skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Explore Research Products in the PAR
It may take a few hours for recently added research products to appear in PAR search results.


  • NSF Public Access
  • Search Results
  • Differences in respiration rates and abrasion losses may muddle attribution of breakdown to macroinvertebrates versus microbes in litterbag experiments
Title: Differences in respiration rates and abrasion losses may muddle attribution of breakdown to macroinvertebrates versus microbes in litterbag experiments
Abstract Leaf breakdown is an important process in forested headwater streams. A common method used to quantify the role of macroinvertebrate and microbial communities in leaf litter breakdown involves using paired mesh bags that either allow or exclude macroinvertebrate access to leaves. We examined common assumptions of the paired litterbag method to test (1) whether mesh size alters microbial respiration and (2) whether the effects of abrasive flows (e.g., from water and sediment) differ between coarse‐ and fine‐mesh litterbags. We measured rates of microbial respiration on Acer rubrum and Rhododendron maximum leaves incubated in coarse‐ and fine‐mesh litterbags. We also measured rates of abrasion using aerated concrete blocks in pairs of coarse‐ and fine‐mesh bags in ten streams across a gradient of discharge. We found that rates of microbial respiration on Acer rubrum leaves conditioned in fine‐mesh bags were 65% greater than the rates of respiration in paired coarse‐mesh bags, but respiration rates on Rhododendron maximum were similar in coarse‐ and fine‐mesh bags. Abrasion was, on average, 56% greater in coarse‐mesh than paired fine‐mesh bags, and these effects were greater in streams with higher discharge. These results suggest that more caution is required when attributing the difference in leaf breakdown between coarse‐ and fine‐mesh bags to macroinvertebrates. Because the effect of mesh size on microbial respiration of Acer leaves and abrasion are opposite in direction, the effect that dominates and creates bias likely depends on both environmental context and experimental design.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1655789
PAR ID:
10465717
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
River Research and Applications
Volume:
38
Issue:
10
ISSN:
1535-1459
Page Range / eLocation ID:
1721 to 1729
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. ; ; ; (, Ecology)
    Abstract Understanding the observed temperature dependence of decomposition (i.e., its apparent activation energy) requires separation of direct effects of temperature on consumer metabolism (i.e., the inherent activation energy) from those driven by indirect seasonal patterns in phenology and biomass, and by longer‐term, climate‐driven shifts in acclimation, adaptation, and community assembly. Such parsing is important because studies that relate temperature to decomposition usually involve multi‐season data and/or spatial proxies for long‐term shifts, and so incorporate these indirect factors. The various effects of such factors can obscure the inherent temperature dependence of detrital processing. Separating the inherent temperature dependence of decomposition from other drivers is important for accurate prediction of the contribution of detritus‐sourced greenhouse gases to climate warming and requires novel approaches to data collection and analysis. Here, we present breakdown rates of red maple litter incubated in coarse‐ and fine‐mesh litterbags (the latter excluding macroinvertebrates) for serial approximately one‐month increments over one year in nine streams along a natural temperature gradient (mean annual: 12.8°–16.4°C) from north Georgia to central Alabama, USA. We analyzed these data using distance‐based redundancy analysis and generalized additive mixed models to parse the dependence of decomposition rates on temperature, seasonality, and shredding macroinvertebrate biomass. Microbial decomposition in fine‐mesh bags was significantly influenced by both temperature and seasonality. Accounting for seasonality corrected the temperature dependence of decomposition rate from 0.25 to 0.08 eV. Shredder assemblage structure in coarse‐mesh bags was related to temperature across both sites and seasons, shifting from “cold” stonefly‐dominated communities to “warm” communities dominated by snails or crayfish. Shredder biomass was not a significant predictor of either coarse‐mesh or macroinvertebrate‐mediated (i.e., coarse‐ minus fine‐mesh) breakdown rates, which were also jointly influenced by temperature and seasonality. Unlike fine‐mesh bags, however, temperature dependence of litter breakdown did not differ between models with and without seasonality for either coarse‐mesh (0.36 eV) or macroinvertebrate‐mediated (0.13 eV) rates. We conclude that indirect (non‐thermal) seasonal and site‐level effects play a variable and potentially strong role in shaping the apparent temperature dependence of detrital breakdown. Such effects should be incorporated into studies designed to estimate inherent temperature dependence of slow ecological processes. 
    more » « less
  2. ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; (, Ecosphere)
    Abstract Disturbances can alter the structure and function of ecosystems. In stream ecosystems, changes in discharge and physicochemistry at short, intermediate, and long recurrence intervals can affect food webs and ecosystem processes. In this paper, we compare pH regimes in streams at La Selva Biological Station, Costa Rica, where episodic acidification frequency across the stream network varies widely due to buffering from inputs of bicarbonate‐rich interbasin groundwater. To examine the effects of acidification on ecosystem structure and function, we experimentally increased the buffering capacity of a headwater stream reach and compared it to an unbuffered upstream reach. We compared these reaches to a naturally buffered and unbuffered reaches of a second headwater stream. We quantified ecosystem structural (macroinvertebrate assemblages on leaf litter and coarse woody debris) and functional responses (leaf litter and coarse woody debris decomposition rates, and growth rates of a focal insect taxon [Diptera: Chironomidae]). Non‐metric multidimensional scaling and analysis of similarity revealed that macroinvertebrate assemblages were relatively homogenous across the four study reaches, although the naturally buffered reach was the most dissimilar. Ecosystem function, as measured by chironomid growth rates, was greater in the naturally buffered reach, while decomposition rates did not differ across the four reaches. Our results indicate that biological assemblages are adapted to pH regimes of frequently acidified stream reaches. Our experiment informs the effects on structure and function at short time scales in streams that experience moderate acidification, but larger magnitude acidification events in response to hydroclimatic change, as projected under climate change scenarios, may induce stronger responses in streams. 
    more » « less
  3. ; ; ; ; (, Freshwater Science)
    Forested headwater streams disproportionately rely on inputs of organic matter to fuel their food webs, and characterizing the breakdown of organic matter offers insights into ecosystem function. Organic matter breakdown rates can be influenced by the availability of limiting nutrients, and describing patterns of breakdown rates across nutrient gradients is increasingly relevant as inland waters undergo eutrophication. Here, we determined the breakdown rates of coarse woody debris (kwood) across 5 streams located at La Selva Biological Station, Costa Rica, that receive a gradient of interbasin modified groundwater inputs, creating a gradient in P concentration (6–134 lg/L soluble reactive P [SRP]). The fastest breakdown rate (kwood 50.77/y) occurred in the stream with the highest SRP, and kwood was positively correlated with SRP across the 5 streams. Further, we characterized the assemblage of macroinvertebrates from wood packs. Macroinvertebrate assemblages were different between the 5 streams, with more dense and diverse assemblages in streams with higher SRP and faster breakdown rates. Our results contribute to a growing field of study on the effect of nutrients on organic matter dynamics in inland waters by characterizing the effect of SRP on breakdown rates of wood in tropical streams. 
    more » « less
  4. ; ; ; (, Forests)
    In northern hardwood forests, litter decomposition might be affected by nutrient availability, species composition, stand age, or access by decomposers. We investigated these factors at the Bartlett Experimental Forest in New Hampshire. Leaf litter of early and late successional species was collected from four stands that had full factorial nitrogen and phosphorus additions to the soil and were deployed in bags of two mesh sizes (63 µm and 2 mm) in two young and two mature stands. Litter bags were collected three times over the next 2 years, and mass loss was described as an exponential function of time represented by a thermal sum. Litter from young stands had higher initial N and P concentrations and decomposed more quickly than litter from mature stands (p = 0.005), regardless of where it was deployed. Litter decomposed more quickly in fine mesh bags that excluded mesofauna (p < 0.001), which might be explained by the greater rigidity of the large mesh material making poor contact with the soil. Neither nutrient addition (p = 0.94 for N, p = 0.26 for P) nor the age of the stand in which bags were deployed (p = 0.36) had a detectable effect on rates of litter decomposition. 
    more » « less
  5. ; ; (, PLOS ONE)
    Schädler, Martin (Ed.)
    Decomposition is an essential ecosystem service driven by interacting biotic and abiotic factors. Increasing temperatures due to climate change can affect soil moisture, soil fauna, and subsequently, decomposition. Understanding how projected climate change scenarios will affect decomposition is of vital importance for predicting nutrient cycling and ecosystem health. In this study, we experimentally addressed the question of how the early stages of decomposition would vary along a gradient of projected climate change scenarios. Given the importance of biodiversity for ecosystem service provisioning, we measured the effect of invertebrate exclusion on red maple ( Acer rubrum ) leaf litter breakdown along a temperature gradient using litterbags in warming chambers over a period of five weeks. Leaf litter decomposed more slowly in the warmer chambers and in the litterbag treatment that minimized invertebrate access. Moreover, increasing air temperature reduced invertebrate abundance and richness, and altered the community composition, independent of exclusion treatment. Using structural equation models, we were able to disentangle the effects of average air temperature on leaf litter loss, finding a direct negative effect of warming on the early stages of decomposition, independent of invertebrate abundance. This result indicates that not only can climate change affect the invertebrate community, but may also directly influence how the remaining organisms interact with their environment and their effectiveness at provisioning ecosystem services. Overall, our study highlights the role of biodiversity in maintaining ecosystem services and contributes to our understanding of how climate change could disrupt nutrient cycling. 
    more » « less
  • Citation Formats
  • MLA
  • APA
  • Chicago
  • BibTeX
  • Save / Share this Record
  • Send to Email