Title: The Role of Intermediate Collaborative Forums in Polycentric Environmental Governance
In complex, polycentric environmental governance systems, actors may choose to collaborate with one another to reduce their collective vulnerability and enhance system function. However, collaboration can be costly, and little evidence exists for how particular collaborative forums impact the broader governance system in which they are embedded. To address this gap, we investigate the role of intermediate collaborative forums, which support collaboration among a subset of system actors, in polycentric governance systems. Empirically, we analyze the structural and functional role of an intermediate collaborative forum called the Arizona Municipal Water Users Association (AMWUA) within the municipal surface water governance network for the Phoenix Metropolitan Area (PMA) in Arizona, United States. To do this, we draw from 21 interviews with water professionals in the PMA, which we analyze through a combination of network analysis and qualitative coding. We find that AMWUA facilitates strong bonding capacities among members, allowing for streamlined bridging to the rest of the network that enhances information processing and advocacy of member needs. Our findings advance theory on the role of collaboration in polycentric systems and inform the design of collaborative institutions to improve environmental governance.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1923880 2048133
PAR ID:
10442482
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ;
Publisher / Repository:
Oxford University Press
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory
ISSN:
1053-1858
Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. ABSTRACT Environmental challenges require collaboration across jurisdictions, often through forums or intermediary spaces for repeated interaction. A persistent forum design question concerns inclusion criteria, or which actors should be included. Ecology of Games, public choice, and collaborative governance detail various costs and benefits of expanding inclusion, but less attention has been paid to specific variations in inclusion criteria. To address this, we conduct a comparative case study of four water user associations in Arizona, U.S. that either restrict participation to a certain sector and/or to those holding specific water rights. We assess how inclusion criteria impact participants' perceptions of various dimensions of forum functionality, considering management concerns that may confound the relationship. Drawing on a survey and semi‐structured interviews of forum participants, we find that more restrictive forums benefit from an internal spillover of high coordination to other capacities that require increased buy‐in (e.g., lobbying) while more inclusive forums can create an external spillover of broader regional cooperation as participants interact with more diverse users. Management concerns, particularly the relative concern for groundwater versus surface water and financial resources, confound this relationship. Our findings provide new theoretical and practical insight into how inclusion rules affect forum functionality in complex governance systems. 
    more » « less
  2. null (Ed.)
    Despite the known benefits of integrated policy and planning, traditional governance decisions in the food-energy-water (FEW) nexus are often made without cross-sector collaboration, potentially leading to unintended consequences and decreased resource security. Applying collaborative governance approaches to the FEW nexus provides an opportunity to shift towards integrated policy of food, energy, and water governance; doing so first requires an understanding of the limitations of current governance structures and the opportunities for change. We conduct a social network analysis of stakeholders in Phoenix, AZ using secondary data sources to construct the social network of collaboration and to analyze the ability of the governance landscape to facilitate or hinder collaborative governance. The social network measures indicate potential challenges to collaborative governance of FEW nexus stakeholders, such as limited trust between actors. However, leveraging bridging actors provides opportunities to increase collaborative governance between sectors. This research is important for implementing collaborative FEW nexus governance in practice. 
    more » « less
  3. Collaborative governance has emerged as a promising approach for addressing complex water sustainability issues, with purported benefits from enhanced democracy to improved environmental outcomes. Collaborative processes are often assumed to be inherently more equitable than traditional governance approaches due to their goal of engaging diverse actors in the development of policy and management solutions. However, when collaborative water governance processes ignore issues of politics and power in their design, they risk creating or even exacerbating existing inequities. How, then, can collaborative water governance processes be designed to enhance, rather than undermine, equity? To answer this question, we first conduct an extensive review of the collaborative governance literature to identify common design features of collaborative processes, which each present potential benefits and challenges for actualizing equitable collaborative water governance. After critically discussing these design features, we explore how they are executed through two case studies of collaborative water governance in western North America: groundwater governance reform in California and transnational Colorado River Delta governance. In reflecting on these cases, we chart an agenda for future collaborative water governance research and practice that moves beyond engaging diverse actors to promoting equity among them. 
    more » « less
  4. Both centralized and decentralized governance arrangements often fail in successfully managing complex and delicate natural systems like forests. As a result, forests are often poorly managed and overexploited. We argue that polycentric governance systems offer a promising alternative to traditional governance systems to address the non-linear, unpredictable, dynamic, and interconnected nature of socioecological processes within and outside of forests. The success of polycentric governance relies heavily on the engagement of a variety of actors who prioritize long-term health of ecosystems as well as the establishment of resilient institutional frameworks. By combining theoretical analysis with empirical insights, we discuss the adoption of more responsive and agile governance structures capable of navigating complexity and promoting sustainable forest management for achieving longer-term environmental resilience and human well-being. We present questions for future research on comparatively evaluating the efficacy of different governance arrangements in shaping incentives for managing forest systems. 
    more » « less
  5. Abstract Flood governance often operates as a polycentric network where authority, resources, and responsibilities are distributed across multiple organizations, yet the structural and cognitive factors that shape collaboration remain underexplored in flood contexts. We examine inter‐organizational ties in the Beaumont–Port Arthur region, Southeast Texas, using an organizational survey and self‐bounded network. We build three directed, unweighted collaboration networks: an All‐Issues network and two phase‐specific networks for preparation/mitigation and response/recovery. We decompose the survey data into nine driver‐ and impact‐specific layers to examine how collaboration varies across flood‐governance concerns. We report whole‐network statistics and estimate Exponential Random Graph Models (ERGMs) to test cognitive homophily, shared risk framing, and perceived competence. All‐Issues collaboration is denser, more reciprocal, and more clustered than phase‐specific networks, with response/recovery the most decentralized. Subnetworks focused on infrastructure and geophysical drivers are better connected than socio‐economic‐driver or social‐impact subnetworks. ERGMs show that collaboration does not favor same‐type partners. Instead, shared risk framing predicts tie formation in phase‐relevant ways: higher precipitation importance increases response ties, higher infrastructure‐driver importance increases preparation ties, and similarity in precipitation assessments increases ties in the full network. Perceived competence alignment also matters: smaller differences in operational‐confidence ratings increase the likelihood of collaboration. Across models, organizations with shared collaborators are more likely to be connected, suggesting that flood‐governance collaboration is organized through locally reinforcing clusters. These findings point to two actionable strategies: foster shared framing around less connected social and economic issues and empower brokerage among less connected actors while maintaining robust technical coordination on infrastructure. 
    more » « less