skip to main content

Title: Photodecay of guaiacol is faster in ice, and even more rapid on ice, than in aqueous solution
Snowpacks contain a wide variety of inorganic and organic compounds, including some that absorb sunlight and undergo direct photoreactions. How the rates of these reactions in, and on, ice compare to rates in water is unclear: some studies report similar rates, while others find faster rates in/on ice. Further complicating our understanding, there is conflicting evidence whether chemicals react more quickly at the air–ice interface compared to in liquid-like regions (LLRs) within the ice. To address these questions, we measured the photodegradation rate of guaiacol (2-methoxyphenol) in various sample types, including in solution, in ice, and at the air–ice interface of nature-identical snow. Compared to aqueous solution, we find modest rate constant enhancements (increases of 3- to 6-fold) in ice LLRs, and much larger enhancements (of 17- to 77-fold) at the air–ice interface of nature-identical snow. Our computational modeling suggests the absorption spectrum for guaiacol red-shifts and increases on ice surfaces, leading to more light absorption, but these changes explain only a small portion (roughly 2 to 9%) of the observed rate constant enhancements in/on ice. This indicates that increases in the quantum yield are primarily responsible for the increased photoreactivity of guaiacol on ice; relative to solution, our results suggest that the quantum yield is larger by a factor of roughly 3–6 in liquid-like regions and 12–40 at the air–ice interface.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Environmental Science: Processes & Impacts
Page Range / eLocation ID:
1666 to 1677
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract. Photochemical reactions of contaminants in snow and ice can be importantsinks for organic and inorganic compounds deposited onto snow from theatmosphere and sources for photoproducts released from snowpacks into theatmosphere. Snow contaminants can be found in the bulk ice matrix, ininternal liquid-like regions (LLRs), or in quasi-liquid layers (QLLs) at theair–ice interface, where they can readily exchange with the firn air. Somestudies have reported that direct photochemical reactions occur faster inLLRs and QLLs than in aqueous solution, while others have found similarrates. Here, we measure the photodegradation rate constants for loss of thethree dimethoxybenzene isomers under varying experimental conditions,including in aqueous solution, in LLRs, and at the air–ice interface ofnature-identical snow. Relative to aqueous solution, we find modestphotodegradation enhancements (3- and 6-fold) in LLRs for two of theisomers and larger enhancements (15- to 30-fold) at the air–ice interfacefor all three isomers. We use computational modeling to assess the impact oflight absorbance changes on photodegradation rate enhancements at theinterface. We find small (2–5 nm) bathochromic (red) absorbance shifts atthe interface relative to in solution, which increases light absorption, butthis factor only accounts for less than 50 % of the measured rate constantenhancements. The major factor responsible for photodegradation rateenhancements at the air–ice interface appears to be more efficientphotodecay: estimated dimethoxybenzene quantum yields are 6- to 24-foldlarger at the interface compared to in aqueous solution and account for themajority (51 %–96 %) of the observed enhancements. Using a hypotheticalmodel compound with an assumed Gaussian-shaped absorbance peak, we find thata shift in the peak to higher or lower wavelengths can have a minor tosubstantial impact on photodecay rate constants, depending on the originallocation of the peak and the magnitude of the shift. Changes in other peakproperties at the air–ice interface, such as peak width and height (i.e.,molar absorption coefficient), can also impact rates of light absorption anddirect photodecay. Our results suggest our current understanding ofphotodegradation processes underestimates the rate at which some compoundsare broken down, as well as the release of photoproducts into theatmosphere. 
    more » « less
  2. Abstract. Snow in the environment acts as a host to rich chemistry and provides a matrix for physical exchange of contaminants within the ecosystem. The goal of this review is to summarise the current state of knowledge of physical processes and chemical reactivity in surface snow with relevance to polar regions. It focuses on a description of impurities in distinct compartments present in surface snow, such as snow crystals, grain boundaries, crystal surfaces, and liquid parts. It emphasises the microscopic description of the ice surface and its link with the environment. Distinct differences between the disordered air–ice interface, often termed quasi-liquid layer, and a liquid phase are highlighted. The reactivity in these different compartments of surface snow is discussed using many experimental studies, simulations, and selected snow models from the molecular to the macro-scale.

    Although new experimental techniques have extended our knowledge of the surface properties of ice and their impact on some single reactions and processes, others occurring on, at or within snow grains remain unquantified. The presence of liquid or liquid-like compartments either due to the formation of brine or disorder at surfaces of snow crystals below the freezing point may strongly modify reaction rates. Therefore, future experiments should include a detailed characterisation of the surface properties of the ice matrices. A further point that remains largely unresolved is the distribution of impurities between the different domains of the condensed phase inside the snowpack, i.e. in the bulk solid, in liquid at the surface or trapped in confined pockets within or between grains, or at the surface. While surface-sensitive laboratory techniques may in the future help to resolve this point for equilibrium conditions, additional uncertainty for the environmental snowpack may be caused by the highly dynamic nature of the snowpack due to the fast metamorphism occurring under certain environmental conditions.

    Due to these gaps in knowledge the first snow chemistry models have attempted to reproduce certain processes like the long-term incorporation of volatile compounds in snow and firn or the release of reactive species from the snowpack. Although so far none of the models offers a coupled approach of physical and chemical processes or a detailed representation of the different compartments, they have successfully been used to reproduce some field experiments. A fully coupled snow chemistry and physics model remains to be developed.

    more » « less
  3. Abstract. While photooxidants are important in atmospheric condensed phases, there arevery few measurements in particulate matter (PM). Here we measure lightabsorption and the concentrations of three photooxidants – hydroxyl radical(⚫OH), singlet molecular oxygen (1O2*),and oxidizing triplet excited states of organic matter (3C*) –in illuminated aqueous extracts of wintertime particles from Davis,California. 1O2* and 3C*, which are formedfrom photoexcitation of brown carbon (BrC), have not been previously measuredin PM. In the extracts, mass absorption coefficients for dissolved organiccompounds (MACDOC) at 300 nm range between 13 000 and30 000 cm2 (g C)−1 are approximately twice ashigh as previous values in Davis fogs. The average (±1σ)⚫OH steady-state concentration in particle extracts is4.4(±2.3)×10-16 M, which is very similar to previous valuesin fog, cloud, and rain: although our particle extracts are moreconcentrated, the resulting enhancement in the rate of ⚫OHphotoproduction is essentially canceled out by a corresponding enhancement inconcentrations of natural sinks for ⚫OH. In contrast,concentrations of the two oxidants formed primarily from brown carbon (i.e.,1O2* and 3C*) are both enhanced in theparticle extracts compared to Davis fogs, a result of higher concentrationsof dissolved organic carbon and faster rates of light absorption in theextracts. The average 1O2* concentration in the PM extractsis 1.6(±0.5)×10-12 M, 7 times higher than past fogmeasurements, while the average concentration of oxidizing triplets is 1.0(±0.4)×10-13 M, nearly double the average Davis fog value.Additionally, the rates of 1O2* and 3C*photoproduction are both well correlated with the rate of sunlightabsorption. Since we cannot experimentally measure photooxidants under ambient particlewater conditions, we measured the effect of PM dilution on oxidantconcentrations and then extrapolated to ambient particle conditions. As theparticle mass concentration in the extracts increases, measuredconcentrations of ⚫OH remain relatively unchanged,1O2* increases linearly, and 3C* concentrations increase lessthan linearly, likely due to quenching by dissolved organics. Based on ourmeasurements, and accounting for additional sources and sinks that should beimportant under PM conditions, we estimate that [⚫OH] inparticles is somewhat lower than in dilute cloud/fog drops, while [3C*]is 30 to 2000 times higher in PM than in drops, and [1O2*] isenhanced by a factor of roughly 2400 in PM compared to drops. Because ofthese enhancements in 1O2* and 3C* concentrations,the lifetimes of some highly soluble organics appear to be much shorter inparticle liquid water than under foggy/cloudy conditions. Based onextrapolating our measured rates of formation in PM extracts, BrC-derivedsinglet molecular oxygen and triplet excited states are overall the dominantsinks for organic compounds in particle liquid water, with an aggregate rateof reaction for each oxidant that is approximately 200–300 times higherthan the aggregate rate of reactions for organics with ⚫OH. Forindividual, highly soluble reactive organic compounds it appears that1O2* is often the major sink in particle water, which is a newfinding. Triplet excited states are likely also important in the fate ofindividual particulate organics, but assessing this requires additionalmeasurements of triplet interactions with dissolved organic carbon innatural samples. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract Quasi-vertical profiles (QVPs) of polarimetric radar data have emerged as a powerful tool for studying precipitation microphysics. Various studies have found enhancements in specific differential phase K dp in regions of suspected secondary ice production (SIP) due to rime splintering. Similar K dp enhancements have also been found in regions of sublimating snow, another proposed SIP process. This work explores these K dp signatures for two cases of sublimating snow using nearly collocated S- and Ka-band radars. The presence of the signature was inconsistent between the radars, prompting exploration of alternative causes. Idealized simulations are performed using a radar beam-broadening model to explore the impact of nonuniform beam filling (NBF) on the observed reflectivity Z and K dp within the sublimation layer. Rather than an intrinsic increase in ice concentration, the observed K dp enhancements can instead be explained by NBF in the presence of sharp vertical gradients of Z and K dp within the sublimation zone, which results in a K dp bias dipole. The severity of the bias is sensitive to the Z gradient and radar beamwidth and elevation angle, which explains its appearance at only one radar. In addition, differences in scanning strategies and range thresholds during QVP processing can constructively enhance these positive K dp biases by excluding the negative portion of the dipole. These results highlight the need to consider NBF effects in regions not traditionally considered (e.g., in pure snow) due to the increased K dp fidelity afforded by QVPs and the subsequent ramifications this has on the observability of sublimational SIP. Significance Statement Many different processes can cause snowflakes to break apart into numerous tiny pieces, including when they evaporate into dry air. Purported evidence of this phenomenon has been seen in data from some weather radars, but we noticed it was not seen in data from others. In this work we use case studies and models to show that this signature may actually be an artifact from the radar beam becoming too big and there being too much variability of the precipitation within it. While this breakup process may actually be occurring in reality, these results suggest we may have trouble observing it with typical weather radars. 
    more » « less
  5. Abstract. Significant rates of primary production occur in the oligotrophic ocean, without any measurable nutrients present in the mixed layer, fueling a scientific paradox that has lasted for decades. Here, we provide a new determination of the annual mean physical supply of nitrate to the euphotic zone in the western subtropical North Atlantic. We combine a 3-year time series of measurements of tritiugenic 3He from 2003 to 2006 in the surface ocean at the Bermuda Atlantic Time-series Study (BATS) site with a sophisticated noble gas calibrated air–sea gas exchange model to constrain the 3He flux across the sea–air interface, which must closely mirror the upward 3He flux into the euphotic zone. The product of the 3He flux and the observed subsurface nitrate–3He relationship provides an estimate of the minimum rate of new production in the BATS region. We also apply the gas model to an earlier time series of 3He measurements at BATS in order to recalculate new production fluxes for the 1985 to 1988 time period. The observations, despite an almost 3-fold difference in the nitrate–3He relationship, yield a roughly consistent estimate of nitrate flux. In particular, the nitrate flux from 2003 to 2006 is estimated to be 0.65 ± 0.14 mol m−2 yr−1, which is ~40 % smaller than the calculated flux for the period from 1985 to 1988. The difference in nitrate flux between the time periods may be signifying a real difference in new production resulting from changes in subtropical mode water formation. Overall, the nitrate flux is larger than most estimates of export fluxes or net community production fluxes made locally for the BATS site, which is likely a reflection of the larger spatial scale covered by the 3He technique and potentially also by the decoupling of 3He and nitrate during the obduction of water masses from the main thermocline into the upper ocean. The upward nitrate flux is certainly large enough to support observed rates of primary production at BATS and more generally in the oligotrophic subtropical ocean. 
    more » « less