A controversial aspect of Pliocene (5.3–2.6 Ma) climate is whether El Niño‐like (El Padre) conditions, characterized by a reduced trans‐equatorial sea‐surface temperature (SST) gradient, prevailed across the Pacific. Evidence for El Padre is chiefly based on reconstructions of sea‐surface conditions derived from the oxygen isotope (δ18O) and Mg/Ca compositions of shells belonging to the planktic foraminifer
- NSF-PAR ID:
- 10456538
- Publisher / Repository:
- DOI PREFIX: 10.1029
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Paleoceanography and Paleoclimatology
- Volume:
- 35
- Issue:
- 7
- ISSN:
- 2572-4517
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
more » « less
Abstract Neogloboquadrina pachyderma is the dominant species of planktonic foraminifera found in polar waters and is therefore invaluable for paleoceanographic studies of the high latitudes. However, the geochemistry of this species is complicated due to the development of a thick calcite crust in its final growth stage and at greater depths within the water column. We analyzed the in situ Mg/Ca and δ18O in discrete calcite zones using laser ablation‐inductively coupled plasma‐mass spectrometry, electron probe microanalysis, and secondary ion mass spectrometry within modernN. pachyderma shells from the highly dynamic Fram Strait and the seasonally isothermal/isohaline Irminger Sea. Here we compare shell geochemistry to the measured temperature, salinity, and δ18Oswin which the shells calcified to better understand the controls onN. pachyderma geochemical heterogeneity. We present a relationship between Mg/Ca and temperature inN. pachyderma lamellar calcite that is significantly different than published equations for shells that contained both crust and lamellar calcite. We also document highly variable secondary ion mass spectrometry δ18O results (up to a 3.3‰ range in single shells) on plankton tow samples which we hypothesize is due to the granular texture of shell walls. Finally, we document that the δ18O of the crust and lamellar calcite ofN. pachyderma from an isothermal/isohaline environment are indistinguishable from each other, indicating that shifts inN. pachyderma δ18O are primarily controlled by changes in environmental temperature and/or salinity rather than differences in the sensitivities of the two calcite types to environmental conditions. -
more » « less
Abstract The West Pacific Warm Pool (WPWP)'s response to increased
p CO2during the Pliocene is a key model validation target. Different temperature proxies show different trends: The foraminiferal Mg/Ca sea surface temperature (SST) record shows Pliocene WPWP temperatures ~1.2°C cooler than today (Wara et al., 2005,https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1112596 ), whereas a TEX86study finds a cooling trend and claims the Pliocene WPWP was warmer than today (Zhang et al., 2014,https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1246172 ). We focus on understanding biases in Mg/Ca data as the best way to constrain the temperature of the Pliocene WPWP. The strongest nonthermal controls on foraminiferal Mg/Ca are Mg/Ca of seawater and dissolution. Dissolution, which imparts a cool bias to Mg/Ca temperatures, depends on Δ[CO32−], the difference from the carbonate ion concentration needed for calcite saturation. Thus, Pliocene proxy discrepancies might stem from varying Δ[CO32−] over time. To constrain the effect of changing dissolution on the Mg/Ca data, we collected benthic foraminiferal B/Ca data (a proxy for Δ[CO32−]) from the WPWP spanning 0–5.5 Ma. We find no long‐term trend in Δ[CO32−], but variations above and below the threshold of foraminiferal dissolution yield an ~0.4°C cold bias when averaged over the middle to early Pliocene. Changes in seawater Mg/Ca create an ~0.6°C cold bias in the Pliocene Mg/Ca data. After accounting for these biases, we find that the Pliocene WPWP was ~0.1°C cooler than the late Holocene, ranging from −0.5°C to +0.5°C including all uncertainties. Our reconstruction shows a much lower east‐west temperature gradient in the Pliocene tropical Pacific than today, supporting a permanent El Niño‐like “El Padre” state. -
more » « less
Abstract Earth's hydrological cycle was profoundly perturbed by massive carbon emissions during an ancient (56 Ma) global warming event referred to as the Paleocene‐Eocene thermal maximum (PETM). One approach to gaining valuable insight into the response of the hydrological cycle is to construct sea‐surface salinity (SSS) records that can be used to gauge changes in the rates of evaporation and precipitation during the PETM in such climatically sensitive areas as the circum‐Antarctic region. Here, we pair oxygen isotope (δ18O) and magnesium‐calcium (Mg/Ca) measurements to reconstruct PETM sea‐surface temperatures (SSTs) and δ18O composition of seawater (δ18Osw) at austral Site 690 (Weddell Sea). Several discrepancies emerge between the δ18O‐ and Mg/Ca‐based SST records, with the latter indicating that the earliest PETM was punctuated by a short‐lived ~4°C increase in local SSTs. Conversion of the δ18Oswvalues to SSS reveals a ~4 ppt decrease ~50 ka after peak PETM warming at Site 690. This negative SSS (δ18Osw) anomaly coincides with a prominent minimum in the planktic foraminifer δ18O record published for the Site 690 PETM section. Thus, our revised interpretation posits that this δ18O minimum signals a decrease in surface‐ocean δ18Oswfostered by a transient increase in mean annual precipitation in the Weddell Sea region. The results of this study corroborate the view that the poleward flux of atmospheric moisture temporarily increased during a distinctive stage of the PETM.
-
more » « less
Abstract Foraminiferal Mg/Ca has proven to be a powerful paleothermometer for reconstructing past sea‐surface temperature, which, among other applications, is a critical parameter for boron isotope reconstructions of past surface ocean pH and PCO2. However, recent laboratory culture studies indicate seawater pH and the total dissolved inorganic carbon content (DIC) may both exert a significant additional control on foraminiferal Mg/Ca, likely influencing paleotemperature records as a result of seawater chemistry evolution on geologic timescales. In addition, the seawater Mg/Ca composition (Mg/Casw) has been shown to reduce the sensitivity of foraminiferal Mg/Ca to temperature and possibly its sensitivity to the carbonate system as well. Here we present new Mg/Ca data from laboratory culture experiments with living planktic foraminifera—
Globigerinoides ruber (p),Trilobatus sacculifer , andOrbulina universa — grown under a range of different pH and/or seawater DIC conditions and in low Mg/Caswto mimic the chemical composition of the Paleocene ocean. We also conducted targeted [Ca] experiments to help define Mg/Cacalcite–Mg/Caswrelationships for each species and conducted new pH experiments withG .bulloides . We find that pH effects on foraminiferal Mg/Ca are reduced or absent at Mg/Casw = 1.5 mol/mol in all three species, and thatT .sacculifer is generally insensitive to variable DIC and pH, making it the ideal species for Mg/Ca SST reconstructions back to 20 Ma. We apply our newT .sacculifer calibration to a Middle Miocene Mg/Ca record and provide recommendations for interpreting Mg/Ca records from extinct species. -
more » « less
Abstract The
δ 18O signal in ice cores from the Quelccaya Ice Cap (QIC), Peru, corresponds with and has been used to reconstruct Niño region sea surface temperatures (SSTs), but the physical mechanisms that tie El Niño–Southern Oscillation (ENSO)‐related equatorial Pacific SSTs to snowδ 18O at 5,680 m in the Andes have not been fully established. We use a proxy system model to simulate how QIC snowδ 18O varies by ENSO phase. The model accurately simulates higher and lowerδ 18O values during El Niño and La Niña, respectively. We then explore the relative roles of ENSO forcing on different components of the forward model: (i) the seasonality and amount of snow gain and loss at the QIC, (ii) the initial water vaporδ 18O values, and (iii) regional temperature. Most (more than two thirds) of the ENSO‐related variability in the QICδ 18O can be accounted for by ENSO's influence on South American summer monsoon (SASM) activity and the resulting change in the initial water vapor isotopic composition. The initial water vaporδ 18O values are affected by the strength of upstream convection associated with the SASM. Since convection over the Amazon is enhanced during La Niña, the water vapor over the western Amazon Basin—which serves as moisture source for snowfall on QIC—is characterized by more negativeδ 18O values. In the forward model, higher initial water vaporδ ‐values during El Niño yield higher snowδ 18O at the QIC. Our results clarify that the ENSO‐related isotope signal on Quelccaya should not be interpreted as a simple temperature response.
