The importance of considering local context and partnering with target users is well established in co-design. Less common is an examination of the adaptations needed when deploying the same co-design program across heterogenous settings to maximize program efficacy and equity. We report on our experience co-designing educational games with six culturally and socioeconomically diverse afterschool sites over two years, and insights from interviewing ten program administrators across all sites. We found that even within the same afterschool program network, site differences in organizational culture and resources impacted the effectiveness of co-design programs, the co-design output, and expectations for student engagement. We characterize our afterschool partners into different archetypes – Safe Havens, Recreation Centers, Homework Helpers, and STEM Enrichment Centers. We provide recommendations for conducting co-design at each archetype and reflect on strategies for increasing equitable partnerships between researchers and afterschool centers.
more »
« less
Comparative Design-Based Research: How Afterschool Programs Impact Learners' Engagement with a Video Game Codesign
Community-based afterschool programs are valuable spaces for researchers to codesign technologies with direct relevance to local communities. However, afterschool programs differ in resources available, culture, and student demographics in ways that may impact the efficacy of the codesign process and outcome. We ran a series of multi-week educational game codesign workshops across five programs over twenty weeks and found notable differences, despite deploying the same protocol. Our findings characterize three types of programs: Safe Havens, Recreation Centers, and Homework Helpers. We note major differences in students' patterns of participation directly influenced by each program's culture and expectations for equitable partnerships and introduce Comparative Design-Based Research (cDBR) as a beneficial lens for codesign.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1906753
- PAR ID:
- 10558001
- Publisher / Repository:
- Proceedings of the 17th International Conference of the Learning Sciences - ICLS 2023
- Date Published:
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Location:
- https://2023.isls.org/proceedings/
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Fostering equal design partnerships in adult-child codesign interactions is a well-documented challenge in HCI. It is assumed that adults come into these interactions with power and have to make adjustments to allow childrens’ input to be equally valued. However, power is not a unilateral construct - it is in part determined by social and cultural norms that often disadvantage minoritized groups. Striving for equal partnership without centering users’ and participants’ intersectional identities may lead to unproductive adult-child codesign interactions. We codesigned a game, primarily facilitated by a black woman researcher, with K-5 afterschool programs comprised of students from three different communities – a middle-class, racially diverse community; a low-income, primarily African American community; and a working-class rural, white, community over a period of 20 weeks. We share preliminary insights on how racial and gender biases affect codesign partnerships and describe future research plans to modify our program structure to foster more effective adult-child interactions.more » « less
-
null (Ed.)We present the Wearable Learning Cloud Platform (WLCP), a web-based platform that supports embodied educational game creation, play, and math learning in real classrooms. WLCP is a novel learning technology that supports students’ exploratory and active movement within learning environments, blending hands-on activities and collaborative games within classroom culture. We present preliminary findings from several experiments that show that a variety of embodied games created via the WLCP helps students learn mathematics in real K-12 school settings and afterschool programs.more » « less
-
We present the Wearable Learning Cloud Platform (WLCP), a web-based platform that supports embodied educational game creation, play, and math learning in real classrooms. WLCP is a novel learning technology that supports students’ exploratory and active movement within learning environments, blending hands-on activities and collaborative games within classroom culture. We present preliminary findings from several experiments that show that a variety of embodied games created via the WLCP helps students learn mathematics in real K-12 school settings and afterschool programs.more » « less
-
This case study describes the iterative process used to develop a virtual coaching program for out-of-school-time (OST) educators, particularly those who work in afterschool and library settings. The program, called ACRES (Afterschool Coaching for Reflective Educators in STEM), used a design-based implementation research (DBIR) approach to consider issues related to scale-up. Afterschool and library settings are complex systems that include supports and barriers that require adaptation for implementation. Throughout the design process, program developers worked to identify the essential elements of the program that should be maintained across contexts, while attending to the diverse needs of individual OST settings. Survey and interview data were collected from the full range of stakeholders throughout the implementation process to verify the importance of the essential elements to the professional learning model, and to gather early indicators of the program’s potential related to three key concepts for successful scale-up of programs: sustainability, spread, and shift. Conclusions are shared in relation to how these types of results support the scale-up of programs, and the strengths and gaps in the process used to apply the DBIR approach in our work.more » « less