An official website of the United States government
Empirical performance measurements of computer systems almost always exhibit variability and anomalies. Run-to-run and server-to-server variations are common for CPU, memory, disk, and network performance characteristics. In our previous work, we focused on taming performance variability for memory, disk, and network and established an interactive analysis service at: https://confirm.fyi/ to help users of the CloudLab testbed better plan and conduct their experiments. In this paper, we describe our analysis of CPU variability based on over 1.3M performance measurements from nearly 1,800 servers and present our initial findings. The focus of this work is on capturing hardware variability, which can make repeatable experiments more difficult and can impact conclusions; it it this important for systems researchers to understand. (We note that, though we do not study it in this work, in the cloud, multi-tenancy and resource sharing an exacerbate the problem.) Variability also inevitably impacts performance and operation of middleware and high-level applications, contributing to the straggler problems in many domains, including HPC, Big Data, and Machine Learning, and on many types of cyberinfrastructures. We analyze the data from the CloudLab servers allocated in an exclusive fashion, with no virtualization. While our analysis focuses on the testbed that aims to promote reproducible research, we believe our approach and the findings can be of value to people who manage, analyze, and utilize shared computing resources in supercomputers, clouds, and datacenters.
more »
« less
This content will become publicly available on February 1, 2030
Is Big Data Performance Reproducible in Modern Cloud Networks?
Performance variability has been acknowledged as a problem for over a decade by cloud practitioners and performance engineers. Yet, our survey of top systems conferences reveals that the research community regularly disregards variability when running experiments in the cloud. Focusing on networks, we assess the impact of variability on cloud-based big-data workloads by gathering traces from mainstream commercial clouds and private research clouds. Our data collection consists of millions of datapoints gathered while transferring over 9 petabytes of data. We characterize the network variability present in our data and show that, even though commercial cloud providers implement mechanisms for quality-of-service enforcement, variability still occurs, and is even exacerbated by such mechanisms and service provider policies. We show how big-data workloads suffer from significant slowdowns and lack predictability and replicability, even when state-of-the-art experimentation techniques are used. We provide guidelines for practitioners to reduce the volatility of big data performance, making experiments more repeatable.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1743363
- PAR ID:
- 10197401
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Proceedings of the Seventeenth USENIX Symposium on Networked Systems Design and Implementation (NSDI)
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
The emergence of big data has created new challenges for researchers transmitting big data sets across campus networks to local (HPC) cloud resources, or over wide area networks to public cloud services. Unlike conventional HPC systems where the network is carefully architected (e.g., a high speed local interconnect, or a wide area connection between Data Transfer Nodes), today's big data communication often occurs over shared network infrastructures with many external and uncontrolled factors influencing performance. This paper describes our efforts to understand and characterize the performance of various big data transfer tools such as rclone, cyberduck, and other provider-specific CLI tools when moving data to/from public and private cloud resources. We analyze the various parameter settings available on each of these tools and their impact on performance. Our experimental results give insights into the performance of cloud providers and transfer tools, and provide guidance for parameter settings when using cloud transfer tools. We also explore performance when coming from HPC DTN nodes as well as researcher machines located deep in the campus network, and show that emerging SDN approaches such as the VIP Lanes system can deliver excellent performance even from researchers' machines.more » « less
-
Data-driven causality discovery is a common way to understand causal relationships among different components of a system. We study how to achieve scalable data-driven causal- ity discovery on Amazon Web Services (AWS) and Microsoft Azure cloud and propose a causality discovery as a service (CDaaS) framework. With this framework, users can easily re- run previous causality discovery experiments or run causality discovery with different setups (such as new datasets or causality discovery parameters). Our CDaaS leverages Cloud Container Registry service and Virtual Machine service to achieve scal- able causality discovery with different discovery algorithms. We further did extensive experiments and benchmarking of our CDaaS to understand the effects of seven factors (big data engine parameter setting, virtual machine instance number, type, subtype, size, cloud service, cloud provider) and how to best provision cloud resources for our causality discovery service based on certain goals including execution time, budgetary cost and cost-performance ratio. We report our findings from the benchmarking, which can help obtain optimal configurations based on each application’s characteristics. The findings show proper configurations could lead to both faster execution time and less budgetary cost.more » « less
-
Edge computing has emerged as a popular paradigm for running latency-sensitive applications due to its ability to offer lower network latencies to end-users. In this paper, we argue that despite its lower network latency, the resource-constrained nature of the edge can result in higher end-to-end latency, especially at higher utilizations, when compared to cloud data centers. We study this edge performance inversion problem through an analytic comparison of edge and cloud latencies and analyze conditions under which the edge can yield worse performance than the cloud. To verify our analytic results, we conduct a detailed experimental comparison of the edge and the cloud latencies using a realistic application and real cloud workloads. Both our analytical and experimental results show that even at moderate utilizations, the edge queuing delays can offset the benefits of lower network latencies, and even result in performance inversion where running in the cloud would provide superior latencies. We finally discuss practical implications of our results and provide insights into how application designers and service providers should design edge applications and systems to avoid these pitfalls.more » « less
-
IEEE (Ed.)A hybrid cloud that combines both public and private clouds is becoming more and more popular due to the advantages of improved security, scalability, and guaranteed SLA (Service-Level Agreement) at a lower cost than a separate private or public cloud. The existing studies rarely consider VM migrations in a hybrid cloud environment with dynamically changed VM workloads. From an enterprise’s perspective, these migrations are necessary to minimize the cost of utilizing public clouds and guarantee SLAs of VMs in a hybrid cloud environment. In this paper, we propose an elastic VM allocation and migration algorithm for a hybrid cloud, called E-VM, to fully utilize the resources in a private cloud and to minimize the cost of using a public cloud while guaranteeing the SLAs of all VMs. The E-VM considers the bi-direction migration between private and public clouds. Two components, VM-predictor and VM-selector, are designed and implemented in E-VM to determine if a migration has to be triggered between private and public clouds and which VMs will be migrated to the opposite cloud, respectively. Moreover, E-VM is designed based on the existing public cloud pricing models and can be easily adapted to any cloud service provider. According to simulator results based on a set of captured industrial VM traces/workloads and additional experiments directly on a real-world hybrid cloud, the proposed E-VM can significantly reduce the total cost of using the public cloud compared to the existing VM migration schemes.more » « less
