Title: Robust Mendelian randomization in the presence of residual population stratification, batch effects and horizontal pleiotropy
Abstract Mendelian Randomization (MR) studies are threatened by population stratification, batch effects, and horizontal pleiotropy. Although a variety of methods have been proposed to mitigate those problems, residual biases may still remain, leading to highly statistically significant false positives in large databases. Here we describe a suite of sensitivity analysis tools that enables investigators to quantify the robustness of their findings against such validity threats. Specifically, we propose the routine reporting of sensitivity statistics that reveal the minimal strength of violations necessary to explain away the MR results. We further provide intuitive displays of the robustness of the MR estimate to any degree of violation, and formal bounds on the worst-case bias caused by violations multiple times stronger than observed variables. We demonstrate how these tools can aid researchers in distinguishing robust from fragile findings by examining the effect of body mass index on diastolic blood pressure and Townsend deprivation index.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2106908 1943497 1705121
PAR ID:
10337285
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Nature Communications
Volume:
13
Issue:
1
ISSN:
2041-1723
Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. We develop an omitted variable bias framework for sensitivity analysis of instrumental variable estimates that naturally handles multiple side effects (violations of the exclusion restriction assumption) and confounders (violations of the ignorability of the instrument assumption) of the instrument, exploits expert knowledge to bound sensitivity parameters and can be easily implemented with standard software. Specifically, we introduce sensitivity statistics for routine reporting, such as (extreme) robustness values for instrumental variables, describing the minimum strength that omitted variables need to have to change the conclusions of a study. Next, we provide visual displays that fully characterize the sensitivity of point estimates and confidence intervals to violations of the standard instrumental variable assumptions. Finally, we offer formal bounds on the worst possible bias under the assumption that the maximum explanatory power of omitted variables is no stronger than a multiple of the explanatory power of observed variables. Conveniently, many pivotal conclusions regarding the sensitivity of the instrumental variable estimate (e.g., tests against the null hypothesis of a zero causal effect) can be reached simply through separate sensitivity analyses of the effect of the instrument on the treatment (the first stage) and the effect of the instrument on the outcome (the reduced form). We apply our methods in a running example that uses proximity to college as an instrumental variable to estimate the returns to schooling. 
    more » « less
  2. A<sc>bstract</sc> Cerebrospinal and interstitial fluid transport play a central role in brain metabolic waste clearance, yet non-invasive quantification of deep-brain flow dynamics remains challenging. Magnetic Resonance Artificial Intelligence Velocimetry (MR-AIV) is a physics-informed neural network framework that infers three-dimensional velocity, pressure, and permeability fields from dynamic contrastenhanced MRI by embedding porous-media flow physics into the learning process. Here, we present a methodological refinement and systematic evaluation of MR-AIV. We introduce a universal, anatomically informed, region-of-interest–based permeability initialization that improves anatomical alignment and physical consistency across subjects. We quantify the sensitivity of inferred fields to key modelling choices, including initialization strategies, permeability bounds, diffusivity assumptions, signal–concentration relationships, and measurement noise. Across these conditions, MR-AIV yields stable velocity and permeability estimates with preserved spatial structure. Together, these results establish practical guidelines and identify stable operating regimes for reliable deployment of MR-AIV. By improving robustness and reproducibility, this work strengthens MR-AIV as a minimally invasive approach for mapping brain-wide porous fluid transport and supports its application to studies of neurological health and disease. 
    more » « less
  3. Scheduling in multi-channel wireless communication system presents formidable challenges in effectively allocating resources. To address these challenges, we investigate a multi-resource restless matching bandit (MR-RMB) model for heterogeneous resource systems with an objective of maximizing long-term discounted total rewards while respecting resource constraints. We have also generalized to applications beyond multi-channel wireless. We discuss the Max-Weight Index Matching algorithm, which optimizes resource allocation based on learned partial indexes. We have derived the policy gradient theorem for index learning. Our main contribution is the introduction of a new Deep Index Policy (DIP), an online learning algorithm tailored for MR-RMB. DIP learns the partial index by leveraging the policy gradient theorem for restless arms with convoluted and unknown transition kernels of heterogeneous resources. We demonstrate the utility of DIP by evaluating its performance for three different MR-RMB problems. Our simulation results show that DIP indeed learns the partial indexes efficiently. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract Manufacturing Supply Networks (MSNs) involve interrelated groups making network-specific and group-specific decisions across multiple levels to realize network and group performances. The interrelations between groups result in correlations between network and group performances. Uncertainties and disruptions adversely impact the correlated network and group performances. Simultaneously realizing (co-realizing) network and group performances requires co-designing MSNs, considering the correlations, uncertainties, and disruptions involved. Limited, incomplete, and inaccurate information during the early stages of design necessitates focusing on design exploration. Hence, facilitating ‘co-design exploration’ – the simultaneous exploration of network and group solution spaces is crucial. The Co-Design Exploration of MSNs for Resilience (CoDE-MR) framework facilitates co-design exploration, considering mitigating disruption impacts. However, the CoDE-MR framework does not consider the recovery aspect of resilience and the impacts of uncertainties. The Co-Design Exploration of MSNs for Robustness and Resilience (CoDE-MRR) framework is presented in this paper to bridge this gap. CoDE-MRR framework supports considering network-group performance correlations, managing impacts of uncertainties and disruptions, and co-design exploration to identify solutions that ensure satisfactory network and group performances under uncertainties and disruptions. In this framework, we integrate the coupled-compromise decision support problem construct with robust design metric - design capability index, resilience metric – resilience index, inventory-based recovery strategies, and interpretable self-organizing map-based visualization to facilitate co-design exploration of MSNs for robustness and resilience. The framework’s efficacy is demonstrated using a steel MSN example. The generic nature of constructs used makes the framework generic and well-suited for co-design exploration of multilevel systems to ensure robustness and resilience. 
    more » « less
  5. The recent rise in the adoption of sensing technologies, such as laser scanners and drones for improving efficiency, safety, and productivity, has driven the need for a technically skilled workforce prepared to implement these technologies. Academia is also inclined to meet this need, but is often impaired by the high cost of sensing technologies and the need for hands-on experiences. Mixed Reality (MR) has been explored as an alternative learning environment to equip construction students with the needed technical skills due to its potential to provide experiential learning. However, to advance the adoption of MR as an alternative learning environment, concerns persist regarding the safety risks and potential distractions posed by reduced situational awareness (SA) during interactions. While studies have explored SA in various domains, its assessment within MR environments for construction education remains unexplored. This study addresses that gap by evaluating participants’ SA and cognitive load while interacting with sensing technologies in an MR learning environment. Nineteen undergraduate students participated in MR-based tasks. Their SA and cognitive load were assessed using the Situational Awareness Rating Technique (SART), NASA Task Load Index (NASA-TLX), and eye-tracking metrics. Results showed that participants generally had a strong awareness of their surroundings, reflected in high familiarity and the ability to process relevant information during MR tasks. The findings also indicate that participants with lower SA exhibited longer fixation durations, while those with higher SA showed shorter fixation durations. Additionally, individuals with lower SA experienced greater cognitive load and demonstrated more extensive visual scanning (e.g., higher fixation count). These findings not only align with cognitive load theory and prior eye-tracking research but also offer practical recommendations for MR instructional design. This study contributes to the development of virtual learning environments cognizant of users' SA, which often culminates in reduced cognitive overload, enhanced student learning, improved attention, and engagement. 
    more » « less