An official website of the United States government
A detailed damage survey is combined with high-resolution mobile, rapid-scanning X-band polarimetric radar data collected on the Shawnee, Oklahoma, tornado of 19 May 2013. The focus of this study is the radar data collected during a period when the tornado was producing damage rated EF3. Vertical profiles of mobile radar data, centered on the tornado, revealed that the radar reflectivity was approximately uniform with height and increased in magnitude as more debris was lofted. There was a large decrease in both the cross-correlation coefficient ( ρ hv ) and differential radar reflectivity ( Z DR ) immediately after the tornado exited the damaged area rated EF3. Low ρ hv and Z DR occurred near the surface where debris loading was the greatest. The 10th percentile of ρ hv decreased markedly after large amounts of debris were lofted after the tornado leveled a number of structures. Subsequently, ρ hv quickly recovered to higher values. This recovery suggests that the largest debris had been centrifuged or fallen out whereas light debris remained or continued to be lofted. Range–height profiles of the dual-Doppler analyses that were azimuthally averaged around the tornado revealed a zone of maximum radial convergence at a smaller radius relative to the leading edge of lofted debris. Low-level inflow into the tornado encountering a positive bias in the tornado-relative radial velocities could explain the existence of the zone. The vertical structure of the convergence zone was shown for the first time.
more »
« less
This content will become publicly available on June 12, 2026
A Novel Technique to Correct Debris Centrifuging Bias in Doppler Velocity Measurements from Tornadoes
Abstract Due to differences between air and debris motions, debris centrifuging creates bias in wind estimates based on Doppler velocities and radar wind retrievals in tornadoes. Anomalous radial divergence, azimuthal wind underestimation, and vertical velocity bias associated with debris centrifuging can lead to erroneous interpretations of tornado intensity and structure from radar data. A novel spectral velocity correction technique is developed to reduce bias by identifying rain and debris motion in radar signals using dual-polarization spectral density estimation and fuzzy logic classification. This technique successfully improves Doppler velocity estimates in simulated S-band polarimetric time series data, although debris concentration modulates both the magnitude and correctability of velocity bias. Large bias magnitudes associated with high debris concentrations are the most difficult to fully correct using this technique, especially at low elevation angles and near the center of the tornado. However, the magnitudes of corrections applied are proportional to the original bias magnitudes, suggesting that the technique performs consistently across low and high debris concentrations. Spectral correction results in an overall 84% reduction in bias in simulations. The spectral correction technique is also applied to dual-polarization S-band radar observations of the 20 May 2013 Moore, Oklahoma tornado. Overall increases in Doppler velocity magnitudes, especially at lower elevation angles, imply that spectral correction can successfully reduce centrifuging bias in observed Doppler velocities.
more »
« less
- PAR ID:
- 10609464
- Publisher / Repository:
- American Meteorological Society
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Journal of Atmospheric and Oceanic Technology
- ISSN:
- 0739-0572
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Abstract An EF1 tornado was documented using photographs, a high-resolution video, and a mobile radar as it entered Selden, KS on 24 May 2021. The kinematic structure of the tornadic wind field was presented by tracking lofted debris and analyzing single-Doppler velocities. Tracking of debris on the side of the tornado farthest from the observer was possible due to the transparent nature of the debris cloud. The analysis suggests that the circulation was axisymmetric with the maximum horizontal velocities located at low levels. The positive vertical velocities were strongest on the forward side of the tornado. The maximum vertical velocities were associated with a secondary vortex. For the first time, the data set provided an opportunity to assess the orientation of a large, lofted debris based on the images recorded by a movie and compare these observations with the differential radar reflectivity (ZDR) recorded by a mobile polarimetric radar. T-matrix calculations of wood boards yielded a mean ZDRthat was negative and was also observed in the ZDRanalysis suggesting a preference for lofted debris to be vertically oriented.more » « less
-
Abstract When a tornado lofts debris to the height of the radar beam, a signature known as the tornadic debris signature (TDS) can sometimes be observed on radar. The TDS is a useful signature for operational forecasters because it can confirm the presence of a tornado and provide information about the amount of damage occurring. Since real-time estimates of tornadic intensity do not have a high degree of accuracy, past studies have hypothesized that the TDS could also be an indicator of the strength of a tornado. However, few studies have related the tornadic wind field to TDS characteristics because of the difficulty of obtaining accurate, three-dimensional wind data in tornadoes from radar data. With this in mind, the goals of this study are twofold: 1) to investigate the relationships between polarimetric characteristics of TDSs and the three-dimensional tornadic winds, and 2) to define relationships between polarimetric radar variables and debris characteristics. Simulations are performed using a dual-polarization radar simulator called SimRadar; large-eddy simulations (LESs) of tornadoes; and a single-volume,-matrix-based emulator. Results show that for all simulated debris types increases in horizontal and vertical wind speeds are related to decreases in correlation coefficient and increases in TDS area and height and that, conversely, decreases in horizontal and vertical wind speeds are related to increases in correlation coefficient and decreases in TDS area and height. However, the range of correlation coefficient values varies with debris type, indicating that TDSs that are composed of similar debris types can appear remarkably different on radar in comparison with a TDS with diverse scatterers. Such findings confirm past observational hypotheses and can aid operational forecasters in tornado detection and potentially the categorization of damage severity using radar data.more » « less
-
Abstract The Weather Surveillance Radar-1988 Doppler (WSR-88D) network has undergone several improvements in the last decade with the upgrade to dual-polarization capabilities and the ability for forecasters to rescan the lowest levels of the atmosphere more frequently through the use of Supplemental Adaptive Intra-volume Scanning (SAILS). SAILS reduces the revisit period for scanning the lowest 1 km of the atmosphere but comes at the cost of a longer delay between scans at higher altitudes. This study quantifies how often radar volume coverage patterns (VCPs) and all available SAILS options are used during the issuance of 148 882 severe thunderstorm and 18 263 tornado warnings, and near 10 474 tornado, 58 934 hail, and 127 575 wind reports in the dual-polarization radar era. A large majority of warnings and storm reports were measured with a VCP providing denser low-level sampling coverage. More frequent low-level updates were employed near tornado warnings and reports compared to severe thunderstorm warnings and hail or wind hazards. Warnings issued near a radar providing three extra low-level scans (SAILSx3) were more likely to be verified by a hazard with a positive lead time than warnings with fewer low-level scans. However, extra low-level scans were more frequently used in environments supporting organized convection as shown using watches issued by the Storm Prediction Center. In recent years, the number of midlevel radar elevation scans is declining per hour, which can adversely affect the tracking of convective polarimetric signatures, like Z DR columns, which were found above the lowest elevation angle in over 99% of cases examined.more » « less
-
Spectral polarimetry has the potential to be used to study microphysical properties in relation to the dynamics within a radar resolution volume by combining Doppler and polarimetric measurements. The past studies of spectral polarimetry have focused on using radar measurements from higher elevation angles, where both the size sorting from the hydrometeors’ terminal velocities and polarimetric characteristics are maintained. In this work, spectral polarimetry is applied to data from the 0° elevation angle, where polarimetric properties are maximized. Radar data collected by the C-band University of Oklahoma Polarimetric Radar for Innovations in Meteorology and Engineering (OU-PRIME) during a hailstorm event on 24 April 2011 are used in the analysis. The slope of the spectral differential reflectivity exhibits interesting variations across the hail core, which suggests the presence of size sorting of hydrometeors caused by vertical shear in a turbulent environment. A nearby S-band polarimetric Weather Surveillance Radar-1988 Doppler (KOUN) is also used to provide insights into this hailstorm. Moreover, a flexible numerical simulation is developed for this study, in which different types of hydrometeors such as rain and melting hail can be considered individually or as a combination under different sheared and turbulent conditions. The impacts of particle size distribution, shear, turbulence, attenuation, and mixture of rain and melting hail on polarimetric spectral signatures are investigated with the simulated Doppler spectra and spectral differential reflectivity.more » « less
