skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: Regulation by impasse: Pesticide registration, capital and the state in Costa Rica
Costa Rica's prodigious use of pesticides, as well as the burgeoning plantation sector that these agrochemicals support, exacerbates the tensions between extraction and preservation at the heart of the country's development model. We explore these tensions through a study of the country's pesticide registry, the regulatory process to approve active ingredients and formulations for use. After nearly two decades of reform efforts, the registry is widely recognized to be non-functioning: most of the country's pesticides exist in administrative limbo and relatively few new compounds have been approved. Based on extensive interviews and in-depth policy analysis, we construct four phases of reform and use a strategic-relational approach to the state to analyze this process. We conceptualize the registry's gridlock as a form of governance that we term regulation by impasse, an arrangement reproduced through disputes within and between the cognizant ministries, juridical bodies and other regulating authorities, in relation to the shifting strategies and contexts of political economic and wider social forces. We argue that hegemony is tenuously maintained through the registry dispute itself, while revealing the deeply frayed condition of the Costa Rican development model.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2026088
PAR ID:
10439681
Author(s) / Creator(s):
;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space
Volume:
6
Issue:
2
ISSN:
2514-8486
Page Range / eLocation ID:
901 to 922
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Pesticide use can impact not only cultivated land, but also protected ecosystems that receive pesticide inputs due to aquatic connectivity or atmospheric transport from agricultural regions. In Costa Rica's Caribbean lowlands, pesticides applied to banana and pineapple plantations are a potential source of pollution to ecological reserves. Macroinvertebrates and fish are both potentially useful bioindicators of agrochemical pollution in aquatic systems, and our goal was to determine whether three common stream consumer species (one fish and two aquatic insect species) could serve as bioindicators for the organophosphate pesticide ethoprophos. We identified thresholds at which ethoprophos impacts the survival (LC50) and observed behavior (LOEC – lowest observed effect concentration) for each species. The LC50 of the guppy Priapichthys annectens was 1530 µg/L, with observable behavioral changes occurring at 1000 µg/L. Insects were more sensitive: the mayfly Traverella holzenthali had an LC50 of 15 µg/L and an LOEC of 2.5 µg/L, and the caddisfly Leptonema sp. had an LC50 of approximately 30 µg/L and an LOEC of 5 µg/L. The LC50 values are notably higher than ambient concentrations recorded from polluted Costa Rican streams and suggest that these taxa are not ideal indicator species. However, the lower LOEC values (in the same order of magnitude as ambient concentrations) highlight the potential ecological importance of behavioral modification due to pesticides. Quantifying the thresholds at which common pesticides impact ecosystems is a key step in identifying bioindicator species and protecting tropical biodiversity. 
    more » « less
  2. Pesticide overuse has been an increasing concern in China. Digital technology, such as smartphone access, is considered an effective way to promote proper use of pesticides. Using the Chinese Extended Family Database (2015, 2017, and 2019), this study empirically examines the impact of smartphone access on pesticide use intensity among Chinese farmers. The results show a “double-edged sword” effect of smartphone access on pesticide use intensity. In rural areas with a low level of digital economy, greater smartphone access led to higher pesticide use intensity. In rural areas with a high digital economy level, smartphone access reduced pesticide use intensity. The study results show that reducing pesticide use intensity through digital technology is not a linear process but a complicated one that involves social and engineering integration, including an increase in access to smartphones, development of a regional digital economy, reconstruction of agricultural extension systems, and enhancement of the capacity of digital technology. 
    more » « less
  3. Science learning reforms require shifting epistemic and power structures so students and teachers build knowledge together within the context of meaningful questions and problems. Curricular customization allows teachers to preserve these reform-oriented goals while adapting for their specific contexts and students. This paper presents three cases from professional learning communities (PLCs) who followed the same curriculum customization model, but with different equity goals: supporting bi/multilingual learners’ ownership of learning, increasing the relevance of curriculum for students, and encouraging more student voices and multiple perspectives. Together, these cases highlight how the collaborative customization model facilitated productive tensions that lead to teacher learning 
    more » « less
  4. Lindgren, R; Asino, T I; Kyza, E A; Looi, C K; Keifert, D T; Suárez, E (Ed.)
    Science learning reforms require shifting epistemic and power structures so students and teachers build knowledge together within the context of meaningful questions and problems. Curricular customization allows teachers to preserve these reform-oriented goals while adapting for their specific contexts and students. This paper presents three cases from professional learning communities (PLCs) who followed the same curriculum customization model, but with different equity goals: supporting bi/multilingual learners’ ownership of learning, increasing the relevance of curriculum for students, and encouraging more student voices and multiple perspectives. Together, these cases highlight how the collaborative customization model facilitated productive tensions that lead to teacher learning. 
    more » « less
  5. Women faculty remain under-represented among all academic ranks within STEM fields, and especially at the rank of (full) Professor. While researchers have studied the underlying, systemic factors that contribute to these outcomes, and a range of possible interventions, how reform of the Associate-to-Full promotion system unfolds within a STEM-intensive university remains a black box. Drawing from in-depth longitudinal case study data, we find that reform involves an ongoing process of wrestling with strategic ambiguity. More specifically, we identify three interrelated micro-processes that inform efforts at reform: 1) negotiations over the what of promotion criteria and systems; 2) struggles over who controls the formulation of promotion policy and interpretation of criteria; and 3) decisions over how the change process itself should unfold (externally or internally aligned). This paper makes several new contributions to the field: 1) we introduce the idea of strategic ambiguity as something that is negotiated and navigated rather than something to be eliminated; 2) we provide a more nuanced understanding of the microprocesses that unfold throughout the promotion reform process, and 3) we show how contests over control between low- and high-power individuals and groups are inextricably intertwined with promotion system reform. 
    more » « less