An official website of the United States government
Both the Cambrian explosion, more than half a billion years ago, and its Ordovician aftermath some 35 Myr later, are often framed as episodes of widespread ecological opportunity, but not all clades originating during this interval showed prolific rises in morphological or functional disparity. In a direct analysis of functional disparity, instead of the more commonly used proxy of morphological disparity, we find that ecological functions of Class Bivalvia arose concordantly with and even lagged behind taxonomic diversification, rather than the early-burst pattern expected for clades originating in supposedly open ecological landscapes. Unlike several other clades originating in the Cambrian explosion, the bivalves' belated acquisition of key anatomical novelties imposed a macroevolutionary lag, and even when those novelties evolved in the Early Ordovician, functional disparity never surpassed taxonomic diversity. Beyond this early period of animal evolution, the founding and subsequent diversification of new major clades and their functions might be expected to follow the pattern of the early bivalves—one where interactions between highly dynamic environmental and biotic landscapes and evolutionary contingencies need not promote prolific functional innovation.
more »
« less
Ecological novelty at the start of the Cambrian and Ordovician radiations of echinoderms
Abstract The Cambrian and Ordovician radiations marked the origins of all major echinoderm clades and established their Phanerozoic ecological blueprint. Recent claims of modest innovation of early echinoderms and other animals suggest constraints on novelty during the origins of phyla. Here, we document the life‐habit richness, body size, tiering, habitat usage, mobility, diet and foraging habits of 366 Cambrian–Ordovician echinoderm genera across a time‐scaled phylogeny to identify the timing and impact of novelty. Most early echinoderms were sedentary, filter‐feeding microbivores, and their body sizes, diets and modes of locomotion were largely unchanged through time, despite major volatility in taxonomic composition. Cambrian echinoderms lived close to the seafloor, with stylophorans first evolving semi‐infaunality. Many Ordovician echinoderms lived farther from the seafloor, with more complex filter‐feeding organs and tiering structure, often using other organisms as substrates. Mobile carnivores and mass‐feeders emerge then, too, across diverse asterozoans and echinozoans. Most of these novelties coincide with the origins of individual clades during the early and late Cambrian (Terreneuvian/Series 2 and Furongian), and 10–20 million years pass before most become ecologically important. Life‐habit evolution within most taxa involved new variations in these traits, with crinoids and asterozoans better able to shift strategies. The Ordovician radiation records more new variability in pre‐existing Cambrian life habits rather than radical re‐invention, with important novelties (like mobile carnivory and mass‐feeding, increased height off the seafloor, and biotic substrates) becoming ecologically more impactful. Taxa with these strategies were those best able to capitalize on the newly heterogeneous Ordovician world.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2322080
- PAR ID:
- 10490524
- Publisher / Repository:
- Wiley-Blackwell
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Palaeontology
- Volume:
- 67
- Issue:
- 1
- ISSN:
- 0031-0239
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
The Paleozoic Era was host to many significant biotic events such as the Great Ordovician Biodiversification Event, the Late Ordovician Mass Extinction, and the Late Devonian extinctions. These events were likely catalyzed by abiotic (e.g. climate) versus biotic drivers. Echinoderms are globally distributed, temporally expansive, and easily identifiable; these qualities make them an excellent model system to test hypotheses relating biodiversity with abiotic factors. Biodiversity patterns of echinoderms are currently not well understood because of a lack of focus on the dynamics of the entire clade. To remedy this, we have worked to expand current understandings of Paleozoic echinoderm diversity patterns by investigating the global distribution and temporal occurrences of taxa spanning the entire clade. Results suggest patterns of diversity unique to previously established trends that predominantly centered on a limited number of echinoderm groups. To examine the connection between climate change and Paleozoic echinoderm biodiversity (i.e., diversification, extinction, and origination rates), we collated stable oxygen isotope data from the primary literature spanning the Ordovician to the Devonian. We compiled these data to create a continuous curve of δO values during the described period to better evaluate in tandem with echinoderm diversity metrics. When the δO curve is compared to the echinoderm biodiversity patterns, we found that cooling periods coincide with increased extinction rates, corroborating prior hypotheses that major end-Ordovician cooling triggered changes in echinoderm biodiversity at a global level and further identifying a potential pattern in abiotic drivers in echinoderm biodiversity. The connection between Paleozoic echinoderm biodiversity and other abiotic factors will be further studied by comparing these recovered patterns with paleolatitudinal distributions.more » « less
-
Abstract Evidence from the earliest-known crinoids (Tremadocian, Early Ordovician), called protocrinoids, is used to hypothesize initial steps by which elements of the calyx evolved. Protocrinoid calyces are composed of extraxial primary and surrounding secondary plates (both of which have epispires along their sutures) that are unlike those of more crownward fossil and extant crinoids in which equivalent calycinal plating is strongly organized. These reductions inspired several schemes by which to name the plates in these calyces. However, the primary-secondary systems seen in protocrinoids first appeared among Cambrian stem radial echinoderms, with primaries representing centers around which secondaries were sequentially added during ontogeny. Therefore, the protocrinoid calyx represents an intermediate condition between earliest echinoderms and crownward crinoids. Position and ontogeny indicate certain primaries remained as loss of secondaries occurred, resulting in abutting of primaries into the conjoined alternating circlets characteristic of crinoids. This transformative event included suppression of secondary plating and modification or, more commonly, elimination of respiratory structures. These data indicate subradial calyx plate terminology does not correspond with most common usage, but rather, supports an alternative redefinition of these traditional expressions. Extension and adoral growth of fixed rays during calyx ontogeny preceded conjoined primaries in earliest crinoids. Restriction with modification or elimination of calyx respiratory structures also accompanied this modification. Phylogenetic analyses strongly support crinoid origination from early pentaradiate echinoderms, separate from blastozoans. Accordingly, all Tremadocian crinoids express a distinctive aggregate of plesiomorphic and apomorphic commonalities; all branch early within the crinoid clade, separate from traditional subclass-level clades. Nevertheless, each taxon within this assemblage expresses at least one diagnostic apomorphy of camerate, cladid, or disparid clades.more » « less
-
Davoult, D (Ed.)Abstract: The two main approaches in interpreting the significance of non-radial fossil echinoderms (carpoids) have consistently produced the same two distinct clusters of results for over a century of investigation. Studies based on conceptual models imbued with Haeckelian precepts consider bilaterally symmetric or asymmetric morphologies of carpoids plesiomorphic for the phylum. These approaches do not find a place for carpoids within an existing phylogenetic framework for the phylum because it is assumed that they primitively lack pentaradiality. Emphasis on differences between these taxa and pentaradial echinoderms forces them outside of and downward from more crownward clades. It is crucial to examine the data supporting these supposed differences. Is it worth considering non-pentaradial echinoderms as members of a well-known group of echinoderms, the blastozoans, which already includes many secondarily-derived, non-pentaradial members? Followers of an empirical model think so, presenting an integration of paleontology, embryology, body wall homology, and image analysis that derives echinoderms from a bilaterian, archimeric larva, not bilateral adults. Unprecedented modification of a single mesocoel (hydrocoel) initiated the pentaradial adult echinoderm, most parsimoniously with five primary lobes in stem forms of each major clade within the phylum. The unique water vascular system led to rearrangement of adult axes that literally have no parallel with those of any other invertebrate, representing an iconic synapomorphy for the Echinodermata. There are few, if any, developmental or stratigraphic data defending carpoids as 'bilateral precursors'. Their free appendage is now shown to be an ambulacrum, undermining any supposition of a 'head', 'tail', or 'gill slits'. Pentaradiality is plesiomorphic for the phylum, obviating the requirement for a triradial intermediate (helicoplacoids) between carpoids and pentaradial forms. Carpoids, a subset of blastozoans, exploited motility as a feeding mode, leading to extraordinary adaptations that belie their interpretation as ancestral echinoderms.more » « less
-
Fortunian archaeocyath sponges acquired biomineralization in the beginning of the Cambrian explosionArchaeocyaths are biocalcified sponges largely restricted to the early Cambrian Period. Their perforated cup-shaped body facilitated filter feeding. Many of them were clonal modular animals that formed the earliest metazoan skeletal reefs. In Siberia, archaeocyaths extend from late Age 2 to Age 4 of the early Cambrian, representing an ∼15 m.y. range (ca. 525−510 Ma). Elsewhere, archaeocyaths emerged later than in Siberia and, in places, survived to the middle-late Cambrian. The existing fossil record thus indicates an out-of-Siberia scenario and delayed biomineralization in archaeocyaths relative to many other animals, which acquired biomineralization in the Fortunian Age of the early Cambrian. Here we report two microscopic archaeocyath species—Primocyathus uniseriatus Wang and Xiao, gen. et sp. nov. and Sinocyathus biseriatus Wang and Xiao, gen. et sp. nov.—from the Fortunian Kuanchuanpu Formation (ca. 533 Ma) in South China. Preserved as phosphatized internal molds, they are interpreted to have had a biomineralized, two-walled, perforated, cup-shaped skeleton. They were likely filter feeders, but their solitary habit and millimetric body size indicate that they were unlikely reef framework builders. They substantially extend the stratigraphic range of archaeocyaths, challenge the out-of-Siberia hypothesis, support archaeocyath biomineralization in the beginning of the Cambrian explosion, and imply a Precambrian divergence of sponge classes.more » « less
