Title: The Puzzle of Spatial Sex Differences: Current Status and Prerequisites to Solutions
Abstract In this review, I summarize what we know about the development of sex‐related differences in spatial skills, their potential malleability, and their possible causes. Current evidence suggests that sex differences increase in size with age, at least for skills with assessments suitable for use across development. However, male advantages vary from nonexistent to substantial, depending on the skills assessed, task parameters, and culture. Training and practice can improve spatial skills, although interventions tested so far do not eliminate the male advantage (when there is one). The complex pattern of increases with age, task variation, and cultural variation challenges efforts to theorize about causation. Progress requires identifying the underlying cognitive and neural structure of the spatial domain, developing reliable and valid assessment tools suitable for use across wide age ranges, gathering large datasets from a variety of cultural settings, and identifying and investigating specific mechanisms for growth and change. more »« less
Branch, Carrie L.; Sonnenberg, Benjamin R.; Pitera, Angela M.; Benedict, Lauren M.; Kozlovsky, Dovid Y.; Bridge, Eli S.; Pravosudov, Vladimir V.
(, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences)
null
(Ed.)
The greater male variability phenomenon predicts that males exhibit larger ranges of variation in cognitive performance compared with females; however, support for this pattern has come exclusively from studies of humans and lacks mechanistic explanation. Furthermore, the vast majority of the literature assessing sex differences in cognition is based on studies of humans and a few other mammals. In order to elucidate the underpinnings of cognitive variation and the potential for fitness consequences, we must investigate sex differences in cognition in non-mammalian systems as well. Here, we assess the performance of male and female food-caching birds on a spatial learning and memory task and a reversal spatial task to address whether there are sex differences in mean cognitive performance or in the range of variation in performance. For both tasks, male and female mean performance was similar across four years of testing; however, males did exhibit a wider range of variation in performance on the reversal spatial task compared with females. The implications for mate choice and sexual selection of cognitive abilities are discussed and future directions are suggested to aid in the understanding of sex-related cognitive variation.
Rayner, Jack G; Bock, Samantha L; Lonski, Andrew J; Riddle, Nicole C; Wilkinson, Gerald S
(, bioRxiv)
Sex-biased longevity is observed across a wide range of animal taxa, including bats, for reasons not well understood. Patterns of cytosine methylation vary predictably with age in many organisms, offering a valuable means to investigate differences in patterns of aging at the molecular level. We tested sex differences in cytosine methylation across 14 bat species and compared patterns of age-associated variation. Sex differences were overrepresented on the X chromosome, showing a strong pattern of female hypermethylation within promoter regions. Sex and age-associated differences in methylation were non-randomly distributed with respect to proximity to putative sex hormone receptor binding sites, with sites hypermethylated in males and females tending to be underrepresented near androgen and estrogen receptor binding sites, respectively. Across species, we observed the relative steepness of male versus female slopes of age-associated variation was associated with the strength of precopulatory sexual selection, with especially strong trends towards male-biased age-associated slopes in two harem-polygynous species that exhibit female-biased longevity. Our results offer insights into how patterns of methylation differ across sexes and ages, and raise intriguing questions for future research, such as whether sex differences in molecular aging reflect sex-biased longevity, for which records in bats are sparse.
Pašukonis, Andrius; Serrano-Rojas, Shirley Jennifer; Fischer, Marie-Therese; Loretto, Matthias-Claudio; Shaykevich, Daniel A; Rojas, Bibiana; Ringler, Max; Roland, Alexandre B; Marcillo-Lara, Alejandro; Ringler, Eva; et al
(, eLife)
Sex differences in vertebrate spatial abilities are typically interpreted under the adaptive specialization hypothesis, which posits that male reproductive success is linked to larger home ranges and better navigational skills. The androgen spillover hypothesis counters that enhanced male spatial performance may be a byproduct of higher androgen levels. Animal groups that include species where females are expected to outperform males based on life-history traits are key for disentangling these hypotheses. We investigated the association between sex differences in reproductive strategies, spatial behavior, and androgen levels in three species of poison frogs. We tracked individuals in natural environments to show that contrasting parental sex roles shape sex differences in space use, where the sex performing parental duties shows wider-ranging movements. We then translocated frogs from their home areas to test their navigational performance and found that the caring sex outperformed the non-caring sex only in one out of three species. In addition, males across species displayed more explorative behavior than females and androgen levels correlated with explorative behavior and homing accuracy. Overall, we reveal that poison frog reproductive strategies shape movement patterns but not necessarily navigational performance. Together this work suggests that prevailing adaptive hypotheses provide an incomplete explanation of sex differences in spatial abilities.
Thompson González, Nicole; Machanda, Zarin; Otali, Emily; Muller, Martin N.; Enigk, Drew K.; Wrangham, Richard; Emery Thompson, Melissa
(, Evolution, Medicine, and Public Health)
Abstract BackgroundSocial isolation is a key risk factor for the onset and progression of age-related disease and mortality in humans. Nevertheless, older people commonly have narrowing social networks, with influences from both cultural factors and the constraints of senescence. We evaluate evolutionarily grounded models by studying social aging in wild chimpanzees, a system where such influences are more easily separated than in humans, and where individuals are long-lived and decline physically with age. MethodologyWe applied social network analysis to examine age-related changes in social integration in a 7+ year mixed-longitudinal dataset on 38 wild adult chimpanzees (22 females, 16 males). Metrics of social integration included social attractivity and overt effort (directed degree and strength), social roles (betweenness and local transitivity) and embeddedness (eigenvector centrality) in grooming networks. ResultsBoth sexes reduced the strength of direct ties with age (males in-strength, females out-strength). However, males increased embeddedness with age, alongside cliquishness. These changes were independent of age-related changes in social and reproductive status. Both sexes maintained highly repeatable inter-individual differences in integration, particularly in mixed-sex networks. Conclusions and implicationsAs in humans, chimpanzees appear to experience senescence-related declines in social engagement. However, male social embeddedness and overall sex differences were patterned more similarly to humans in non-industrialized versus industrialized societies. Such comparisons suggest common evolutionary roots to ape social aging and that social isolation in older humans may hinge on novel cultural factors of many industrialized societies. Lastly, individual and sex differences are potentially important mediators of successful social aging in chimpanzees, as in humans.Lay summary: Few biological models explain why humans so commonly have narrowing social networks with age, despite the risk factor of social isolation that small networks pose. We use wild chimpanzees as a comparative system to evaluate models grounded in an evolutionary perspective, using social network analysis to examine changes in integration with age. Like humans in industrialized populations, chimpanzees had lower direct engagement with social partners as they aged. However, sex differences in integration and older males’ central positions within the community network were more like patterns of sociality in several non-industrialized human populations. Our results suggest common evolutionary roots to human and chimpanzee social aging, and that the risk of social isolation with age in industrialized populations stems from novel cultural factors.
Abstract BackgroundMorphologic sex differences between males and females typically emerge after the primordial germ cell migration and gonad formation, although sex is determined at fertilization based on chromosome composition. A key debated sexual difference is the embryonic developmental rate, within vitroproduced male embryos often developing faster. However, the molecular mechanisms driving early embryonic sex differences remain unclear. ResultsTo investigate the transcriptional sex difference during early development,in vitroproduced bovine blastocysts were collected and sexed by PCR. A significant male-biased development was observed in expanded blastocysts. Ultra-low input RNA-seq analysis identified 837 DEGs, with 231 upregulated and 606 downregulated in males. Functional enrichment analysis revealed male-biased DEGs were associated with metabolic regulation, whereas female-biased DEGs were related to female gonad development, sex differentiation, inflammatory pathways, and TGF-beta signaling. Comparing X chromosome and autosome expression ratio, we found that female-biased DEGs contributed to the higher X-linked gene dosage, a phenomenon not observed in male embryos. Moreover, we identified the sex-biased transcription factors and RNA-bind proteins, including pluripotent factors such asSOX21andPRDM14, and splicing factorsFMR1andHNRNPH2. Additionally, we revealed 1,555 significantly sex-biased differential alternative splicing (AS), predominantly skipped exons, mapped to 906 genes, with 59 overlapping with DEGs enriched in metabolic and autophagy pathways. By incorporating novel isoforms from long reads sequencing, we identified 1,151 sex-biased differentially expressed isoforms (DEIs) associated with 1,017 genes. Functional analysis showed that female-biased DEIs were involved in the negative regulation of transcriptional activity, while male-biased DEIs were related to energy metabolism. Furthermore, we identified sex-biased differential exon usage inDENND1B, DIS3L2, DOCK11, IL1RAPL2,andZRSR2Y,indicating their sex-specific regulation in early embryo development. ConclusionThis study provided a comprehensive analysis of transcriptome differences between male and female bovine blastocysts, integrating sex-biased gene expression, alternative splicing, and isoform dynamics. Our findings indicate that enriched metabolism processes in male embryos may contribute to the faster developmental pace, providing insights into sex-specific regulatory mechanisms during early embryogenesis. Plain English summaryMale and female early embryos develop at different speeds, with male embryos often developing faster than female embryos. However, the reasons behind these early differences remain unclear. In this study, we examined gene activity in bovine embryos to uncover the biological factors regulating these early sex differences. We collected in vitro-produced bovine blastocysts, examined their sex, and confirmed that male embryos develop faster. By analyzing global gene activity, including alternative splicing, which allows one gene to code for multiple RNA isoforms and proteins, we found distinct gene expression profiles between male and female embryos. Male embryos showed higher activity in genes related to metabolism and cellular functions, while female embryos had increased activity in genes associated with female-specific gonad development and gene expression regulation. We also examined differences in how genes on the X chromosome were expressed. Female embryos had higher X-linked gene expression, which may contribute to sex-specific developmental regulation. Additionally, we identified sex-specific transcription factors and RNA-binding proteins that regulate early embryo development, some of which are known to control pluripotency and gene splicing. Overall, our study provides new insights into how gene activity shapes early sex differences, suggesting that enhanced metabolism in male embryos may be a key driver of their faster developmental rate. HighlightsMale embryos develop faster due to increased gene expression in metabolism pathwaysFemale embryos exhibit higher X-linked gene expression, suggesting X-dosage compensation plays a role in early developmentSex-biased alternative splicing events contribute to embryonic metabolism, autophagy, and transcriptional regulation in embryosSex-biased isoform diversity contributes to distinct developmental regulation in male and female embryosKey pluripotency factors (SOX21, PRDM14) and splicing regulators (FMR1, HNRNPH2) drive sex-specific gene expression
Newcombe, Nora S. The Puzzle of Spatial Sex Differences: Current Status and Prerequisites to Solutions. Child Development Perspectives 14.4 Web. doi:10.1111/cdep.12389.
Newcombe, Nora S. The Puzzle of Spatial Sex Differences: Current Status and Prerequisites to Solutions. Child Development Perspectives, 14 (4). https://doi.org/10.1111/cdep.12389
@article{osti_10455020,
place = {Country unknown/Code not available},
title = {The Puzzle of Spatial Sex Differences: Current Status and Prerequisites to Solutions},
url = {https://par.nsf.gov/biblio/10455020},
DOI = {10.1111/cdep.12389},
abstractNote = {Abstract In this review, I summarize what we know about the development of sex‐related differences in spatial skills, their potential malleability, and their possible causes. Current evidence suggests that sex differences increase in size with age, at least for skills with assessments suitable for use across development. However, male advantages vary from nonexistent to substantial, depending on the skills assessed, task parameters, and culture. Training and practice can improve spatial skills, although interventions tested so far do not eliminate the male advantage (when there is one). The complex pattern of increases with age, task variation, and cultural variation challenges efforts to theorize about causation. Progress requires identifying the underlying cognitive and neural structure of the spatial domain, developing reliable and valid assessment tools suitable for use across wide age ranges, gathering large datasets from a variety of cultural settings, and identifying and investigating specific mechanisms for growth and change.},
journal = {Child Development Perspectives},
volume = {14},
number = {4},
publisher = {Wiley-Blackwell},
author = {Newcombe, Nora S.},
}
Warning: Leaving National Science Foundation Website
You are now leaving the National Science Foundation website to go to a non-government website.
Website:
NSF takes no responsibility for and exercises no control over the views expressed or the accuracy of
the information contained on this site. Also be aware that NSF's privacy policy does not apply to this site.
An official website of the United States government
