skip to main content


Title: A Flux‐Based Threshold for Anaerobic Activity in the Ocean
Abstract

Anaerobic microbial activity in the ocean causes losses of bioavailable nitrogen and emission of nitrous oxide to the atmosphere, but its predictability at global scales remains limited. Resource ratio theory suggests that anaerobic activity becomes sustainable when the ratio of oxygen to organic matter supply is below the ratio required by aerobic metabolisms. Here, we demonstrate the relevance of this framework at the global scale using three‐dimensional ocean datasets, providing a new interpretation of existing observations. Evaluations of the location and extent of anoxic zones and a diagnostic rate of pelagic nitrogen loss are consistent with previous estimates. However, we demonstrate that a threshold based on substrate‐supply fluxes is qualitatively different from a threshold based solely on the ambient oxygen concentration. This implies that use of the flux‐based threshold in global biogeochemical models can result in different predictions of anaerobic activity and nitrogen loss.

 
more » « less
NSF-PAR ID:
10367078
Author(s) / Creator(s):
 ;  ;  ;  
Publisher / Repository:
DOI PREFIX: 10.1029
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Geophysical Research Letters
Volume:
48
Issue:
5
ISSN:
0094-8276
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract

    Nitrite is a pivotal component of the marine nitrogen cycle. The fate of nitrite determines the loss or retention of fixed nitrogen, an essential nutrient for all organisms. Loss occurs via anaerobic nitrite reduction to gases during denitrification and anammox, while retention occurs via nitrite oxidation to nitrate. Nitrite oxidation is usually represented in biogeochemical models by one kinetic parameter and one oxygen threshold, below which nitrite oxidation is set to zero. Here we find that the responses of nitrite oxidation to nitrite and oxygen concentrations vary along a redox gradient in a Pacific Ocean oxygen minimum zone, indicating niche differentiation of nitrite-oxidizing assemblages. Notably, we observe the full inhibition of nitrite oxidation by oxygen addition and nitrite oxidation coupled with nitrogen loss in the absence of oxygen consumption in samples collected from anoxic waters. Nitrite-oxidizing bacteria, including novel clades with high relative abundance in anoxic depths, were also detected in the same samples. Mechanisms corresponding to niche differentiation of nitrite-oxidizing bacteria across the redox gradient are considered. Implementing these mechanisms in biogeochemical models has a significant effect on the estimated fixed nitrogen budget.

     
    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    Large‐scale loss of oxygen under global warming is termed “ocean deoxygenation” and is caused by the imbalance between physical supply and biological consumption of oxygen in the ocean interior. Significant progress has been made in the theoretical understanding of ocean deoxygenation; however, many questions remain unresolved. The oxygen change in the tropical thermocline is poorly understood, with diverging projections among different models. Physical oxygen supply is controlled by a suite of processes that transport oxygen‐rich surface waters into the interior ocean, which is expected to weaken due to increasing stratification under global warming. Using a numerical model and a series of sensitivity experiments, the role of ocean mixing is examined in terms of effects on the mean state and the response to a transient warming. Both vertical and horizontal (isopycnal) mixing coefficients are systematically varied over a wide range, and the resulting oxygen distributions in equilibrated and transient simulations are examined. The spatial patterns of oxygen loss are sensitive to both vertical and isopycnal mixing, and the sign of tropical oxygen trend under climate warming can reverse depending on the choice of mixing parameters. An elevated level of isopycnal mixing disrupts the vertical advective‐diffusive balance of the tropical thermocline, increasing the mean state oxygen as well as the magnitude of the transient oxygen decline. These results provide first‐order explanations for the diverging behaviors of simulated tropical oxygen with respect to ocean mixing parameters.

     
    more » « less
  3. Conway, T. ; Fitzsimmons, J. ; Middag, R ; Noble, T. ; Planquette, H. (Ed.)

    Because nitrogen availability limits primary production over much of the global ocean, understanding the controls on the marine nitrogen inventory and supply to the surface ocean is essential for understanding biological productivity and exchange of greenhouse gases with the atmosphere. Quantifying the ocean’s inputs, outputs, and internal cycling of nitrogen requires a variety of tools and approaches, including measurements of the nitrogen isotope ratio in organic and inorganic nitrogen species. The marine nitrogen cycle, which shapes nitrogen availability and speciation in the ocean, is linked to the elemental cycles of carbon, phosphorus, and trace elements. For example, the majority of nitrogen cycle oxidation and reduction reactions are mediated by enzymes that require trace metals for catalysis. Recent observations made through global-scale programs such as GEOTRACES have greatly expanded our knowledge of the marine nitrogen cycle. Though much work remains to be done, here we outline key advances in understanding the marine nitrogen cycle that have been achieved through these analyses, such as the distributions and rates of dinitrogen fixation, terrestrial nitrogen inputs, and nitrogen loss processes.

     
    more » « less
  4. Abstract

    Nitrite is a central molecule in the nitrogen cycle because nitrite oxidation to nitrate (an aerobic process) retains fixed nitrogen in a system and its reduction to dinitrogen gas (anaerobic) reduces the fixed nitrogen inventory. Despite its acknowledged requirement for oxygen, nitrite oxidation is observed in oxygen-depleted layers of the ocean’s oxygen minimum zones (OMZs), challenging the current understanding of OMZ nitrogen cycling. Previous attempts to determine whether nitrite-oxidizing bacteria in the anoxic layer differ from known nitrite oxidizers in the open ocean were limited by cultivation difficulties and sequencing depth. Here, we construct 31 draft genomes of nitrite-oxidizing bacteria from global OMZs. The distribution of nitrite oxidation rates, abundance and expression of nitrite oxidoreductase genes, and relative abundance of nitrite-oxidizing bacterial draft genomes from the same samples all show peaks in the core of the oxygen-depleted zone (ODZ) and are all highly correlated in depth profiles within the major ocean oxygen minimum zones. The ODZ nitrite oxidizers are not found in the Tara Oceans global dataset (the most complete oxic ocean dataset), and the major nitrite oxidizers found in the oxygenated ocean do not occur in ODZ waters. A pangenomic analysis shows the ODZ nitrite oxidizers have distinct gene clusters compared to oxic nitrite oxidizers and are microaerophilic. These findings all indicate the existence of nitrite oxidizers whose niche is oxygen-deficient seawater. Thus, specialist nitrite-oxidizing bacteria are responsible for fixed nitrogen retention in marine oxygen minimum zones, with implications for control of the ocean’s fixed nitrogen inventory.

     
    more » « less
  5. null (Ed.)
    Abstract. Decreasing concentrations of dissolved oxygen in the ocean are considered one of the main threats to marine ecosystems as they jeopardize the growthof higher organisms. They also alter the marine nitrogen cycle, which isstrongly bound to the carbon cycle and climate. While higher organisms ingeneral start to suffer from oxygen concentrations < ∼ 63 µM (hypoxia), the marine nitrogen cycle responds to oxygenconcentration below a threshold of about 20 µM (microbial hypoxia),whereas anoxic processes dominate the nitrogen cycle at oxygenconcentrations of < ∼ 0.05 µM (functionalanoxia). The Arabian Sea and the Bay of Bengal are home to approximately21 % of the total volume of ocean waters revealing microbial hypoxia.While in the Arabian Sea this oxygen minimum zone (OMZ) is also functionallyanoxic, the Bay of Bengal OMZ seems to be on the verge of becoming so. Eventhough there are a few isolated reports on the occurrence of anoxia prior to1960, anoxic events have so far not been reported from the open northernIndian Ocean (i.e., other than on shelves) during the last 60 years.Maintenance of functional anoxia in the Arabian Sea OMZ with oxygenconcentrations ranging between > 0 and ∼ 0.05 µM is highly extraordinary considering that the monsoon reverses thesurface ocean circulation twice a year and turns vast areas of the ArabianSea from an oligotrophic oceanic desert into one of the most productiveregions of the oceans within a few weeks. Thus, the comparably lowvariability of oxygen concentration in the OMZ implies stable balancesbetween the physical oxygen supply and the biological oxygen consumption,which includes negative feedback mechanisms such as reducing oxygenconsumption at decreasing oxygen concentrations (e.g., reduced respiration).Lower biological oxygen consumption is also assumed to be responsible for aless intense OMZ in the Bay of Bengal. According to numerical model results,a decreasing physical oxygen supply via the inflow of water masses from thesouth intensified the Arabian Sea OMZ during the last 6000 years, whereas areduced oxygen supply via the inflow of Persian Gulf Water from the northintensifies the OMZ today in response to global warming. The first issupported by data derived from the sedimentary records, and the latterconcurs with observations of decreasing oxygen concentrations and aspreading of functional anoxia during the last decades in the Arabian Sea.In the Arabian Sea decreasing oxygen concentrations seem to have initiated aregime shift within the pelagic ecosystem structure, and this trend is alsoseen in benthic ecosystems. Consequences for biogeochemical cycles are asyet unknown, which, in addition to the poor representation of mesoscalefeatures in global Earth system models, reduces the reliability of estimatesof the future OMZ development in the northern Indian Ocean. 
    more » « less