<?xml-model href='http://www.tei-c.org/release/xml/tei/custom/schema/relaxng/tei_all.rng' schematypens='http://relaxng.org/ns/structure/1.0'?><TEI xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0">
	<teiHeader>
		<fileDesc>
			<titleStmt><title level='a'>The kinematic structure of magnetically aligned HI filaments</title></titleStmt>
			<publicationStmt>
				<publisher>Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society</publisher>
				<date>10/10/2023</date>
			</publicationStmt>
			<sourceDesc>
				<bibl> 
					<idno type="par_id">10562529</idno>
					<idno type="doi">10.1093/mnras/stad2792</idno>
					<title level='j'>Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society</title>
<idno>0035-8711</idno>
<biblScope unit="volume">526</biblScope>
<biblScope unit="issue">3</biblScope>					

					<author>Doyeon A Kim</author><author>S E Clark</author><author>M E Putman</author><author>Larry Li</author>
				</bibl>
			</sourceDesc>
		</fileDesc>
		<profileDesc>
			<abstract><ab><![CDATA[We characterize the kinematic and magnetic properties of Hi filaments located in a high Galactic latitude region (165° &lt; α &lt; 195° and 12° &lt; δ &lt; 24°). We extract three-dimensional filamentary structures using fil3d from the Galactic Arecibo L-Band Feed Array Hi (GALFA-Hi) survey 21-cm emission data. Our algorithm identifies coherent emission structures in neighbouring velocity channels. Based on the mean velocity, we identify a population of local and intermediate velocity cloud (IVC) filaments. We find the orientations of the local (but not the IVC) Hi filaments are aligned with the magnetic field orientations inferred from Planck 353GHz polarized dust emission. We analyse position–velocity diagrams of the velocity-coherent filaments, and find that only 15percent of filaments demonstrate significant major-axis velocity gradients with a median magnitude of 0.5kms−1pc−1, assuming a fiducial filament distance of 100pc. We conclude that the typical diffuse Hi filament does not exhibit a simple velocity gradient. The reported filament properties constrain future theoretical models of filament formation.]]></ab></abstract>
		</profileDesc>
	</teiHeader>
	<text><body xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><p>proposed as a product of thermal instability and turbulent compression and shear <ref type="bibr">(Heitsch, Naab &amp; Walch 2011 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Inoue &amp; Inutsuka 2016 )</ref>. The joint influences of turbulence and magnetic fields can form thin, elongated density structures <ref type="bibr">(Smith et al. 2016 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Gazol &amp; Villagran 2021 )</ref>. Furthermore, stretching induced by turbulence alone can form filaments that are confined by the Lorentz force <ref type="bibr">(Hennebelle 2013 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Seifried et al. 2020</ref> ; Ib &#225; &#732; nez-Mej &#237;a, Mac Low &amp; Klessen 2022 ). Because a filamentary geometry can result from a variety of physical scenarios, the fact of filamentarity does not on its own specify the filament formation mechanism; there may be multiple mechanisms operating across interstellar environments (e.g. <ref type="bibr">Hacar et al. 2022</ref> ). In addition to its morphology, the kinematic structure of filaments can help to constrain the physics of their formation.</p><p>Although a comprehensive analysis of diffuse H I filament kinematics has not yet been disclosed, some visually-inspected tentative velocity gradients along H I filaments are reported <ref type="bibr">(Kalberla et al. 2016 )</ref>. The kinematic structure of filaments has been analysed more thoroughly in molecular environments. Clear velocity gradients are sometimes identified in molecular filaments, either running lengthwise along the filament long axis <ref type="bibr">(Dobashi et al. 1992 )</ref>, or along the orthogonal axis <ref type="bibr">(Fern &#225;ndez-L &#243;pez et al. 2014 )</ref>. Non-self-gravitating filaments ('striations') in the vicinity of a dense filament of the Taurus molecular cloud display a large-scale velocity gradient suggestive of accretion along the striations <ref type="bibr">(Goldsmith et al. 2008 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Palmeirim et al. 2013 )</ref>. The kinematic description of some filaments depends on both the spatial scales and conditions. For instance, <ref type="bibr">Hacar et al. ( 2013 )</ref> suggests that the Taurus B213 filament is actually composed of many distinct velocity structures, while a level of turbulence and type of gas tracers influence the alignment level of the filament <ref type="bibr">(Heyer, Soler &amp; Burkhart 2020 )</ref>. To further search for clues on the formation and evolution of filamentary structures in this paper, we examine the kinematics of H I filaments. To access the kinematics of H I filaments, we utilize threedimensional data from the Galactic Arecibo L -Band Feed Array H I (GALFA-H I ) surv e y <ref type="bibr">(Peek et al. 2018 )</ref>. As <ref type="bibr">Clark et al. ( 2014 )</ref> demonstrated, angular resolution and sensitivity are critical for identifying and characterizing slender H I filaments. We use GALFA-H I 's highest available spatial and spectral resolution (4 arcmin and 0.184 km s -1 , respectively) to study coherent structures in positionposition-velocity space, i.e. the kinetic structure of 3D filaments <ref type="bibr">(Beaumont et al. 2013 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Clark, Peek &amp; Miville-Desch &#710; enes 2019 )</ref>. In this paper, we investigate the kinematic properties and magnetic field orientation of filamentary H I structures at high Galactic latitudes. The paper is organized as follows. In Sections 2 and 3 , we introduce the data and outline the steps to extract the 3D H I filaments. Section 4 discusses our methods to examine the magnetic field orientation and kinematic properties of individual filaments. In Section 5 , we present our results. Finally, we discuss the possible implications of our results in Section 6 and conclude in Section 7 .</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="2">DATA</head><p>H I filaments are extracted from cubes of neutral hydrogen produced by the Galactic Arecibo L -Band Feed Array H I (GALFA-H I ) Surv e y <ref type="bibr">(Peek et al. 2018 )</ref>. GALFA-H I is a high angular and kinematic resolution surv e y of Galactic H I co v ering 13 000 deg 2 (approximately 1/3 of the sky) with 4 arcmin spatial resolution. We use the publicly available GALFA-H I data, which have a pixel size of 1 arcmin 2 and 0.184 km s -1 channel spacing o v er the v elocity range | v| &lt; 188.4 km s -1 . All velocities are measured in the LSR frame. The median rms noise is 352 mK at this resolution. In this paper, we focus on filaments residing in a high Galactic latitude region with an area of 360 deg 2 at 165</p><p>In Fig. <ref type="figure">1</ref> , we show an o v erlay of integrated intensity maps e v aluated in two different velocity ranges o v er the spatial region we co v er. The blue map is inte grated o v er -50 &#8804; v &#8804; -20 km s -1 , while the red is integrated over -20 &#8804; v &#8804; 20 km s -1 . As shown, H I structures are visually distinct at different velocities.</p><p>We also employ the Planck 353 GHz (PR3.1) Stokes linear polarization maps <ref type="bibr">(Planck Collaboration III 2018 )</ref>. The native spatial resolution of the Planck data is FWHM = 4.9 arcmin, comparable to GALFA-H I <ref type="bibr">(Planck Collaboration XIX 2015 )</ref>. For our analysis, we smooth the data to FWHM = 1 &#8226; to impro v e the signal-to-noise of the Planck data.</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="3">D E T E C T I N G D F I L A M E N T S</head><p>We outline a procedure to extract 3D filaments from an emission cube. This algorithm is referred to as fil3d and will be described further and released to the public in a forthcoming work <ref type="bibr">(Putman et al. in prep)</ref>. To extract filamentary structures embedded in the diffuse ISM in the Milky Way, we first filter out large-scale diffuse Galactic emission. We apply an unsharp mask (USM), which ef fecti vely performs a high-pass spatial filter on the raw data. For this step, we first smooth each velocity slice of the data cube with a 30 arcmin Gaussian beam, then subtract the smoothed version from the original, and finally threshold the smoothed, subtracted data at zero. We then run FilFinder <ref type="bibr">(Koch &amp; Rosolowsky 2015 )</ref> to identify filamentary structures on each velocity channel of USM GALFA-H I data.</p><p>FilFinder employs the techniques of mathematical morphology to identify and segment two-dimensional filamentary structures o v er a wide dynamic range in brightness <ref type="bibr">(Shih 2009 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Koch &amp; Rosolowsky 2015 )</ref>. To eliminate irregularities while maintaining a main structure, the algorithm first flattens and smooths the image, then applies an adaptive threshold to pick out all linear structures. These possible filament candidates are then trimmed to a pixel-wide skeleton with minimum connectivity using a Medial Axis Transform <ref type="bibr">(Arcelli &amp; Di Baja 1985 )</ref>. The resulting skeletons are 'pruned' to be final filamentary structures by removing short branches that trace small deviations from the long axis of a filament. With the abo v e procedures e x ecuted o v er the GALFA-H I velocity range | v| &#8804; 188 . 4 km s -1 , we end up with collections of two-dimensional filamentary structures in individual velocity channels. We will refer to each FilFinder -detected 2D filament as a 'node'. From these, we search for spatially o v erlapping node objects in neighbouring velocity channels to obtain velocity-coherent structures. For instance, we start with a node at one channel, then search for objects at the next velocity channel that significantly o v erlaps (share 85 per cent of pixels in common) with the first node. This search is e x ecuted one node at a time and continues until there are no objects found to yield a significant o v erlap  The red contours outline the shapes of the nodes at velocity channels within the fil3d velocity width. This same filament will be used for several of the following plots. in subsequent channels. As fil3d parameters, we assume the distance to be 100 parsecs and set the characteristic scale width as 0.1 parsec, which is the resolution of the GALFA-H I data at this distance.</p><p>Each collection of 2D nodes forms a 3D filament and if a node is not matched with another in either adjacent velocity channel, it is rejected. We verify that all 3D filaments are unique in that each occupies a distinct set of spectral and spatial coordinates. The final projected shape of the 3D filament is defined by the line-of-sight sum of its constituent 2D nodes: we refer to this shape as the 'merged mask' of the 3D filament.</p><p>In the high Galactic latitude region studied here, we initially find 325 3D filament candidates and apply the below filters to obtain 269 3D filaments for our final sample. For the final sample to ensure filament-like morphology, we only accept 3D structures with merged masks with an aspect ratio (the ratio between the length of the major axis to its minor axis) of at least 6:1. We also apply a linewidth filter (see Section 4.1 ), which remo v es an additional 10 per cent of the candidate filaments in our region. Roughly 1 per cent of the H I flux in this region of the sky corresponds to 3D filaments.</p><p>Fig. <ref type="figure">2</ref> shows the merged masks of our final selection of 3D filaments. An example of the individual nodes (or channel maps) for a filament as found by fil3d is shown in Fig. <ref type="figure">3</ref> .</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="4">A NA LY S I S M E T H O D S</head></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="4.1">Linewidth estimation</head><p>The thermal linewidth is a useful indicator of the physical nature of ISM structures. fil3d catalogues filamentary structures which span greater than two velocity channels, and over half of the 3D filaments found occupy only two channels. Considering the fine spectral resolution of GALFA-H I (0.184 km s -1 ), such a narrow velocity width deems unphysical. Cold gas in the Milky Way has a typical linewidth of around 2-3 km s -1 <ref type="bibr">(Kalberla &amp; Haud 2018 )</ref>.</p><p>Upon inspection of the two-channel filaments, many were found to have additional emission within the merged mask in adjacent channels that was not captured by our criteria as clearly filamentary. Thus, rather than adopting the fil3d velocity range as the filament velocity width, we define a procedure for fitting a line profile that we consider to be more representative of all the emission associated with each filament.</p><p>To derive the linewidth of each filament, we find the median USM intensity for each channel within the filament's merged mask area for channels &#177;10 km s -1 from the filament's central velocity, as shown in Fig. <ref type="figure">4</ref> . For this analysis, we re-bin the data into 4 arcmin pixels, to approximately match the GALFA-H I angular resolution. In Fig. <ref type="figure">4</ref> , the blue dots denote the data points, and the orange line indicates a  <ref type="figure">3</ref> . The x -axis shows the velocity and the y -axis denotes the USM median intensity within a merged masked area of the filament (blue dots). The orange curve is the best-fit Gaussian of this velocity spectrum. The grey region indicates the fil3ddetected velocity range. The physical velocity width of a filament is defined as the FWHM of the fitted Gaussian. The best-fit Gaussian peaks near the fil3d -detected velocity range, and we confirm via visual inspection that emission within the Gaussian-selected velocity range is associated with the fil3d -detected filament.</p><p>best-fit Gaussian to the data. The linewidth we adopt going forward for each filament is the full-width at half-maximum (FWHM) of the orange curve. Fig. <ref type="figure">4</ref> shows two intensity peaks, one at &#8776; 0 km s -1 and another at &#8776; 2 km s -1 . The peak near the fil3d detected range is associated with the selected filament, while the 0 km s -1 peak corresponds to contamination from another filament.</p><p>We further implement a two-step examination to eliminate filaments from unassociated emission that is not coincident with the peak velocity in the intensity spectrum. As the first step, we check that the fil3d -detected channels are located within 1 &#963; of the peak of the fitted Gaussian. For filaments that meet this criterion, we then examine the individual channel maps to make sure that the filament emission is located within the merged mask area and does not extend significantly beyond it. Approximately ten per cent of the total detected filaments are eliminated in these two-step examinations.</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="4.2">Magnetic field orientation</head><p>The thermal emission from interstellar dust is linearly polarized because the short axes of dust grains are preferentially oriented parallel to the ambient magnetic field <ref type="bibr">(Purcell 1975 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Andersson, Lazarian &amp; Vaillancourt 2015 )</ref>. Thus, the linear polarization of this radiation is orthogonal to the plane-of-sky magnetic field orientation in the dusty ISM. To measure the magnetic field orientation towards H I filaments, we use Planck polarization maps (Planck Collaboration III 2018 ) at 353 GHz, a frequency dominated by thermal dust emission. It is important to note that photometric dust polarization measures emission integrated over the line of sight and is therefore not v elocity-resolv ed as our 3D filaments are.</p><p>The polarization fraction ( p ) and polarization angle ( &#968;) in our analysis follow the IAU convention in Equatorial coordinates and are defined with the observed Stokes parameters ( I , Q , U ):</p><p>To obtain the mean dust polarization fraction and polarization angle for an individual filament, we apply equations ( <ref type="formula">1</ref>) and ( <ref type="formula">2</ref>), respectively. We define the plane-of-sky magnetic field orientation ( &#966;) to be rotated 90 &#8226; from the measured polarization angle ( &#968;).</p><p>We compute the magnetic field orientation for each filament by measuring the mean Stokes parameters within the merged mask area.</p><p>The propagated statistical uncertainties (used in Section 6.2 ) are computed from the noise covariance matrices and quantified in Planck Collaboration XIX ( 2015 ) as</p><p>where C QQ , C UU are the internal variances and C QU denotes the offdiagonal terms of the noise covariance matrix. The uncertainty on the polarized intensity is given by</p><p>(4)</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="4.3">Filament position-velocity diagrams</head><p>Given the relative orientation of the filaments with respect to the magnetic field and the resolution of the H I observations, we focus on analysing the velocity gradients along the long axis of the filaments. To compute the velocity gradient, we employ the position-velocity (PV) diagram of each filament. A PV diagram measures the distribution of velocities along a projected position and has been employed in understanding the large-scale kinematics of gaseous structures (Garc &#237;a- <ref type="bibr">Burillo et al. 2003 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Veena et al. 2018 )</ref>. We construct PV diagrams here to determine the direction and magnitude of any velocity gradient. For consistency, we define the direction of the gradient to point from the lowest velocity to the highest velocity.</p><p>To ensure, we capture the internal kinematics of filaments, we construct two distinct PV diagrams with the USM data. The first PV diagram e v aluates the intensity within spinal pixels &#964; ( x , y ), or pixels that pass through the long axis spine (central region) of a 3D filament. Fig. <ref type="figure">5</ref> shows the contour of the mask of a full 3D filament o v er the brightness temperature map of the filament at different velocity channels.</p><p>For the first PV diagram, we construct the spinal pixels of 3D filaments by rotating the masks of the 3D filament to project onto a global horizontal axis. Here, the amount of rotation ( &#952; ) is the angle between the spinal pixels of the non-rotated filament &#964; ( x , y ) and the global horizontal axis. After the rotation, all pixels are projected onto grids of equal size. The spinal pixels are the central pixels in every column of this projected mask:</p><p>where prime indicates the rotated frame and R ( &#952; ) represents a rotation matrix written as</p><p>In the second PV diagram, we e v aluate the median brightness temperature along the long axis of a filament. As shown, a majority of the 3D filaments hav e irre gular shapes that the spinal pixels may not al w ays capture the full extent of a filament. Addressing this account, we e v aluate the range of velocities at the median brightness temperature along a given column of the rotated merged mask. In the right-hand panel of Fig. <ref type="figure">6</ref> , we show the range of velocities at the median brightness temperature along a given column of the rotated merged mask. As shown in Fig. <ref type="figure">6</ref> , not surprisingly, both Downloaded from <ref type="url">https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/526/3/4345/7273846</ref> by guest on 28 December 2024  the 'spinal row' and 'median brightness temperature' PV diagrams are highly correlated. This similarity shows that either method is broadly representative of the filament velocity structure.</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="4.4">Measuring velocity gradients</head><p>We determine the presence (or lack) of velocity gradient along the major axis of filaments using PV diagrams from Section 4.3 . To extract a single velocity value along a filament and evaluate the magnitude and direction, we use the intensity-weighted mean velocity along each projected position (the position used as the x -axis of Fig. <ref type="figure">6</ref> ) and fit a slope to the points (as shown in Fig. <ref type="figure">7</ref> ). For example, the intensity-weighted mean velocity at position P = p j is expressed as</p><p>where v fwhm abo v e is e v aluated o v er the FWHM from the v elocity width fit in Section 4.1 at a given position.</p><p>In the top row of Fig. <ref type="figure">7</ref> , we show the intensity-weighted mean velocity along the projected long axe of a filament ( x -axis). With these data for each filament, we perform a weighted least squares regression to obtain a best-fit linear model (solid line). The second moment, &#958; 2 , is used as the weight in the regression. At each pixel ( p j ):</p><p>which shares the same notation as equation ( <ref type="formula">7</ref>). We show the square root of the second moment ( &#958; ) in the bottom row of Fig. <ref type="figure">7</ref> . The magnitude of the slope represents the magnitude of a potential velocity gradient, and the sign of the slope denotes the directional component parallel to the filament's long axis. Not all filaments demonstrate velocity gradients (examples are shown in Fig. <ref type="figure">A3</ref> ). To select filaments that have significant velocity gradients, we e v aluate the goodness of the linear fit to the data. This can be assessed from the coefficient of determination ( R 2 ), which is the ratio of the variance explained by a fitted model to the total v ariance. The v alues for R 2 range from 0 to 1. An ideal model which perfectly explains all the variance in an observation will result in R 2 = 1. A poor fit, on the other hand, will result in a R 2 close to 0. We e v aluate R 2 independently for the two PV diagrams described in Section 4.3 as both capture related yet separate kinematics of a given filament. We consider a filament velocity gradient significant if one of the PV diagrams has the R 2 slope fit greater than 0.5 (see Fig. <ref type="figure">8</ref> ).</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="5">R E S U LT S</head></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="5.1">Local and IVC filament populations</head><p>Fig. <ref type="figure">9</ref> shows the central velocity distribution of the 3D filaments and suggests they can be separated into two distinct groups. The first group, 157 filaments, has a central velocity near v &#8776; 0 km s -1 , which suggests the filaments belong to local gas co-rotating with the . We e v aluate R 2 to determine the goodness-of-fit and consider R 2 &gt; 0.5 fits to have statistically significant gradients.</p><p>Figure <ref type="figure">8</ref>. Histograms of the velocity gradient slope magnitudes e v aluated from spinal and median brightness temperature PV diagrams using a uniform distance of 100 pc. The high R 2 samples (orange) have preferentially higher magnitudes, around 0.1 to 1 km s -1 pc -1 , compared with the total distribution (blue). local standard of rest (LSR). The second group has 48 filaments with velocities v &lt; -30 km s -1 . This second group of filaments is likely part of a previously identified intermediate velocity cloud (IVC) that has velocities that deviate from a simple model of Galactic rotation <ref type="bibr">(Wakker 2004 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Putman, Peek &amp; Joung 2012 )</ref>.</p><p>We assess the properties of the local and IVC filaments separately. In Fig. <ref type="figure">10</ref> , we compare the line widths, median column densities, and lengths of the two populations. In general, we make use of the USM data because the raw data can be affected by some contamination from diffuse Galactic emission. The raw data is used when estimating column densities.</p><p>As shown on the left of Fig. <ref type="figure">10</ref> , the IVC filaments tend to have larger velocity widths (linewidths of filaments are e v aluated using the technique described in Section 4.1 ). The mean linewidth of the local filaments is 3.1 km s -1 , consistent with the typical thermal linewidths of cold H I structures in the Milky Way, and with the theoretical cold neutral medium (CNM) temperatures <ref type="bibr">(Wolfire et al. 1995 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Kalberla &amp; Kerp 2009 )</ref>. The IVC filament linewidths peak at 6.2 km s -1 , indicating this is a population of warmer filaments. This would be expected for filaments directly associated with an IVC complex <ref type="bibr">(Haud 2008 )</ref>.</p><p>We e v aluate the column densities of the filaments and compare them in Fig. <ref type="figure">10</ref> . The column density N H I is computed with</p><p>where T b ( v) is the brightness temperature for a given point within the merged mask area at one velocity channel v and | . . . | indicates the moment 0 e v aluated o v er the linewidth of each filament. As demonstrated from the centre plot of Fig. <ref type="figure">10</ref> , the median column densities of the two populations are comparable with a median of &#8776;10 19 . 6 cm -2 . These values are derived from the raw data because the USM data o v ersubtracted the column density. Thus, the estimated column densities with the raw data may be biased high by the inclusion of diffuse Galactic emission un-associated with the filaments. The column density is computed from the raw data using equation ( <ref type="formula">9</ref>) with the integral over the velocity width from the FWHM estimation. Right: The length of the filament major axes, when a uniform 'fiducial' distance of 100 pc is assumed. The rightmost panel of Fig. <ref type="figure">10</ref> shows the major-axis filament lengths for each filament population, assuming all filaments are at a fiducial of 100 pc. The distributions of the two populations are fairly consistent. Ho we ver, if the likely distance difference between the IVC and the local filaments is taken into account, the length distribution of the IVC filaments will shift further right.</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="5.2">Alignment with the magnetic field</head><p>The magnetic field orientation ( &#966;) of individual filaments is measured using the Planck 353 GHz Stokes parameter maps (see Section 4.2 ). The left-hand panel of Fig. <ref type="figure">11</ref> demonstrates the difference between the mean magnetic field orientations ( &#966;) and spatial orientations ( &#952; ) of filaments, while the right-hand panel shows the measurement uncertainty e v aluated from the smoothed Planck Stokes covariance using equation ( <ref type="formula">4</ref>) o v er the area of the filament merged mask.</p><p>Consistent with <ref type="bibr">Clark et al. ( 2014 )</ref>, Fig. <ref type="figure">11</ref> demonstrates that the majority of the 3D H I filaments are well-aligned with the ambient magnetic field with relatively low &#966; uncertainties in general. Ho we ver, we find different behaviour when we compare the local and IVC populations.  component of the magnetic field orientation in a density-weighted integral along the line of sight.</p><p>To further e v aluate the relati ve orientation between the major axes of filaments and the magnetic field, we compute the extended projected Rayleigh statistics (PRS, <ref type="bibr">Jow et al. 2018 )</ref>. The global PRS value ( Z x ) quantifies the level of agreement between the orientations of the filaments and their av erage relativ e orientation with respect to the local magnetic field:</p><p>where &#952; denotes a projection angle, &#966; and n are the mean magnetic field orientation measured in the same frame as &#952; and the number of filaments, respectively, and Z x 0 indicates strong parallel alignment while Z x 0 indicates strong perpendicular alignment.</p><p>We obtain Z x = 14.4 and &#963; Z x = 0 . 94 for the o v erall filament population. The number density averaged Z x of the local filaments is greater than that of the IVC filaments, which re-confirms what we visually inspect from Fig. <ref type="figure">12</ref>. While the H I filaments at high Galactic latitudes are generally well-aligned with the ambient magnetic field, the local filaments are better aligned with the field. We find no significant correlation between the column densities of filaments and the level of magnetic field alignment, consistent with the findings for low-density dust filaments in Planck Collaboration XXXII ( 2016 ).</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="5.3">Filament kinematics</head><p>We examine the internal kinematics of the filaments by analysing the velocity gradients. As mentioned in Section 4.3 , we extract velocity gradients parallel to major axes of filaments with two types of PV diagrams, then fit linear models to estimate the magnitudes and the directions of gradients. To select filaments with significant velocity gradients, we compare the R -squared metric on the fitted linear models. Approximately 15 per cent of the H I filaments have R 2 &gt; 0.5 for at least one of two PV diagrams, and we consider those samples to demonstrate statistically significant velocity gradients. The estimated gradients from the two PV diagrams are highly correlated; the Spearman correlation coefficient between the two methods is 0.96. The strong agreement between these two methods builds confidence that our gradient inference is robust to particular choices in the PV diagram construction.</p><p>A majority of filaments do not show significant velocity gradients along their length. One driving factor for this seems oscillatory patterns observed in the PV diagrams. Oscillations in the intensityweighted mean velocity along the length of filaments, as seen in Fig. <ref type="figure">7</ref> and multiple examples in the Appendix, can suppress the magnitude of a slope and yield a lower R 2 value.</p><p>Gradient magnitudes are computed assuming a fiducial distance of 100 pc, roughly the distance to the Local Bubble (LB) wall <ref type="bibr">(Lallement et al. 2022 )</ref>. Our velocity gradient measurements are limited by the GALFA-H I sensitivity and resolution: we are only sensitiv e abo v e 10 -2 km s -1 pc -1 for a typical filament. The magnitude distribution shown in Fig. <ref type="figure">8</ref> demonstrates that the statistically significant gradients ( R 2 &#8805; 0.5) all have a magnitude greater than the GALFA-H I resolution limit and have a median velocity gradient of 0.5 km s -1 pc -1 . If the distance to the IVC filaments are taken account, their gradient magnitude would be smaller than O(0 . 1) km s -1 pc -1 . Fig. <ref type="figure">13</ref> illustrates the direction of gradients. The background is the moment 1 map e v aluated in the [ -10, 10] km s -1 range, and the arrows are positioned at each filament's location and point in the direction of increasing velocity. The colours of the arrows denote the central channel detected by fil3d , and the bold arrows show the filaments with R 2 &gt; 0.5. Although no global trend is evident, some regions of local bulk flow seem to be captured (for example, the bottom right) by our analysis.</p><p>The filaments with significant velocity gradients do not appear to correlate with other physical properties such as the filament's central velocity , column density , or magnetic field alignment; ho we ver, there is a weak correlation with filament length. Shorter filaments are more likely to have a statistically significant gradient, and the local filaments tend to be somewhat shorter than the IVC filaments in the sk y. F or instance, 92 per cent of the local filaments with v elocity gradients hav e their major ax es shorter than approximately 5 parsec (72 per cent of all local filaments have lengths less than 5 parsec).</p><p>We attempted to e v aluate the gradient perpendicular to the major axis of filaments; ho we ver, at most only two resolution elements are available across the minor axis of a filament. We performed a preliminary investigation of the kinematic structure perpendicular to the major axis o v er a region slightly wider than the filament masks.</p><p>Though a few filaments show gradients, we did not find clear evidence for perpendicular velocity gradients. To investigate a perpendicular gradient, much higher spatial resolution data of the filaments are needed.</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="6">D I S C U S S I O N</head></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="6.1">Origin and galactic environment</head><p>The H I filaments can be placed into two groups based on their mean detected velocities as shown in Fig. <ref type="figure">9</ref> . The first group clusters around v = 0 km s -1 , which is consistent with gas associated with the solar neighbourhood (we refer to this filament population as 'local'). The second group of filaments clusters around at -60 km s -1 &lt; v &lt; -30 km s -1 , and can be associated with an IVC. The bimodality in the filament population is robust to fil3d parameter choices.</p><p>Given their low absolute velocities and position at high Galactic latitude, the 'local' filaments are likely located relatively nearby. A prominent feature of the nearby ISM is the wall of the LB. The LB is a low-density cavity of the ISM that surrounds the Sun <ref type="bibr">(Lallement et al. 2014 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Pelgrims et al. 2020 )</ref>. The column densities of our filaments imply they are located at a distance at least as far as the wall of the LB. The distance to the LB wall varies as a function of position in the sky, but is at least 100 pc away in most directions (e.g. <ref type="bibr">Cox &amp; Reynolds 1987 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Snowden et al. 2000 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Murray, Peek &amp; Kim 2020 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Lallement et al. 2022</ref> ), thus, we set 100 pc as a lower-limit for filaments' estimated distance.</p><p>The formation of the local filaments is plausibly be linked to the formation of the LB. The winds from massive stars and explosions from nearby supernovae <ref type="bibr">(Cox &amp; Smith 1974 )</ref>, perhaps from the Sco-Cen association <ref type="bibr">(Crutcher 1982 )</ref>, injected the energy needed to stretch the cavity wall and redistribute the interstellar medium o v er spatial scales of a few hundred parsecs. In this process, filamentary structures can be created from the compressed interstellar magnetic fields in the walls or shells of H I gas shaped by the expanding bubbles <ref type="bibr">(Alves et al. 2018 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Frisch &amp; Dwarkadas 2018 )</ref>. Under this scenario, the projected magnetic field follows the curvature of the expanding bubble, which leads to a large-scale correlation between H I geometry and magnetic field orientation. The existence of IVC filaments with similar properties, ho we ver, suggests that if the abo v e bubble-linked formation mechanism is correct, it must be a sufficient, but not necessary, filament formation catalyst.</p><p>Our IVC filaments directly o v erlap with the large IVC complex called the Intermediate-Velocity Arch (IV Arch), which stretches <ref type="bibr">Wakker 2004</ref> ). The IV Arch is at a z-height abo v e the Galactic plane between 0.8 and 1.5 kpc <ref type="bibr">(Kuntz &amp; Danly 1996 )</ref>, and has a local maximum N H I column density in the spatial and kinematic region of our IVC filaments. The physical environment of the IV Arch is not well known, but its physical properties, including the magnetic field, local energy sources, and ISM composition, are unlikely to be identical to those of the LB. Despite these differences, 3D filaments are still found, indicating a variety of physical conditions can produce them.</p><p>The difference in distance between the IVC and the LB leads to a natural size disparity between the two filament populations. The rightmost panel of Fig. <ref type="figure">10</ref> shows that the two filament groups have a similar length; ho we ver, the IV Arch is approximately ten times further away than the neutral wall of the LB, which leads the IVC filaments to have lengths of around tens of parsecs. The line width dif ference between the two populations may represent the lower-pressure environment of the IVCs. Future work that maps filaments across the sky at a range of velocities will be key to further investigating the properties of H I filaments in different Galactic locations.</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="6.2">Implications of filaments' magnetic field alignments</head><p>Fig. <ref type="figure">11</ref> demonstrates that a majority of the H I filaments are well aligned with the plane-of-sky magnetic field orientation inferred from the Planck dust polarization angle. This agrees with previous analyses of H I filaments <ref type="bibr">(Clark et al. 2015 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Clark &amp; Hensley 2019 )</ref>, which find that structures in the diffuse medium are preferentially oriented to the local magnetic field. These previous works quantified the orientation of linear H I structures in individual velocity channel maps using the Rolling Hough Transform <ref type="bibr">(Clark et al. 2014 )</ref>. Distinct from previous work, we explicitly measure the orientation of three-dimensional, velocity-coherent H I filaments.</p><p>When comparing the relative magnetic field orientations between the local and IVC filament populations, we find the IVC filaments are less aligned to the Planck 353 GHz magnetic field. This is perhaps not surprising. Polarized dust emission is a line-of-sight (LOS) integrated quantity. Along a single LOS, multiple layers of dust clouds with different spectral energy distributions (SEDs) and magnetic properties may exist, each contributing to the measured polarization angle <ref type="bibr">(Clark 2018 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Pelgrims et al. 2021 )</ref>. While 'local' gas within the LB has a relatively uniform galactic dust-to-gas emission ratio with a moderate H I column density <ref type="bibr">(Jones et al. 1995 )</ref>, the dust content significantly decreases for more distant gas clouds (e.g. IVCs and HVCs) <ref type="bibr">(Peek 2013 )</ref>. A lower dust content may result from lower metallicities, usually related to the amount of dust, of distant clouds <ref type="bibr">(Wakker &amp; van Woerden 1997 )</ref>, or less heating from the interstellar radiation field due to their distance from the Galactic disc <ref type="bibr">(Saul, Peek &amp; Putman 2014 )</ref>.</p><p>The density-weighted dust polarization at high Galactic latitudes is dominated by the local ISM because the mean dust column of the local ISM is approximately twice that of the IVCs <ref type="bibr">(Panopoulou et al. 2019 )</ref>. In other words, a lack of alignment between the dust polarization and the IVC filaments does not necessarily indicate the IVC filaments are not well aligned with their local magnetic field. F or instance, P anopoulou et al. ( <ref type="formula">2019</ref>) estimated the plane-of-sk y magnetic field orientation as a function of distance using stellar distance and starlight polarization measurements. They found that two clouds at different distances (IVC and LVC) exhibit significant differences in column density and polarization properties; not only do the two clouds differ in p , but also the mean magnetic field orientation at the distance of each cloud differs by 60 &#8226; . <ref type="bibr">Clark &amp; Hensley ( 2019 )</ref> found that the linear H I structures at the velocities coincident with these two clouds agree well with the magnetic field orientations measured by <ref type="bibr">Panopoulou et al. ( 2019 )</ref>. In order to examine the relative orientation of the IVC filaments to their ambient magnetic field, this type of tomographic investigation (e.g. <ref type="bibr">Pelgrims et al. 2023</ref> ) is required to disentangle the magnetic field structures along the LOS.</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="6.3">Velocity gradients</head><p>A number of theoretical models predict velocity gradients along various ISM filaments. H I filaments, if created by thermal instability and turbulent compression and shear, are aligned with the local magnetic field due to the turbulent shear strain induced at the shock front <ref type="bibr">(Inoue &amp; Inutsuka 2016 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Ntormousi et al. 2016 )</ref>. Some literature predicts bulk gas motions along filaments as the magnetic field directs the assembled flow along the field lines <ref type="bibr">(Crutcher et al. 2010 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Tritsis &amp; Tassis 2016 )</ref>.</p><p>In our study, only approximately 15 per cent of the identified H I filaments demonstrate small velocity gradients along their major axes. Because the majority of filaments do not exhibit clear velocity gradients, we conclude that long-axis velocity gradients are not a ubiquitous characteristic of this filament population. Furthermore, the filaments' velocity gradients are not strongly correlated with their magnetic field alignments or column densities. Only a weak anticorrelation between the length of filament and velocity gradients is observed.</p><p>The viewing angle between the 3D filament orientation and the line of sight may contribute to an anticorrelation between filament length and velocity gradient magnitude <ref type="bibr">(Fern &#225;ndez-L &#243;pez et al. 2014 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Chen et al. 2020 )</ref>. For fixed values of gas velocity gradient and filament length, filaments oriented more parallel to the line of sight should exhibit stronger radial velocity gradients and have shorter plane-ofsk y e xtents. Although we see a hint of this e xpected anticorrelation in the data, we cannot conclude this trend is physically meaningful since most of our filaments do not exhibit clear velocity gradients in the first place. Moreo v er, we find that longer filaments are more likely to include knots of emission with more complicated velocity structures, as seen in Fig. <ref type="figure">7</ref> and <ref type="figure">A3</ref> , which results in a lower R 2 score. This physically or unphysically associated emission that is often present in the PV diagrams of longer filaments dilutes the magnitude of the velocity gradients and affects the goodness of fit.</p><p>Periodic velocity structures, somewhat similar to what is seen here, are also reported along the lengths of molecular filaments <ref type="bibr">(Hacar et al. 2013 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Barnes et al. 2018 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Liu, Stutz &amp; Yuan 2019 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Henshaw et al. 2020 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Hacar et al. 2022 )</ref>. Velocity oscillations are present o v er different scales in the molecular filaments, and their origin is often assumed to be related to small-scale gravitational accretion or outflows of young stellar objects <ref type="bibr">(Hacar &amp; Tafalla 2011 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Liu et al. 2019 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Henshaw et al. 2020 )</ref>. We note that the mean gradient magnitudes between the molecular and our H I filaments are similar <ref type="bibr">(Goodman et al. 1993 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Hacar &amp; Tafalla 2011 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Fern &#225;ndez-L &#243;pez et al. 2014 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Jim &#233;nez-Serra et al. 2014 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Dhabal et al. 2018 ;</ref><ref type="bibr">Chen et al. 2020 )</ref>. Although a strong correlation between the H I and 13 CO gas velocities is noted in molecular cloud candidates <ref type="bibr">(Soler et al. 2019 )</ref>, our H I filaments are not self-gravitating, nor near star-forming re gions. An y similarity between the kinematic structure of H I and molecular filaments must either be coincidental or related to other physics. Further studies are needed to explore the similarity between the velocity structures of atomic and molecular filaments.</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head n="7">C O N C L U S I O N</head><p>In this work, we study the kinematics and magnetic field alignment of 3D H I filaments at high Galactic latitude. The highlights of our findings can be summarized as follows.</p><p>(i) We use a new filament-finding algorithm, fil3d , which searches for velocity-coherent filamentary structures. fil3d first finds filamentary ('node') objects in every velocity channel with FilFinder <ref type="bibr">(Koch &amp; Rosolowsky 2015 )</ref>, and then constructs threedimensional filaments by extending nodes that significantly o v erlap with neighbouring velocity channels. We run fil3d on GALFA-H I in a high Galactic latitude region, and identify 269 3D H I filaments after aspect ratio and velocity profile filtering.</p><p>(ii) We observe our 3D filaments can be separated into two groups based on their mean detected velocities. The two groups differ in line widths, magnetic field alignments, and physical sizes, but share similar morphological properties. The results suggest the two groups of filaments originate from the LB and the IV-Arch, respectively.</p><p>(iii) We derive physical line widths of H I filaments by fitting a Gaussian to the USM intensity spectrum of individual filaments. The estimated velocity widths agree well with those of CNM structures. The typical linewidth of local and IVC filaments are 3.1 and 6.2 km s -1 , respectively.</p><p>(iv) We find the local H I filaments are well-aligned with the ambient magnetic field measured from the Planck 353 GHz data. IVC filaments do not show the same level of alignment. This difference is likely due to the fact that the polarized dust emission is LOS integrated and the IVC filaments do not dominate the column. A further tomographic effort is needed to disentangle the magnetic field structures along the line of sight.</p><p>(v) We develop a method of assessing filament velocity gradients from two types of PV diagrams. We find 15 per cent of our filaments show significant velocity gradients along their long axes with their typical gradient amplitudes ranging between 0.1 to 1.2 km s -1 pc -1 .</p><p>The results of this work show the importance of velocities and spectral and spatial resolution in studies of H I filaments. This paper presents the first finding of the alignment of velocity-coherent filamentary structures with the magnetic field and the presence of these structures at the Milky Way's disc-halo interface in the IVCs. Future tomography of the Galactic magnetic field will provide further insight into the alignment of filaments with the magnetic field at varying distances <ref type="bibr">(Tassis et al. 2018 )</ref>. The finding that H I filaments do not typically display long-axis velocity gradients sets constraints on theoretical models of diffuse filament formation.</p></div>
<div xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0"><head>A P P E N D I X : G A L L E RY O F V E L O C I T Y G R A D I E N T S</head><p>Here, we show PV diagrams of H I filaments located in different parts of the sky as shown in Fig. <ref type="figure">A1</ref> . The letters on the filaments in Fig. <ref type="figure">A1</ref> correspond to following PV diagrams. Fig. <ref type="figure">A2</ref> shows the PV diagrams using the two methods discussed in the text, and Fig. <ref type="figure">A3</ref> shows the intensity-weighted mean velocity translated from the two types of PV diagrams. The R 2 is e v aluated for each method and the grey band represents the one sigma uncertainty of the fitted models (see text). </p></div><note xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0" place="foot" xml:id="foot_0"><p>MNRAS 526,4345-4358 (2023)   </p></note>
			<note xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0" place="foot" xml:id="foot_1"><p>Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/526/3/4345/7273846 by guest on 28 December 2024</p></note>
			<note xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0" place="foot" xml:id="foot_2"><p>MNRAS 526,4345-4358 (2023)    FigureA2. PV diagrams of referenced filaments. We assume the distance to these filaments to be 100 pc. Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/526/3/4345/7273846 by guest on 28 December 2024</p></note>
			<note xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0" place="foot" xml:id="foot_3"><p>MNRAS 526,4345-4358 (2023)    Figure A3. Slope fits for the referenced filaments. This paper has been typeset from a T E X/L A T E X file prepared by the author. &#169; 2023 The Author(s) Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Royal Astronomical Society Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/526/3/4345/7273846 by guest on 28 December 2024</p></note>
		</body>
		</text>
</TEI>
