<?xml-model href='http://www.tei-c.org/release/xml/tei/custom/schema/relaxng/tei_all.rng' schematypens='http://relaxng.org/ns/structure/1.0'?><TEI xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0">
	<teiHeader>
		<fileDesc>
			<titleStmt><title level='a'>Size and print path effects on mechanical properties of material extrusion 3D printed plastics</title></titleStmt>
			<publicationStmt>
				<publisher></publisher>
				<date>02/24/2022</date>
			</publicationStmt>
			<sourceDesc>
				<bibl> 
					<idno type="par_id">10344333</idno>
					<idno type="doi">10.1007/s40964-022-00275-w</idno>
					<title level='j'>Progress in Additive Manufacturing</title>
<idno>2363-9512</idno>
<biblScope unit="volume"></biblScope>
<biblScope unit="issue"></biblScope>					

					<author>Jia-Ruey Ai</author><author>Bryan D. Vogt</author>
				</bibl>
			</sourceDesc>
		</fileDesc>
		<profileDesc>
			<abstract><ab><![CDATA[Print conditions for thermoplastics by filament-based material extrusion (MatEx) are commonly optimized to maximize the elastic modulus. However, these optimizations tend to ignore the impact of thermal history that depends on the specimen size and print path selection. Here, we investigate the effect of size print path (raster angle and build orientation) and print sequence on the mechanical properties of polycarbonate (PC) and polypropylene (PP). Examination of parallel and series printing of flat (XY) and stand-on (YZ) orientation of Type V specimens demonstrated that to observe statistical differences in the mechanical response that the interlayer time between printed roads should be approximately 5 s or less. The print time for a single layer in XY orientation is much longer than that for a single layer in YZ orientation, so print sequence only impacts the mechanical response in the YZ orientation. However, the specimen size and raster angle did influence the mechanical properties in XY orientation due to the differences in thermal history associated with intralayer time between adjacent roads. Moreover, all of these effects are significantly larger when printing PC than PP. These differences between PP and PC are mostly attributed to the mechanism of interface consolidation (crystallization vs. glass formation), which changes the requirements for a strong interface between roads (crystals vs. entanglements). These results illustrate how the print times dictated by the print path layout impact observed mechanical properties. This work also demonstrated that the options available in some standards developed for traditional manufacturing will change the quantitative results when applied to 3D printed parts.]]></ab></abstract>
		</profileDesc>
	</teiHeader>
	<text><body xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="1.">INTRODUCTION</head><p>Advances in machine design and processing have enabled 3D printing (3DP) of plastics by materials extrusion (MatEx) to transition from rapid prototyping to production (additive manufacturing, AM) <ref type="bibr">[1]</ref><ref type="bibr">[2]</ref><ref type="bibr">[3]</ref><ref type="bibr">[4]</ref>. Here we use the term MatEx to describe thermal filament-based printed as prescribed by the revised ISO/ASTM2900 Additive Manufacturing -General Principles -Terminology. This printing modality has also commonly referred as Fused Filament Fabrication (FFF) and by the Stratasys trademarked Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM). In addition to potential advantages of 3DP for plastic manufacture associated with low initial investments and potential for mass customization, the quick turnaround from design to parts enables 3DP to be a key production method to respond to crises as demonstrated with the COVID-19 pandemic <ref type="bibr">[5,</ref><ref type="bibr">6]</ref>. The increased variety of filaments available <ref type="bibr">[7,</ref><ref type="bibr">8]</ref>, especially engineering plastics <ref type="bibr">[9]</ref><ref type="bibr">[10]</ref><ref type="bibr">[11]</ref>, has expanded potential applications for AM. However, one limitation <ref type="bibr">[12,</ref><ref type="bibr">13]</ref> to widespread adaptation of MatEx for manufacturing is their inferior mechanical properties, which can strongly depend on the process <ref type="bibr">[14]</ref><ref type="bibr">[15]</ref><ref type="bibr">[16]</ref><ref type="bibr">[17]</ref><ref type="bibr">[18]</ref><ref type="bibr">[19]</ref>. Mechanical properties are path dependent and generally anisotropic that depends on build orientation <ref type="bibr">[20]</ref>. The inferior mechanical properties are attributed to incomplete filling (voids) and limitations with polymer diffusion to provide entanglements across interfaces between printed roads <ref type="bibr">[21,</ref><ref type="bibr">22]</ref>. These attributes are controlled by details of the printing process and thus determining how to optimize the mechanical properties associated with MatEx 3D printing has been a significant thrust <ref type="bibr">[23]</ref><ref type="bibr">[24]</ref><ref type="bibr">[25]</ref>. There have also been significant efforts to understand layer bonding in MatEx 3D printing due to its importance for the ultimate properties of the printed part <ref type="bibr">[26]</ref><ref type="bibr">[27]</ref><ref type="bibr">[28]</ref>.</p><p>As the effective weld time <ref type="bibr">[29]</ref> for interface development between printed roads depends on the print details, the process parameters optimized for mechanical properties may be limited to the examined part shape. For products, the printed parts need to satisfy multiple characteristics through multiple-objective optimization, which tends to involve additional tradeoffs <ref type="bibr">[30]</ref>. Recently, optimization routines have been applied to representative objects instead of mechanical test coupons <ref type="bibr">[31,</ref><ref type="bibr">32]</ref>, but direct comparisons were not drawn. To understand print processes, instrumentation, typically measuring temperature, flow and pressure <ref type="bibr">[21,</ref><ref type="bibr">33,</ref><ref type="bibr">34]</ref>, provide process monitoring during the print that can assess potential issues to avoid expensive, post-print product monitoring like x-ray microcomputed tomography (&#181;CT) <ref type="bibr">[35,</ref><ref type="bibr">36]</ref>. Measurement of flow <ref type="bibr">[37,</ref><ref type="bibr">38]</ref> and temperature <ref type="bibr">[39,</ref><ref type="bibr">40]</ref> during MatEx 3D printing are particularly important as these parameters correlate with the ultimate properties of the printed part. These in-line monitoring data can be applied with models to predict the interlayer strength <ref type="bibr">[21]</ref> or applied to polymer weld theory <ref type="bibr">[11]</ref>. The properties can be altered through post processing of 3D printed parts, which relaxes residual stresses <ref type="bibr">[41,</ref><ref type="bibr">42]</ref>. Despites these complexities, reporting of empirical optimization of print process parameters remains common <ref type="bibr">[43]</ref><ref type="bibr">[44]</ref><ref type="bibr">[45]</ref><ref type="bibr">[46]</ref>, but the growing knowledge about the underlying principles that relate rate, temperature and pressure dependencies of the polymer flow during printing <ref type="bibr">[21]</ref> to mechanical properties would suggest that the optimization should be object dependent. This object dependence is consistent with recent comparisons of standard test methods, ASTM D638-14 vs. UNE 116005 <ref type="bibr">[47]</ref> and ASTM D638 vs. ASTEM D3039 <ref type="bibr">[20]</ref>, as well as specimen size with ASTM D638 <ref type="bibr">[48]</ref>. The measured properties depend on standard selection, but physical insights into these observations have been limited.</p><p>From a molecular perspective, the bonding strength at interface between adjacent roads is related to the local chain conformation that depends on the local thermal history. The development of interfacial strength can be related with the welding of the printed roads, which should effectively be mechanistically similar to conventional welding where (1) surface contact, (2) surface rearrangement, (3) surface wetting, (4) chain diffusion, and (5) chain relaxation <ref type="bibr">[49]</ref> define the weld quality. Typically, the welding quality relies on polymer diffusion across the interface to form bridging entanglements, which depends on the geometry of adjacent printed roads <ref type="bibr">[50,</ref><ref type="bibr">51]</ref> and the build (layer) orientation <ref type="bibr">[52]</ref>. The overall print layout can affect the local thermal history, which determines the effective diffusion time <ref type="bibr">[53]</ref>.Thus, printing multiple parts simultaneously can lead to changes in the mechanical properties as increased cooling between printed layers (interlayer time) leads to less effective polymer diffusion across interlayer to deteriorate mechanical properties <ref type="bibr">[54]</ref>. The print path can significantly impact the mechanical properties of printed parts <ref type="bibr">[55]</ref>. With the common optimization of print parameters for MatEx 3D printing based on objects that differ from the printed product, it is constructive to understand the origin and extent of sensitivity of mechanical properties to the object shape and the overall print path. Here, two standard ASTM D638 tensile bar sizes (Type IV and V) along with parallel and series printing of the specimens were examined for polycarbonate (PC) and polypropylene (PP). These plastics have been previously demonstrated for 3DP <ref type="bibr">[7,</ref><ref type="bibr">[56]</ref><ref type="bibr">[57]</ref><ref type="bibr">[58]</ref><ref type="bibr">[59]</ref>, including as composites <ref type="bibr">[60,</ref><ref type="bibr">61]</ref>, with PC exhibiting properties for potential engineering applications, while PP offers potential for much lower cost. The elastic modulus was independent of these characteristics, but the failure was dependent on the specimen size. Based on further investigation into raster angle and build orientation, these differences were attributed to the efficacy of the welding quality that depends on the time between both interlayer and intralayer adjacent printed roads. If the time is sufficiently large between the printing of these adjacent roads, the mechanical response is effectively independent of specimen size and print sequence. The size effect on mechanical properties is significantly weaker for PP as the weld strength does not require large diffusion for entanglement as crystallization between adjacent roads strengthens the interface. These results illustrate that the sensitivity of the mechanical properties to details of the part size and shape, build orientation, and print sequence is related to the thermal history of adjacent printed roads.</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="2.">Experimental procedure</head><p>Filaments of amorphous bisphenol-A polycarbonate (PC, Makrolon 3208, Covestro) were fabricated using a HAKKE single screw extruder (Rheomex 252p) and drawn by a take-up wheel to a diameter of 1.7 &#177; 0.03 mm. Additional details about the filament fabrication are included in the Supplementary Information (SI). Filaments of semi-crystalline polypropylene (PP) with diameter 1.75 &#177; 0.05 mm were acquired from Verbatim, Inc. (P/N 55950) and contained ~0.5 wt% of phthalates. The commercial PP filament contained 0.1 wt% bis-2 ethylhexyl phthalate (DEHP), 0.1 wt% benzyl butyl phthalate (BBP), 0.1 wt% dibutyl phthalate (DBP), and 0.1 wt% diisobutyl phthalate (DIBP), per specification from the manufacturer, to improve the flow properties.</p><p>ASTM D638 type IV and type V tensile bars were printed with a Roboze One +400 Xtreme printer These specimens differ in the width and length of the dogbone shape as illustrated in Fig. <ref type="figure">1a</ref>, while a common thickness (2 mm) was used. The ASTM tensile specimen were printed using the following parameters: 0.25 mm layer height, 0.48 mm extrusion width, 20 mm/s printing speed, 100% infill, and 0/90&#176; rectilinear infill pattern unless otherwise noted. Full explicit printing parameters are provided in the Supplementary Information (SI). These print conditions were determined from prior experience with PC <ref type="bibr">[62]</ref> and the manufacturer guidance for PP along with understanding of the thermal properties of these polymers as described in the SI. Five specimens were printed for each condition is suggested by ASTM D638. The use of five samples provides statistical significance to the properties reported and illustrates the reproducibility of the print under the conditions examined. Two distinct printing sequences (series and parallel) were used to understand the effect of thermal history. For series printing, all specimens have identical thermal histories, while for parallel printing, different interlayer thermal histories occur, especially for the first and the last specimen printed. Printing in series involved fully printing one specimen before moving to the next as shown in  ). The cross-sectional area (A0) in the gauge region prior to testing was determined using digital calipers. For determination of the Young's Modulus, the true strain (&#120576; %&amp;'( = &#8747; )" "</p><p>) was determined from a video extensometer that measured the initial displacement, whereas engineering stress-strain are used for all other properties reported due to the limited field of view for the video extensometer. The tensile data was also used to determine the toughness from the area under the stress-strain curve prior to failure as &#119880; * = &#8747; &#120590;&#119889;&#120576; + " , . The fracture surfaces were examined by scanning electron microscopy (SEM, Thermoscientific Apereo S) with an accelerating voltage of 1 kV and current of 25 pA.</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="3.">Results and Discussion</head><p>The tensile properties of 3D printed polymers are commonly measured using standards, such as ASTM D638, which were developed for traditional polymer manufacture. As shown in Fig <ref type="figure">2a</ref>, the PC exhibits brittle failure when printed in a type IV dogbone at raster angles of 0&#176;/90&#176;. This is counter to injection molded PC, which exhibits ductile failure <ref type="bibr">[63]</ref>, but consistent with brittle fracture observed with other 3D printed PC dependent on build orientation and testing rate <ref type="bibr">[57]</ref>. However, decreasing the specimen size to type V with the same print conditions leads to ductile failure as shown in Fig 2b . This difference does not appear to be the interlayer thermal history as tensile behavior is similar for the type V printed in parallel as shown in Fig 2c . This change from series to parallel alters the thermal history between layers (see Table <ref type="table">1</ref>). As an aside, thermal annealing post processing of the type IV specimens does not produce ductility approaching that of the type V specimens (additional information provided in SI). Despite the significant differences in the stress-strain behavior of the type IV and type V specimens, the elastic modulus of the printed PC is approximately 1.8 GPa, irrespective of the print history. A prior comparison of type I and type IV printed PLA indicated that the optimized ultimate tensile strength (UTS) was not significantly influenced by the selection, but the type IV geometry tends to produce higher UTS over the full print parameter space <ref type="bibr">[48]</ref>. Examination of the stress at failure indicates a slightly larger UTS with the type V geometry, which is consistent with the prior comparison with PLA in terms of the specimen size effect. Yielding for the specimen printing with the type V geometry significantly increases the toughness of the printed PC (Fig <ref type="figure">2d</ref>). Toughness is more sensitive to the appearance of the tensile curves than elastic modulus or UTS, which are more common metrics to quantify the properties of printed plastics. ) associated with the five printed specimens for each case.</p><p>To assess universality of this behavior, a semi-crystalline polymer, PP, was printed using the same geometries and print paths. Unlike PC, PP consistently exhibited ductile failure (Fig <ref type="figure">3a-c</ref>) with strain hardening after yielding. This strain hardening is attributed to the extension of tie chains between PP crystals <ref type="bibr">[64]</ref>. The elastic modulus and yield stress are both effectively independent of the print details for the three cases examined. However, the type IV specimens tend to fail at slightly lower tensile strains. Fig 3d illustrates this difference in terms of the toughness of the printed parts, where the Type IV geometry leads to a lower toughness despite no statistical difference in the elastic modulus with the different tensile geometries. Table <ref type="table">2</ref> summarizes the mechanical properties obtained for the PP and PC as a function of the specimen geometry and print sequence for the flat orientation with alternating 0&#176;/90&#176; raster angles. The primary differences for the different print conditions are in the toughness and strain to break.  The details of the print path are important to understand these size effects. Some mechanical anisotropy is built into the samples from the build orientation of the printed roads relative to the direction of the applied stress. This internal anisotropy has been reported to be particularly evident for fracture <ref type="bibr">[65]</ref>. For the tensile specimens, the thickness, build orientation (flat, XY) and general print conditions are identical, but the width in the gauge region differs by nearly a factor of 2 between Type IV and V specimens. Although the nominal print fill is parallel (0&#176;) for the odd layers and perpendicular (90&#176;) for the even layers, the printed perimeter and turns near the printed perimeter leads to &gt;50% parallel roads (see Table <ref type="table">3</ref>). To test if this difference in the raster angle details is responsible for the different fracture behavior, unidirectional (0&#176; or 90&#176;) builds were investigated with both geometries. Nonetheless, the modulus of the PC printed with 90&#176; raster angle was slightly higher (1.91 &#177; 0.08 GPa). Averaging of the elastic modulus for the different build orientations is consistent with the results obtained for the 0&#176;/90&#176; raster angle shown previously.</p><p>Fig <ref type="figure">4c</ref> shows the stress-strain behavior of Type IV PC specimens with 0&#176; raster angle. The tensile stress decreases in discrete steps after an apparent yield point but is associated with intralayer failure of weld lines <ref type="bibr">[66]</ref>. The larger specimen size extends the cooling time between adjacent intralayer roads to lead to weaker weld lines for Type IV than Type V specimens with 0&#176; raster angle. The Type IV PC specimens printed at 90&#176; raster angle exhibits brittle failure in all cases (Fig <ref type="figure">4d</ref>). These differences in the stress-strain behavior with fully oriented roads is consistent changes in the intralayer cooling time based on size and raster angle as summarized in Table <ref type="table">4</ref>.       artifacts from the printed roads are not as prominent in the PP specimens. These micrographs point towards an improved interface between the printed roads as well as improved flow prior to solidification that minimizes voids. This is likely partially attributable to the lower solidification temperature of PP (88 &#176;C) than PC (143 &#176;C), but more importantly, crystallization across the interface between roads provides a robust mechanical bond without requiring significant diffusion for entanglements as in the case of PC and other glassy polymers <ref type="bibr">[67]</ref>. The strength of a weld for glassy polymers depends directly on diffusion and the ability to form entanglements <ref type="bibr">[68]</ref>. The lack of entanglements does not impact the mechanical properties of polypropylene as significantly due to the effective crosslinking of chains by crystallization <ref type="bibr">[69]</ref>. This mechanistic difference means that the conditional requirements for effective welding in 3D printing will be different for glassy and crystalline polymers. Prior work has demonstrated the importance of interlayer time on the mechanical properties of 3D printed ABS, especially when printed in the stand-on (YZ) orientation <ref type="bibr">[54]</ref>. This result is qualitatively counter to the results reported here. However, the effective time between printed layers will depend on the build orientation and sequence. To shorten the interlayer time, specimens of both PC and PP were printed in the stand-on (YZ) orientation in both series and parallel. The short interlayer time in gauge region (see Table <ref type="table">1</ref>) leads to good welding between layers, so that the PC printed in series in the stand-on orientation exhibits a similar Young's modulus compared to specimens printed with a flat orientation (Fig <ref type="figure">8a</ref>). These specimens are more brittle than those printed with 90&#176; raster angle only in flat orientation, which is likely associated with the perimeter in the flat specimens. However when the stand-on orientation is used in parallel for PC, there is a substantial decrease in the modulus and the stress at break is less than one quarter of the specimens printed in series in stand-on orientation. This behavior is consistent with the change in interlayer time and the time scales where the intralayer (Table <ref type="table">4</ref>) time impacts the mechanical response. Similar to the flat orientation, the sequence (series vs. parallel) for printing PP in stand-on orientation does not significantly alter the mechanical response with a small decrease in the strain at break. We attribute this difference in behavior to the reinforcement of crystallites at interfaces between printed roads. Table <ref type="table">5</ref> summarizes the properties of the specimens printed with stand-on orientation. These results suggest that crystallinity leads to decreased sensitivity to the details of the print (size, build orientation, sequence), but crystallization tends to lead to challenges in the dimensional accuracy <ref type="bibr">[8,</ref><ref type="bibr">70]</ref>.  </p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="4.">CONCLUSIONS</head><p>The process path dependence of the mechanical response of MatEx 3D printed PC and PP was systematically examined. For amorphous PC, the effect of printing multiple samples in parallel was dependent on the build orientation. For the flat orientation, there was no statistical change in the mechanical properties between parallel and series printing but selection of the test coupon size, which is associated with intralayer cooling time, influenced the specimen failure mechanism.</p><p>For stand-on orientation, there was a difference in the mechanical performance between parallel and series printing due to the short interlayer time in the gauge region of interest. These effects can be explained in terms of the thermal history of both interlayer and intralayer printed roads that determines the weld strength between roads and can influence the failure mode. The significance of these selections decreases with PP. There were limited differences in the mechanical response irrespective of sequence, size, and build orientation examined. This insensitivity to processing parameters for PP is attributed to its ability to form strong weld lines through crystallization across printed roads without the diffusion requirements for entanglements which strengthen the glassy PC. The selection of the test coupon has limited impact on the elastic modulus, but influences yielding and large strain behavior, so care should be taken in appropriately selecting print coupon size and build orientation for 3D printed plastics mechanical data use in design. Additionally, these results illustrate that only comparison of elastic modulus of the printed parts does not always provide an accurate representation of the differences in the mechanical response.</p></div></body>
		</text>
</TEI>
