An official website of the United States government
Data dashboards provide a means for sharing multiple data products at a glance and were ubiquitous during the COVID-19 pandemic. Data dashboards tracked global and country-specific statistics and provided cartographic visualizations of cases, deaths, vaccination rates and other metrics. We examined the role of geospatial data on COVID-19 dashboards in the form of maps, charts, and graphs. We organize our review of 193 COVID-19 dashboards by region and compare the accessibility and operationality of dashboards over time and the use of web maps and geospatial visualizations. We found that of the dashboards reviewed, only 17% included geospatial visualizations. We observe that many of the COVID-19 dashboards from our analysis are no longer accessible (66%) and consider the ephemeral nature of data and dashboards. We conclude that coordinated efforts and a call to action to ensure the standardization, storage, and maintenance of geospatial data for use on data dashboards and web maps are needed for long-term use, analyses, and monitoring to address current and future public health and other challenging issues.
more »
« less
Visualizing multilayer spatiotemporal epidemiological data with animated geocircles
Abstract ObjectiveThe COVID-19 pandemic emphasized the value of geospatial visual analytics for both epidemiologists and the general public. However, systems struggled to encode temporal and geospatial trends of multiple, potentially interacting variables, such as active cases, deaths, and vaccinations. We sought to ask (1) how epidemiologists interact with visual analytics tools, (2) how multiple, time-varying, geospatial variables can be conveyed in a unified view, and (3) how complex spatiotemporal encodings affect utility for both experts and non-experts. Materials and MethodsWe propose encoding variables with animated, concentric, hollow circles, allowing multiple variables via color encoding and avoiding occlusion problems, and we implement this method in a browser-based tool called CoronaViz. We conduct task-based evaluations with non-experts, as well as in-depth interviews and observational sessions with epidemiologists, covering a range of tools and encodings. ResultsSessions with epidemiologists confirmed the importance of multivariate, spatiotemporal queries and the utility of CoronaViz for answering them, while providing direction for future development. Non-experts tasked with performing spatiotemporal queries unanimously preferred animation to multi-view dashboards. DiscussionWe find that conveying complex, multivariate data necessarily involves trade-offs. Yet, our studies suggest the importance of complementary visualization strategies, with our animated multivariate spatiotemporal encoding filling important needs for exploration and presentation. ConclusionCoronaViz’s unique ability to convey multiple, time-varying, geospatial variables makes it both a valuable addition to interactive COVID-19 dashboards and a platform for empowering experts and the public during future disease outbreaks. CoronaViz is open-source and a live instance is freely hosted at http://coronaviz.umiacs.io.
more »
« less
- PAR ID:
- 10539561
- Publisher / Repository:
- Oxford University Press
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association
- Volume:
- 31
- Issue:
- 11
- ISSN:
- 1067-5027
- Format(s):
- Medium: X Size: p. 2507-2518
- Size(s):
- p. 2507-2518
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
null (Ed.)The COVID-19 pandemic brought to the forefront an unprecedented need for experts, as well as citizens, to visualize spatio-temporal disease surveillance data. Web application dashboards were quickly developed to fill this gap, including those built by JHU, WHO, and CDC, but all of these dashboards supported a particular niche view of the pandemic (ie, current status or specific regions). In this paper1, we describe our work developing our own COVID-19 Surveillance Dashboard, available at https://nssac.bii.virginia.edu/covid19/dashboard/, which offers a universal view of the pandemic while also allowing users to focus on the details that interest them. From the beginning, our goal was to provide a simple visual way to compare, organize, and track near-real-time surveillance data as the pandemic progresses. Our dashboard includes a number of advanced features for zooming, filtering, categorizing and visualizing multiple time series on a single canvas. In developing this dashboard, we have also identified 6 key metrics we call the 6Cs standard which we propose as a standard for the design and evaluation of real-time epidemic science dashboards. Our dashboard was one of the first released to the public, and remains one of the most visited and highly used. Our group uses it to support federal, state and local public health authorities, and it is used by people worldwide to track the pandemic evolution, build their own dashboards, and support their organizations as they plan their responses to the pandemic. We illustrate the utility of our dashboard by describing how it can be used to support data story-telling – an important emerging area in data science.more » « less
-
Abstract—The COVID-19 pandemic brought to the forefront an unprecedented need for experts, as well as citizens, to visualize spatio-temporal disease surveillance data. Web application dashboards were quickly developed to fill t his g ap, b ut a ll of these dashboards supported a particular niche view of the pandemic (ie, current status or specific r egions). I n t his paper, we describe our work developing our COVID-19 Surveillance Dashboard, which offers a unique view of the pandemic while also allowing users to focus on the details that interest them. From the beginning, our goal was to provide a simple visual tool for comparing, organizing, and tracking near-real-time surveillance data as the pandemic progresses. In developing this dashboard, we also identified 6 key metrics which we propose as a standard for the design and evaluation of real-time epidemic science dashboards. Our dashboard was one of the first r eleased t o the public, and continues to be actively visited. Our own group uses it to support federal, state and local public health authorities, and it is used by individuals worldwide to track the evolution of the COVID-19 pandemic, build their own dashboards, and support their organizations as they plan their responses to the pandemic.more » « less
-
Abstract ObjectivesWe conducted interviews with state epidemiologists involved in the state-level COVID-19 response to understand the challenges and opportunities that state epidemiologists and state health departments faced during COVID-19 and consider the implications for future pandemic responses. MethodsAs part of a broader study on policymaking during COVID-19, we analyzed 12 qualitative interviews with state-epidemiologists from 11 US states regarding the challenges and opportunities they experienced during the COVID-19 response. ResultsInterviewees described the unprecedented demands COVID-19 placed on them, including increased workloads as well as political and public scrutiny. Decades of under-funding and constraints posed particular challenges for meeting these demands and compromised state responses. Emergency funding contributed to ameliorating some challenges. However, state health departments were unable to absorb the funds quickly, which created added pressure for employees. The emergency funding also did not resolve longstanding resource deficits. ConclusionsState health departments were not equipped to meet the demands of a comprehensive COVID-19 response, and increased funding failed to address shortfalls. Effective future pandemic responses will require sustained investment and adequate support to manage on-going and surge capacity needs. Increased public interest and skepticism complicated the COVID-19 response, and additional measures are needed to address these factors.more » « less
-
Background: In the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, scientists have scrambled to collect and analyze SARS-CoV-2 genomic data to inform public health responses to COVID-19 in real-time. Open-source phylogenetic and data visualization platforms for monitoring SARS-CoV-2 genomic epidemiology have rapidly gained popularity for their ability to illuminate spatial-temporal transmission patterns worldwide. However, the utility of such tools to inform public health decision-making for COVID-19 in real-time remains to be explored. Objective: The objective of this study was to convene experts in public health, infectious diseases, virology, and bioinformatics – many of whom were actively engaged in the COVID-19 response at the time of their participation – to discuss the application of phylodynamic tools to inform pandemic responses. Methods: A series of four virtual focus group discussions were hosted between June 2020 and June 2021, covering the pre- and post-variant and vaccination eras of the COVID-19 crisis. Audio recordings were transcribed verbatim, and an iterative, thematic qualitative framework was used for analysis. Results: Of the 41 individuals invited, 23 total participants (56.1%) agreed to participate. Across the four focus group sessions, 15 (65%) of the participants were female, 17 (74%) were white, and 5 (22%) were black. Participants were described as molecular epidemiologists (ME, n=9), clinician-researchers (n=3), infectious disease experts (ID, n=4), and public health professionals (PH) at the local (n=4), state (n=2), and federal (n=1) levels. Collectively, participants felt that successful uptake of phylodynamic tools relies on the strength of academic-public health partnerships. They called for interoperability standards in sequence data sharing and cited many resource issues that must be addressed, including timeliness and cost, in addition to improving issues related to sampling bias and the translation of phylodynamic findings into public health action. Conclusions: This was the first qualitative study to characterize the perspectives of key experts regarding the utility of phylodynamic tools for the public health response to COVID-19. The focus group participants identified key areas for improvement of existing and future phylogenetic and data visualization platforms for monitoring SARS-CoV-2 genomic epidemiology. This information is critical to both policymakers and developers as they consider how to handle existing and emerging SARS-CoV-2 variants during the ongoing crisis.more » « less
