An official website of the United States government
To be successful in their future careers, students must be able to process information, devise creative solutions, and apply previous knowledge to new situations. Learning through only traditional teaching practices that rely heavily on lecture format and memorization is insufficient to prepare students for the future. Interactive project-based learning that experiences productive failure provides the opportunity for students to problem-solve novel topics and potentially fail at finding the solution. Through explanation, elaboration, comparison of iterations, refinement, and implementations, students can be more prepared to solve future problems. Our study examined the benefits of productive failure on high school students from both formal and informal learning environments working in collaborative teams to design and create 3D plant models. This STEAM project integrates science, design, and technology through innovative learning experiences in plant and agricultural science using emergent technologies. This learning experience encourages students to work together in collaborative teams of self-identified science, technophile, and art students to create 3D models of plants used in research at the Donald Danforth Plant Science Center in St. Louis, MO. Students learn about scientific research, the importance of plants in our society, and practice science communication skills. To create the 3D models, students must learn-by-doing to become proficient in using previously unfamiliar 3D modeling software where their teachers are merely facilitators. Students become active participants in their own learning by overcoming challenges through research, troubleshooting, teamwork, and perseverance. We used a mixed-method assessment approach comparing pre- and post-reflection questions. Students experience many challenges with learning the 3D model programs. They reported that they overcame difficulties working with the 3D modeling programs primarily through help from others and consulting outside resources, such as YouTube videos, as well as through continued effort. Students indicated that they faced challenges when creating their models but recognized that this project was a learning experience. Productive failure through the process of struggling and learning from one’s mistakes can encourage positive learning outcomes and give students a better ability to overcome future challenges.
more »
« less
Modeling 3D Plants: Student Achievement Through Productive Failure
To be successful in their future careers, students must be able to process information, devise creative solutions, and apply previous knowledge to new situations. Learning through only traditional teaching practices that rely heavily on lecture format and memorization is insufficient to prepare students for the future. Interactive project-based learning that experiences productive failure provides the opportunity for students to problem-solve novel topics and potentially fail at finding the solution. Through explanation, elaboration, comparison of iterations, refinement, and implementations, students can be more prepared to solve future problems. Our study examined the benefits of productive failure on high school students from both formal and informal learning environments working in collaborative teams to design and create 3D plant models. This STEAM project integrates science, design, and technology through innovative learning experiences in plant and agricultural science using emergent technologies. This learning experience encourages students to work together in collaborative teams of self-identified science, technophile, and art students to create 3D models of plants used in research at the Donald Danforth Plant Science Center in St. Louis, MO. Students learn about scientific research, the importance of plants in our society, and practice science communication skills. To create the 3D models, students must learn-by-doing to become proficient in using previously unfamiliar 3D modeling software where their teachers are merely facilitators. Students become active participants in their own learning by overcoming challenges through research, troubleshooting, teamwork, and perseverance. We used a mixed-method assessment approach comparing pre- and post-reflection questions. Students experience many challenges with learning the 3D model programs. They reported that they overcame difficulties working with the 3D modeling programs primarily through help from others and consulting outside resources, such as YouTube videos, as well as through continued effort. Students indicated that they faced challenges when creating their models but recognized that this project was a learning experience. Productive failure through the process of struggling and learning from one’s mistakes can encourage positive learning outcomes and give students a better ability to overcome future challenges.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1949463
- PAR ID:
- 10499614
- Publisher / Repository:
- Society for the Advancement of Biology Education Research (SABER) Midwest
- Date Published:
- Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
- STEAM education 3D modeling plant science productive failure
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Group collaboration and results dissemination in project-based STEAM learning benefits student performance, communication skills, and self-efficacy. In our project, high school students experience the integration of science, design, and technology as they create 3D plant models. Collaborative teams of self-identified science, technophile, and art students create models of plants, research their biology and importance, and disseminate their results. Student reflections before this activity indicate their preference to work in groups (47%), individually (20%), or both (33%). After the activity, 95% of the students reported positive experiences working in groups (exchange of ideas and new perspectives, growth of relationships, help to solve problems, project efficiency) and disseminating results (show the work done, gain confidence communicating results). Lessons learned and best practices from using teamwork and science communication for high school STEAM learning are discussed.more » « less
-
Goal: address the disconnect between science, design, and technology at the high school level. Objectives: 1. integrate art/design into STEM education (STEAM), 2. foster plant science knowledge, 3. apply augmented and virtual reality (AVR) technologies, and 4. inspire interest in and provide skills for future STEAM careers. Collaborative teams of self-identified science, technophile, and art students receive training in 3D modeling. With support from scientists, the students create models of research plants, practice science communication skills during public/scientific events, and make connections to real-life situations using AVR devices. We use a mixed-methods assessment approach. Results from the first year of this project indicate that students are more aware of the role of art/design in science and vice versa. Students acknowledge the benefits of productive failure when facing challenges creating 3D models and are more interested in STEAM career paths.more » « less
-
This project addresses the disconnect between science, design, and technology and how high school students can benefit from innovative learning experiences in plant science that integrate these disciplines while gaining interest in and skills for future STEM careers. We created a research experience where students work in collaborative teams of self-identified science, technophile, and art students to create 3D models of plants under research at the Donald Danforth Plant Science Center. Through augmented and virtual reality immersive experiences, the students understand the benefits of integrating science, technology, and design. The students also practice their communication skills by disseminating their projects. We use a mixed-methods approach to assess changes in students’ understanding of the role of design and technology in STEM, gain of knowledge and appreciation of plant science, and development of interests in STEM subjects and careers. Preliminary results indicate that students are more aware of the role of design in science and vice versa and are more interested in STEAM subjects. Future results will provide a better understanding of the impact on plant awareness and interest in STEAM careers. This project will contribute to the body of knowledge on theory, best practices, and practical technological applications in STEAM education.more » « less
-
This project addresses the disconnect between science, design, and technology and how high school students can benefit from innovative learning experiences in plant science that integrate these disciplines while gaining interest in and skills for future STEM careers. We created a project-based 3D modeling learning module with educators as facilitators and students working in collaborative teams of self-identified science, technophile, and art students. Students created 3D models of plants under research at the Donald Danforth Plant Science Center and learned about the applications of 3D modeling in augmented and virtual reality platforms. They also disseminated their project results through handouts and presentations. We used a mixed-methods approach to assess the impact of implementing this module on students’ learning and interests in STEAM subjects and careers. We found that students are more aware of the intersection of art and design with science and gained literacy in plant science, design, and technology. The students also gained 21st century skills such as collaboration, communication, creative thinking, and problem-solving and showed more interest in STEAM subjects and careers. This project contributes to the body of knowledge on theory, best practices, and practical technological applications in STEAM education.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Conference Paper:
- The DOI is not currently available.
