Title: Influence of magmatism on the architecture of transpressional faults and shear zones in the deep crust of the Late Cretaceous Southern California batholith
Abstract Structural analyses combined with U-Pb zircon petrochronology show the influence of arc magmatism on the evolution of two transpressional shear zones in the deep root of the Late Cretaceous Southern California batholith. The mid-crustal Black Belt and lower-crustal Cucamonga shear zones (eastern San Gabriel Mountains, California, USA) formed at ca. 84 Ma, shortly after a large mass of tonalite and granodiorite intruded the lower crust. Both shear zones were active until at least ca. 74 Ma and probably until 72–70 Ma. In the mid-crustal shear zone, rheological contrasts between mingling magmas localized deformation at dike margins. The deformation began as hypersolidus flow in partially crystallized dikes and then transitioned to deformation below the solidus when alternations between viscous creep and brittle faulting produced interlayered pseudotachylyte, cataclasite, and mylonite. As the dikes solidified, strain hardening drove shear zone growth and created thin (10–30 m) high-strain zones and faults that are widely spaced across ~1 km. In contrast, the lower-crustal Cucamonga shear zone was magma-starved, lacks the variety of shear zone fabrics exhibited by its mid-crustal counterpart, and formed by the reactivation of a preexisting fabric that records pure reverse displacements at 124–93 Ma. The two shear zones created a partitioned style of intra-arc transpression where sinistral-reverse (mostly arc-parallel with some arc-oblique) displacements were accommodated on moderately dipping faults and shear zones and arc-normal shortening was accommodated by coeval folds. This study shows how a magmatic surge influenced the architecture and style of Late Cretaceous transpression in the Southern California batholith, including the evolution of high-strain zones that record alternating episodes of brittle, ductile, and hypersolidus deformation. The results illustrate how magmatism localizes strain on deep-crustal faults during orogenesis and oblique convergence.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2138734
PAR ID:
10583834
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
Geological Society of America Bulletin
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Geological Society of America Bulletin
Volume:
137
Issue:
9-10
ISSN:
0016-7606
Page Range / eLocation ID:
4533 to 4557
Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
Lower crustal shear zone, magmatism, transpression, pseudotachylyte, mylonite
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. In the eastern San Gabriel Mountains, located north of Los Angeles, California, the late Cenozoic Cucamonga thrust has uplifted and exposed the lower crustal root of the Mesozoic Southern California Batholith. We use structural data and U-Pb zircon analyses from these exposures to document changes in the style of intra-arc deformation in the batholith as the Laramide Orogeny began during the Late Cretaceous (at or after ~90 Ma). At the base of the uplifted section, a 4 km-thick package of metasedimentary rock records the intrusion of amphibolite, charnokite and other dikes of probable Jurassic to Early Cretaceous age. The oldest gneissic fabrics (S1, S2) in these rocks record Early Cretaceous partial melting, granulite-facies metamorphism, and top-to-the-S and -SE (present day reference frame) reverse motion on surfaces that dip moderately to the N and NW. These structures define a D1/D2 thrust system that formed on the trench side of the arc and was active during the Early Cretaceous. From 89-77 Ma this thrust system was reactivated by oblique-slip shear zones (D3) that record sinistral-reverse displacements on N- and NW-dipping surfaces. The timing of deformation in these latter shear zones is indicated by the age of 90-85 Ma syn-kinematic intrusions of the Tonalite of San Sevaine Lookout. After emplacement of the tonalite, the lower crustal section was deformed by a series of S-vergent, overturned folds. The emplacement of granodioritic dikes into the axial planes of some of these folds suggests that they formed during the latest stages of D3 transpression and tonalite emplacement. Superimposed on all these structures are a series of ductile-to-brittle thrust faults and folds that appear to be related to formation of the late Cenozoic Cucamonga thrust fault at the southern edge of the San Gabriel mountains. These data show that the Southern California Batholith in the San Gabriel Mountains records a tectonic transition from Early Cretaceous reverse faulting and crustal imbrication on the trench side of the arc to Late Cretaceous transpression and oblique sinistral-reverse deformation during a magmatic flare-up from 89-77 Ma. Another major episode of shortening and crustal imbrication occurred during the late Cenozoic when the Cucamonga thrust uplifted the San Gabriel block. 
    more » « less
  2. The Southern California Batholith is a ~500-km-wide segment of the Mesozoic California arc that lies between the northern Peninsular Ranges and the southern Sierra Nevada mountains. We use structural data and U-Pb zircon analyses from the eastern San Gabriel mountains to examine how the batholith responded to the onset of the Laramide orogeny during the Late Cretaceous. Zircon analyses show that the middle and lower crust of the batholith was hot and records a magmatic flareup from 90-77 Ma. From 90 to 86 Ma, tonalite of the San Sevaine Lookout intruded a thick package of metasedimentary rock that records a history of reverse displacements, crustal imbrication, and granulite metamorphism prior to tonalite intrusion. During the early stages of the magmatic flare-up, granodiorite dikes were emplaced and soon became tightly folded and disaggregated as younger sheets of comagmatic tonalite intruded. Deformation accompanied the magmatism, forming two parallel shear zones several 100 m thick. These two shear zones, which include the Black Belt Mylonite, are composed of thin (≤10 m) high-strain zones spaced several tens of meters apart. Each discrete high-strain zone contains subparallel layers of mylonite, ultramylonite, cataclasite and pseudotachylyte, all recording oblique sinistral-reverse displacements on gently and moderately dipping surfaces. This architecture, whereby individual high-strain zones are widely spaced and parallel the margins of intruding tonalite sheets, reveals the influence of magma emplacement on shear zone structure. U-Pb zircon geochronology on syn-tectonic dikes indicate that these different styles of deformation all formed within the same 89-85 Ma interval, suggesting that they reflect non-steady flow on deep seismogenic faults. Widespread (garnet) granulite-facies metamorphism and partial melting accompanied intrusion of the tonalites and sinistral- reverse displacements. The ages of undeformed dikes indicate that the deformation was over by 77-75 Ma. Together, these data show that arc magmatism and transpression within the Mesozoic California arc occurred from ~90 until ~75 Ma, implying that flat-slab subduction and the migration of the Laramide orogenic front into the North America interior occurred after ~75 Ma. 
    more » « less
  3. Gordon, SM; Miller, RB; Rusmore, ME; Tikoff, B (Ed.)
    The Late Cretaceous paleogeography of Southern California potentially plays a central role in resolving conflicting models for postulated large-magnitude dextral translations along the western margin of North America (the Baja-BC hypothesis) and the beginning of the Laramide orogeny. The Mt. Pinos sector of the Southern California Batholith provides a unique window into this time because it preserves evidence for a kinematically and temporally partitioned fault system that includes a ductile shear zone (the Tumamait shear zone) and a ductile-to-brittle thrust fault (the Sawmill thrust). These two structures accommodated intra-arc strain during the Late Cretaceous to Paleocene during three phases of deformation (D3-D5) that are superimposed on older (D1 and D2) structures. D1 structures only occur in Pre-Mesozoic rocks and provide a reference frame for understanding subsequent deformation phases. D2 structures form part of a previously unmapped dextral-normal shear zone that predates the Tumamait shear zone. The initiation of displacements within the Tumamait shear zone is recorded by the formation of D3 mylonites which everywhere record reverse-sinistral movement. Petrochronology of syn- D3 titanites give lower-intercept 206Pb/238U dates ranging from 77.0 to 74.0 Ma and upper amphibolite-facies temperatures ranging from 699 to 718°C. Subsequent folding of the D3 mylonites during D4 was synchronous with late-stage, peraluminous magmatism at ca. 70 Ma. Near the Sawmill thrust, the D4 event resulted in a S4 crenulation cleavage and asymmetric, overturned folds that record top-to-the-NE tectonic displacements. NE-directed thrusting along the Sawmill thrust occurred at 67-66 Ma is interpreted to have been kinematically linked to D4 deformation. This thrust placed upper plate rocks of the Southern California Batholith above the Late Cretaceous Pelona schist. We interpret deformational fabrics in the Mt. Pinos area to record a kinematically partitioned, transpressional system that involved sinistral-reverse shearing (D3) closely followed by folding and arc-directed thrusting (D4-D5). We speculate that D3 structures developed in response to opening of the Kula-Farallon plate boundary and we hypothesize that the Kula-Farallon-North American plate triple junction was located at the present-day location of the Garlock Fault at ca. 85 Ma thereby segmenting the arc at this location. This geometry resulted in in dextral shearing in the Sierra Nevada Batholith (and northward) and sinistral shearing in the Southern California Batholith and Baja California. Continued subduction of the Farallon plate beneath the Southern California Batholith led to a major arc flare-up event from 90-70 Ma which was associated with D3 sinistral transpression. We interpret D3-D5 structures to record oblique convergence and the underthrusting of the Hess oceanic plateau beneath the Southern California Batholith at ca. 70-66 Ma. Our model for the segmentation of the California arc is compatible with a moderate (1000-1600 km), ‘Sierra-BC’ translation model in which the Insular superterrane was located north of the Southern California Batholith in the Late Cretaceous. 
    more » « less
  4. Structural analyses combined with U‐Pb zircon petrochronology show the influence of arc magmatism on the evolution of two transpressional shear zones in the deep root of the Late Cretaceous Southern California batholith.  The mid-crustal Black Belt and lower-crustal Cucamonga shear zones (eastern San Gabriel Mountains) formed at ~84 Ma shortly after a large mass of tonalite and granodiorite intruded the lower crust.  Both shear zones were active until at least ~74 Ma and probably until 72-70 Ma.  In the mid-crustal shear zone, rheological contrasts between mingling magmas localized deformation at dike margins.  The deformation began as hypersolidus flow in partially crystallized dikes and then transitioned to deformation below the solidus when alternations between viscous creep and brittle faulting produced interlayered pseudotachylyte, cataclasite, and mylonite. As the dikes solidified, strain hardening drove shear zone growth and created thin (10-30 m) high-strain zones and faults that are widely spaced across ~1 km. In contrast, the lower-crustal Cucamonga shear zone was magma-starved, lacks the variety of shear zone fabrics exhibited by its mid-crustal counterpart, and formed by the reactivation of a pre-existing fabric that records pure reverse displacements at 124-93 Ma.  The two shear zones created a partitioned style of intra-arc transpression where sinistral-reverse (mostly arc-parallel with some arc-oblique) displacements were accommodated on moderately dipping faults and shear zones and arc-normal shortening was accommodated by coeval folds.  This study shows how a magmatic surge influenced the architecture and style of Late Cretaceous transpression in the Southern California batholith, including the evolution of high-strain zones that record alternating episodes of brittle, ductile, and hypersolidus deformation.  The results illustrate how magmatism localizes strain on deep-crustal faults during orogenesis and oblique convergence. We conducted U-Pb analyses on 11 zircon-bearing samples to determine the timing of magmatism, metamorphism, and deformation in the Black Belt and Cucamonga shear zones. Some zircons exhibited interior core and rim domains that reflect a history of deformation and metamorphism at amphibolite- to granulite-facies conditions.  The methods used in this study closely follow those outlined in Kylander-Clark et al. (2013) and are described in detail by Schwartz et al. (2024b).  U-Pb ratios were collected at the University of California, Santa Barbara using a Nu Plasma multi-collector inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer (MC-ICPMS) with a Photon Machines 193 ArF excimer laser with HelEx cell. Spot size and frequency were 35 µm and 4 Hz, respectively.  The primary standard (91500) was accessed every 10 analyses to correct for in-run fractionation of Pb/U and Pb isotopes. A secondary standard (Temora-2) was analyzed every ~10 analyses to assess data reproducibility. Uncertainties are reported as 2SE internal calculated from Iolite and IsoplotR (Paton et al., 2010; Vermeesch, 2018).  We assigned a 2% uncertainty to all dates for interlab comparisons to account for the reproducibility of standards. Zircon ages are reported using the 206Pb/238U date for analyses <1100 Ma, and the 207Pb/206Pb date for those >1100 Ma. For the former, discordance is calculated as the percent difference between the 207Pb/235U and 206Pb/238U dates. Corrections for minor amounts of common Pb in zircon were made on 206Pb/238U dates following the methods of Tera and Wasserburg (1972) using measured 207Pb/206Pb and 238U/206Pb ratios and an age-appropriate Pb isotopic composition of Stacey and Kramers (1975).  Zircons with large common Pb corrections (e.g., analyses interpreted as having ~20% or greater contribution from common Pb) were discarded. No corrections were made on 207Pb/206Pb dates due to large uncertainties in measured 204Pb. Cathodoluminescence images were obtained using a FEI Quanta scanning electron microscope before and after ablation to evaluate analyzed areas and compare them with growth textures. Where possible, we targeted all growth domains and report 207Pb/206Pb-corrected 206Pb/238U ages of texturally homogeneous populations. In a few cases where a laser spots overlapped multiple domains we report the data in tables but did not considered them in weighted mean calculations. Concordia plots and error-weighted average ages are shown in the accompanying journal article. Trace elements were measured simultaneously with U-Pb isotopes by LA-SF-ICPMS using Zr as the internal standard and nominal values of 43.14 % Zr. Trace element data were reduced using Iolite (Paton et al., 2010, 2011) and concentrations calculated relative to NIST-612 as a primary standard. BHVO-2G was analyzed as a secondary standard to assess reproducibility of the data. For zircon, model Ti-in-zircon temperatures were calculated using the Ferry and Watson (Ferry and Watson, 2007) calibration. Samples of granulite-facies rocks from the Cucamonga terrane contain rutile, allowing us to estimate the activity of TiO2 to be one.  For samples that lack rutile we assume a value of 0.6 based on the presence of ilmenite. # Data from: Influence of magmatism on the architecture of transpressional faults and shear zones in the deep crust of the Late Cretaceous Southern California batholith [https://doi.org/10.5061/dryad.jh9w0vtn6](https://doi.org/10.5061/dryad.jh9w0vtn6) ## Description of the data and file structure All isotopic, geochemical, and trace element data were collected as part of a study to determine the timing of magmatism, metamorphism, and deformation in the Black Belt and Cucamonga shear zones in the southeastern San Gabriel Mountains in Southern California. Some zircons exhibited interior core and rim domains that reflect a history of deformation and metamorphism at amphibolite- to granulite-facies conditions. Where possible, we used zircon trace-element concentrations and ratios, particularly U (ppm), U/Th, Gd/Yb, and Dy/Yb, to distinguish metamorphic age populations. For more information on methods and an interpretation of the data, please see the publication in the journal *GSA Bulletin* by Klepeis et al. (2025). ### Files and variables #### File: Supplementary_Table_1_U-Pb_zircon_FINAL.xlsx **Description:** The table in the data sheet tab titled 'Table 1. U-Pb data unknowns' presents all U-Pb isotope data for the 11 samples analyzed plus the standards used. All standards are listed at the bottom of the table. The zircon standards include: Plesovice(Ples), which is used as a zircon U-Pb age standard; 91500, which is a primary zircon reference standard used for age normalization and reproducibility; Australian zircon suite (AusZ), which is a zircon age standard that is used as a secondary check on accuracy; GJ-1 zircon (GJ), which is a widely used zircon standard, the Malinau/Malim zircon suite (Mali) which is an additional age validation standard. Trace element standards include NIST 612 (N612), which is a synthetic silicate glass standard (see more information below), and BHVO, which is a natural basalt reference standard (see more information below). In the 'Table 1. U-Pb data unknowns' tab, n/a means not applicable. This refers to the lack of best ages and absolute error calculations for the standards N612 and BVHO. This information isn't applicable because these are non-zircon trace element standards, so no age is calculated. In contrast, the zircon standards (91500, AusZ, GJ, Mali, Plesovice) all have well-known ages, so best age and absolute error calculations are included. In the Table 1 data tab, n.d. means not detected. Only 1 average value and a standard deviation for the trace element analyses are provided for each sample in columns AP and AQ, respectively (the rest of the cells are blank). The tab titled 'NIST 612' shows data that used the widely used synthetic glass standard from the U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology. The standard is commonly analyzed to calibrate trace-element concentrations during LA-ICP-MS work. The tab titled 'BHVO' reports data from a well-characterized natural basalt reference material (from Hawaii). This is used as a secondary standard to monitor analytical accuracy and precision. In the BHVO data tab, n.d. means not detected. Isotopic ratios and Apparent ages are not corrected for common lead. For the 206Pb/238U ages, common lead was corrected by inferring the initial Pb-composition from the Stacey and Kramers (1975) two stage isotope evolution model (Vermeesch, 2018). Analyses with greater than 10% uncertainty in 207Pb/206Pb age (1-sigma) or 5% uncertainty in 206Pb/238U age (1-sigma), 20% discordance, and/or 5% reverse discordance are excluded. Accepted ages were calculated by using 206Pb/238U ages for grains younger than 1100 Ma and 207Pb/206Pb ages for grains older than 1100 Ma. ##### Variables * U, U/Th, 238U/206U, 207Pb/206Pb, 207Pb/206Pb vs 238U/206Pb isotopic ratios, apparent ages and absolute errors. * Trace-element data for P, Ti, V, Y, Zr, Nb, La, Ce, Pr, Nd, Sm, Eu, Gd, Tb, Dy, Ho, Er, Tm, Yb, Lu, Hf, Ta Abbreviations include: ppm is parts per million, abs is absolute, Ma is millions of years, abs err is absolute error, error corr is error correction. ## Code/software Uncertainties were calculated using Iolite and IsoplotR (Paton et al., 2010; Vermeesch, 2018) 
    more » « less
  5. null (Ed.)
    Abstract Recovering the time-evolving relationship between arc magmatism and deformation, and the influence of anisotropies (inherited foliations, crustal-scale features, and thermal gradients), is critical for interpreting the location, timing, and geometry of transpressional structures in continental arcs. We investigated these themes of magma-deformation interactions and preexisting anisotropies within a middle- and lower-crustal section of Cretaceous arc crust coinciding with a Paleozoic boundary in central Fiordland, New Zealand. We present new structural mapping and results of Zr-in-titanite thermometry and U-Pb zircon and titanite geochronology from an Early Cretaceous batholith and its host rock. The data reveal how the expression of transpression in the middle and lower crust of a continental magmatic arc evolved during emplacement and crystallization of the ∼2300 km2 lower-crustal Western Fiordland Orthogneiss (WFO) batholith. Two structures within Fiordland’s architecture of transpressional shear zones are identified. The gently dipping Misty shear zone records syn-magmatic oblique-sinistral thrust motion between ca. 123 and ca. 118 Ma, along the lower-crustal WFO Misty Pluton margin. The subhorizontal South Adams Burn thrust records mid-crustal arc-normal shortening between ca. 114 and ca. 111 Ma. Both structures are localized within and reactivate a recently described >10 km-wide Paleozoic crustal boundary, and show that deformation migrated upwards between ca. 118 and ca. 114 Ma. WFO emplacement and crystallization (mainly 118–115 Ma) coincided with elevated (>750 °C) middle- and lower-crustal Zr-in-titanite temperatures and the onset of mid-crustal cooling at 5.9 ± 2.0 °C Ma−1 between ca. 118 and ca. 95 Ma. We suggest that reduced strength contrasts across lower-crustal pluton margins during crystallization caused deformation to migrate upwards into thermally weakened rocks of the mid-crust. The migration was accompanied by partitioning of deformation into domains of arc-normal shortening in Paleozoic metasedimentary rocks and domains that combined shortening and strike-slip deformation in crustal-scale subvertical, transpressional shear zones previously documented in Fiordland. U-Pb titanite dates indicate Carboniferous–Cretaceous (re)crystallization, consistent with reactivation of the inherited boundary. Our results show that spatio-temporal patterns of transpression are influenced by magma emplacement and crystallization and by the thermal structure of a reactivated boundary. 
    more » « less