skip to main content


Title: Robust point-process Granger causality analysis in presence of exogenous temporal modulations and trial-by-trial variability in spike trains
Assessing directional influences between neurons is instrumental to understand how brain circuits process information. To this end, Granger causality, a technique originally developed for time-continuous signals, has been extended to discrete spike trains. A fundamental assumption of this technique is that the temporal evolution of neuronal responses must be due only to endogenous interactions between recorded units, including self-interactions. This assumption is however rarely met in neurophysiological studies, where the response of each neuron is modulated by other exogenous causes such as, for example, other unobserved units or slow adaptation processes. Here, we propose a novel point-process Granger causality technique that is robust with respect to the two most common exogenous modulations observed in real neuronal responses: within-trial temporal variations in spiking rate and between-trial variability in their magnitudes. This novel method works by explicitly including both types of modulations into the generalized linear model of the neuronal conditional intensity function (CIF). We then assess the causal influence of neuron i onto neuron j by measuring the relative reduction of neuron j ’s point process likelihood obtained considering or removing neuron i . CIF’s hyper-parameters are set on a per-neuron basis by minimizing Akaike’s information criterion. In synthetic data sets, generated by means of random processes or networks of integrate-and-fire units, the proposed method recovered with high accuracy, sensitivity and robustness the underlying ground-truth connectivity pattern. Application of presently available point-process Granger causality techniques produced instead a significant number of false positive connections. In real spiking responses recorded from neurons in the monkey pre-motor cortex (area F5), our method revealed many causal relationships between neurons as well as the temporal structure of their interactions. Given its robustness our method can be effectively applied to real neuronal data. Furthermore, its explicit estimate of the effects of unobserved causes on the recorded neuronal firing patterns can help decomposing their temporal variations into endogenous and exogenous components.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1942585 1755780 2226123
NSF-PAR ID:
10220612
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ;
Editor(s):
Morrison, Abigail
Date Published:
Journal Name:
PLOS Computational Biology
Volume:
17
Issue:
1
ISSN:
1553-7358
Page Range / eLocation ID:
e1007675
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Extracting directional connectivity in a neuronal ensemble from spiking observations is a key challenge in understanding the circuit mechanisms of brain function. Existing methods proceed in two stages, by first estimating the latent processes that govern spiking, followed by characterizing connectivity using said estimates. As such, the extracted networks in the second stage are highly sensitive to the accuracy of the estimates in the first stage. In this work, we introduce a framework to directly extract Granger causal links from spiking observations, without requiring intermediate time-domain estimation, by explicitly modeling the endogenous and exogenous latent processes that underlie spiking activity. Our proposed method integrates several techniques such as point processes, state-space modeling and Pólya-Gamma augmentation. We demonstrate the utility of our proposed approach using simulated data and application to real data from the rat brain during sleep. 
    more » « less
  2. Granger causality is among the widely used data-driven approaches for causal analysis of time series data with applications in various areas including economics, molecular biology, and neuroscience. Two of the main challenges of this methodology are: 1) over-fitting as a result of limited data duration, and 2) correlated process noise as a confounding factor, both leading to errors in identifying the causal influences. Sparse estimation via the LASSO has successfully addressed these challenges for parameter estimation. However, the classical statistical tests for Granger causality resort to asymptotic analysis of ordinary least squares, which require long data duration to be useful and are not immune to confounding effects. In this work, we address this disconnect by introducing a LASSO-based statistic and studying its non-asymptotic properties under the assumption that the true models admit sparse autoregressive representations. We establish fundamental limits for reliable identification of Granger causal influences using the proposed LASSO-based statistic. We further characterize the false positive error probability and test power of a simple thresholding rule for identifying Granger causal effects and provide two methods to set the threshold in a data-driven fashion. We present simulation studies and application to real data to compare the performance of our proposed method to ordinary least squares and existing LASSO-based methods in detecting Granger causal influences, which corroborate our theoretical results. 
    more » « less
  3. null (Ed.)
    Neuronal activity correlations are key to understanding how populations of neurons collectively encode information. While two-photon calcium imaging has created a unique opportunity to record the activity of large populations of neurons, existing methods for inferring correlations from these data face several challenges. First, the observations of spiking activity produced by two-photon imaging are temporally blurred and noisy. Secondly, even if the spiking data were perfectly recovered via deconvolution, inferring network-level features from binary spiking data is a challenging task due to the non-linear relation of neuronal spiking to endogenous and exogenous inputs. In this work, we propose a methodology to explicitly model and directly estimate signal and noise correlations from two-photon fluorescence observations, without requiring intermediate spike deconvolution. We provide theoretical guarantees on the performance of the proposed estimator and demonstrate its utility through applications to simulated and experimentally recorded data from the mouse auditory cortex. 
    more » « less
  4. It is widely assumed that distributed neuronal networks are fundamental to the functioning of the brain. Consistent spike timing between neurons is thought to be one of the key principles for the formation of these networks. This can involve synchronous spiking or spiking with time delays, forming spike sequences when the order of spiking is consistent. Finding networks defined by their sequence of time-shifted spikes, denoted here as spike timing networks, is a tremendous challenge. As neurons can participate in multiple spike sequences at multiple between-spike time delays, the possible complexity of networks is prohibitively large. We present a novel approach that is capable of (1) extracting spike timing networks regardless of their sequence complexity, and (2) that describes their spiking sequences with high temporal precision. We achieve this by decomposing frequency-transformed neuronal spiking into separate networks, characterizing each network’s spike sequence by a time delay per neuron, forming a spike sequence timeline. These networks provide a detailed template for an investigation of the experimental relevance of their spike sequences. Using simulated spike timing networks, we show network extraction is robust to spiking noise, spike timing jitter, and partial occurrences of the involved spike sequences. Using rat multi-neuron recordings, we demonstrate the approach is capable of revealing real spike timing networks with sub-millisecond temporal precision. By uncovering spike timing networks, the prevalence, structure, and function of complex spike sequences can be investigated in greater detail, allowing us to gain a better understanding of their role in neuronal functioning. 
    more » « less
  5. Abstract

    Data-driven analysis and monitoring of complex dynamical systems have been gaining popularity due to various reasons like ubiquitous sensing and advanced computation capabilities. A key rationale is that such systems inherently have high dimensionality and feature complex subsystem interactions due to which majority of the first-principle based methods become insufficient. We explore the family of a recently proposed probabilistic graphical modeling technique, called spatiotemporal pattern network (STPN) in order to capture the Granger causal relationships among observations in a dynamical system. We also show that this technique can be used for anomaly detection and root-cause analysis for real-life dynamical systems. In this context, we introduce the notion of Granger-STPN (G-STPN) inspired by the notion of Granger causality and introduce a new nonparametric technique to detect causality among dynamical systems observations. We experimentally validate our framework for detecting anomalies and analyzing root causes in a robotic arm platform and obtain superior results compared to when other causality metrics were used in previous frameworks.

     
    more » « less