skip to main content

Title: Multiple Environmental Influences on the Lightning of Cold-Based Continental Convection. Part II: Sensitivity Tests for Its Charge Structure and Land–Ocean Contrast

In Part I, an electrification scheme was described and a simulation of an observed cold-based storm from the U.S. Great Plains was validated with electrical observations. Most charge in the storm was separated by rebounding collisions of secondary ice originating from prior graupel–snow collisions. In this Part II, sensitivity tests are performed with the control simulation (Part I) and influences from environmental factors (aerosols, temperature, moisture, and shear) on lightning are elucidated. Environmental factors [e.g., convective available potential energy (CAPE)] controlling updraft speed are salient. When ascent is reduced by 30% and 70%, flashes become 70% fewer and disappear, respectively; faster ascent promotes positive cloud-to-ground (+CGs) flashes. Since cloud base is too cold (1°C) for coalescence, cloud condensation nucleus aerosol concentrations do not influence the lightning appreciably. The electrical response to varying concentrations of active ice nuclei is limited by most ice particles being secondary and less sensitive—a natural “buffer.” Imposing a maritime sounding suggests that the land–sea contrast in lightning for such storms is due to the vertical structure of environmental temperature and humidity. Weak CAPE, and both entrainment and condensate weight from a low cloud base, suppress ascent and charging. Maritime thermodynamic conditions reduce simulated flash rates by two orders of magnitude. Reducing aerosol loadings from continental to maritime only slightly reinforces this suppression. Last, a conceptual model is provided for how any simulated storm is either normal because graupel/hail is mostly positively charged or else is inverted/anomalous because graupel/hail is mostly negatively charged, with environmental factors controlling the charging. Impacts from microphysical processes, including three processes of secondary ice production, on lightning are analyzed.

more » « less
Author(s) / Creator(s):
Publisher / Repository:
American Meteorological Society
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences
Page Range / eLocation ID:
p. 263-300
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract

    We gridded 11 years of cloud‐to‐ground (CG) flashes detected by the U.S. National Lightning Detection Network during the warm season in 15 km × 15 km × 15 min grid cells to identify storms with substantial CG flash rates clearly dominated by flashes lowering one polarity of charge to the ground or the other (+CG flashes vs. −CG flashes). Previous studies in the central United States had found that the gross charge distribution of storms dominated by +CG flashes included a large upper negative charge over a large middle level positive charge, a reversal of the usual polarities. In each of seven regions spanning the contiguous United States (CONUS), we compared 17 environmental parameters of storms dominated by +CG flashes with those of storms dominated by –CG flashes. These parameters were chosen based on their expected roles in modulating supercooled liquid water content (SLWC) in the updraft because laboratory experiments have shown that SLWC affects the polarity of charge exchanged during rebounding collisions between riming graupel and small ice particles in the mixed phase region. This, in turn, would affect the vertical polarity of a storm's charge distribution and the dominant polarity of CG flashes. Our results suggest that the combination of parameters conducive to dominant +CG flash activity and, by inference, to anomalous storm charge structure varies widely from region to region, the lack of a favorable value of any particular parameter in a given region being offset by favorable values of one or more other parameters.

    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    Exceptionally high‐energy lightning strokes >106 J (X1000 stronger than average) in the very low‐frequency band between 5 and 18 kHz, also known as superbolts (SB), occur mostly during winter over the North‐East Atlantic, the Mediterranean Sea, and over the Altiplano in South America. Here we compare the World‐Wide Lightning Location Network database with meteorological and aerosol data to examine the causes of lightning stroke high energies. Our results show that the energy per stroke increases sharply as the distance between the cloud'scharging zone(where the cloud electrification occurs) and the surface decreases. Since thecharging zoneoccurs above the 0°C isotherm, this distance is shorter when the 0°C isotherm is closer to the surface. This occurs either due to cold air mass over the ocean during winter or high surface altitude in the Altiplano during summer thunderstorms. Stroke energy decreases with the warm phase of the cloud, as proxied by the cloud base temperature, and increases with a more developed cloud, as proxied by the cloud top temperature, but to a much lesser extent than the distance between the surface and 0°C isotherm. Aerosols play no significant role. It is hypothesized that a shorter distance between thecharging zoneand the ground represents less electrical resistance that allows stronger discharge currents.

    more » « less
  3. Abstract

    A supercell thunderstorm formed as part of a cluster of severe storms near Kingfisher, Oklahoma on May 29, 2012 during the Deep Convective Clouds and Chemistry field experiment. This storm produced 5 hail, an EF‐1 tornado, and copious lightning over the course of a few hours within range of the Oklahoma Lightning Mapping Array and the KTLX WSR‐88D radar. This study focuses on a ∼1‐h interval during which a line of secondary convection formed and intensified within the anvil of the Kingfisher supercell. An analysis of radar reflectivity, radial velocity, and low‐level divergence shows that the formation of the secondary convection was consistent with a previously proposed mechanism; the instability leading to the convection was initiated by diabatic cooling in dry air below the anvil from sublimation, melting and evaporation of virga falling from the anvil, coincident with weak rising motion above a surface outflow boundary adjacent to the sub‐anvil downdraft. Prior to the formation of the secondary convection, flashes extended up to 60 km from the deep convection into the anvil. After the line of secondary convection formed, it initiated long lightning flashes that propagated along the line, and it continued to produce lightning as it moved eastward out from under the anvil. The charge structure inferred from flashes in the parent storm and in the downstream anvil suggests that charge was separated locally in the anvil following the development of an outflow boundary by the Kingfisher storm, which also contributed to the initiation of the secondary convection.

    more » « less
  4. Abstract

    A developing supercell storm on 29–30 May 2012 in north‐central Oklahoma was observed with the Oklahoma Lightning Mapping Array (OKLMA) and three mobile radars. The storm's vertical charge structure inferred from the OKLMA was anomalous overall but varied considerably even within 10 km of the bounded weak echo region (BWER) and the bounded weak lightning region (BWLR) or lightning hole. Near the BWER, three distinct charge structures were observed—an inverted dipole, an inverted tripole, and a bottom‐heavy normal tripole. One column within each structure was analyzed relative to the Doppler‐derived wind field and environmental properties derived by a diabatic Lagrangian analysis (DLA). Within each column, back trajectories of graupel and hail particles additionally illustrate the history of the diagnosed in‐cloud microphysical properties, which are expected to influence noninductive electrification and may have contributed to the observed charge profiles. This study objectively demonstrates the complicated scenarios presented by the three‐dimensional motions around and through the updraft and provides likely constraints on how each of the three distinct vertical charge distributions could have been produced within this focused region of the storm.

    more » « less
  5. Abstract

    In this study we explored the environmental conditions hypothesized to induce a dominant charge structure in thunderstorms in the province of Cordoba, Argentina, during the RELAMPAGO‐CACTI (Remote sensing of Electrification, Lightning, And Mesoscale/microscale Processes with Adaptive Ground Observations‐Clouds, Aerosols, Complex Terrain Interactions) field campaigns. Hypothesized environmental conditions are thought to be related to small warm cloud residence time and warm rain growth suppression, which lead to high cloud liquid water contents in the mixed‐phase zone, contributing to positive charging of graupel and anomalous charge structure storms. Data from radiosondes, a cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) ground‐based instrument and reanalysis were used to characterize the proximity inflow air of storms with anomalous and normal charge structures. Consistent with the initial hypothesis, anomalous storms had small warm cloud depth caused by dry low‐level humidity and low 0°C height. Anomalous storms were associated with lower CCN concentrations than normal storms, an opposite result to the initial expectation. High CAPE is not an important condition for the development of anomalous storms in Argentina, as no clear pattern could be found among the different parameters calculated for updraft proxy that would be consistent with the initial hypothesis.

    more » « less