skip to main content


Title: Effects of amino acid additives on protein solubility – insights from desorption and direct electrospray ionization mass spectrometry
Naturally occurring amino acids have been broadly used as additives to improve protein solubility and inhibit aggregation. In this study, improvements in protein signal intensity obtained with the addition of l -serine, and structural analogs, to the desorption electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (DESI-MS) spray solvent were measured. The results were interpreted at the hand of proposed mechanisms of solution additive effects on protein solubility and dissolution. DESI-MS allows for these processes to be studied efficiently using dilute concentrations of additives and small amounts of proteins, advantages that represent real benefits compared to classical methods of studying protein stability and aggregation. We show that serine significantly increases the protein signal in DESI-MS when native proteins are undergoing unfolding during the dissolution process with an acidic solvent system ( p -value = 0.0001), or with ammonium bicarbonate under denaturing conditions for proteins with high isoelectric points ( p -value = 0.001). We establish that a similar increase in the protein signal cannot be observed with direct ESI-MS, and the observed increase is therefore not related to ionization processes or changes in the physical properties of the bulk solution. The importance of the presence of serine during protein conformational changes while undergoing dissolution is demonstrated through comparisons between the analyses of proteins deposited in native or unfolded states and by using native state-preserving and denaturing desorption solvents. We hypothesize that direct, non-covalent interactions involving all three functional groups of serine are involved in the beneficial effect on protein solubility and dissolution. Supporting evidence for a direct interaction include a reduction in efficacy with d -serine or the racemic mixture, indicating a non-bulk-solution physical property effect; insensitivity to the sample surface type or relative placement of serine addition; and a reduction in efficacy with any modifications to the serine structure, most notably the carboxyl functional group. An alternative hypothesis, also supported by some of our observations, could involve the role of serine clusters in the mechanism of solubility enhancement. Our study demonstrates the capability of DESI-MS together with complementary ESI-MS experiments as a novel tool for understanding protein solubility and dissolution and investigating the mechanism of action for solubility-enhancing additives.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2003379
NSF-PAR ID:
10348077
Author(s) / Creator(s):
;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
The Analyst
Volume:
146
Issue:
21
ISSN:
0003-2654
Page Range / eLocation ID:
6592 to 6604
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Rationale

    Purification of recombinant proteins is a necessary step for functional or structural studies and other applications. Immobilized metal affinity chromatography is a common recombinant protein purification method. Mass spectrometry (MS) allows for confirmation of identity of expressed proteins and unambiguous detection of enzymatic substrates and reaction products. We demonstrate the detection of enzymes purified on immobilized metal affinity surfaces by direct or ambient ionization MS, and follow their enzymatic reactions by direct electrospray ionization (ESI) or desorption electrospray ionization (DESI).

    Methods

    A protein standard, His‐Ubq, and two recombinant proteins, His‐SHAN and His‐CS, expressed inEscherichia coliwere immobilized on two immobilized metal affinity systems, Cu–nitriloacetic acid (Cu‐NTA) and Ni‐NTA. The proteins were purified on surface, and released in the ESI spray solvent for direct infusion, when using the 96‐well plate form factor, or analyzed directly from immobilized metal affinity‐coated microscope slides by DESI‐MS. Enzyme activity was followed by incubating the substrates in wells or by depositing substrate on immobilized protein on coated slides for analysis.

    Results

    Small proteins (His‐Ubq) and medium proteins (His‐SAHN) could readily be detected from 96‐well plates by direct infusion ESI, or from microscope slides by DESI‐MS after purification on surface from clarifiedE. colicell lysate. Protein oxidation was observed for immobilized proteins on both Cu‐NTA and Ni‐NTA; however, this did not hamper the enzymatic reactions of these proteins. Both the nucleosidase reaction products for His‐SAHN and the methylation product of His‐CS (theobromine to caffeine) were detected.

    Conclusions

    The immobilization, purification, release and detection of His‐tagged recombinant proteins using immobilized metal affinity surfaces for direct infusion ESI‐MS or ambient DESI‐MS analyses were successfully demonstrated. Recombinant proteins were purified to allow identification directly out of clarified cell lysate. Biological activities of the recombinant proteins were preserved allowing the investigation of enzymatic activity via MS.

     
    more » « less
  2. Rationale

    Examining surface protein conformations, and especially achieving this with spatial resolution, is an important goal. The recently discovered ionization processes offer spatial‐resolution measurements similar to matrix‐assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) and produce charge states similar to electrospray ionization (ESI) extending higher‐mass protein applications directly from surfaces on high‐performance mass spectrometers. Studying a well‐interrogated protein by ion mobility spectrometry‐mass spectrometry (IMS‐MS) to access effects on structures using a solidvs.solvent matrix may provide insights.

    Methods

    Ubiquitin was studied by IMS‐MS using new ionization processes with commercial and homebuilt ion sources and instruments (Waters SYNAPT G2(S)) and homebuilt 2 m drift‐tube instrument; MS™ sources). Mass‐to‐charge and drift‐time (td)‐measurements are compared for ubiquitin ions obtained byinletandvacuumionization using laserspray ionization (LSI), matrix‐ (MAI) and solvent‐assisted ionization (SAI), respectively, and compared with those from ESI under conditions that are most comparable.

    Results

    Using the same solution conditions with SYNAPT G2(S) instruments, td‐distributions of various ubiquitin charge states from MAI, LSI, and SAI are similar to those from ESI using a variety of solvents, matrices, extraction voltages, a laser, and temperature only, showing subtle differences in more compact features within the elongated distribution of structures. However, on a homebuilt drift‐tube instrument, within the elongated distribution of structures, both similar and different td‐distributions are observed for ubiquitin ions obtained by MAI and ESI. MAI‐generated ions are frequently narrower in their td‐distributions.

    Conclusions

    Direct comparisons between ESI and the new ionization methods operational directly from surfaces suggest that the protein in its solution structure prior to exposure to the ionization event is either captured (frozen out) at the time of crystallization, or that the protein in the solid matrix is associated with sufficient solvent to maintain the solution structure, or, alternatively, that the observed structures are those related to what occurs in the gas phase with ESI‐ or MAI‐generated ions and not with the solution structures.

     
    more » « less
  3. Decavanadate (V 10 O 28 6− or V10) is a paradigmatic member of the polyoxidometalate (POM) family, which has been attracting much attention within both materials/inorganic and biomedical communities due to its unique structural and electrochemical properties. In this work we explored the utility of high-resolution electrospray ionization (ESI) mass spectrometry (MS) and ion exclusion chromatography LC/MS for structural analysis of V10 species in aqueous solutions. While ESI generates abundant molecular ions representing the intact V10 species, their isotopic distributions show significant deviations from the theoretical ones. A combination of high-resolution MS measurements and hydrogen/deuterium exchange allows these deviations to be investigated and interpreted as a result of partial reduction of V10. While the redox processes are known to occur in the ESI interface and influence the oxidation state of redox-active analytes, the LC/MS measurements using ion exclusion chromatography provide unequivocal evidence that the mixed-valence V10 species exist in solution, as extracted ion chromatograms representing V10 molecular ions at different oxidation states exhibit distinct elution profiles. The spontaneous reduction of V10 in solution is seen even in the presence of hydrogen peroxide and has not been previously observed. The susceptibility to reduction of V10 is likely to be shared by other redox active POMs. In addition to the molecular V10 ions, a high-abundance ionic signal for a V 10 O 26 2− anion was displayed in the negative-ion ESI mass spectra. None of the V 10 O 26 cations were detected in ESI MS, and only a low-abundance signal was observed for V 10 O 26 anions with a single negative charge, indicating that the presence of abundant V 10 O 26 2− anions in ESI MS reflects gas-phase instability of V 10 O 28 anions carrying two charges. The gas-phase origin of the V 10 O 26 2− anion was confirmed in tandem MS measurements, where mild collisional activation was applied to V10 molecular ions with an even number of hydrogen atoms (H 4 V 10 O 28 2− ), resulting in a facile loss of H 2 O molecules and giving rise to V 10 O 26 2− as the lowest-mass fragment ion. Water loss was also observed for V 10 O 28 anions carrying an odd number of hydrogen atoms ( e.g. , H 5 V 10 O 28 − ), followed by a less efficient and incomplete removal of an OH˙ radical, giving rise to both HV 10 O 26 − and V 10 O 25 − fragment ions. Importantly, at least one hydrogen atom was required for ion fragmentation in the gas phase, as no further dissociation was observed for any hydrogen-free V10 ionic species. The presented workflow allows a distinction to be readily made between the spectral features revealing the presence of non-canonical POM species in the bulk solution from those that arise due to physical and chemical processes occurring in the ESI interface and/or the gas phase. 
    more » « less
  4. Real-time in situ mass spectrometry analysis of airborne particles is important in a number of applications, including exposure studies in ambient air, industrial settings, and assessing impacts on visibility and climate. However, obtaining molecular and 3D structural information is more challenging, especially for heterogeneous solid or semi-solid particles. We report a study of extractive electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (EESI-MS) for the analysis of solid particles with an organic coating. The goal is to elucidate how much of the overall particle content is sampled, and the sensitivity of this technique to the surface layers. It is shown that for NaNO3 particles coated with glutaric acid (GA), very little of the solid NaNO3 core is sampled compared to the GA coating, while for GA particles coated with malonic acid (MA), significant signals from both the MA coating and the GA core are observed. However, conventional ESI-MS of the same samples collected on a Teflon filter and extracted detects much more core material compared to EESI-MS in both cases. These results show that for the experimental conditions used here, EESI-MS does not sample the entire particle, but instead is more sensitive to surface layers. Separate experiments on single component particles of NaNO3, glutaric acid or citric acid show that there must be a kinetics limitation to dissolution that is important in determining EESI-MS sensitivity. We propose a new mechanism of EESI solvent droplet interaction with solid particles that is consistent with the experimental observations. In conjunction with previous EESI-MS studies of organic particles, these results suggest EESI does not necessarily sample the entire particle when solid, and that not only solubility but also surface energies and the kinetics of dissolution play an important role. 
    more » « less
  5. Rationale

    Simple, affordable, and rapid methods for identifying the molecular weight (MW) distribution and macromolecular composition of polymeric materials are limited. Current tools require extensive solvent consumption, linear calibrations, and expensive consumables. A simple method for the determination of average MW (Mn,Mw) and chain end groups is demonstrated for synthetic homopolymer standards using direct injection electrospray ionization‐mass spectrometry (ESI‐MS) and an open‐sourced charge deconvolution (CDC) algorithm.

    Methods

    Five homopolymer standards in the 1–7 kDa MW range were analyzed using direct‐injection ESI‐MS on a quadrupole/time‐of‐flight mass spectrometer. The samples investigated, viz. two poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO) and two poly(styrene sulfonic acid) (PSS) standards with narrow polydispersity and one poly(d,l‐alanine) (pAla) standard with undefined polydispersity, were chosen to illustrate challenges with ESI‐MS quantitation. Using the UniDec program, weight average MWs (Mw) obtained from the charge‐deconvoluted spectra were compared to the reportedMwdata of the standards from size exclusion chromatography (SEC) measurements.

    Results

    The MW data derived for the PSS, PEO, and pAla standards agreed well with the corresponding reportedMwor MW range values. The method was able to provide MW, degree of polymerization (DP), and polydispersity index (PDI) information for polymers with narrow (PSS, PEO) as well as broader (pAla) molecular weight distribution; this feature provides an advantage over MW analysis via matrix‐assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) for ESI‐compatible materials. PSS standards differing in average MW by only a few repeat units could be confidently distinguished. Additionally, the oligomeric resolution observed for all samples studied unveiled chain‐end information not available through chromatographic analysis.

    Conclusions

    Overall, the free and easy‐to‐use UniDec CDC algorithm provides a simple, alternative method to measuring MW and DP for polymeric materials without high solvent consumption, expensive ionization sources, or calibration curves. Information about the masses of individual oligomers and the possibility to further characterize these oligomers using tandem mass spectrometry and/or ion mobility techniques constitutes additional benefits of this approach vis‐à‐vis traditional MW and PDI elucidation through SEC.

     
    more » « less