Title: Toward Improved Regional Hydrological Model Performance Using State‐Of‐The‐Science Data‐Informed Soil Parameters
Abstract Accurate soil moisture and streamflow data are an aspirational need of many hydrologically relevant fields. Model simulated soil moisture and streamflow hold promise but models require validation prior to application. Calibration methods are commonly used to improve model fidelity but misrepresentation of the true dynamics remains a challenge. In this study, we leverage soil parameter estimates from the Soil Survey Geographic (SSURGO) database and the probability mapping of SSURGO (POLARIS) to improve the representation of hydrologic processes in the Weather Research and Forecasting Hydrological modeling system (WRF‐Hydro) over a central California domain. Our results show WRF‐Hydro soil moisture exhibits increased correlation coefficients (r), reduced biases, and increased Kling‐Gupta Efficiencies (KGEs) across seven in situ soil moisture observing stations after updating the model's soil parameters according to POLARIS. Compared to four well‐established soil moisture data sets including Soil Moisture Active Passive data and three Phase 2 North American Land Data Assimilation System land surface models, our POLARIS‐adjusted WRF‐Hydro simulations produce the highest mean KGE (0.69) across the seven stations. More importantly, WRF‐Hydro streamflow fidelity also increases, especially in the case where the model domain is set up with SSURGO‐informed total soil thickness. The magnitude and timing of peak flow events are better captured,rincreases across nine United States Geological Survey stream gages, and the mean KGE across seven of the nine gages increases from 0.12 to 0.66. Our pre‐calibration parameter estimate approach, which is transferable to other spatially distributed hydrological models, can substantially improve a model's performance, helping reduce calibration efforts and computational costs.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1854951
PAR ID:
10517714
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
AGU
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Water Resources Research
Volume:
59
Issue:
9
ISSN:
0043-1397
Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Comprehensive assessments of hydrological components are crucial for enhancing operational water supply simulations. However, hydrological models are often evaluated based on their surface flow simulations, while the validation of subsurface and groundwater components tends to be overlooked or not well documented. In this study, we evaluated the outputs of two hydrological models, the Large Basin Runoff Model (LBRM) and the Weather Research and Forecasting – Hydrological modeling extension package (WRF-Hydro), for potential implementation in operational water balance forecasting in the Great Lakes region. We examined the simulated hydrological variables including surface (e.g. snow water equivalent, evapotranspiration, and streamflow), subsurface (e.g. soil moisture at different layers), and groundwater components with observed or reference data from ground-based stations and remotely sensed images. The findings of this study provide valuable insights into the capabilities and limitations of each model. These findings contribute to more informed water management strategies for the Great Lakes region. 
    more » « less
  2. This study uses a suite of Weather Research and Forecasting Hydrological modeling system (WRF-Hydro) simulations to examine changes in the hydrological response related to spatial shifts in extreme precipitation. In early October 2015, much of central and coastal South Carolina experienced intense precipitation, with some areas reporting more than 20 inches of rain over a 5-day period. This extreme rainfall resulted in widespread flooding and associated impacts to life and property, including 36 dam failures and 19 fatalities. The heavy precipitation was attributed to a combination of factors: a stationary front along the U.S. Atlantic coast, an upper-level low pressure area to the west, and abundant tropical moisture. Recently, terrain modification experiments with the WRF model were completed to ascertain the influence of the lower Appalachian Mountains on precipitation amount and spatial distribution during this event. These experiments involved an approach to artificially raise and lower terrain in the model, which resulted in a shift of precipitation in accordance with the altered flow regime. This research builds on this previous work by using meteorological conditions derived from the terrain modification experiments to force WRF-Hydro simulations centered on South Carolina. We first compare simulated streamflow from the control run with observations from United States Geological Survey (USGS) monitoring sites to facilitate model calibration and configuration. Next, we carry out three simulations, each utilizing meteorological forcing from each of the terrain modification experiments. We then compare streamflow time series at the same points for which model calibration was completed. This work provides a multiscale overview of the hydrological implications of terrain modification experiments, considering not only large-scale changes in precipitation but also localized impacts. Moreover, our results can further understanding of terrain-precipitation interactions. 
    more » « less
  3. This study uses a suite of Weather Research and Forecasting Hydrological modeling system (WRF-Hydro) simulations to examine changes in the hydrological response related to spatial shifts in extreme precipitation. In early October 2015, much of central and coastal South Carolina experienced intense precipitation, with some areas reporting more than 20 inches of rain over a 5-day period. This extreme rainfall resulted in widespread flooding and associated impacts to life and property, including 36 dam failures and 19 fatalities. The heavy precipitation was attributed to a combination of factors: a stationary front along the U.S. Atlantic coast, an upper-level low pressure area to the west, and abundant tropical moisture. Recently, terrain modification experiments with the WRF model were completed to ascertain the influence of the lower Appalachian Mountains on precipitation amount and spatial distribution during this event. These experiments involved an approach to artificially raise and lower terrain in the model, which resulted in a shift of precipitation in accordance with the altered flow regime. This research builds on this previous work by using meteorological conditions derived from the terrain modification experiments to force WRF-Hydro simulations centered on South Carolina. We first compare simulated streamflow from the control run with observations from United States Geological Survey (USGS) monitoring sites to facilitate model calibration and configuration. Next, we carry out three simulations, each utilizing meteorological forcing from each of the terrain modification experiments. We then compare streamflow time series at the same points for which model calibration was completed. This work provides a multiscale overview of the hydrological implications of terrain modification experiments, considering not only large-scale changes in precipitation but also localized impacts. Moreover, our results can further understanding of terrain-precipitation interactions. 
    more » « less
  4. Remotely sensed hydrologic variables, in conjunction with streamflow data, have been increasingly used to conduct multivariable calibration of hydrologic model parameters. Here, we calibrated the Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) model using different combinations of streamflow and remotely sensed hydrologic variables, including Atmosphere–Land Exchange Inverse (ALEXI) Evapotranspiration (ET), Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS) ET, and Soil MERGE (SMERGE) soil moisture. The results show that adding remotely sensed ET and soil moisture to the traditionally used streamflow for model calibration can impact the number and values of parameters sensitive to hydrologic modeling, but it does not necessarily improve the model performance. However, using remotely sensed ET or soil moisture data alone led to deterioration in model performance as compared with using streamflow only. In addition, we observed large discrepancies between ALEXI or MODIS ET data and the choice between these two datasets for model calibration can have significant implications for the performance of the SWAT model. The use of different combinations of streamflow, ET, and soil moisture data also resulted in noticeable differences in simulated hydrologic processes, such as runoff, percolation, and groundwater discharge. Finally, we compared the performance of SWAT and the SWAT-Carbon (SWAT-C) model under different multivariate calibration setups, and these two models exhibited pronounced differences in their performance in the validation period. Based on these results, we recommend (1) the assessment of various remotely sensed data (when multiple options available) for model calibration before choosing them for complementing the traditionally used streamflow data and (2) that different model structures be considered in the model calibration process to support robust hydrologic modeling. 
    more » « less
  5. Abstract. In steep wildfire-burned terrains, intense rainfall can produce large runoff that can trigger highly destructive debris flows. However, the abilityto accurately characterize and forecast debris flow susceptibility in burned terrains using physics-based tools remains limited. Here, we augmentthe Weather Research and Forecasting Hydrological modeling system (WRF-Hydro) to simulate both overland and channelized flows and assess postfiredebris flow susceptibility over a regional domain. We perform hindcast simulations using high-resolution weather-radar-derived precipitation andreanalysis data to drive non-burned baseline and burn scar sensitivity experiments. Our simulations focus on January 2021 when an atmospheric rivertriggered numerous debris flows within a wildfire burn scar in Big Sur – one of which destroyed California's famous Highway 1. Compared to thebaseline, our burn scar simulation yields dramatic increases in total and peak discharge and shorter lags between rainfall onset and peakdischarge, consistent with streamflow observations at nearby US Geological Survey (USGS) streamflow gage sites. For the 404 catchments located inthe simulated burn scar area, median catchment-area-normalized peak discharge increases by ∼ 450 % compared to the baseline. Catchmentswith anomalously high catchment-area-normalized peak discharge correspond well with post-event field-based and remotely sensed debris flowobservations. We suggest that our regional postfire debris flow susceptibility analysis demonstrates WRF-Hydro as a compelling new physics-basedtool whose utility could be further extended via coupling to sediment erosion and transport models and/or ensemble-based operational weatherforecasts. Given the high-fidelity performance of our augmented version of WRF-Hydro, as well as its potential usage in probabilistic hazardforecasts, we argue for its continued development and application in postfire hydrologic and natural hazard assessments. 
    more » « less