An official website of the United States government
Abstract A recent supercell modeling study showed that coherent turbulent structures associated with significant near-surface vertical vorticity in the ambient environment may serve as seeds for tornadoes. These structures, colloquially coined “vorticity worms” owing to their elongated and meandering appearance, develop within the surface layer in strong flow and are distinct from the larger-scale horizontal convective rolls often seen in the mixed layer. Elongated coherent turbulent structures are a common feature of the atmosphere and have been heavily studied by the boundary layer community, but before the recent simulation, they have not been previously implicated as facilitators of tornadogenesis. Observations of these structures around supercells have been limited, and historically, the observing platforms most often used in storm-focused data collection have not prioritized the precipitation-free inflow surface layer especially at the spatial and temporal resolution required to capture these structures and their interactions with storms. In recent field deployments, the National Severe Storms Laboratory used a truck-mounted pulsed Doppler lidar to perform near-ground scans to search for vorticity worms in real supercell inflow to compare with the simulation findings. Multiple deployments revealed vorticity worms and near-surface horizontal vorticity in supercell inflow that were consistent with the recently published supercell simulations that motivated this work. In two presented cases, vorticity worms were associated with the development of pretornadic, near-ground vortices, although neither circulation reached tornadic strength. These observations provide credibility to the recent simulations and suggest that continued observations of these coherent structures and research into their role in tornadogenesis are worth pursuing. Significance StatementNew simulations suggest that a source of rotation for tornadoes may originate in the ambient environment in the form of streak-like coherent structures near the ground. We used a mobile Doppler lidar to document the existence of these streak-like structures around storms and present cases where these structures developed into regions of enhanced rotation when they moved near the storm’s updraft. These observations provide credibility to the recent simulations and suggest that more research and observations of these structures around storms are needed to confirm if these structures play a role in tornado formation.
more »
« less
A New Pathway for Tornadogenesis Exposed by Numerical Simulations of Supercells in Turbulent Environments
Abstract A simulation of a supercell storm produced for a prior study on tornado predictability is reanalyzed for the purpose of examining the fine-scale details of tornadogenesis. It is found that the formation of a tornado-like vortex in the simulation differs from how such vortices have been understood to form in previous numerical simulations. The main difference between the present simulation and past ones is the inclusion of a turbulent boundary layer in the storm’s environment in the present case, whereas prior simulations have used a laminar boundary layer. The turbulent environment contains significant near-surface vertical vorticity (ζ > 0.03 s−1at z= 7.5 m), organized in the form of longitudinal streaks aligned with the southerly ground-relative winds. The ζ streaks are associated with corrugations in the vertical plane in the predominantly horizontal, westward-pointing environmental vortex lines; the vortex-line corrugations are produced by the vertical drafts associated with coherent turbulent structures aligned with the aforementioned southerly ground-relative winds (longitudinal coherent structures in the surface layer such as these are well known to the boundary layer and turbulence communities). The ζ streaks serve as focal points for tornadogenesis, and may actually facilitate tornadogenesis, given how near-surface ζ in the environment can rapidly amplify when subjected to the strong, persistent convergence beneath a supercell updraft. Significance StatementIn high-resolution computer simulations of supercell storms that include a more realistic, turbulent environment, the means by which tornado-like vortices form differs from the mechanism identified in prior simulations using a less realistic, laminar environment. One possibility is that prior simulations develop intense vortices for the wrong reasons. Another possibility could be that tornadoes form in a wide range of ways in the real atmosphere, even within supercell storms that appear to be similar, and increasingly realistic computer simulations are finally now capturing that diversity.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2150792
- PAR ID:
- 10492371
- Publisher / Repository:
- American Meteorological Society
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences
- Volume:
- 81
- Issue:
- 3
- ISSN:
- 0022-4928
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 481 to 518
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Abstract Three relatively high-resolution (75-m horizontal grid spacing), large-eddy simulation (LES) ensembles of tornadic supercell storms are used to investigate the effect of a more realistic treatment of the lower boundary condition on supercell storm simulations. These ensembles vary only in the parameterization of near-surface turbulence: one ensemble uses the semislip scheme, whereas the other two employ versions of the “thin boundary layer equations” (TBLE) approach. Each simulated storm is a long-lived supercell, with an intense mesocyclone and at least one tornado-like vortex (TLV). The primary differences observed across the ensembles are (i) the amplitude of near-surface turbulent eddies in the environmental boundary layer and (ii) the intensity of the TLVs, with both TBLE schemes resulting in stronger turbulent eddies in the environment and stronger TLVs within the simulated storms. Although substantial variations in precipitation distribution and cold pool strength are also found among the simulations, the differences in these larger-scale storm attributes from one ensemble to another are not statistically significant. Significance StatementThe assumptions implicit in the semislip boundary condition, which is the lower boundary condition most commonly used in convective storm simulations that include surface drag, are problematic. An alternative approach to modeling the effects of the lower boundary, borrowed from the engineering large-eddy simulation community, is adopted for numerical simulations of supercell storms. The approach at least avoids some of the thorny assumptions inherent in the semislip condition. Though it is not yet possible to know which storm simulations are ultimately the “best,” an awareness of their sensitivities to the handling of the unresolved/underresolved flow in the near-surface layer is an important first step toward improving their realism.more » « less
-
Abstract Present-day simulations of supercell thunderstorms have high resolution and incorporate the physical processes known to be conducive to simulating tornado-like vortices (TLVs). In such supercell simulations, TLVs are identified by the strength, duration, and location of the vertical vorticity in the simulated supercell. To bring the analysis of these supercell-produced TLVs a step closer to observations and theory, the TLV in an advanced supercell simulation is identified as the tornado center, and the Cartesian model velocities are transformed to cylindrical coordinates and azimuthally averaged. The azimuthally averaged TLV exhibits many of the observed and theoretically modeled features of tornadoes, including an end-wall vortex with strong maximum vertical and azimuthal velocities (wmaxandυmax) close to the ground with transition to the weaker core velocities (wcandυc) aloft through vortex breakdown. A theory for the rotating-flow boundary layer with radial and azimuthal inflow velocities modeled on the axisymmetric analysis is shown to produce good qualitative agreement with the analyzed axisymmetric TLVs; however, the theoreticalwmaxandυmaxare too large as the theory does not account for vortex breakdown. Estimation of the corner flow swirl ratio suggests a limit ofυmax/υcslightly greater than unity; sinceυcis a feature of the mesocyclone, there is a limit on the extent to which the amplified velocities of the end-wall velocities can be realized. To augment the diversity of cases, the present analysis is applied to a simplified set of supercell simulations; the present theory explains several features of the axisymmetric vortices.more » « less
-
Abstract It has long been observed that interactions of a supercell with other storms or storm-scale boundaries sometimes seem to directly instigate tornadogenesis. First, the authors explore the frequency of such constructive interactions. WSR-88D radar data are used to categorize 136 tornadic supercells into isolated supercells and supercells that interacted with external factors within 20 min before tornadogenesis. Most cases (80%) showed some form of external influence prior to tornadogenesis. Common patterns of interactions, the typical supercell quadrant that is affected, and changes in azimuthal shear are also identified. To further study these interactions, two sets of idealized CM1 simulations are performed. The first set demonstrates that the speed of the near-ground horizontal flow relative to the updraft can control whether a vortex patch develops into a tornado. A weaker updraft-relative flow is favorable because the developing vortex stays in the updraft region longer and becomes less tilted. Building on these results, it is shown that external outflow can lead to tornado formation by a deceleration of the updraft-relative flow. The deceleration is caused by the pressure gradient force associated with the external outflow, which is already noticeable several kilometers ahead of the outflow boundary. This offers another possible mechanism by which external outflow can act as a catalyst for supercell tornadogenesis.more » « less
-
Abstract Tornadic and nontornadic supercells have been observed in close proximity to one another, despite coexisting in a similar environment. One possibility is that localized heterogeneity in the environment produces changes in tornadogenesis likelihood. Such environmental heterogeneity may be induced by supercell thunderstorms themselves. This study investigates whether adjacent supercells influence one another, particularly focusing on influences to tornadogenesis likelihood. The study uses idealized numerical simulations of isolated supercells to identify how supercells introduce heterogeneity into their surrounding environment. Then, a series of multistorm simulations are used to investigate how storm-induced heterogeneity affects neighboring supercells and tornadogenesis likelihood. The most influential forms of storm-induced heterogeneity are found to be residual cold pools in the wake of supercells, dry air descending from aloft on the upshear flank of supercells, and left-moving splits from supercells. Residual cold pools and descending dry air weakened neighboring supercells and decreased the likelihood of tornadogenesis. Mergers with left-moving splits momentarily strengthened supercells and increased tornadogenesis likelihood before other storm-induced heterogeneity weakened these supercells. In the most hostile examples of storm-induced heterogeneity, neighboring supercells weakened to the point of dissipation. In the most favorable examples of storm-induced heterogeneity, low-level supercell updrafts nearly doubled their vertical velocity. These findings may explain why tornado production can vary between supercells coexisting in a similar environment. Significance StatementSupercells are intense thunderstorms that can produce tornadoes. While research has excelled in identifying environmental ingredients favorable for tornadoes, multiple supercells within the same general environment can vary in tornado production. This study investigates whether supercell thunderstorms themselves can influence neighboring storms and their likelihood of producing a tornado. It was found that supercells can modify the surrounding environment, creating regions where neighboring storms can have increased or decreased likelihood of producing a tornado. These results may be helpful for forecasting tornadoes during a multisupercell event.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.1175/JAS-D-23-0161.1
