The NSF Public Access Repository (PAR) system and access will be unavailable from 11:00 PM ET on Thursday, November 12th until 12:00 AM ET on Friday, November 13th due to maintenance. We apologize for the inconvenience.
Explore Research Products in the PAR It may take a few hours for recently added research products to appear in PAR search results.
Title: Modeling effects of matrix heterogeneity on population persistence at the patch-level
Habitat loss and fragmentation is the largest contributing factor to species extinction and declining biodiversity. Landscapes are becoming highly spatially heterogeneous with varying degrees of human modification. Much theoretical study of habitat fragmentation has historically focused on a simple theoretical landscape with patches of habitat surrounded by a spatially homogeneous hostile matrix. However, terrestrial habitat patches are often surrounded by complex mosaics of many different land cover types, which are rarely ecologically neutral or completely inhospitable environments. We employ an extension of a reaction diffusion model to explore effects of heterogeneity in the matrix immediately surrounding a patch in a one-dimensional theoretical landscape. Exact dynamics of a population exhibiting logistic growth, an unbiased random walk in the patch and matrix, habitat preference at the patch/matrix interface, and two functionally different matrix types for the one-dimensional landscape is obtained. These results show existence of a minimum patch size (MPS), below which population persistence is not possible. This MPS can be estimated via empirically derived estimates of patch intrinsic growth rate and diffusion rate, habitat preference, and matrix death and diffusion rates. We conclude that local matrix heterogeneity can greatly change model predictions, and argue that conservation strategies should not only consider patch size, configuration, and quality, but also quality and spatial structure of the surrounding matrix. more »« less
Fletcher, Robert J.; Smith, Thomas A.; Kortessis, Nicholas; Bruna, Emilio M.; Holt, Robert D.
(, Ecology)
Abstract Habitat loss is often considered the greatest near‐term threat to biodiversity, while the impact of habitat fragmentation remains intensely debated. A key issue of this debate centers on the problem of scale–landscape or patch–at which to assess the consequences of fragmentation. Yet patterns are often confounded across scales, and experimental designs that could solve this scaling problem remain scarce. We conducted two field experiments in 30 experimental landscapes in which we manipulated habitat loss, fragmentation, and patch size for a community of four insect herbivores that specialize on the cactusOpuntia. In the first experiment, we destroyed 2088Opuntiapatches in either aggregated or random patterns and compared the relative effects of landscape‐scale loss and fragmentation to those of local patch size on species occurrence. This experiment focused on manipulating the relative separation of remaining patches, where we hypothesized that aggregated loss would disrupt dispersal more than random loss, leading to lower occurrence. In the second experiment, we destroyed 759Opuntiapatches to generate landscapes that varied in patch number and size for a given amount of habitat loss and assessed species occurrence. This experiment focused on manipulating the subdivision of remaining habitat, where we hypothesized that an increase in the number of patches for a given amount of loss would lead to negative effects on occurrence. For both, we expected that occurrence would increase with patch size. We find strong evidence for landscape‐scale effects of habitat fragmentation, with aggregated loss and a larger number of patches for a given amount of habitat loss leading to a lower frequency of patches occupied in landscapes. In both experiments, occurrence increased with patch size, yet interactions of patch size and landscape‐scale loss and fragmentation drove species occurrence in patches. Importantly, the direction of effects were consistent across scales and effects of patch size were sufficient to predict the effects of habitat loss and fragmentation across entire landscapes. Our experimental results suggest that changes at both the patch and landscape scales can impact populations, but that a long‐standing pattern—the patch‐size effect—captures much of the key variation shaping patterns of species occurrence.
Fletcher, Robert J.; Betts, Matthew G.; Damschen, Ellen I.; Hefley, Trevor J.; Hightower, Jessica; Smith, Thomas A.; Fortin, Marie‐Josée; Haddad, Nick M.
(, Global Ecology and Biogeography)
Abstract Fragmentation and scaleAlthough habitat loss has well‐known impacts on biodiversity, the effects of habitat fragmentation remain intensely debated. It is often argued that the effects of habitat fragmentation, or the breaking apart of habitat for a given habitat amount, can be understood only at the scale of entire landscapes composed of multiple habitat patches. Yet, fragmentation also impacts the size, isolation and habitat edge for individual patches within landscapes. Addressing the problem of scale on fragmentation effects is crucial for resolving how fragmentation impacts biodiversity. Scaling frameworkWe build upon scaling concepts in ecology to describe a framework that emphasizes three “dimensions” of scale in habitat fragmentation research: the scales of phenomena (or mechanisms), sampling and analysis. Using this framework, we identify ongoing challenges and provide guidance for advancing the science of fragmentation. ImplicationsWe show that patch‐ and landscape‐scale patterns arising from habitat fragmentation for a given amount of habitat are fundamentally related, leading to interdependencies among expected patterns arising from different scales of phenomena. Aggregation of information when increasing the grain of sampling (e.g., from patch to landscape) creates challenges owing to biases created from the modifiable areal unit problem. Consequently, we recommend that sampling strategies use the finest grain that captures potential underlying mechanisms (e.g., plot or patch). Study designs that can capture phenomena operating at multiple spatial extents offer the most promise for understanding the effects of fragmentation and its underlying mechanisms. By embracing the interrelationships among scales, we expect more rapid advances in our understanding of habitat fragmentation.
Hulting, Katherine A; Brudvig, Lars A; Damschen, Ellen I; Levey, Douglas J; Resasco, Julian; Tewksbury, Joshua J; Haddad, Nick M
(, Journal of Ecology)
Abstract Habitat loss is a major threat to biodiversity, but the effects of habitat fragmentation are less clear. Examining drivers of key demographic processes, such as reproduction, will clarify species‐level responses to fragmentation and broader effects on biodiversity. Yet, understanding how fragmentation affects demography has been challenging due to the many ways landscapes are altered by co‐occurring habitat loss and fragmentation, coupled with the rarity of experiments to disentangle these effects.In a large, replicated fragmentation experiment with open savanna habitats surrounded by pine plantation forests, we tested the effects of inter‐patch connectivity, patch edge‐to‐area ratio, and within‐patch distance from an edge on plant reproductive output. Using five experimentally planted species of restoration interest—three wind‐pollinated grass species and two insect‐pollinated forb species—we measured plant flowering, pollination rate, and seed production.All plant species were more likely to flower and produce more flowering structures farther from the forest edge. Connectivity and distance from an edge, however, had no effect on the pollination rate (regardless of pollination mode). Despite no influence of fragmentation on pollination, plant seed production increased farther from the edge for four of five species, driven by the increase in flower production.Synthesis. Altogether, we demonstrate that plant reproductive output (seed production) is decreased by habitat fragmentation through edge effects on flowering. Our work provides evidence that an important contributor to plant demography, reproductive output, is altered by edge effects in fragmented patches. These species‐level impacts of fragmentation may provide insight into the mechanisms of fragmentation effects on community‐level changes in biodiversity.
Abstract: Globally, habitat loss and fragmentation pose significant threats to biodiversity. Habitat corridors are often used in fragmented landscapes to reconnect isolated patches. However, understanding how corridors function can be challenging, as their effects may be confounded with simultaneous changes to habitat area, edge amount, and connectivity among patches. Here, we used a long-term, landscape-scale experiment to investigate two potential mechanisms by which corridors may influence biodiversity - via increasing habitat connectivity or through increasing the amount of edge. With pitfall trap sampling conducted over 5 years (9 to 15 years since site establishment), we assessed the relative effects of connectivity and edge effects by measuring ant biodiversity in four ways: (1) taxonomic diversity, (2) functional diversity, (3) community composition, and (4) site-to-site variance in community composition (i.e., beta diversity). We found evidence of both connectivity and edge effects on ant diversity and community composition. Taxonomic diversity increased linearly in all patch types over time yet accumulated more quickly in connected than isolated patches. The faster accumulation of taxonomic diversity in connected patches was associated with greater site-to-site variance in community composition. Although we found no differences in mean taxonomic diversity within patches (alpha diversity), the faster accumulation of taxonomic diversity and greater beta diversity among patches with corridors suggests that ant diversity in connected patches may eventually surpass that of isolated patch types. Finally, while we found no effect of edge amount for how fast taxonomic diversity accumulated over time, functional group diversity accumulated more quickly in winged patches that have more edge habitat relative to interior habitat than rectangular patches. Taken together, these results add to a body of literature that shows the potential for habitat corridors to have positive effects on biodiversity by increasing connectivity and that these effects may continue to accrue over time. TechnicalInfo: # Data from: Corridors increase ant diversity over time Dataset DOI: [10.5061/dryad.z08kprrwn](https://doi.org/10.5061/dryad.z08kprrwn) ## Description of the data and file structure Ant community data were collected from the Savannah River Site Corridor Experiment between 2015 and 2019. Experimental landscapes within the Corridor Experiment were established at the Savannah River Site (SRS) in South Carolina in the winter of 1999-2000 and 2006. The Savannah River Site is a National Environmental Research Park, a United States Department of Energy site that is managed by the United States Department of Agriculture Forest Service. Each experimental landscape (N = 7) consists of a center square patch (1 ha) surrounded on each side by four peripheral patches that are each equal in area (~1.4 ha, Fig. 1) and located 150 m away. For each experimental landscape, one peripheral patch is connected to the center patch by a corridor (150×25 m; hereafter "connected"). The three remaining peripheral patches are isolated and are one of two types. They either have 75×25 m projections equal in area to the corridor on opposite sides (hereafter “winged”) or are rectangular in shape. Comparisons among these treatments allow us to disentangle the effects of connectivity and edge amount that typically confound the interpretation of habitat corridor effects. Thus, to isolate effects of connectivity, we compare winged and connected patches, and to isolate effects of edge amount we compare the winged patches with the rectangular patches. To characterize the ant community, in each year we deployed pitfall traps in the experimental landscapes between July and August, the time of peak ant activity in our study system. Once per year, we placed 22 pitfall traps within a permanent grid established in each of the landscape patches (Fig. 1; 66 traps per experimental landscape × 7 experimental landscapes = 462 traps/year). Pitfall traps were evenly dispersed across each patch, 25m away from the nearest neighboring pitfall trap with traps located along the edge 12.5m away from the matrix tree line. We randomly chose one of the duplicated isolated peripheral patch types at the start of sampling. Each pitfall trap consisted of a 50-mL centrifuge tube filled with 25 mL of a 50/50 solution of propylene glycol and 70% ethanol. We added a couple of drops of clear, unscented dish soap to each gallon of trapping solution to help break surface tension when arthropods fell into the trap. To account for digging-in effects, we dug traps at least 48 hours prior to opening (Greenslade 1973). To dig in traps, we removed a core of soil the same size as the 50 mL centrifuge tube. We opened traps for 48 hours when the chance of rain was low. After collecting traps at the end of sampling, we replaced the trapping solution with 95% ethanol and identified all ants to species or to species complexes with keys and species descriptions in (MacGown 2003). ### Files and variables #### File: FunctionalGroups.csv ##### Variables * Species: Genus and species epithet * Subfamily: Subfamily assigned to each ant species. * FunctionalGroup_Andersen: Functional grouping assigned to each species according to Andersen 1997. Functional groupings describe a species association with environmental attributes and their competitive abilities. These functional groupings include: dominant Dolichoderinae, subordinate Camponotini, hot climate specialists, cold climate specialists, tropical climate specialists, opportunists, generalized Myrmicinae, and cryptic species. * Functional_Group_DelToroetal: Functional grouping assigned to each species according to Del Toro et al. 2015. Del Toro et al.’s classification scheme separates ant species into four functional roles in ecosystems. These functional groupings include soil movers, decomposers, invertebrate community regulators, and seed dispersers * Native_YorN: Describes whether a species is native to the southeastern United States (Y = native, N = non-native). #### File: Corridor_AntCommunityData_2015to2019.csv ##### Variables * Year: Sampling year * Block: Identity assigned to each experimental landscape (n=7). * Patch: Letter assigned to each patch within a landscape. * Type: Experimental treatment assigned to each patch within each experimental landscape. Experimental treatments include (Connected, Rectangular, and Winged) * Species: Species of ant identified * ProportionOfTrapsWithSpp: Proportion of traps containing the species summarized at the patch level for each year.
James, Aubrie R.M.; Burnette, Timothy E.; Mack, Jasmine; James, David E.; Eckhart, Vincent M.; Geber, Monica A.
(, Journal of Ecology)
1. Spatial partitioning is a classic hypothesis to explain plant species coexistence, but evidence linking local environmental variation to spatial sorting, demography and species' traits is sparse. If co-occurring species' performance is optimized differently along environmental gradients because of trait variation, then spatial variation might facilitate coexistence. 2. We used a system of four naturally co-occurring species of Clarkia (Onagraceae) to ask whether distribution patchiness corresponds to variation in two environmental variables that contribute to hydrological variation. We then reciprocally sowed Clarkia into each patch type and measured demographic rates in the absence of congeneric competition. Species sorted in patches along one or both gradients, and in three of the four species, germination rate in the ‘home’ patch was higher than all other patches. 3. Spatially variable germination resulted in the same three species exhibiting the highest population growth rates in their home patches. 4. Species' trait values related to plant water use, as well as indicators of water stress in home patches, differed among species and corresponded to home patch attributes. However, post-germination survival did not vary among species or between patch types, and fecundity did not vary spatially. 5. Synthesis. Our research demonstrates the likelihood that within-community spatial heterogeneity affects plant species coexistence, and presents novel evidence that differential performance in space is explained by what happens in the germination stage. Despite the seemingly obvious link between adult plant water-use and variation in the environment, our results distinguish the germination stage as important for spatially variable population performance.
Fonseka, Nalin, Goddard Ⅱ, Jerome, Henderson, Alketa, Nichols, Dustin, and Shivaji, Ratnasingham. Modeling effects of matrix heterogeneity on population persistence at the patch-level. Retrieved from https://par.nsf.gov/biblio/10475125. Mathematical Biosciences and Engineering 19.12 Web. doi:10.3934/mbe.2022638.
Fonseka, Nalin, Goddard Ⅱ, Jerome, Henderson, Alketa, Nichols, Dustin, & Shivaji, Ratnasingham. Modeling effects of matrix heterogeneity on population persistence at the patch-level. Mathematical Biosciences and Engineering, 19 (12). Retrieved from https://par.nsf.gov/biblio/10475125. https://doi.org/10.3934/mbe.2022638
Fonseka, Nalin, Goddard Ⅱ, Jerome, Henderson, Alketa, Nichols, Dustin, and Shivaji, Ratnasingham.
"Modeling effects of matrix heterogeneity on population persistence at the patch-level". Mathematical Biosciences and Engineering 19 (12). Country unknown/Code not available: Mathematical Biosciences and Engineering. https://doi.org/10.3934/mbe.2022638.https://par.nsf.gov/biblio/10475125.
@article{osti_10475125,
place = {Country unknown/Code not available},
title = {Modeling effects of matrix heterogeneity on population persistence at the patch-level},
url = {https://par.nsf.gov/biblio/10475125},
DOI = {10.3934/mbe.2022638},
abstractNote = {Habitat loss and fragmentation is the largest contributing factor to species extinction and declining biodiversity. Landscapes are becoming highly spatially heterogeneous with varying degrees of human modification. Much theoretical study of habitat fragmentation has historically focused on a simple theoretical landscape with patches of habitat surrounded by a spatially homogeneous hostile matrix. However, terrestrial habitat patches are often surrounded by complex mosaics of many different land cover types, which are rarely ecologically neutral or completely inhospitable environments. We employ an extension of a reaction diffusion model to explore effects of heterogeneity in the matrix immediately surrounding a patch in a one-dimensional theoretical landscape. Exact dynamics of a population exhibiting logistic growth, an unbiased random walk in the patch and matrix, habitat preference at the patch/matrix interface, and two functionally different matrix types for the one-dimensional landscape is obtained. These results show existence of a minimum patch size (MPS), below which population persistence is not possible. This MPS can be estimated via empirically derived estimates of patch intrinsic growth rate and diffusion rate, habitat preference, and matrix death and diffusion rates. We conclude that local matrix heterogeneity can greatly change model predictions, and argue that conservation strategies should not only consider patch size, configuration, and quality, but also quality and spatial structure of the surrounding matrix.},
journal = {Mathematical Biosciences and Engineering},
volume = {19},
number = {12},
publisher = {Mathematical Biosciences and Engineering},
author = {Fonseka, Nalin and Goddard Ⅱ, Jerome and Henderson, Alketa and Nichols, Dustin and Shivaji, Ratnasingham},
editor = {Yang Kuang}
}
Warning: Leaving National Science Foundation Website
You are now leaving the National Science Foundation website to go to a non-government website.
Website:
NSF takes no responsibility for and exercises no control over the views expressed or the accuracy of
the information contained on this site. Also be aware that NSF's privacy policy does not apply to this site.