skip to main content

Title: Uncertainty sources for measurable ocean carbonate chemistry variables

The ocean carbonate system is critical to monitor because it plays a major role in regulating Earth's climate and marine ecosystems. It is monitored using a variety of measurements, and it is commonly understood that all components of seawater carbonate chemistry can be calculated when at least two carbonate system variables are measured. However, several recent studies have highlighted systematic discrepancies between calculated and directly measured carbonate chemistry variables and these discrepancies have large implications for efforts to measure and quantify the changing ocean carbon cycle. Given this, the Ocean Carbonate System Intercomparison Forum (OCSIF) was formed as a working group through the Ocean Carbon and Biogeochemistry program to coordinate and recommend research to quantify and/or reduce uncertainties and disagreements in measurable seawater carbonate system measurements and calculations, identify unknown or overlooked sources of these uncertainties, and provide recommendations for making progress on community efforts despite these uncertainties. With this paper we aim to (1) summarize recent progress toward quantifying and reducing carbonate system uncertainties; (2) advocate for research to further reduce and better quantify carbonate system measurement uncertainties; (3) present a small amount of new data, metadata, and analysis related to uncertainties in carbonate system measurements; and (4) restate and explain the rationales behind several OCSIF recommendations. We focus on open ocean carbonate chemistry, and caution that the considerations we discuss become further complicated in coastal, estuarine, and sedimentary environments.

more » « less
Award ID(s):
2148468 1923312
Author(s) / Creator(s):
 ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  
Publisher / Repository:
Wiley Blackwell (John Wiley & Sons)
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Limnology and Oceanography
Medium: X Size: p. 1-21
["p. 1-21"]
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract

    Carbonate chemistry variables such as PCO2, pH, and mineral saturation state (Ω) are commonly thought of as covarying in open‐ocean settings but have decoupled over geologic time‐scales and among modern dynamic coastal margins and estuaries. Predicting responses of vulnerable coastal organisms to past, present, and future ocean acidification (OA) scenarios requires the empirical identification of organismal sensitivity thresholds to individual carbonate chemistry parameters. Conversely, most OA experiments involve chemistry manipulations that result in covariance of carbonate system variables. We developed the Dynamic Ocean Acidification Manipulation Experimental System (DOAMES)—a feed‐forward, flow‐through carbonate chemistry control system capable of decoupling PCO2, pH, orΩby independently manipulating total alkalinity (TAlk) and total inorganic carbon (TCO2). DOAMES proof‐of‐concept can manipulate source seawater with stable or variable carbonate chemistry and produce experimental treatments with constant and dynamic carbonate chemistry regimes. The combination of dynamic input and output allows for offset treatments that impose a ΔPCO2on naturally variable conditions. After overcoming several operational challenges, DOAMES is capable of simultaneously generating three different experimental treatments within 1% ± 1% of TCO2and TAlk targets. The achieved precision and accuracy resulted in the successful decoupling of pH andΩArin five trials. We tested the viability of sensitive bivalve embryos raised in DOAMES‐manipulated seawater and found no difference in development when compared to the control, demonstrating DOAMES suitability for organismal studies. DOAMES provides a novel tool to evaluate organismal effects of exposure to decoupled carbonate system variables and to past, current, and future carbonate chemistry scenarios.

    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    Foraminiferal Mg/Ca has proven to be a powerful paleothermometer for reconstructing past sea‐surface temperature, which, among other applications, is a critical parameter for boron isotope reconstructions of past surface ocean pH and PCO2. However, recent laboratory culture studies indicate seawater pH and the total dissolved inorganic carbon content (DIC) may both exert a significant additional control on foraminiferal Mg/Ca, likely influencing paleotemperature records as a result of seawater chemistry evolution on geologic timescales. In addition, the seawater Mg/Ca composition (Mg/Casw) has been shown to reduce the sensitivity of foraminiferal Mg/Ca to temperature and possibly its sensitivity to the carbonate system as well. Here we present new Mg/Ca data from laboratory culture experiments with living planktic foraminifera—Globigerinoides ruber(p),Trilobatus sacculifer, andOrbulina universa— grown under a range of different pH and/or seawater DIC conditions and in low Mg/Caswto mimic the chemical composition of the Paleocene ocean. We also conducted targeted [Ca] experiments to help define Mg/Cacalcite–Mg/Caswrelationships for each species and conducted new pH experiments withG.bulloides. We find that pH effects on foraminiferal Mg/Ca are reduced or absent at Mg/Casw = 1.5 mol/mol in all three species, and thatT.sacculiferis generally insensitive to variable DIC and pH, making it the ideal species for Mg/Ca SST reconstructions back to 20 Ma. We apply our newT.sacculifercalibration to a Middle Miocene Mg/Ca record and provide recommendations for interpreting Mg/Ca records from extinct species.

    more » « less
  3. With the increasing threat of ocean acidification and the important role of the oceans in the global carbon cycle, highly precise, accurate, and intercomparable determination of inorganic carbon system parameters is required. Thermodynamic relationships enable the system to be fully constrained using a combination of direct measurements and calculations. However, calculations are complicated by many formulations for dissociation constants (over 120 possible combinations). To address these important issues of uncertainty and comparability, we evaluated the various combinations of constants and their (dis)agreement with direct measurements over a range of temperature (−1.9–40 ◦C), practical salinity (15–39) and pCO2 (150–1200 μatm). The results demonstrate that differences between the calculations and measurements are significantly larger than measurement uncertainties, meaning the oft-stated paradigm that one only needs to measure two parameters and the others can be calculated does not apply for climate quality ocean acidification research. The uncertainties in calculated pHt prevent climate quality pHt from being calculated from total alkalinity (TA) and dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) and should be directly measured instead. However, climate quality TA and DIC can often be calculated using measured pH and DIC or TA respectively. Calculations are notably biased at medium-to-high pCO2 values (~500–800 μatm) implying models underestimate future ocean acidification. Uncertainty in the dissociation constants leads to significant uncertainty in the depth of the aragonite saturation horizon (>500 m in the Southern Ocean) and must be considered when studying calcium carbonate cycling. Significant improvements in the precision of the thermodynamic constants are required to improve pHt calculations. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract. Accurate assessment of anthropogenic carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions and their redistribution among the atmosphere, ocean, and terrestrial biosphere in a changing climate is critical to better understand the global carbon cycle, support the development of climate policies, and project future climate change. Here we describe and synthesize data sets and methodology to quantify the five major components of the global carbon budget and their uncertainties. Fossil CO2 emissions (EFOS) are based on energy statistics and cement production data, while emissions from land-use change (ELUC), mainly deforestation, are based on land-use and land-use change data and bookkeeping models. Atmospheric CO2 concentration is measured directly, and its growth rate (GATM) is computed from the annual changes in concentration. The ocean CO2 sink (SOCEAN) is estimated with global ocean biogeochemistry models and observation-based fCO2 products. The terrestrial CO2 sink (SLAND) is estimated with dynamic global vegetation models. Additional lines of evidence on land and ocean sinks are provided by atmospheric inversions, atmospheric oxygen measurements, and Earth system models. The resulting carbon budget imbalance (BIM), the difference between the estimated total emissions and the estimated changes in the atmosphere, ocean, and terrestrial biosphere, is a measure of imperfect data and incomplete understanding of the contemporary carbon cycle. All uncertainties are reported as ±1σ. For the year 2022, EFOS increased by 0.9 % relative to 2021, with fossil emissions at 9.9±0.5 Gt C yr−1 (10.2±0.5 Gt C yr−1 when the cement carbonation sink is not included), and ELUC was 1.2±0.7 Gt C yr−1, for a total anthropogenic CO2 emission (including the cement carbonation sink) of 11.1±0.8 Gt C yr−1 (40.7±3.2 Gt CO2 yr−1). Also, for 2022, GATM was 4.6±0.2 Gt C yr−1 (2.18±0.1 ppm yr−1; ppm denotes parts per million), SOCEAN was 2.8±0.4 Gt C yr−1, and SLAND was 3.8±0.8 Gt C yr−1, with a BIM of −0.1 Gt C yr−1 (i.e. total estimated sources marginally too low or sinks marginally too high). The global atmospheric CO2 concentration averaged over 2022 reached 417.1±0.1 ppm. Preliminary data for 2023 suggest an increase in EFOS relative to 2022 of +1.1 % (0.0 % to 2.1 %) globally and atmospheric CO2 concentration reaching 419.3 ppm, 51 % above the pre-industrial level (around 278 ppm in 1750). Overall, the mean of and trend in the components of the global carbon budget are consistently estimated over the period 1959–2022, with a near-zero overall budget imbalance, although discrepancies of up to around 1 Gt C yr−1 persist for the representation of annual to semi-decadal variability in CO2 fluxes. Comparison of estimates from multiple approaches and observations shows the following: (1) a persistent large uncertainty in the estimate of land-use changes emissions, (2) a low agreement between the different methods on the magnitude of the land CO2 flux in the northern extra-tropics, and (3) a discrepancy between the different methods on the strength of the ocean sink over the last decade. This living-data update documents changes in methods and data sets applied to this most recent global carbon budget as well as evolving community understanding of the global carbon cycle. The data presented in this work are available at (Friedlingstein et al., 2023).

    more » « less
  5. Abstract Measuring, reporting, and verification (MRV) of ocean-based carbon dioxide removal (CDR) presents challenges due to the dynamic nature of the ocean and the complex processes influencing marine carbonate chemistry. Given these challenges, finding the optimal sampling strategies and suite of parameters to be measured is a timely research question. While traditional carbonate parameters such as total alkalinity (TA), dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC), pH, and seawater pCO2 are commonly considered, exploring the potential of carbon isotopes for quantifying additional CO2 uptake remains a relatively unexplored research avenue. In this study, we use a coupled physical-biogeochemical model of the California Current System (CCS) to run a suite of Ocean Alkalinity Enhancement (OAE) simulations. The physical circulation for the CCS is generated using a nested implementation of the Regional Ocean Modeling System (ROMS) with an outer domain of 1/10 ̊ (~10 km) and an inner domain of 1/30 ̊ (~3 km) resolution. The biogeochemical model, NEMUCSC, is a customized version of the North Pacific Ecosystem Model for Understanding Regional Oceanography (NEMURO) that includes carbon cycling and carbon isotopes. The CCS is one of four global eastern boundary upwelling systems characterized by high biological activity and CO2 concentrations. Consequently, the CCS represents an essential test case for investigating the efficacy and potential side effects of OAE deployments. The study aims to address two key questions: (1) the relative merit of OAE to counter ocean acidification versus the additional sequestration of CO2 from the atmosphere, and (2) the footprint of potentially harmful seawater chemistry adjacent to OAE deployments. We plan to leverage these high-resolution model results to competitively evaluate different MRV strategies, with a specific focus on analyzing the spatiotemporal distribution of carbon isotopic signatures following OAE. In this talk, we will showcase our initial results and discuss challenges in integrating high-resolution regional modeling into models of the global carbon cycle. More broadly, this work aims to provide insights into the plausibility of OAE as a climate solution that maintains ocean health and to inform accurate quantification of carbon uptake for MRV purposes. 
    more » « less