skip to main content


Title: Models of Resonant Wave‐Particle Interactions
Abstract

Radiation belt electrons are strongly affected by resonant interactions with cyclotron‐resonant waves. For broad band, small amplitude waves the interactions are well described by quasi‐linear diffusion in pitch angle and energy, but coherent, large amplitude waves such as strong whistler mode chorus call for a different treatment. The standard nonlinear framework reduces the problem to that of a classical pendulum. This picture has generally been confirmed by many numerical simulations, but recent studies have uncovered additional, complex behavior, not captured by the pendulum model, for particles with low pitch angle. We show that avoiding a commonly made approximation leads to a more general but still tractable “second fundamental model” Hamiltonian, which involves not one but two regions of phase trapping. We analyze its phase portraits in detail, and perform representative test particle simulations with slowly changing parameters. We find that the trajectories encompass traditional phase bunching and phase trapping as well as additional behavior best understood using the new model.

 
more » « less
NSF-PAR ID:
10374582
Author(s) / Creator(s):
 ;  ;  ;  ;  
Publisher / Repository:
DOI PREFIX: 10.1029
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Journal of Geophysical Research: Space Physics
Volume:
126
Issue:
6
ISSN:
2169-9380
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Radiation belt electrons are strongly affected by resonant interactions with cyclotron-resonant waves. In the case of a particle passing through resonance with a single, coherent wave, a Hamiltonian formulation is advantageous. With certain approximations, the Hamiltonian has the same form as that for a plane pendulum, leading to estimates of the change at resonance of the first adiabatic invariant I , energy, and pitch angle. In the case of large wave amplitude (relative to the spatial variation of the background magnetic field), the resonant change in I and its conjugate phase angle ξ are not diffusive but determined by nonlinear dynamics. A general analytical treatment of slow separatrix crossing has long been available and can be used to give the changes in I associated with “phase bunching,” including the detailed dependence on ξ , in the nonlinear regime. Here we review this treatment, evaluate it numerically, and relate it to previous analytical results for nonlinear wave-particle interactions. “Positive phase bunching” can occur for some particles even in the pendulum Hamiltonian approximation, though the fraction of such particles may be exponentially small. 
    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    We use test particle simulations to model the interaction between radiation belt electrons and whistler mode chorus waves by focusing on wave amplitude modulations. We quantify the pitch angle and energy changes due to phase trapping and phase bunching (including both advection and scattering) for electrons with various initial energies and pitch angles. Three nonlinear regimes are identified in a broad range of pitch angle‐energy space systematically, each indicating different nonlinear effects. Our simulation results show that wave amplitude modulations can extend the nonlinear regimes, while significantly reducing electron acceleration by phase trapping. By including amplitude modulations, the “advective” changes in pitch angle and energy caused by phase bunching are reduced, while the “diffusive” scattering due to phase bunching is enhanced. Our study demonstrates the importance of wave amplitude modulations in nonlinear effects and suggests that they need to be properly incorporated into future theoretical and numerical studies.

     
    more » « less
  3. Abstract

    The electron resonant interaction with whistler‐mode waves is characterized by transport in pitch angle–energy space. We calculate electron diffusion and advection coefficients (a simplified characterization of transport) for a large range of electron pitch angle and energy using test particle simulations. Nonlinear effects are analyzed by comparing the diffusion coefficients using test particle simulations and quasilinear theory, and by evaluating the advection rates. Dependence of nonlinear effects on the wave amplitude and bandwidth of whistler‐mode waves is evaluated by running test particle simulations with a broad range of wave amplitude and bandwidth. The maximum amplitudes where the quasilinear approach is valid are found to increase with increasing bandwidth, from 50 pT for narrowband waves to 300 pT for broadband waves atL‐shell of 6. Moreover, interactions between intense whistler‐mode waves and small pitch angle electrons lead to large positive advection, which limits the applicability of diffusion‐based models. This study demonstrates the parameter range of the applicability of quasilinear theory and diffusion model for different wave amplitudes and frequency bandwidths of whistler‐mode waves, which is critical for evaluating the effects of whistler‐mode waves on energetic electrons in the Earth’s magnetosphere.

     
    more » « less
  4. This work compares several versions of the equations of motion for a test particle encountering cyclotron resonance with a single, field-aligned whistler mode wave. The gyro-averaged Lorentz equation produces both widespread phase trapping (PT) and “positive phase bunching” of low pitch angle electrons by large amplitude waves. Approximations allow a Hamiltonian description to be reduced to a single pair of conjugate variables, which can account for PT as well as phase bunching at moderate pitch angle, and has recently been used to investigate this unexpected bahavior at low pitch angle. Here, numerical simulations using the Lorentz equation and several versions of Hamiltonian-based equations of motion are compared. Similar behavior at low pitch angle is found in each case. 
    more » « less
  5. This study analyzes the effects of electromagnetic ion cyclotron (EMIC) waves on relativistic electron scattering and losses in the Earth’s outer radiation belt. EMIC emissions are commonly observed in the inner magnetosphere and are known to reach high amplitudes, causing significant pitch angle changes in primarily > 1 MeV electrons via cyclotron resonance interactions. We run test-particle simulations of electrons streaming through helium band waves with different amplitudes and wave normal angles and assess the sensitivity of advective and diffusive scattering behaviors to these two parameters, including the possibility of very oblique propagation. The numerical analysis confirms the importance of harmonic resonances for oblique waves, and the very oblique waves are observed to efficiently scatter both co-streaming and counter-streaming electrons. However, strong finite Larmor radius effects limit the scattering efficiency at high pitch angles. Recently discussed force-bunching effects and associated strong positive advection at low pitch angles are, surprisingly, shown to cause no decrease in the phase space density of precipitating electrons, and it is demonstrated that the transport of electrons into the loss cone balances out the scattering out of the loss cone. In the case of high-amplitude obliquely propagating waves, weak but non-negligible losses are detected well below the minimum resonance energy, and we identify them as the result of non-linear fractional resonances. Simulations and theoretical analysis suggest that these resonances might contribute to subrelativistic electron precipitation but are likely to be overshadowed by non-resonant effects. 
    more » « less