<?xml-model href='http://www.tei-c.org/release/xml/tei/custom/schema/relaxng/tei_all.rng' schematypens='http://relaxng.org/ns/structure/1.0'?><TEI xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0">
	<teiHeader>
		<fileDesc>
			<titleStmt><title level='a'>Principal Blocks for Different Primes, II</title></titleStmt>
			<publicationStmt>
				<publisher></publisher>
				<date>2022</date>
			</publicationStmt>
			<sourceDesc>
				<bibl> 
					<idno type="par_id">10438307</idno>
					<idno type="doi">10.1007/s10013-022-00594-z</idno>
					<title level='j'>Vietnam Journal of Mathematics</title>
<idno>2305-221X</idno>
<biblScope unit="volume"></biblScope>
<biblScope unit="issue"></biblScope>					

					<author>Gabriel Navarro</author><author>Noelia Rizo</author><author>A. A. Schaeffer Fry</author>
				</bibl>
			</sourceDesc>
		</fileDesc>
		<profileDesc>
			<abstract><ab><![CDATA[Abstract                          If              G              is a finite group, we have proposed three new conjectures on the interaction between different primes and their corresponding Brauer principal blocks. In this paper,we give strong support to the validity of Conjectures B and C.]]></ab></abstract>
		</profileDesc>
	</teiHeader>
	<text><body xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="1">Introduction</head><p>Meaningful interaction between the representation theory of finite groups from the perspective of different primes is extremely rare. However, in <ref type="bibr">[26]</ref>, we proposed the following three plausible conjectures, which extended work of several authors (see <ref type="bibr">[3,</ref><ref type="bibr">16,</ref><ref type="bibr">19,</ref><ref type="bibr">29]</ref>).</p><p>If p is a prime and G is a finite group, we denote by B p (G) the principal p-block of G. The main subject of our work is the set Irr p (B p (G)) of the irreducible complex characters in the principal p-block of G whose degree is not divisible by p. This set seems to possess remarkable properties.</p><p>Conjecture A Let G be a finite group and let p and q be different primes. If Irr p (B p (G)) &#8745; Irr q (B q (G)) = {1 G }, that the statement holds. Then <ref type="bibr">[19,</ref>] further imply that we may assume S to be a simple group of Lie type that is not isomorphic to a sporadic or alternating group and is defined in characteristic r 0 &#8712; {p, q}. (We remark that this information was first found in <ref type="bibr">[2]</ref>.) So, let S be of the form S = G/Z(G) for G a group of Lie type of simply connected type defined in characteristic r 0 = p, q. In this case, we may further assume that p and q are both odd and that the Sylow pand q-subgroups of G are abelian, using <ref type="bibr">[19,</ref><ref type="bibr">Proposition 3.5]</ref> (see also <ref type="bibr">[2,</ref><ref type="bibr">Theorem 2.1]</ref>).</p><p>Since p and q are odd, note that we may therefore assume without loss that p &#8805; 5. Furthermore, using [18, Lemma 2.1 and Proposition 2.2], we have p is good for G and p |Z(G)|. This implies that p does not divide the order of any diagonal or graph outer automorphism, so that Aut(S) p may be taken as a subgroup of S F , where F is a generating field automorphism. Now, let t be a p-element in G * whose G * -class is F P -invariant. Then the semisimple character &#967; t of G lies in B p (G) by <ref type="bibr">[12,</ref><ref type="bibr">Corollary 3.4</ref>] and has degree prime to p since &#967; t <ref type="bibr">(1)</ref> = [G * : C G * (t)] r 0 (see e.g. <ref type="bibr">[5,</ref><ref type="bibr">Theorem 8.4.8]</ref>) and Sylow p-subgroups of G * are abelian. But since &#967; t lies in the Lusztig series E(G, t) and B q (G) contains only characters lying in Lusztig series E(G, s) with |s| a power of q (see <ref type="bibr">[4,</ref><ref type="bibr">Theorem 9</ref>.12]), we see that &#967; t does not lie in Irr(B q (S)). Furthermore, as p |Z(G)|, we have t &#8712; O p (G * ), and hence &#967; t is trivial on Z(G). Finally, since p |Z(G)|, we also have C G * (t) is connected, where G * is the ambient reductive group whose fixed points under an appropriate Frobenius endomorphism yields G * (see <ref type="bibr">[21,</ref><ref type="bibr">Exercise 20.16]</ref>). Then for &#981; &#8712; F , we have &#967; &#981; t = &#967; t &#981; * , where &#981; * is an appropriate field automorphism of G * (see <ref type="bibr">[28,</ref><ref type="bibr">Corollary 2.5]</ref>). Hence &#967; t is Aut(G) P -invariant by our choice of t. Lemma 2.2 Suppose that N is a minimal normal subgroup of G, which is a direct product of the different G-conjugates of a non-abelian simple group S. Let P &#8712; Syl p <ref type="bibr">(G)</ref>. Suppose that &#945; &#8712; Irr(S) is Aut(S) p -invariant, where Aut(S) p is some Sylow p-subgroup of Aut(S). Then there are g i &#8712; G, h i &#8712; P and &#963; i &#8712; Aut(S g i ) such that (&#945; g 1 ) &#963;</p><p>Proof Suppose that N is the direct product of = {S g | g &#8712; G}. Now, write</p><p>where O(S i ) is the P -orbit of some S i = S x i , for some x i &#8712; G.</p><p>where N i is the product of the elements in O(S i ). Let us fix an i until the end of the proof. Of course, N i is P -invariant. Let &#945; i = &#945; x i &#8712; Irr(S i ). Suppose that {S y 1 i , . . . , S y r i } are the different P -conjugates of S i , where y j &#8712; P . Hence</p><p>i , and</p><p>By hypothesis, &#945; is invariant under X &#8712; Syl p (Aut(S)). Therefore &#945; i is invariant under</p><p>We have that M i /C i embeds into Aut(S i ). Then N P (S i )C i /C i is a p-subgroup of Aut(S i ), and therefore, there</p><p>We will need the following well-known result of J. Alperin and E. C. Dade.</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head>Theorem 2.3</head><p>Suppose that N is a normal subgroup of G, with G/N a p -group. Let P &#8712; Syl p (G) and assume that G = N C G (P ). Then restriction of characters defines a natural bijection between the irreducible characters of the principals p-blocks of G and N .</p><p>Proof The case where G/N is solvable was proved in <ref type="bibr">[1]</ref> and the general case in <ref type="bibr">[7]</ref>.</p><p>Theorem 2.4 Assume that the "only if" direction of Conjecture C is true for all finite groups. Let p and q be primes. Assume that G is a finite group of order divisible by p and q. If Irr p (B p (G)) = Irr q (B q (G)), then p = q.</p><p>Proof We argue by induction on |G|. Assume that p = q. By Conjecture C, we know that [P , Q] = 1 for some P &#8712; Syl p (G) and Q &#8712; Syl q (G).</p><p>Step 0. If</p><p>Otherwise by [23, Theorem 9.9(c)]</p><p>and by induction we are done.</p><p>Step 1. Let L be a proper normal subgroup of G. Then G/L has order divisible by p or q. Suppose that G/L has p and q -order. We claim that Irr p (B p (L)) = Irr q (B q (L)). Indeed, let &#952; &#8712; Irr q (B q (L)). Then there exists &#967; &#8712; Irr(B q (G)) over &#952;. Then &#967; has qdegree by <ref type="bibr">[15,</ref><ref type="bibr">Theorem 11.29</ref>] and therefore &#967; &#8712; Irr p (B p (G)), by hypothesis. Therefore &#952; &#8712; Irr p (B p (L)). By symmetry, the claim is proved. Therefore, Step 1 follows by using the inductive hypothesis.</p><p>Step 2. Let N be a minimal normal subgroup of G and suppose that N is an elementary abelian p-group.</p><p>Step 3. Let N be a minimal normal subgroup of G and suppose that N is abelian. Then G = C G (N ).</p><p>By Step 0, we may assume that N is a p-group or a q-group. By symmetry, assume that N is a p-group. Write M = C G (N ). We prove first that B p (G) is the only p-block of G covering B p (M). Let B be a p-block of G covering B p (M) and let D be a defect group of B. Then N &#8838; D by <ref type="bibr">[23,</ref><ref type="bibr">Theorem 4.8]</ref> and <ref type="bibr">Lemma 9.20]</ref>) and hence by <ref type="bibr">[23,</ref><ref type="bibr">Theorem 9.19]</ref> we have that B = B p (M) G = B p (G) by the third main theorem (see <ref type="bibr">[23,</ref><ref type="bibr">Theorem 6.7]</ref>). Hence B p (G) is the only p-block of G covering B p (M). In particular, we have that Irr(G/M) &#8838; Irr(B p (G)).</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head>Next, we prove that</head><p>Hence by Theorem 2.3, we have that the restriction map res : Irr(B q (G)) &#8594; Irr(B q (M)) is a bijection. We claim that Irr p (G/M) = {1 G }. Indeed, if &#967; &#8712; Irr p (G/M), then &#967; &#8712; Irr p (B p (G)) = Irr q (B q (G)). Therefore, we have that &#967; M is irreducible and since &#967; lies over 1 M we have &#967; M = 1 M . Hence &#967; = 1 G by the injectivity of the restriction map. Thus</p><p>Step 4. Let N be a minimal normal subgroup of G, then N is not abelian. Suppose the contrary and assume without loss of generality that N is an elementary abelian p-group, so by Step 3 we have G = C G (N ) and N &#8838; Z(G). By <ref type="bibr">[23,</ref><ref type="bibr">Theorem 9.10]</ref> we have that B p (G/N ) is the unique p-block of G/N contained in B p (G). We claim that Irr p (B p (G/N )) = Irr q (B q (G/N )). Indeed, we have that</p><p>where we have used <ref type="bibr">[23,</ref><ref type="bibr">Theorem 9.9]</ref> in the last equality. On the other hand, let &#967; &#8712; Irr q (B q (G/N )), so &#967; &#8712; Irr q (B q (G)) = Irr p (B p (G)) and N &#8838; Ker(&#967; ). Since B p (G/N ) is the only p-block of G/N contained in B p (G), we have that &#967; &#8712; Irr p (B p (G/N )) and the claim is proven. By using the inductive hypothesis, we have that p does not divide |G/N |. Therefore, {1 G } = Irr(B p (G/N )) = Irr p (B p (G/N )) = Irr q (B q (G/N )) and q |G/N | by <ref type="bibr">[26,</ref><ref type="bibr">Lemma 2.1]</ref>). Hence q |G| and this is a contradiction.</p><p>Step 5. Let N be a minimal normal subgroup of G, then pq divides |N |. Suppose that N is a p -group. We claim first that NQ does not have a normal qcomplement. Indeed, suppose the contrary and let X NQ be a normal q-complement.</p><p>Then N &#8745; X is a normal q-complement of N and by the minimality of N we have that either</p><p>, which is a contradiction with Step 4. Therefore NQ does not have a normal q-complement. By <ref type="bibr">[13,</ref><ref type="bibr">Corollary 3]</ref> there is &#964; &#8712; Irr(B q (QN )) non-linear of q -degree. Therefore 1 = &#964; N &#8712; Irr q (B q (N )). By <ref type="bibr">[22,</ref><ref type="bibr">Lemma 4.3]</ref> we have that there is some &#947; &#8712; Irr q (B q (G)) lying over &#964; N . By hypothesis, we have that &#947; is in the principal p-block of G, and therefore &#964; N is in the principal p-block of N , which is a contradiction since N is a p -group and &#964; N = 1.</p><p>Final Step. If N is a minimal normal subgroup of G, then N is semisimple by Step 4. Suppose that N is a direct product of all the different G-conjugates of a simple group S of order divisible by pq. Suppose that (a) of Theorem 2.1 holds and let &#945; be the character in Irr p (B p (S)) (not in Irr(B q (S))) which is Aut(S) p -invariant. Notice that any G-conjugate or Aut(G)-conjugate of &#945; is in the principal p-block and not in the principal q-block of S. By Lemma 2.2, there exists &#964; &#8712; Irr p (B p (N )) which is P -invariant, and such that each of its factors does not belong to the principal q-block. In particular, &#964; does not belong to the principal q-block of N . Now &#964; extends to P N by <ref type="bibr">[14,</ref><ref type="bibr">Corollary 8.16]</ref>. By <ref type="bibr">[22,</ref><ref type="bibr">Lemma 4.3]</ref> there is &#967; &#8712; Irr p (B p (G)) lying over &#964; . Then &#967; &#8712; Irr q (B q (G)) and thus &#964; &#8712; Irr q (B q (N )), which is a contradiction. Assuming (b) in Theorem 2.1 and reasoning analogously we get again a contradiction.</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="3">Conjecture C and p-Solvable Groups</head><p>As of the writing of this article, we can only prove Conjecture C for p-solvable groups by assuming the so called Inductive Alperin-McKay condition (for the prime q). We shall need the following. such that for each &#952;&#8712;Irr p (B p (N )), there is a bijection f &#952; :</p><p>Proof This is Theorem B and Theorem 7.1 of <ref type="bibr">[27]</ref>.</p><p>Let us remark that we shall only need Theorem 3.1 in the case where G/N is a p -group.</p><p>In our proof, we shall also need a McKay divisibility theorem, which was made possible after M. Geck proved a remarkable conjecture on Glauberman correspondents <ref type="bibr">[9]</ref>.</p><p>In the following, we follow the proof of [30, Theorem A], and then use Geck's result. Let S/K = O p (G/K), and notice that P 0 = P &#8745; S is a Sylow p-subgroup of S. By the Frattini argument we have that G = KN G (P 0 ) and N G (P 0 ) &lt; G since O p (G) = 1. Let &#952; 1 , . . . , &#952; s be a complete set of representatives of the orbits of the action of N G (P ) on the P -invariant irreducible characters of K. By [25, Lemma 9.3], we have that</p><p>is a disjoint union. Fix &#952; i &#8712;Irr(K) and observe that &#952; i is also P 0 -invariant. Let &#952; * i &#8712; Irr(C K (P 0 )) be the Glauberman correspondent of &#952; i (see [25, Theorem 2.9], for instance) and let T i be the stabilizer of &#952; i in G. Since the Glauberman correspondence and the action of N G (P 0 ) commute (see <ref type="bibr">[25,</ref><ref type="bibr">Lemma 2.10]</ref>), it follows that <ref type="formula">1</ref>). Hence we have that &#968; * (1) divides &#968;(1) by the main result of <ref type="bibr">[9]</ref>. Moreover, since G = N G (P 0 )K we have that |K :</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head>Again as in the proof of [30, Theorem A] we obtain a bijection</head><p>The remaining part of the proof proceeds exactly as in the proof of [30, Theorem A].</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head>Theorem 3.3 Let G be a finite p-solvable group. Assume that the inductive Alperin-McKay condition (for q) holds for every non-abelian simple group involved in G.</head><p>Then Conjecture C is true for G. In particular, Conjecture C holds for {p, q}-solvable groups.</p><p>Proof By <ref type="bibr">[19]</ref>, we only need to prove that if all Irr p (B p (G)) have q -degree and all Irr q (B q (G)) have p -degree, then [P , Q] = 1 for some P &#8712; Syl p (G) and Q &#8712; Syl q (G).</p><p>Let N be a normal subgroup of G. Since the hypothesis is satisfied by G/N , by induction, we know that [P , Q] &#8838; N for some P &#8712; Syl p (G) and Q &#8712; Syl q (G).</p><p>Suppose that O p (G) = 1. Then we know that Irr(B p (G)) = Irr(G), by Theorem 10.20 of <ref type="bibr">[23]</ref>. Hence, all the irreducible characters in Irr p (G) have q -degree. Let L = O p (G) and let P &#8712; Syl p (G) and Q &#8712; Syl q (G) such that [P , Q] &#8838; L. Therefore Q normalizes P and |G : N G (P )| is not divisible by q. By Theorem 3.2, we have that all characters in Irr(N G (P )/P ) have q -degree. By the It&#244;-Michler theorem we have that QP is normal in N G (P ), and hence [QP , P ] &#8838; P . Then Q acts trivially on P /P , and therefore Q acts trivially on P by coprime action (see <ref type="bibr">[15,</ref><ref type="bibr">Corollary 3.29]</ref>). Thus [Q, P ] = 1 and we are done in this case.</p><p>Suppose that</p><p>We claim that all the irreducible characters in Irr q (B q (N G (Q))) have p -degree. Indeed, let &#967; * &#8712; Irr q (B q (N G (Q))) and let &#952; * &#8712; Irr q (B q (N L (Q))) under &#967; * . Let &#952; &#8712; Irr q (B q (L)) be the pre-image of &#952; * given by the bijection in Theorem 3.1. Again using Theorem 3.1, let &#967; &#8712; Irr(B q (G)|&#952;) be such that f &#952; (&#967; ) = &#967; * , so we know that</p><p>.</p><p>Then &#967;(1)/&#952;(1) is not divisible by q and thus &#967; &#8712; Irr q (B q (G)). By hypothesis, &#967;(1) is not divisible by p. Hence &#967; * (1)/&#952; * (1) is not divisible by p, and therefore, since &#952; * is of p -degree we have that &#967; * (1) is not divisible by p, and the claim follows. Let X = O q (N G (Q)). Then all the elements in Irr(N G (Q)/Q X) = Irr q (B q (N G (Q))) have degree not divisible by p. By the It&#244;-Michler theorem, we have that this group has a normal Sylow p-subgroup (which is a Sylow p-subgroup of G, since |G :</p><p>We thank the referee for pointing out the "in particular" in Theorem 3.3 above. In fact, this observation by the referee gives a different proof of Theorem E in <ref type="bibr">[26]</ref>, something which we have not noticed before.</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="4">Conjecture C and Simple Groups</head><p>As we have mentioned in the Introduction, we note that the "if" direction of Conjecture C follows from the work of Malle-Navarro in <ref type="bibr">[19]</ref>, namely <ref type="bibr">[19,</ref><ref type="bibr">Theorem 4</ref>.1]. Hence we focus on the "only if" direction. First, we consider the cases easily dealt with in GAP: Proposition 4.1 Conjecture C holds for sporadic simple groups, alternating and symmetric groups A n and S n with n &#8804; 8, the Tits group 2 F 4 (2) , G 2 (2) , and groups of Lie type with exceptional Schur multipliers.</p><p>Proof This can be seen using <ref type="bibr">[8]</ref> and its Character Table <ref type="table">Library</ref>.</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="4.1">Conjecture C for Alternating and Symmetric Groups</head><p>Here we prove Conjecture C in the case of alternating groups A n and symmetric groups S n . Note that it follows from <ref type="bibr">[19,</ref><ref type="bibr">Proposition 3.3</ref>] that [P , Q] = 1 for every Sylow p-subgroup P and Sylow q-subgroup Q of S n or A n . Proposition 4.2 Let G be an alternating or symmetric group A n or S n with n &#8805; 9 and let p, q be primes dividing |G|. Then either there exists &#967; &#8712; Irr p (B p (S)) with degree divisible by q or there exists &#967; &#8712; Irr q (B q (S)) with degree divisible by p.</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head>The Strategy</head><p>We first recall some facts and give the basic idea of the proof. The set Irr(S n ) is indexed by partitions of n, and two characters &#967; &#955; , &#967; &#956; corresponding to partitions &#955;, &#956; lie in the same p-block if &#955;, &#956; have the same p-core (and similar for q). In particular, writing n = pm + b with 0 &#8804; b &lt; p, the set Irr(B p (S n )) consists of the characters &#967; &#955; such that &#955; has p-core (b). Furthermore, recall that the degree of the character &#967; &#955; is given by the hooklength formula &#967; &#955; (1)</p><p>, where the denominator is the product of all hooklengths in the tableau corresponding to the partition &#955;. Furthermore, if &#955; is not self-conjugate, then the corresponding character restricts irreducibly to A n .</p><p>So, our strategy will be (up to switching p and q) to illustrate a non-self-conjugate partition &#955; of n with p-core (b) such that the numerator in the hooklength formula has the same p-part as the denominator and larger q-part than the denominator. Our proof will require several technical cases and analysis of the degrees given by the hooklength formula.</p><p>Setting Notation Throughout our proof, we will assume without loss that q &lt; p. We will write mp = wq + r with 0 &#8804; r &lt; q, and let n = mp + b with 0 &#8804; b &lt; p. Note that we may assume that m &gt; 1, since otherwise a Sylow p-subgroup is abelian, and the result follows from [10, Theorem 3.5], together with the principal block version of Brauer's height zero conjecture <ref type="bibr">[20]</ref>. In studying the degrees of the characters that we construct, several expressions will appear repeatedly. Hence we define once and for all:</p><p>which we see are each relatively prime to p. It will also be useful to set the p-adic and q-adic expansions of mp: Let</p><p>with t i &lt; t i+1 , s j &lt; s j +1 , 0 &lt; a i &lt; q, and 0 &lt; b j &lt; p for each appropriate value of i, j . With these established, we further define</p><p>.</p><p>Note that mp = a 1 q t 1 , since p a 1 . In the situation that the expression X becomes relevant, we will see that also mp = b 1 p s 1 . Finally, for an integer x, we will write (x) p (or just x p if it is clear) for the p-part of x.</p><p>Proof of Proposition 4.2 Keep the notation above.</p><p>(I) First, suppose that r &gt; 0. If b = 0, so that n = mp, then consider &#955; = (1 mp-r-1 , 1 + r). Then &#967; &#955; &#8712; Irr(B p (S n )) and &#967; &#955; (1) = Z , which is p but divisible by q since mpr = wq and r &lt; q. If b = 0 and 0 &lt; r &lt; b,</p><p>mp-r+b . Note that the q-part of the numerator of Y must be at least as large as the q-part of the denominator. (Each remainder modulo b appears once as a factor in the numerator.) Hence, this character still has degree that is p and divisible by q, with the possible exception of if q | b and b!(wq + b) has larger q-part than (mp + 1)</p><p>In the latter case, (1 mp , b), giving degree Y , works instead.</p><p>If b = r &gt; 0, note that r + 1 &lt; wq, as otherwise we would have r = q -1 and w = 1 = m, contradicting our assumption that m &gt; 1. Then let &#955; = (1 r , r + 1, wq -1), so that &#967; &#955; (1) = Z &#8226; Z &#8226; (wqr -1)/(2r + 1), which is p and divisible by q unless 2r + 1 = p and p | (m -1) or if 2r + 1 = q and q w. In the latter cases, the partition (1 wq-2 , 1 + r, 1 + r) works, unless we were in the case 2r + 1 = p with p | (m -1) and r + 1 = q with q w. In this case, if q = 2 (and hence r = 1), take &#955; = (1 mp , r), which corresponds to a character &#967; &#955; that lies in B p (S n ) and has degree Y = (mp + 1) &#8226; &#8226; &#8226; (mp + r -1)/(q -2)!. This is relatively prime to p, and is divisible by q since there must be a number between mp and mp + q -1 = mp + r divisible by q, but neither mp = (w + 1)q -1 nor n = mp + r = wq + 2q -2 can be divisible by q. If q = 2, we have r = 1, q = 2, p = 3, and the character corresponding to (1 n-2 , 2) lies in B 2 (S n ) and has degree n -1 = 3m = 2w + 1, which is odd and divisible by 3.</p><p>From now on, we may therefore assume that r = 0, so that mp = wq.</p><p>(II) First, assume that a 1 q t 1 &lt; b 1 p s 1 . If b = 0, so n = mp = wq, consider &#955; = (1 mp-a 1 q t 1 -1 , 1 + a 1 q t 1 ). Then the corresponding degree is X, which we see is equal to</p><p>Note that the q-part of this is q t 2 /q t 1 , which is divisible by q. Furthermore, the p-part is 1, since a 1 q t 1 &lt; b 1 p s 1 implies that the p-part of -i + b 1 p s 1 + &#8226; &#8226; &#8226; + b k p s k is the same as that of i for 1 &#8804; i &#8804; a 1 q t 1 . Now suppose that b &gt; 0, so n = mp + b = wq + b. If a 1 q t 1 = b, consider either (1 mp-a 1 q t 1 -1 , 1 + a 1 q t 1 , b) or (1 mp-a 1 q t 1 -1 , 1 + b, a 1 q t 1 ), depending on whether b is larger or smaller than a 1 q t 1 . Then the corresponding character lies in B p (S n ) and has degree X&#8226;Y &#8226; |b-a 1 q t 1 | n-a 1 q t 1 . Note that since a 1 q t 1 &lt; b 1 p s 1 , the p-part of |b-a 1 q t 1 | p &#8804; p s 1 , and from this we see |b-a 1 q t 1 | and n-a 1 q t 1 = mp+b-a 1 q t 1 have the same p-part. Hence this character is a member of Irr p (B p (S n )). Furthermore, its degree is still divisible by q, except possibly if |ba 1 q t 1 | q &lt; (na 1 q t 1 ) q . This can only happen if (b) q &#8805; q t 2 . In the latter case, consider again the partition (1 mp , b). The degree is Y and hence we have removed mp+b b from the expression Y , which is p and, from before, has q-part of the numerator at least as large as that of the denominator. Since in our situation (mp + b) q = q t 1 &lt; q t 2 &#8804; (b) q , this degree Y is also divisible by q.</p><p>Now assume b = a 1 q t 1 . If b+1 = p or p (m-1), we take &#955; = (1 mp-b-2 , b+1, b+1), with &#967; &#955; <ref type="bibr">(1)</ref> </p><p>. Then &#967; &#955; &#8712; Irr(B p (S n )) and p &#967; &#955; <ref type="bibr">(1)</ref> due to the assumption b + 1 = p or m -1 is not divisible by p. Furthermore, &#967; &#955; (1) is divisible by q since the q-part of the numerators of each of the two fractions is at least that of the denominators, as before, and in this case, the factor (mp-b) is divisible by q t 2 , but no factor in the denominator is. Now, if p = b+1 = 1+a 1 q t 1 and p | (m-1), this forces also b 1 p s 1 = p, as mp-p = b i p s i -p must be divisible by p 2 . Here consider the partition (1 mp-p , b+ p), which gives a character with degree (mp</p><p>Note that the only factor in the numerator divisible by p is mp, which is divisible by p exactly once. Then since the denominator is divisible by p, we see this character lies in Irr p (B p (S n )). Furthermore, since mpp + 1 = i&#8805;2 a i q t i in this case, we see</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head>and that mp-p+1</head><p>p+b-1 = i&#8805;2 a i q t i 2a 1 q t 1 is divisible by q except possibly if q = 2 and t 2 = t 1 + 1. In the latter case, the character corresponding to (1 mp-1 , b + 1), which has degree</p><p>lies in Irr 2 (B 2 (S n )) and has degree divisible by p.</p><p>(III) Finally, suppose that a 1 q t 1 &gt; b 1 p s 1 . Note here that mp = b 1 p s 1 , as mp &#8805; a 1 q t 1 . If b = 0, then reversing the roles of p and q in the corresponding case in (II) above yields a character in B q (S n ) with degree X , which is relatively prime to q but divisible by p.</p><p>Hence we assume b &gt; 0, so n = mp + b = wq + b. Note here that b = w q + b for some integers w , b with 0 &#8804; b &lt; q, and B q (S n ) consists of those characters whose corresponding partitions have q-core (b ). Now, the partition</p><p>Note that the third factor is not divisible by p nor q, since p b and b 1 p s 1b &lt; a 1 q t 1 so b 1 p s 1b and nb 1 p s 1 = mp -(b 1 p s 1b) have the same q-part. Furthermore, p Y , and also q Y as long as b &lt; (qa 1 )q t 1 . So if b &lt; (qa 1 )q t 1 , this character lies in Irr q (B q (S n )) with degree divisible by p.</p><p>So, we now assume that q | Y , so b &#8805; (qa 1 )q t 1 . Then the partition</p><p>, which is divisible by q and is relatively prime to p if b + 1 = p or p (m -1). Hence we may now assume that further p = b + 1 and p | (m -1). Then setting &#955; = (1 mp , b) yields &#967; &#955; &#8712; Irr(B p (S n )) and &#967; &#955; (1) = Y , which is prime to p. Since q | Y , we have q | Y unless q | b and (mp + b) q &gt; (b) q , which forces b = (qa 1 )q t 1 .</p><p>So we are reduced to the case q Y , b = (qa 1 )q t 1 = p -1, and p | (m -1). Then the partition (1 mp-1 , 1 + b) gives a character in B q (S n ) with degree Y &#8226; mp/b, which is divisible by p but is not divisible by q since the q-part of both b and mp are q t 1 .</p><p>Finally, note that in all cases, the &#955; described is not self-conjugate, and hence the characters restrict irreducibly to A n , completing the proof.</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="4.2">Conjecture C for Simple Groups of Lie Type</head><p>Let r 0 be a prime and r := r a 0 be some power of r 0 . For p another prime, we denote by d p (r) the order of r modulo p, respectively modulo 4, if p is odd, respectively p = 2. Here we will prove the remaining direction of Conjecture C for simple groups of Lie type S defined in characteristic r 0 . (For the case of Suzuki and Ree groups, we let r be 2 2n+1 or 3 2n+1 , as appropriate.)</p><p>Several cases here also follow quickly from <ref type="bibr">[19]</ref>:</p><p>Let S be a simple group of Lie type defined over F r , and let p, q be primes such that [P , Q] = 1 for every Sylow p-subgroup P and Sylow q-subgroup Q of S but that at least one of the following conditions holds:</p><p>1. r 0 &#8712; {p, q}; 2. a Sylow p-subgroup or a Sylow q-subgroup of S is abelian; or 3. d p (r) = d q (r);</p><p>Then either there exists &#967; &#8712; Irr p (B p (S)) with degree divisible by q or there exists &#967; &#8712; Irr q (B q (S)) with degree divisible by p.</p><p>Proof First suppose that r 0 &#8712; {p, q} and without loss, say r 0 = p. Then Irr(B p (S)) = Irr(S) \ {St S } contains all characters of degree divisible by q. Let G be a quasisimple group of Lie type of simply connected type such that G/Z(G) = S. Suppose first that there is a semisimple element s of the dual group G * that does not centralize a Sylow q-subgroup of G * and which lies in O p (G * ). (See e.g. <ref type="bibr">[5,</ref><ref type="bibr">Chapter 4]</ref> for a discussion of the dual group G * .) Considering a semisimple character &#967; s corresponding to s (in particular, we may fix &#967; s to correspond to the trivial character of C G * (s) under Jordan decomposition), we see that</p><p>]) and &#967; s is trivial on Z(G) (see e.g. [32, Proposition 2.7]), so &#967; s has degree divisible by q but lies in Irr p (B p (S)) as a character of S. Now suppose that every semisimple element of G * that lies in O p (G * ) centralizes a Sylow q-subgroup of G * . In particular, this means that O p (G * ) has abelian Sylow qsubgroups, so S also has abelian Sylow q-subgroups. (Indeed, in many cases, S &#8764; = O p (G * ), and otherwise the claim can be seen from the observations in [18, Section 2.1].) In this case, Irr q (B q (S)) = Irr(B q (S)) by Brauer's height zero conjecture for principal blocks <ref type="bibr">[20]</ref>. Then let &#967; be any nontrivial unipotent character in Irr(B q (S)). This character will have degree divisible by p by <ref type="bibr">[17,</ref><ref type="bibr">Theorem 6.8]</ref>, unless p = r&#8712;{2, 3} and S is one of the exceptions given in loc. cit. Using Proposition 4.1, this leaves only the case <ref type="bibr">(2)</ref> for n &#8805; 4. Let e be the order of r 2 = 4 modulo q and write n = me + b with b &lt; e. Now, following the proof in [17, Theorem 6.8], we see the nontrivial unipotent characters with degree not divisible by 2 are those whose corresponding symbols contain only the numbers 0, 1, n. Using the theory of e-core and e-cocore partitions (the relevant details of which we have summarized in the section on B n and C n in the proof of [26, Proposition 3.7]), we have one of the characters indexed by symbols 0,b+1 me , 0,me b+1 , or b+1,me 0 lies in B q (S). These characters are not the odd-degree characters, unless b = 0, i.e. e | n. In the latter case, the Steinberg character has degree a power of 2 and lies in B q (S).</p><p>Next, suppose that r 0 &#8712; {p, q} and that a Sylow p-subgroup of S is abelian. Then Irr p (B p (S)) = Irr(B p (S)) by Brauer's height zero conjecture for principal blocks <ref type="bibr">[20]</ref>, and hence the proof of <ref type="bibr">[19,</ref><ref type="bibr">Theorem 5</ref>.1] yields the desired character.</p><p>Finally, assume that r 0 &#8712; {p, q}, that no Sylow por qsubgroup of S is abelian, and that d p (r) = d q (r). Note that the assumption [P , Q] = 1 for every choice of Sylow pand Sylow q-subgroups of S (and hence analogously for G) implies that also [P * , Q * ] = 1 for any Sylow pand qsubgroups of the dual group G * . (Again, this is pointed out already in <ref type="bibr">[19,</ref><ref type="bibr">Theorem 5.1]</ref>.) Now, let d p (r) &#8804; d q (r) and suppose that there exists 1 = s &#8712; Z(Q * ) for some Q * &#8712; Syl q (G * ) such that s centralizes a Sylow p-subgroup of G * . Then the same argument as in the first two paragraphs of <ref type="bibr">[19,</ref><ref type="bibr">Proposition 3.5]</ref>, but now applied to G * , yields that d p (r) = d q (r), a contradiction. Hence, given 1 = s &#8712; Z(Q * ), we havestop C G * (s) contains Q * but does not contain a Sylow p-subgroup P * of G * . Then the corresponding semisimple character &#967; s of G has degree divisible by p but lies in Irr q (B q (G)), since &#967; s (1) = [G * : C G * (s)] r 0 and using <ref type="bibr">[12,</ref><ref type="bibr">Corollary 3.4]</ref>. Furthermore, arguing as in <ref type="bibr">[11,</ref><ref type="bibr">Theorem 3.5</ref>] shows that such s can be chosen so that &#967; s is trivial on Z(G), completing the proof.</p><p>Our task is now to prove Conjecture C in the case that neither p nor q is the defining characteristic, d p (r) = d q (r), and no Sylow por q-subgroup of S is abelian. We begin with the case of exceptional groups of Lie type, by which we mean the groups S = G 2 (r), F 4 (r), E 6 (r), E 7 (r), E 8 (r), 3 D 4 (r), 2 G 2 (r), 2 F 4 (r), and 2 B 2 (r). Proposition 4.4 Let S be an exceptional simple group of Lie type defined over F r , and let p, q be primes such that [P , Q] = 1 for every Sylow p-subgroup P and Sylow q-subgroup Q of S. Then either there exists &#967; &#8712; Irr p (B p (S)) with degree divisible by q or there exists &#967; &#8712; Irr q (B q (S)) with degree divisible by p.</p><p>Proof By Proposition 4.3, we may assume that r is not a power of p nor q, that no Sylow por qsubgroup of S is abelian, and that d p (r) = d q (r). Let d := d p (r) = d q (r). With these constraints, we see that S is not of Suzuki or Ree type, that p and q are at most 7, and that d is a regular number in the sense of Springer <ref type="bibr">[34]</ref> (see also <ref type="bibr">[33,</ref><ref type="bibr">Definition 2.5]</ref>). Hence we see that the principal blocks B p (S) and B q (S) are the unique blocks of S containing p -, respectively, q -degree unipotent characters (see, e.g., <ref type="bibr">[31,</ref><ref type="bibr">Lemma 3.6]</ref>). Under these conditions, we see by observing the explicit list of unipotent character degrees in [5, Section 13.9] that there exists a unipotent character &#967; satisfying either &#967; &#8712; Irr p (B p (S)) and q | &#967;(1) or &#967; &#8712; Irr q (B q (S)) and p | &#967; <ref type="bibr">(1)</ref>.</p><p>We next consider the case of linear and unitary groups. Proposition 4.5 Let S = PSL n (r) with n &#8805; 2, and let p = q be primes such that [P , Q] = 1 for every Sylow p-subgroup P and Sylow q-subgroup Q of S. Then either there exists &#967; &#8712; Irr p (B p (S)) with degree divisible by q or there exists &#967; &#8712; Irr q (B q (S)) with degree divisible by p.</p><p>Proof By Proposition 4.1, we may assume S is not isomorphic to a sporadic or alternating group. Furthermore, by Proposition 4.3, we may assume that r is not a power of p nor q, that no Sylow por qsubgroup of S is abelian, and that d p (r) = d = d q (r).</p><p>Write G := SL n (r), G := GL n (r), and e := d p ( r) = d q ( r). Note that G * &#8764; = G, so we will make this identification. Let P &#8712; Syl p ( G) and Q &#8712; Syl q ( G). It suffices to show that (up to switching p and q) there is some s &#8712; Z( P ) &#8745; G such that |C G (s)| is not divisible by | Q| and sz is not G-conjugate to s for any 1 = z &#8712; Z( G). (Indeed, that s &#8712; G = O r 0 ( G) implies that the corresponding semisimple character &#967; s is trivial on Z( G) and that sz is not conjugate to s for nontrivial z &#8712; Z( G) implies that &#967; s is irreducible on restriction to G using e.g. <ref type="bibr">[32,</ref><ref type="bibr">Proposition 2.7</ref>] and <ref type="bibr">[31,</ref><ref type="bibr">Lemma 1.4]</ref>; the remaining conditions &#967; s &#8712; Irr(B p ( G)) using <ref type="bibr">[12,</ref><ref type="bibr">Corollary 3.4]</ref> and &#967; s <ref type="bibr">(1)</ref> is p but divisible by q since &#967; s (1) = [ G : C G (s)] r 0 .) Now, if 2 &#8712; {p, q}, we see using the results of Weir <ref type="bibr">[35]</ref> that P and Q are naturally isomorphic to the corresponding Sylow subgroups of GL we (r), embedded naturally into GL we (r) &#215; GL b (r) &#8804; GL n (r) where n = we + b with 0 &#8804; b &lt; e. The results of Carter-Fong <ref type="bibr">[6]</ref> yield the same when p or q is 2, except that if (e, b) = (2, 1), then |GL b (r)| is divisible by 2 exactly once, and the Sylow 2-subgroup of GL n (r) in this case is that of GL we (r) &#215; GL b (r).</p><p>Let w = a</p><p>be the p-adic and q-adic expansions of w, with t</p><p>and 1 &#8804; b j &lt; q for each 1 &#8804; j &#8804; k . By <ref type="bibr">[6,</ref><ref type="bibr">35]</ref>, we have P &#8764;</p><p>) and is trivial otherwise. Here we view GL ep t i (r) as the natural diagonally-embedded subgroup. Similarly,</p><p>Without loss of generality, assume a 1 p t 1 &lt; b 1 q m 1 . (Note that we cannot have a 1 p t 1 = b 1 q m 1 , as this would contradict that either a 1 &lt; p &lt; q or b 1 &lt; q &lt; p.) Let x &#8712; Z(P 1 ) have no eigenvalues equal to 1 (indeed, this can be done by taking x as an element of a Sylow p-subgroup of Z(GL p t 1 (r e )) embedded naturally into GL ep t 1 (r)) and consider the element s = diag(x, . . . , x, I n-ea 1 p t 1 ) &#8712; Z( P ), with a 1 copies of x. In fact, taking x (and hence its eigenvalues) to have order p, we obtain det(x) = 1 and hence s &#8712; G. Here C G (s) = C GL a 1 ep t 1 (r) (diag(x, . . . , x)) &#215; GL n-ea 1 p t 1 (r). Now, by considering the structure, and hence size, of Q (namely, each Q j is a wreath product Q C q where Q is a Sylow q-subgroup of GL eq m j -1 (r)), we see |GL a 1 ep t 1 (r) &#215; GL n-ea 1 p t 1 (r)| is not divisible by | Q|. Furthermore, by considering the block sizes, we see that sz and z cannot have the same eigenvalues (and hence they cannot be G-conjugate) for any nontrivial scalar matrix z &#8712; Z(GL n (r)). This completes the proof.</p><p>We next consider the remaining classical types, for which the proof is very similar to the linear and unitary case. Proposition 4.6 Let S = PSp 2n (r) with n &#8805; 2, P 2n+1 (r) with n &#8805; 3, or P 2n (r) with n &#8805; 4. Let p = q be primes such that [P , Q] = 1 for every Sylow p-subgroup P and Sylow q-subgroup Q of S. Then either there exists &#967; &#8712; Irr p B p (S) with degree divisible by q or there exists &#967; &#8712; Irr q B q (S) with degree divisible by p.</p><p>Proof As before, we may assume S is not isomorphic to a sporadic or alternating group, r is not a power of p nor q, no Sylow por qsubgroup of S is abelian, and that d p (r) = d = d q (r).</p><p>First we set some notation. We define H n := Sp 2n (r), SO 2n+1 (r), and SO 2n (r) in the cases S = PSp 2n (r), P 2n+1 (r), and P 2n (r), respectively. Let H := H n and let := O r 0 (H ) so that is perfect and S = /Z( ). Note that the dual groups are H * n = SO 2n+1 (r), Sp 2n (r), and SO 2n (r), respectively, and we will write H * := H * n . Note that Z( ) &#8804; Z(H ) and that H/ and Z(H ) are 2-groups. Let P and Q be Sylow pand q-subgroups of H * .</p><p>In this situation, suffices to show that (up to switching p and q) there is some s &#8712; Z( P ) such that C G (s) is not divisible by | Q|, using similar reasoning to the above case. Indeed, if p is odd, then P may be considered as a Sylow p-subgroup of O r 0 (H * ) and sz cannot be H * -conjugate to s for any 1 = z &#8712; Z(H * ) since Z(H * ) is a 2-group, so a corresponding semisimple character &#967; s of H is trivial on Z(H ) and restricts irreducibly to . If instead p = 2, then such a character &#967; s would have odd degree, and therefore restrict irreducibly to since H/ is a 2-group. Then since is perfect, Z( ) is a 2-group, and &#967; s has odd degree, this forces &#967; s to be trivial on Z( ). Furthermore, as before, &#967; s &#8712; Irr(B p (H )) in either case.</p><p>Assume first that p and q are odd. In these cases, the work of Weir <ref type="bibr">[35]</ref> again describes the structure of P and Q, building off of the case of linear groups. If H * = SO 2n+1 (r) or Sp 2n (r), we have Sylow pand q-subgroups are already Sylow subgroups of GL 2n+1 (r) (and hence of GL 2n (r)) when d is even, and are Sylow subgroups of the naturally-embedded GL n (r) if d is odd. For these cases, let e := d p (r 2 ) = d q (r 2 ), write n = ew + b with 0 &#8804; b &lt; e, and let w = a 1 p t 1 + a 2 p t 2 + &#8226; &#8226; &#8226; + a k p t k = b 1 q m 1 + &#8226; &#8226; &#8226; + b k q m k be the padic and q-adic expansions of w as before. Again without loss, we assume a 1 p t 1 &lt; b 1 q m 1 . In particular, P and Q are again isomorphic to Sylow subgroups of H * ew and of the form P &#8764; = P a 1  1 &#215; &#8226; &#8226; &#8226; &#215; P a k k , where each P i is a Sylow p-subgroup of GL dp t i (r) and can be identified with a Sylow p-subgroup of H * ep t i , and similar for Q. As before, let x &#8712; Z(P 1 ) with no eigenvalues equal to 1 and let s = (x, . . . , x, 1, . . . 1) &#8712; Z( P ) with a 1 copies of x. Then we can see from the centralizer structure of semisimple elements that C H * (s) &#8764; = C H * a 1 ep t 1 (x, . . . , x) &#215; H * n-ea 1 p t 1 . Since the Sylow q-subgroups of H * a 1 ep t 1 and H * n-ea 1 p t 1 can be identified with Sylow subgroups of linear groups in an analogous way as for H * , depending on whether d was even or odd, we have | Q| |C H * (s)| for the same reason as in the case of linear groups above.</p><p>If H * = SO 2n (r), then we have embeddings SO 2n-1 (r) &#8804; H * &#8804; SO 2n+1 (r), and P and Q are both Sylow subgroups of either SO 2n-1 (r) or SO 2n+1 (r). In this case, letting m &#8712; {n, n -1} so that P , Q are Sylow subgroups of SO 2m+1 (r) and now writing m = ew + b with w written with pand q-adic expansions as before, P can again be written P &#8764; = P a 1  1 &#215; &#8226; &#8226; &#8226; &#215; P a k k with each P i a Sylow subgroup of GL dp t i (r), which in this case can also be identified with a Sylow p-subgroup of either SO + 2ep t i (r) or SO - 2ep t i (r). From here, arguing similar to before, we obtain an element s &#8712; Z( P ) with C H * (s) isomorphic to a subgroup of C GO &#177; 2a 1 ep t 1 (r) (diag(x, . . . , x)) &#215; GO &#177; 2(n-ea 1 p t 1 ) (r). Since q is odd, we again see in the same way as above that | Q| does not divide |C H * (s)|.</p><p>We are finally left with the case that 2 &#8712; {p, q}. Let &#292; * denote the group GO 2n+1 (r), Sp 2n (r), or GO 2n (r) respectively, so that [ &#292; * : H * ] divides 2. Note that if p = 2 and H * = &#292; * , then P is index-2 in a Sylow 2-subgroup P of &#292; * , which are again described by Carter-Fong <ref type="bibr">[6]</ref>. Here in the case of GO 2n+1 (r) or Sp 2n (r), writing n = 2 t 1 + &#8226; &#8226; &#8226; + 2 t k for the 2-adic expansion with t 1 &lt; &#8226; &#8226; &#8226; &lt; t k , we have P &#8764; = P 1 &#215;&#8226; &#8226; &#8226;&#215;P k , where P i is a Sylow 2subgroup of GO 2&#8226;2 t i +1 (r), respectively, Sp 2&#8226;2 t i (r). In the case &#292; * = GO 2n (r), we have P is either a Sylow 2-subgroup of GO 2n+1 (r), embedded as before, or of the form P 0 &#215; C 2 &#215; C 2 , where P 0 is a Sylow 2-subgroup of GO 2n-1 (r). From here, we may argue analogously to before, keeping in mind that when p = 2, choosing x &#8712; Z(P 1 ) to have 2 t 1 +1 eigenvalues -1 yields an element of determinant 1, and hence an element of P = P &#8745; H * . Conjecture C for simple groups (and Theorem E) now follows from Propositions 4.1-4.6.</p></div></body>
		</text>
</TEI>
