropy due to the complicated internal three-dimensional microstructure and variant interaction between heterogeneous brain-tissue (axon, myelin, and glia). From our previous study, finite element methods were used to merge micro-scale Representative Volume Elements (RVE) with orthotropic frequency domain viscoelasticity to an integral macro-scale BWM. Quantification of the micro-scale RVE with anisotropic frequency domain viscoelasticity is the core challenge in this study.

    The RVE behavior is expressed by a viscoelastic constitutive material model, in which the frequency-related viscoelastic properties are imparted as storage modulus and loss modulus for the composite comprised of axonal fibers and extracellular glia. Using finite elements to build RVEs with anisotropic frequency domain viscoelastic material properties is computationally very consuming and resource-draining. Additionally, it is very challenging to build every single RVE using finite elements since the architecture of each RVE is arbitrary in an infinite data set. The architecture information encoded in the voxelized location is employed as input data and is consequently incorporated into a deep 3D convolution neural network (CNN) model that cross-references the RVEs’ material properties (output data). The output data (RVEs’ material properties) is calculated in parallel using an in-house developed finite element method, which models RVE samples of axon-myelin-glia composites. This novel combination of the CNN-RVE method achieved a dramatic reduction in the computation time compared with directly using finite element methods currently present in the literature. 

    more » « less
  4. In the present work, we analyze the applicability of two-step homogenization applied to 3D woven composites with high crimp reinforcement. The available micromechanical homogenization approaches (Hashin, Chamis, Hashin-Shtrikman bounds etc.) were developed and validated for unidirectional composites. These formulas have also been used by the community to homogenize tows in 2D and 3D woven composites including reinforcement architectures with high crimp ratios. However, a rigorous study of their applicability to high-crimp geometries is yet to be performed. We utilize Finite Element Analysis (FEA) to calculate the overall engineering constants (Young’s moduli and shear moduli) of tows having various crimp (𝐶𝑅) and wavelength-to-fiber diameter (𝜆/𝑑) ratios. For this analysis, periodic sinusoidal unit cells following shapes of individual fibers are used. Fiber volume fraction is set to 70% and is the same in all cases. Transversely isotropic carbon fiber and isotropic epoxy matrix are used. The results are compared with overall responses of tows modeled using homogenized tow properties obtained from micromechanics and FEA as well as explicitly modeled tows containing multiple parallel fibers. The results of our analysis show dependence of the overall elastic properties on both crimp ratio and the normalized wavelength. Separation of fiber/tow scales is achieved at 𝜆/𝑑 = 50. 
    more » « less
  5. null (Ed.)
    Healthy aging involves local variations in viscoelastic shear properties of the brain. We employ high-resolution, multi-excitation MRE and a novel anisotropic inversion scheme (iTI) to extract local shear anisotropic moduli in vivo. The ratio of transverse to axial moduli, a new MRE metric, remains greater than 1 along the splenium, body and genu regions of the corpus callosum for both young and old subjects. This metric peaks in the body region and decreases with age throughout the corpus callosum. 
    more » « less