skip to main content


Title: A Mélange of Subduction Ages: Constraints on the Timescale of Shear Zone Development and Underplating at the Subduction Interface, Catalina Schist (CA, USA)
Abstract

The presence of mélange at the subduction interface influences numerous geochemical and geophysical processes. However, the relationship between the timescales of mélange development, deformation, and resultant mass transport is poorly understood. Here, we use Sm‐Nd garnet geochronology to elucidate the timing of peak metamorphism for five garnet amphibolite tectonic blocks from the amphibolite‐facies mélange zone of the Catalina Schist (Santa Catalina Island, CA). Ages range from 108 to 116 Ma and do not appear to correlate with the peak metamorphic temperature recorded by each block (between 640 and 740°C). The lack of correlation between age and peak temperature favors the tectonic mixing model previously proposed for the unit. These ages overlap with previous estimates of 111–114 Ma for peak metamorphism of the mélange zone but are predominately younger than an estimate for the structurally lower coherent amphibolite unit of ca. 115 Ma. White mica40Ar/39Ar ages from previous studies suggest that the units cooled asynchronously to 400–425°C by 106 to 97 Ma at rates between 18 and 43°C/Ma. Collectively, these results demonstrate that mélange formation occurred over at least 8 Myr from 116 to 108 Ma and was followed by cooling. The structural and chronologic relationship between the mélange zone and underlying lower‐grade units indicates that the cooling occurred in conjunction with an underplating event between 109 and 108 Ma. The age discrepancy between the mélange zone and the underlying coherent amphibolite unit may indicate that the two units were juxtaposed either during or after the underplating event.

 
more » « less
NSF-PAR ID:
10448404
Author(s) / Creator(s):
 ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  
Publisher / Repository:
DOI PREFIX: 10.1029
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems
Volume:
22
Issue:
9
ISSN:
1525-2027
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. The Easton metamorphic suite of the Northwest Cascades thrust system is an exhumed Jurassic-Cretaceous subduction complex that can be used to test models for subduction zone deformation. Regional blueschist and greenschist within the Easton were accreted in a thermally evolving subduction zone between 150 – 136 Ma. Two units of the Easton metamorphic suite, the Darrington phyllite and the Shuksan greenschist, were originally interpreted as a coherent unit that subducted together in a zone of distributed deformation. The phyllite and greenschist are exposed in a gently SE plunging, steeply inclined, NE vergent, regional synclinorium in the Finney Creek area. New field mapping, microstructural analysis, and thermometry suggest the Darrington phyllite includes a new unit, the Silver phyllite. The Darrington phyllite contains two foliations with the dominant S2 foliation defined by aligned Gr + Ms. The Silver phyllite also preserves two foliations with S1 defined by aligned Ep + Gr in Ab porphyroclasts and relict Ms in fold hinges. The S1 foliation is variably overprinted by the dominant S2 axial planar cleavage of aligned Ms + Chl (148 –140 Ma) that intensifies with proximity to the greenschist contact. In contrast, the Shuksan greenschist dominantly preserves an S1 foliation (~140 Ma) of aligned Ep + Act/Gln + Ms + Chl that is variably overprinted by a weak S2 (140 – 136 Ma) that is axial planar to tight folds in the greenschist and the regional synclinorium. The contact between Silver phyllite and Shuksan greenschist is marked by a Ms + Chl + Ab mylonite that is parallel to the S2 fabric in both units. Raman spectroscopy of carbonaceous material (RSCM) suggests the three units have different thermal histories. Graphite in the Darrington phyllite S2 foliation yields temperatures of 374 – 400 C. The Silver phyllite S1 assemblage records RSCM temperatures of 430 – 450 C while previous Chl ­– Ms thermometry from S2 yielded 310 – 340 C. In contrast, the Shuksan greenschist S1 formed at peak metamorphic conditions of ~360 C. The deformation and thermal history combined with existing Ar/Ar ages suggest that cooling of the Silver phyllite from S1 to S2 was synchronous with prograde metamorphism and formation of S1 in the greenschist during underplating, and that these unit were subducted as discrete tectonic slices rather than as a coherent unit. 
    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    In subduction‐related tectonic mélange, thermobarometry on individual blocks can in principle constrain the scale of lithological mixing along the subduction interface. Previous thermobarometric investigation of the tectonic amphibolite facies mélange unit in the Catalina Schist, Santa Catalina Island, California, USA, has suggested relatively limited mixing among blocks (≤12 km). Here we further investigate scales of mixing among metamorphically disparate (‘exotic’) blocks within epidote‐amphibolite and lawsonite‐blueschist facies mélange of the Catalina Schist using field and petrographic observations, Zr‐in‐rutile thermometry, and quartz‐in‐garnet elastic barometry. A new statistically based method is presented for calculating elastic barometry maximum pressures. The exotic blocks record peak metamorphic temperatures between 580 and 735°C and peak pressures between 1.16 and 1.65 GPa. Temperatures primarily fall in between those recorded by rocks in the amphibolite facies and epidote amphibolite facies units (643–735°C and 553–596°C respectively). The pressure estimates encompass those recorded by blocks from the amphibolite facies mélange (1.34–1.44 GPa), although the exotic blocks record a much larger range of pressures. The large range of recorded temperatures and pressures suggests that blocks within the epidote amphibolite unit were sourced from and mixed along a 20–30 km region of the subduction interface while an exotic block from the lawsonite blueschist facies unit appears to have been sourced from at least 70 km deeper than the unit it is hosted in. Metre‐ to kilometre‐scale variations in matrix mineral rheology likely control strain partitioning at the interface and permit differential transport of mélange blocks over variable length scales.

     
    more » « less
  3. Numerical models of subduction initiation and observations of exhumed subduction complexes indicate that the early stages of subduction are characterized by rapid cooling followed by a prolonged steady thermal state that can last tens of millions of years. Several mechanisms are proposed to drive cooling in subduction zones and include thermal relaxation, exhumation, and underplating, but determining the relative contribution of each mechanism in the history of an exhumed subduction complex can be difficult. The Easton metamorphic suite in the Northwest Cascades of Washington is a Jurassic-Cretaceous subduction complex that records the subduction and accretion of distinct units within a thermally maturing nascent subduction zone. The region preserves an inverted metamorphic sequence with metamorphic temperatures and ages that decrease structurally downward from an early accreted metamorphic sole to younger regionally extensive blueschist facies units. In the metamorphic sole Grt±Cpx amphibolite was metamorphosed at 750-800 C at 1.0 GPa prior to 167 Ma. The amphibolite is underlain by a high temperature Grt-Ab-Gln blueschist that was metamorphosed at ~530 C and 1.0 GPa at 165 Ma. The contact between the units is gradational and the general lack of deformation suggests initial cooling to lower temperatures may have been caused by cooling of the overall subduction zone. Retrograde Lws-Ep-Gln-Ms assemblages suggest that cooling of both the amphibolite and high-grade blueschist units to below 400-500 C was caused by exhumation to 0.7 GPa by 157 Ma. In the regionally extensive blueschist units, Ep-Ab-Chl-Ms±Grt±Lws phyllite was metamorphosed at 430-450 C and 0.7 GPa by 149 Ma. Retrograde fabrics in the phyllite record similar temperatures to peak metamorphic conditions in an underlying Ep-Ab-Gln/Act greenschist/blueschist unit that was accreted and metamorphosed at ≤350 C by ≤140 Ma. The contact between the phyllite and greenschist is marked by a high strain mylonite zone and the combined observations suggest that cooling of the phyllite was driven by underplating of the younger greenschist unit. The observed assemblages and fabrics within the Easton metamorphic suite record cooling as the result of thermal relaxation, underplating, and exhumation at distinctly different times in the subduction history. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract

    The Klamath Mountains in northern California and southern Oregon are thought to record 200+ m.y. of subduction and terrane accretion, whereas the outboard Franciscan Complex records ocean‐continent subduction along the North American margin. Unraveling the Klamath Mountains' Late Jurassic history could help constrain this transition in subduction style. Key is the Mesozoic Condrey Mountain Schist (CMS), comprising, in part, a subduction complex that occupies a structural window through older, overlying central Klamath thrust sheets but with otherwise uncertain relationships to more outboard Klamath or Franciscan terranes. The CMS consists of two units (upper and lower), which could be correlated with (a) other Klamath terranes, (b) the Franciscan, or (c) neither based on regional structures and limited extant age data. Upper CMS protolith and metamorphic dates overlap with other Klamath terranes, but the lower CMS remains enigmatic. We used multiple geochronometers to constrain the timing of lower CMS deposition and metamorphism. Maximum depositional ages (MDAs) derived from detrital zircon geochronology of metasedimentary rocks are 153–135 Ma. Metamorphic ages from white mica K‐Ar and Rb‐Sr multi‐mineral isochrons from intercalated and coherently deformed metamafic lenses are 133–116 Ma. Lower CMS MDAs (<153 Ma) predominantly postdate other Klamath terrane ages, but subduction metamorphism appears to start before the earliest coherent Franciscan underplating (ca. 123 Ma). The lower CMS thus occupies a spatial and temporal position between the Klamath Mountains and Franciscan and preserves a non‐retrogressed record of the Franciscan Complex's early history (>123 Ma), otherwise only partially preserved in retrogressed Franciscan high grade blocks.

     
    more » « less
  5. Abstract

    We investigated a suite of metabasite blocks from serpentinite matrix and shale matrix mélanges of the California Coast Ranges. Our new data set consists of40Ar/39Ar dates of amphibole and phengite and U‐Pb dates of metamorphic zircon. Combined with published geochronology, including prograde Lu‐Hf garnet ages from the same blocks, we can reconstruct the timing and time scales of prograde and retrograde metamorphism of individual blocks. In particular we find that exhumation from amphibole‐eclogite facies conditions occurred as a single episode at 165–157 Ma, with an apparent southward younging trend. The rate and timing of exhumation were initially uniform (when comparing individual blocks) and fast (with cooling rates up to ~140°C/Ma). In the cooler and shallower blueschist facies, exhumation slowed and became less uniform among blocks. Considering the subduction zone system, the high‐grade exhumation temporally correlates with a magmatic arc pulse (Sierra Nevada) and the termination of forearc spreading (Coast Range Ophiolite). Our findings suggest that a geodynamic one‐time event led to exhumation of amphibole‐eclogite facies rocks. We propose that interaction of the Franciscan subduction zone with a spreading ridge led to extraction of the forearc mantle wedge from its position between forearc crust and subducting crust. The extraction led to fast and uniform exhumation of subducted rocks into the blueschist facies. We also show that the Franciscan subduction zone did not undergo significant cooling over time and that its initiation was not coeval with blueschist‐facies metamorphism of the Red Ant schist of the Sierra Nevada foothills.

     
    more » « less