skip to main content


Title: Cross-Feedings, Competition, and Positive and Negative Synergies in a Four-Species Synthetic Community for Anaerobic Degradation of Cellulose to Methane
ABSTRACT Complex interactions exist among microorganisms in a community to carry out ecological processes and adapt to changing environments. Here, we constructed a quad-culture consisting of a cellulolytic bacterium ( Ruminiclostridium cellulolyticum ), a hydrogenotrophic methanogen ( Methanospirillum hungatei ), an acetoclastic methanogen ( Methanosaeta concilii ), and a sulfate-reducing bacterium ( Desulfovibrio vulgaris ). The four microorganisms in the quad-culture cooperated via cross-feeding to produce methane using cellulose as the only carbon source and electron donor. The community metabolism of the quad-culture was compared with those of the R. cellulolyticum -containing tri-cultures, bi-cultures, and mono-culture. Methane production was higher in the quad-culture than the sum of the increases in the tri-cultures, which was attributed to a positive synergy of four species. In contrast, cellulose degradation by the quad-culture was lower than the additive effects of the tri-cultures which represented a negative synergy. The community metabolism of the quad-culture was compared between a control condition and a treatment condition with sulfate addition using metaproteomics and metabolic profiling. Sulfate addition enhanced sulfate reduction and decreased methane and CO 2 productions. The cross-feeding fluxes in the quad-culture in the two conditions were modeled using a community stoichiometric model. Sulfate addition strengthened metabolic handoffs from R. cellulolyticum to M. concilii and D. vulgaris and intensified substrate competition between M. hungatei and D. vulgaris . Overall, this study uncovered emergent properties of higher-order microbial interactions using a four-species synthetic community. IMPORTANCE A synthetic community was designed using four microbial species that together performed distinct key metabolic processes in the anaerobic degradation of cellulose to methane and CO 2 . The microorganisms exhibited expected interactions, such as cross-feeding of acetate from a cellulolytic bacterium to an acetoclastic methanogen and competition of H 2 between a sulfate reducing bacterium and a hydrogenotrophic methanogen. This validated our rational design of the interactions between microorganisms based on their metabolic roles. More interestingly, we also found positive and negative synergies as emergent properties of high-order microbial interactions among three or more microorganisms in cocultures. These microbial interactions can be quantitatively measured by adding and removing specific members. A community stoichiometric model was constructed to represent the fluxes in the community metabolic network. This study paved the way toward a more predictive understanding of the impact of environmental perturbations on microbial interactions sustaining geochemically significant processes in natural systems.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1911781
NSF-PAR ID:
10436734
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ;
Editor(s):
Zhao, Liping; Bello, Maria Gloria
Date Published:
Journal Name:
mBio
Volume:
14
Issue:
2
ISSN:
2150-7511
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract

    In freshwater wetlands, competitive and cooperative interactions between respiratory, fermentative and methanogenic microbes mediate the decomposition of organic matter. These interactions may be disrupted by saltwater intrusion disturbances that enhance the activity of sulfate-reducing bacteria (SRB), intensifying their competition with syntrophic bacteria and methanogens for electron donors. We simulated saltwater intrusion into wetland soil microcosms and examined biogeochemical and microbial responses, employing metabolic inhibitors to isolate the activity of various microbial functional groups. Sulfate additions increased total carbon dioxide production but decreased methane production. Butyrate degradation assays showed continued (but lower) levels of syntrophic metabolism despite strong demand by SRB for this key intermediate decomposition product and a shift in the methanogen community toward acetoclastic members. One month after removing SRB competition, total methane production recovered by only ∼50%. Similarly, butyrate assays showed an altered accumulation of products (including less methane), although overall rates of syntrophic butyrate breakdown largely recovered. These effects illustrate that changes in carbon mineralization following saltwater intrusion are driven by more than the oft-cited competition between SRB and methanogens for shared electron donors. Thus, the impacts of disturbances on wetland biogeochemistry are likely to persist until cooperative and competitive microbial metabolic interactions can recover fully.

     
    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    Deep marine sediments (>1mbsf) harbor ~26% of microbial biomass and are the largest reservoir of methane on Earth. Yet, the deep subsurface biosphere and controls on its contribution to methane production remain underexplored. Here, we use a multidisciplinary approach to examine methanogenesis in sediments (down to 295 mbsf) from sites with varying degrees of thermal alteration (none, past, current) at Guaymas Basin (Gulf of California) for the first time. Traditional (13C/12C and D/H) and multiply substituted (13CH3D and 12CH2D2) methane isotope measurements reveal significant proportions of microbial methane at all sites, with the largest signal at the site with past alteration. With depth, relative microbial methane decreases at differing rates between sites. Gibbs energy calculations confirm methanogenesis is exergonic in Guaymas sediments, with methylotrophic pathways consistently yielding more energy than the canonical hydrogenotrophic and acetoclastic pathways. Yet, metagenomic sequencing and cultivation attempts indicate that methanogens are present in low abundance. We find only one methyl-coenzyme M (mcrA) sequence within the entire sequencing dataset. Also, we identify a wide diversity of methyltransferases (mtaB, mttB), but only a few sequences phylogenetically cluster with methylotrophic methanogens. Our results suggest that the microbial methane in the Guaymas subsurface was produced over geologic time by relatively small methanogen populations, which have been variably influenced by thermal sediment alteration. Higher resolution metagenomic sampling may clarify the modern methanogen community. This study highlights the importance of using a multidisciplinary approach to capture microbial influences in dynamic, deep subsurface settings like Guaymas Basin.

     
    more » « less
  3. Dubilier, Nicole (Ed.)
    ABSTRACT

    Prochlorococcusis an abundant photosynthetic bacterium in the open ocean, where nitrogen (N) often limits phytoplankton growth. In the low-light-adapted LLI clade ofProchlorococcus, nearly all cells can assimilate nitrite (NO2), with a subset capable of assimilating nitrate (NO3). LLI cells are maximally abundant near the primary NO2maximum layer, an oceanographic feature that may, in part, be due to incomplete assimilatory NO3reduction and subsequent NO2release by phytoplankton. We hypothesized that someProchlorococcusexhibit incomplete assimilatory NO3reduction and examined NO2accumulation in cultures of threeProchlorococcusstrains (MIT0915, MIT0917, and SB) and twoSynechococcusstrains (WH8102 and WH7803). Only MIT0917 and SB accumulated external NO2during growth on NO3. Approximately 20–30% of the NO3transported into the cell by MIT0917 was released as NO2, with the rest assimilated into biomass. We further observed that co-cultures using NO3as the sole N source could be established for MIT0917 andProchlorococcusstrain MIT1214 that can assimilate NO2but not NO3. In these co-cultures, the NO2released by MIT0917 is efficiently consumed by its partner strain, MIT1214. Our findings highlight the potential for emergent metabolic partnerships that are mediated by the production and consumption of N cycle intermediates withinProchlorococcuspopulations.

    IMPORTANCE

    Earth’s biogeochemical cycles are substantially driven by microorganisms and their interactions. Given that N often limits marine photosynthesis, we investigated the potential for N cross-feeding within populations ofProchlorococcus, the numerically dominant photosynthetic cell in the subtropical open ocean. In laboratory cultures, someProchlorococcuscells release extracellular NO2during growth on NO3. In the wild,Prochlorococcuspopulations are composed of multiple functional types, including those that cannot use NO3but can still assimilate NO2. We show that metabolic dependencies arise whenProchlorococcusstrains with complementary NO2production and consumption phenotypes are grown together on NO3. These findings demonstrate the potential for emergent metabolic partnerships, possibly modulating ocean nutrient gradients, that are mediated by cross-feeding of N cycle intermediates.

     
    more » « less
  4. Abstract

    Documenting anaerobic microbial metabolisms in hypersaline perennially ice‐covered lakes in Antarctica further refines the environmental limits to life and may reveal rare biogeochemical mechanisms and/or novel microbial catalysts of elemental cycling. We assessed rates of sulfate reduction, methanogenesis, and anaerobic oxidation of methane using radiotracers and generated 16S rRNA gene libraries from the microbial communities inhabiting the deep calcium‐chloride‐rich brine and sediments of Lake Vanda, McMurdo Dry Valleys, Antarctica. Sulfate reduction rates were observed in surface sediments but not in the brine overlying the sediments. Methane formation through the methylotrophic, acetoclastic, and hydrogenotrophic pathways was quantified using14C‐labeled methylamine, acetate, and CO2, respectively, and methanogenesis was detected in both the brine and the sediments. Hydrogenotrophic methanogenesis rates were the highest of all substrates tested in the sediments, while methylotrophic methanogenesis was highest in the brines. Anaerobic oxidation of methane was below the limit of detection in both the brines and sediments. The major taxa ofBacteriaandArchaeadetected were most similar to organisms previously observed in hypersaline environments and included examples related to known sulfate‐reducing bacteria other thanDeltaproteobacteria(surprisingly, sulfate‐reducingDeltaproteobacteriawere not observed in this study), and both methanogenic and methanotrophicArchaea. These data indicate an active microbial community in the anoxic brine of Lake Vanda that while similar in terms of community structure and metabolism to other brine habitats, is uniquely evolved to survive in this extreme environment.

     
    more » « less
  5. Abstract

    Anaerobic fungi and methanogenic archaea are two classes of microorganisms found in the rumen microbiome that metabolically interact during lignocellulose breakdown. Here, stable synthetic co-cultures of the anaerobic fungusCaecomyces churrovisand the methanogenMethanobacterium bryantii(not native to the rumen) were formed, demonstrating that microbes from different environments can be paired based on metabolic ties. Transcriptional and metabolic changes induced by methanogen co-culture were evaluated inC. churrovisacross a variety of substrates to identify mechanisms that impact biomass breakdown and sugar uptake. A high-quality genome ofC. churroviswas obtained and annotated, which is the first sequenced genome of a non-rhizoid-forming anaerobic fungus.C. churrovispossess an abundance of CAZymes and carbohydrate binding modules and, in agreement with previous studies of early-diverging fungal lineages, N6-methyldeoxyadenine (6mA) was associated with transcriptionally active genes. Co-culture with the methanogen increased overall transcription of CAZymes, carbohydrate binding modules, and dockerin domains in co-cultures grown on both lignocellulose and cellulose and caused upregulation of genes coding associated enzymatic machinery including carbohydrate binding modules in family 18 and dockerin domains across multiple growth substrates relative toC. churrovismonoculture. Two other fungal strains grown on a reed canary grass substrate in co-culture with the same methanogen also exhibited high log2-fold change values for upregulation of genes encoding carbohydrate binding modules in families 1 and 18. Transcriptional upregulation indicated that co-culture of theC. churrovisstrain with a methanogen may enhance pyruvate formate lyase (PFL) function for growth on xylan and fructose and production of bottleneck enzymes in sugar utilization pathways, further supporting the hypothesis that co-culture with a methanogen may enhance certain fungal metabolic functions. Upregulation of CBM18 may play a role in fungal–methanogen physical associations and fungal cell wall development and remodeling.

     
    more » « less