An official website of the United States government
Dispositions, along with skills and knowledge, form the three components of competency-based education. Moreover, studies have shown dispositions to be necessary for a successful career. However, unlike evidence-based teaching and learning approaches for knowledge acquisition and skill development, few studies focus on translating dispositions into observable behavioral patterns. An operationalization of dispositions, however, is crucial for students to understand and achieve respective learning outcomes in computing courses. This paper describes a multi-institutional study investigating students’ understanding of dispositions in terms of their behaviors while completing coursework. Students in six computing courses at four different institutions filled out a survey describing an instance of applying each of the five surveyed dispositions (adaptable, collaborative, persistent, responsible, and self-directed) in the courses’ assignments. The authors evaluated data by using Mayring’s qualitative content analysis. The result was a coding scheme with categories summarizing students’ concepts of dispositions and how they see themselves applying dispositions in the context of computing. These results are a first step in understanding dispositions in computing education and how they manifest in student behavior. This research has implications for educators developing new pedagogical approaches to promote and facilitate dispositions. Moreover, the operationalized behaviors constitute a starting point for new assessment strategies of dispositions.
more »
« less
Computing Students’ Understanding of Dispositions: A Qualitative Study
Dispositions, along with skills and knowledge, form the three components of competency-based education. Moreover, studies have shown dispositions to be necessary for a successful career. However, unlike evidence-based teaching and learning approaches for knowledge acquisition and skill development, few studies focus on translating dispositions into observable behavioral patterns. An operationalization of dispositions, however, is crucial for students to understand and achieve respective learning outcomes in computing courses. This paper describes a multi-institutional study investigating students’ understanding of dispositions in terms of their behaviors while completing coursework. Students in six computing courses at four different institutions filled out a survey describing an instance of applying each of the five surveyed dispositions (adaptable, collaborative, persistent, responsible, and self-directed) in the courses’ assignments. The authors evaluated data by using Mayring’s qualitative content analysis. The result was a coding scheme with categories summarizing students’ concepts of dispositions and how they see themselves applying dispositions in the context of computing. These results are a first step in understanding dispositions in computing education and how they manifest in student behavior. This research has implications for educators developing new pedagogical approaches to promote and facilitate dispositions. Moreover, the operationalized behaviors constitute a starting point for new assessment strategies of dispositions.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2216121
- PAR ID:
- 10415576
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Proceedings of the 28th ACM Conference on Innovation and Technology in Computer Science Education
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Dispositions, skills, and knowledge form the three components of competency-based education. Moreover, dispositions are considered crucial for students to succeed in the workplace. Few studies investigate how dispositions manifest in the form of observable behaviors, which causes challenges for both students and educators. Computing students, for example, may not understand what is expected of them, and how to achieve dispositions. This paper presents the results of a qualitative, multi-institutional study on students’ understanding of the dispositions adaptable, persistent, self-directed, meticulous, and professional. Perceptions were gathered by asking for exemplary situations of students applying each of the five dispositions in the context of assignments within computing courses. Students who indicated they did not apply the disposition were asked to describe the hindering circumstances. The data was evaluated by using Mayring’s content analysis technique, resulting in the development of deductive-inductive categories of observable behaviors reflecting the student’s perspective. For meticulous and professional, new categories representing observable behaviors were developed. For adaptable, persistent, and self-directed, the authors confirmed and extended prior work. Moreover, factors hindering students in applying the investigated dispositions are identified. The resulting categories with observable student behaviors are an important step toward the operationalization of competency-based learning outcomes including dispositions. A common understanding of dispositions will also help with the design of new forms of instruction and measures to foster the application of dispositions in the context of computing education.more » « less
-
This full research paper contributes to current work on fostering professional dispositions in computing and engineering education by identifying the categories of behaviors that students associate with dispositions while doing course work. Professional dispositions, demonstrated through desirable behaviors in the workplace, such as being persistent or self-directed, are explicitly sought by employers. Fostering dispositions among students has been identified in various curricular recommendations as an important goal. In prior work, the authors used reflection exercises, in which students were presented with the definition of a disposition and asked to answer an open-ended reflection prompt on how they applied the disposition in their own work. Thematic analysis of student responses to reflection exercises resulted in categories of behaviors that students associated with dispositions. In the work discussed in this paper, the authors used vignette exercises to collect and analyze similar data and gain further insight into behavioral categories and students’ perceptions of dispositions. Vignettes include short scenarios that demonstrate the application of dispositions in real life. A vignette exercise involves students reading a vignette scenario, identifying the disposition demonstrated by the scenario, and answering the same open-ended reflection prompt as in the reflection exercises from the earlier studies. The research question for this study is: Which behavioral categories obtained from analyzing student responses to reflection exercises were confirmed using vignette exercises (and which were not confirmed), and which behavioral categories were refined? To answer this question, researchers from four different institutions of higher education collected data in multiple courses over two semesters. The student open-ended responses to vignettes were thematically analyzed to identify behavioral categories for four dispositions: collaborative, meticulous, persistent and self-directed. The ultimate goal of this work is to create classroom interventions and learning activities that foster dispositions among students based on behavioral categories. This study supports this goal in two ways. It provides another iteration of behavioral category analysis and introduces vignettes to encourage students to reflect candidly and communicate clearly how they apply dispositions in terms of behaviors. The study results and their implications for fostering dispositions in a classroom setting are presented and discussed.more » « less
-
Vignettes are short stories along with a set of questions that engage the reader to comment on the story. Vignettes have been used in professional academic programs (e.g., teacher preparation and medical education), for professional development in various fields (e.g., teaching ethics in psychology and medicine), and in various research fields for data collection. In this work, vignettes are used to elicit students' understanding of dispositions in computing education. Professional dispositions enable behaviors that are valued in the workplace, such as adaptability or self-directedness. They are often explicitly stated in computing job postings. While the relevance of dispositions is widely recognized in the workplace, only recently have curricular guidelines for computing programs recognized professional dispositions as an integral part of competencies and as complementary to knowledge and skills. There is scarce literature on the use of vignettes in teaching undergraduate computing, or on how best to foster dispositions in students. In this project, four faculty from four diverse institutions in the U.S., along with three consulting experts, have collaborated to design and evaluate the use of vignettes in the classroom. This paper documents researchers' efforts to gain insights into students' perceptions of dispositions through the use of vignettes. Such insights may guide educators to identify pedagogical strategies for fostering dispositions among students. This paper presents an iterative process for vignette design with continuous review by researchers and focus group members. The vignettes in this study use stories of situations which demonstrate the application of a disposition, drawn from various fields and walks of life to represent diverse groups and experiences. Students are presented with the vignette story and asked to identify the disposition illustrated. To elicit students' understanding of dispositions in terms of their personal behaviors, students are asked to describe a situation in which they have experienced the disposition. Lessons learned in the design and use of vignettes are discussed.more » « less
-
Dispositions are cultivable behaviors desirable in the workplace. Examples of dispositions are being adaptable, meticulous, and self-directed. The eleven dispositions described in the CC2020 report should not be confused with the professional knowledge of computing topics, or with skills, including technical skills, along with cross-disciplinary skills such as critical thinking, problem-solving, teamwork, or communication. Dispositions, more inherent to human characteristics, identify personal qualities and behavioral patterns important for successful professional careers. The leaders of this special session collaborate on a multi-institutional project funded by the National Science Foundation. Using their experiences at four higher education institutions, they will demonstrate how to foster dispositions among computing students through two hands-on activities. The audience will get first-hand experience using reflection exercises and vignettes, and will participate in debating their design, merits, and limitations. The resulting interaction will provide the audience ample time to discuss the benefits and challenges of incorporating and fostering dispositions in computing programs. It is hoped that participants will leave with concrete ideas on how to extend the current work to their own courses, programs, and institutions.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Conference Paper:
- The DOI is not currently available.
