skip to main content


Title: Paleobiological reconstructions of articular function require all six degrees of freedom
Abstract

Paleobiologists typically exclude impossible joint poses from reconstructions of extinct animals by estimating the rotational range of motion (ROM) of fossil joints. However, this ubiquitous practice carries the assumption that osteological estimates of ROM consistently overestimate true joint mobility. Because studies founded on ROM‐based exclusion have contributed substantially to our understanding of functional and locomotor evolution, it is critical that this assumption be tested. Here, we evaluate whether ROM‐based exclusion is, as currently implemented, a reliable strategy. We measured the true mobilities of five intact cadaveric joints using marker‐based X‐ray Reconstruction of Moving Morphology and compared them to virtual osteological estimates of ROM made allowing (a) only all three rotational, (b) all three rotational and one translational, and (c) all three rotational and all three translational degrees of freedom. We found that allowing combinations of motions in all six degrees of freedom is necessary to ensure that true mobility is always successfully captured. In other words, failing to include joint translations in ROM analyses results in the erroneous exclusion of many joint poses that are possible in life. We therefore suggest that the functional and evolutionary conclusions of existing paleobiological reconstructions may be weakened or even overturned when all six degrees of freedom are considered. We offer an expanded methodological framework for virtual ROM estimation including joint translations and outline recommendations for future ROM‐based exclusion studies.

 
more » « less
PAR ID:
10360290
Author(s) / Creator(s):
 ;  
Publisher / Repository:
Wiley-Blackwell
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Journal of Anatomy
Volume:
239
Issue:
6
ISSN:
0021-8782
Format(s):
Medium: X Size: p. 1516-1524
Size(s):
p. 1516-1524
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Reconstructions of movement in extinct animals are critical to our understanding of major transformations in vertebrate locomotor evolution. Estimates of joint range of motion (ROM) have long been used to exclude anatomically impossible joint poses from hypothesized gait cycles. Here we demonstrate how comparative ROM data can be harnessed in a different way to better constrain locomotor reconstructions. As a case study, we measured nearly 600,000 poses from the hindlimb joints of the Helmeted Guineafowl and American alligator, which represent an extant phylogenetic bracket for the archosaurian ancestor and its pseudosuchian (crocodilian line) and ornithodiran (bird line) descendants. We then used joint mobility mapping to search for a consistent relationship between full potential joint mobility and the subset of joint poses used during locomotion. We found that walking and running poses are predictably located within full mobility, revealing additional constraints for reconstructions of extinct archosaurs. The inferential framework that we develop here can be expanded to identify ROM-based constraints for other animals and, in turn, will help to unravel the history of vertebrate locomotor evolution.

     
    more » « less
  2. In evolutionary biomechanics, musculoskeletal computer models of extant and extinct taxa are often used to estimate joint range of motion (ROM) and muscle moment arms (MMAs), two parameters which form the basis of functional inferences. However, relatively few experimental studies have been performed to validate model outputs. Previously, we built a model of the short-beaked echidna ( Tachyglossus aculeatus ) forelimb using a traditional modelling workflow, and in this study we evaluate its behaviour and outputs using experimental data. The echidna is an unusual animal representing an edge-case for model validation: it uses a unique form of sprawling locomotion, and possesses a suite of derived anatomical features, in addition to other features reminiscent of extinct early relatives of mammals. Here we use diffusible iodine-based contrast-enhanced computed tomography (diceCT) alongside digital and traditional dissection to evaluate muscle attachments, modelled muscle paths, and the effects of model alterations on the MMA outputs. We use X-ray Reconstruction of Moving Morphology (XROMM) to compare ex vivo joint ROM to model estimates based on osteological limits predicted via single-axis rotation, and to calculate experimental MMAs from implanted muscles using a novel geometric method. We also add additional levels of model detail, in the form of muscle architecture, to evaluate how muscle torque might alter the inferences made from MMAs alone, as is typical in evolutionary studies. Our study identifies several key findings that can be applied to future models. 1) A light-touch approach to model building can generate reasonably accurate muscle paths, and small alterations in attachment site seem to have minimal effects on model output. 2) Simultaneous movement through multiple degrees of freedom, including rotations and translation at joints, are necessary to ensure full joint ROM is captured; however, single-axis ROM can provide a reasonable approximation of mobility depending on the modelling objectives. 3) Our geometric method of calculating MMAs is consistent with model-predicted MMAs calculated via partial velocity, and is a potentially useful tool for others to create and validate musculoskeletal models. 4) Inclusion of muscle architecture data can change some functional inferences, but in many cases reinforced conclusions based on MMA alone. 
    more » « less
  3. Abstract

    Our knowledge of vertebrate functional evolution depends on inferences about joint function in extinct taxa. Without rigorous criteria for evaluating joint articulation, however, such analyses risk misleading reconstructions of vertebrate animal motion. Here we propose an approach for synthesizing raycast-based measurements of 3-D articular overlap, symmetry, and congruence into a quantitative “articulation score” for any non-interpenetrating six-degree-of-freedom joint configuration. We apply our methodology to bicondylar hindlimb joints of two extant dinosaurs (guineafowl, emu) and, through comparison with in vivo kinematics, find that locomotor joint poses consistently have high articulation scores. We then exploit this relationship to constrain reconstruction of a pedal walking stride cycle for the extinct dinosaurDeinonychus antirrhopus, demonstrating the utility of our approach. As joint articulation is investigated in more living animals, the framework we establish here can be expanded to accommodate additional joints and clades, facilitating improved understanding of vertebrate animal motion and its evolution.

     
    more » « less
  4. null (Ed.)
    Extant mammals are both taxonomically and ecologically diverse, having evolved a remarkable array of locomotor ecologies (e.g., swimming, digging, and flying). Evolution of the therian-type forelimb, with a highly reduced pectoral girdle and ball-and-socket shoulder joint, has been heralded as a key innovation that enabled mammals to co-opt their forelimbs for diverse functions. The acquisition of the mammal forelimb can be traced through their forerunners, the non-mammalian synapsids (NMS), but exactly how this musculoskeletal transformation proceeded and its impact on functional diversification have not be quantitatively tested. To explore the evolution of forelimb functional diversity in synapsids, we measured shoulder joint osteological range of motion (ROM) in a range of extant amniotes (lizards, monotremes, therian mammals), and compared their patterns of joint mobility to exemplars from each of the major grades of NMS: ‘pelycosaurs’, basal therapsids, and non-mammalian cynodonts. Three-dimensional models of the shoulder girdles and humeri were digitally aligned in an anatomical ‘neutral pose’ using a semi-automated approach based on articular surface morphology. ROM was then determined for the shoulder joint using a fully automated method, where the humerus was moved in flexion-extension, adduction-abduction, and pronation-supination until bone-to-bone contact occurred. Relative degree and directionality of mobility were then compared across taxa. We find an increase in total shoulder joint ROM through synapsid evolution, suggesting that more derived NMS could perform a wider range of limb movements. However, we also see more complex trends in directionality of shoulder mobility that may be indicators of forelimb posture. Extant lepidosaurs and monotremes had the greatest ROM in abduction-adduction, whereas therians had more ROM in flexion-extension, likely related to ‘sprawling’ vs. ‘erect’ gaits. Therapsids and cynodonts both had greatest ROM in abduction-adduction, matching previous reconstructions of these taxa as sprawling to semi-erect. However, ‘pelycosaurs’ had the greatest ROM in flexion-extension, despite having abducted forelimbs, suggesting they did not move their forelimbs in same manner as modern sprawling animals. Our results demonstrate the complex nature of forelimb evolution in synapsids and provide novel insights into the functional transformation and diversification of the mammalian forelimb. Funding Sources Funding information: NSF DEB- 1757749 (S.E.P) and NSF DEB-1754502 (K.D.A). 
    more » « less
  5. Abstract

    Compliant mechanisms with reconfigurable degrees of freedom are gaining attention in the development of kinesthetic haptic devices, robotic systems, and mechanical metamaterials. However, available devices exhibit limited programmability and form-customizability, restricting their versatility. To address this gap, we propose a metastructure concept featuring reconfigurable motional freedom and tunable stiffness, adaptable to various form factors and applications. These devices incorporate passive flexures and actively stiffness-changing rods to modify kinematic freedom. A rational design pipeline informs the flexures’ topological arrangements, geometric parameters, and control signals based on targeted mobilities, enabling the creation of unitary joints with up to six degrees of freedom. Our demonstrative application examples include a wrist device that has an effective stiffness of 0.370 Nm/deg (unlocked state, 5% displacement) to 2.278 Nm/deg (locked state, 1% displacement) to enable dynamic joint mobility control, a haptic thimble device (2.27-52.815 Nmm−1at 1% displacement) that mimics the sensation of touching physical materials ranging from soft gel to metal surfaces, and a wearable device composed of multiple joints tailored for the arm and hand to augment haptic experiences or facilitate muscle training. We believe the presented method can help democratize compliant metastructures development and expand their versatility for broader contexts.

     
    more » « less