skip to main content


Title: Weighting effective number of species measures by abundance weakens detection of diversity responses
Abstract

The effective number of species (ENS) has been proposed as a robust measure of species diversity that overcomes several limitations in terms of both diversity indices and species richness (SR). However, it is not yet clear ifENSimproves interpretation and comparison of biodiversity monitoring data, and ultimately resource management decisions.

We used simulations of five stream macroinvertebrate assemblages and spatially extensive field data of stream fishes and mussels to show (a) how differentENSformulations respond to stress and (b) how diversity–environment relationships change with values ofq, which weightENSmeasures by species abundances.

Values ofENSderived from whole simulated assemblages with all species weighted equally (true SR) steadily decreased as stress increased, andENS‐stress relationships became weaker and more different among assemblages with increased weighting.

The amount of variation inENSacross the fish and mussel assemblages that was associated with environmental gradients decreased with increasingq.

Synthesis and applications. Species diversity is valued by many human societies, which often have policies designed to protect and restore it. Natural resources managers and policy makers may use species richness and diversity indices to describe the status of ecological communities. However, these traditional diversity measures are known subject to limitations that hinder their interpretation and comparability. The effective number of species (ENS) was proposed to overcome the limitations. Unfortunately, our analyses show thatENSdoes not improve interpretability of how species diversity responds to either stress or natural environmental gradients. Moreover, incorporating the relative abundance of individuals in different species (evenness) into diversity measures as implemented inENScan actually weaken detection of diversity responses. Natural resources managers and policy makers therefore need to be cautious when interpreting diversity measures, includingENS, whose values are jointly influenced by richness and evenness. We suggest that both researchers and practitioners measure and report three aspects of diversity (species richness, evenness, and composition) separately when assessing and monitoring the diversity of ecological communities.

 
more » « less
PAR ID:
10461395
Author(s) / Creator(s):
 ;  ;
Publisher / Repository:
Wiley-Blackwell
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Journal of Applied Ecology
Volume:
56
Issue:
5
ISSN:
0021-8901
Page Range / eLocation ID:
p. 1200-1209
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract

    The study of diversity has become increasingly sophisticated, including the use of measures of phylogenetic diversity.

    We calculate the spatial variation in species richness, taxonomic beta diversity, and alpha and beta phylogenetic diversity (PDαandPDβ, respectively) of Atlantic Forest harvestman communities using a data set containing 556 species from 68 sites, distributed in 12 Brazilian states.

    We compare the congruence of phylogenetic and taxonomic diversity patterns, and also comparePDαwith null model expectations, to check for phylogenetic clustering or overdispersion in communities.

    Species richness andPDαare correlated, peaking in southern and south‐eastern coastal sites and decreasing towards the interior and towards the north‐east.PDαin north‐eastern sites was higher than expected, while a clustered phylogenetic pattern characterised most other sites.

    Communities in the southern and south‐eastern regions were dominated by species from the large family Gonyleptidae, presenting a high richness and a lowPDα. As the dominance of Gonyleptidae decreased towards the north, where local communities have fewer species, but a higherPDα, they contain representatives of other families. The beta diversity was more sensitive to the compositional changes involving closely related Gonyleptidae species, whilePDβis more influenced by deeper phylogenetic compositional changes, between more distant lineages.

    Phylogenetic diversity may be of special importance to assess the conservation value of distantly related lineages. These species‐poor groups are less likely to influence taxonomic‐based diversity analyses, but their importance for conservation arises from their phylogenetic distinctiveness, captured byPDαandPDβmeasures.

     
    more » « less
  2. Summary

    Diacylglycerol kinase (DGK) phosphorylates diacylglycerol (DAG) to generate phosphatidic acid (PA), and bothDAGandPAare lipid mediators in the cell. Here we show thatDGK1 in rice (Oryza sativa) plays important roles in root growth and development.

    Two independentOsDGK1‐knockout (dgk1) lines exhibited a higher density of lateral roots (LRs) and thinner seminal roots (SRs), whereasOsDGK1‐overexpressing plants displayed a lowerLRdensity and thickerSRsthan wild‐type (WT) plants.

    Overexpression ofOsDGK1led to a decline in theDGKsubstrateDAGwhereas specificPAspecies decreased indgk1roots. Supplementation ofDAGtoOsDGK1‐overexpressing seedlings restored theLRdensity andSRthickness whereas application ofPAtodgk1seedlings restored theLRdensity andSRthickness to those of theWT. In addition, treatment of rice seedlings with theDGKinhibitor R59022 increased the level ofDAGand decreasedPA, which also restored the root phenotype ofOsDGK1‐overexpressing seedlings close to that of theWT.

    Together, these results indicate thatDGK1 and associated lipid mediators modulate rice root architecture;DAGpromotesLRformation and suppressesSRgrowth whereasPAsuppressesLRnumber and promotesSRthickness.

     
    more » « less
  3. Summary

    Mesophyll conductance (gm) is the diffusion ofCO2from intercellular air spaces (IAS) to the first site of carboxylation in the mesophyll cells. In C3species,gmis influenced by diverse leaf structural and anatomical traits; however, little is known about traits affectinggmin C4species.

    To address this knowledge gap, we used online oxygen isotope discrimination measurements to estimategmand microscopy techniques to measure leaf structural and anatomical traits potentially related togmin 18 C4grasses.

    In this study,gmscaled positively with photosynthesis and intrinsic water‐use efficiency (TEi), but not with stomatal conductance. Also,gmwas not determined by a single trait but was positively correlated with adaxial stomatal densities (SDada), stomatal ratio (SR), mesophyll surface area exposed toIAS(Smes) and leaf thickness. However,gmwas not related to abaxial stomatal densities (SDaba) and mesophyll cell wall thickness (TCW).

    Our study suggests that greaterSDadaandSRincreasedgmby increasingSmesand creating additional parallel pathways forCO2diffusion inside mesophyll cells. Thus,SDada,SRandSmesare important determinants of C4gmand could be the target traits selected or modified for achieving greatergmandTEiin C4species.

     
    more » « less
  4. Summary

    The biological and functional diversity of ectomycorrhizal (ECM) associations remain largely unknown in South America. In Patagonia, theECMtreeNothofagus pumilioforms monospecific forests along mountain slopes without confounding effects of vegetation on plant–fungi interactions.

    To determine how fungal diversity and function are linked to elevation, we characterized fungal communities, edaphic variables, and eight extracellular enzyme activities along six elevation transects in Tierra del Fuego (Argentina and Chile). We also tested whether pairingITS1rDNAIllumina sequences generated taxonomic biases related to sequence length.

    Fungal community shifts across elevations were mediated primarily by soilpHwith the most species‐rich fungal families occurring mostly within a narrowpHrange. By contrast, enzyme activities were minimally influenced by elevation but correlated with soil factors, especially total soil carbon. The activity of leucine aminopeptidase was positively correlated withECMfungal richness and abundance, and acid phosphatase was correlated with nonECM fungal abundance. Several fungal lineages were undetected when using exclusively paired or unpaired forwardITS1 sequences, and these taxonomic biases need reconsideration for future studies.

    Our results suggest that soil fungi inN. pumilioforests are functionally similar across elevations and that these diverse communities help to maintain nutrient mobilization across the elevation gradient.

     
    more » « less
  5. Abstract Questions

    What are the primary biotic and abiotic factors driving composition and abundance of naturally regenerated tree seedlings across forest landscapes of Maine? Do seedling species richness (SR) and density (SD) decrease with improved growing conditions (climate and soil), but increase with increased diversity of overstorey composition and structure? Does partial harvesting disproportionately favour relative dominance of shade‐intolerant hardwoods (PIHD) over shade‐tolerant softwoods (PTSD)?

    Location

    Forest landscapes across the diverse eco‐regions and forest types of Maine,USA.

    Methods

    This study usedUSDAForest Service Forest Inventory Analysis permanent plots (n = 10 842), measured every 5 yr since 1999. The best models for each response variable (SR,SD,PIHDandPTSD) were developed based onAICand biological interpretability, while considering 35 potential explanatory variables incorporating climate, soil, site productivity, overstorey structure and composition, and past harvesting.

    Results

    Mean annual temperature was the most important abiotic factor, whereas overstorey tree size diversity was the most important biotic factor forSRandSD. Both mean annual temperature and overstorey tree size diversity had a curvilinear relationship withSRandSD. Average overstorey shade tolerance and percentage tolerant softwood basal area in the overstorey were the top predictor variables ofPIHDandPTSD,respectively. Partial harvesting favouredPIHDbut notPTSD.

    Conclusions

    This is one of the first studies to comprehensively evaluate a number of factors influencing naturally established tree seedlings at a broad landscape scale in the Northern Forest region of the easternUSAand Canada. Despite limitations associated with relatively small plot size, large seedling size class and lack of direct measurements of light, water and nutrients, this study documents the influence of these factors amid high variability associated with patterns of natural regeneration. The curvilinear relationship between mean annual temperature withSRandSDsupports the argument that species richness and abundance usually have unimodal relationships with productivity indicators, whereas the curvilinear relationship between overstorey tree size diversity andSRandSDsuggest that moderate overstorey diversity incorporates multiple species as well as higher seedling individuals.

     
    more » « less