skip to main content


Title: A paradox of parasite resistance: disease-driven trophic cascades increase the cost of resistance, selecting for lower resistance with parasites than without them
Award ID(s):
1655656 2010826
NSF-PAR ID:
10384187
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Evolutionary Ecology
ISSN:
0269-7653
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Rice resistance (R) genes have been effectively deployed to prevent blast disease caused by the fungal pathogen Magnaporthe oryzae, one of the most serious threats for stable rice production worldwide. Weedy rice competing with cultivated rice may carry novel or lost R genes. The quantitative trait locus qBR12.3b was previously mapped between two single nucleotide polymorphism markers at the 10,633,942-bp and 10,820,033-bp genomic positions in a black-hull-awned (BHA) weed strain using a weed-crop-mapping population under greenhouse conditions. In this study, we found a portion of the known resistance gene Ptr encoding a protein with four armadillo repeats and confers a broad spectrum of blast resistance. We then analyzed the sequences of the Ptr gene from weedy rice, PtrBHA, and identified a unique amino acid glutamine at protein position 874. Minor changes of protein conformation of the PtrBHAgene were predicted through structural analysis of PtrBHA, suggesting that the product of PtrBHAis involved in disease resistance. A gene-specific codominant marker HJ17-13 from PtrBHAwas then developed to distinguish alleles in weeds and crops. The PtrBHAgene existed in 207 individuals of the same mapping population, where qBR12.3b was mapped using this gene-specific marker. Disease reactions of 207 individuals and their parents to IB-33 were evaluated. The resistant individuals had PtrBHAwhereas the susceptible individuals did not, suggesting that HJ17-13 is reliable to predict qBR12.3b. Taken together, this newly developed marker, and weedy rice genotypes carrying qBR12.3b, are useful for blast improvement using marker assisted selection.

     
    more » « less
  2. Theory often predicts that host populations should evolve greater resistance when parasites become abundant. Furthermore, that evolutionary response could ameliorate declines in host populations during epidemics. Here, we argue for an update: when all host genotypes become sufficiently infected, higher parasite abundance can select for lower resistance because its cost exceeds its benefit. We illustrate such a “resistance is futile” outcome with mathematical and empirical approaches. First, we analyzed an eco-evolutionary model of parasites, hosts, and hosts’ resources. We determined eco-evolutionary outcomes for prevalence, host density, and resistance (mathematically, “transmission rate”) along ecological and trait gradients that alter parasite abundance. With high enough parasite abundance, hosts evolve lower resistance, amplifying infection prevalence and decreasing host density. In support of these results, a higher supply of nutrients drove larger epidemics of survival-reducing fungal parasites in a mesocosm experiment. In two-genotype treatments, zooplankton hosts evolved less resistance under high-nutrient conditions than under low-nutrient conditions. Less resistance, in turn, was associated with higher infection prevalence and lower host density. Finally, in an analysis of naturally occurring epidemics, we found a broad, bimodal distribution of epidemic sizes consistent with the resistance is futile prediction of the eco-evolutionary model. Together, the model and experiment, supplemented by the field pattern, support predictions that drivers of high parasite abundance can lead to the evolution of lower resistance. Hence, under certain conditions, the most fit strategy for individual hosts exacerbates prevalence and depresses host populations. 
    more » « less
  3. null (Ed.)
    Antimicrobial resistance is a well-documented public health concern. The role that drinking water distribution pipes have as sources of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) is not well known. Metals are a known stressor for antibiotic resistance development, implying that aging metal-pipe infrastructure could be a source of ARGs. The objective of this study was to determine if ARGs, metal resistance genes (MRGs), and intI 1 were pervasive across various pipe biofilm sample types (biomass surfaces, pipe surfaces, corrosion tubercles, and under corrosion tubercles) and if the resistance genes associated with particular microbial taxa. Eight sample types in triplicate ( n = 24) were taken from inside a >100 year-old, six ft. section of a full-scale chloraminated cast iron drinking water main. Droplet digital PCR (ddPCR) was employed as a novel approach to quantify ARGs in pipes from full-scale drinking water distribution systems (DWDS) because it yielded higher detection frequencies than quantitative PCR (qPCR). Illumina sequencing was employed to characterize the microbial community based on 16S rRNA genes. ARGs and MRGs were detected in all 24 pipe samples. Every sample contained targeted genes. Interestingly, the mean absolute abundances of ARGs and MRGs only varied by approximately one log value across sample types, but the mean relative abundances (copy numbers normalized to 16S rRNA genes) varied by over two log values. The ARG and MRGs concentrations were not significantly different between sample types, despite significant changes in dominant microbial taxa. The most abundant genera observed in the biofilm communities were Mycobacterium (0.2–70%), and β-lactam resistance genes bla TEM , bla SHV , and the integrase gene of class 1 integrons ( intI 1) were positively correlated with Mycobacterium . The detection of ARGs, MRGs, and class 1 integrons across all sample types within the pipe indicates that pipes themselves can serve as sources for ARGs in DWDS. Consequently, future work should investigate the role of pipe materials as well as corrosion inhibitors to determine how engineering decisions can mitigate ARGs in drinking water that stem from pipe materials. 
    more » « less