More Like this

1. Making Continental Crust on Water-bearing Terrestrial Planets

   Borisova, Anastassia; Bernadet, Justine; Guitreau, Martin; Safonov, Oleg; Asimow, Paul D; Nedelec, Anne; Bohrson, Wendy A; Kosova, Svetlana; de_Parseval, Philippe (December 2024, American Geophysical Union)

   Debate regarding early Earth differentiation focuses on the fate, nature, origin, volume, and processes responsible for protocrust(s) and felsic crust formation. One specific aspect of this debate is how Hadean zircons and their felsic parental magmas fit with an expected ultramafic environment. Based on our new experiments, thermodynamic modeling, and elemental partitioning, we infer that felsic liquids could have been generated by shallow (< 20 km) interaction between primordial hydrated peridotite (serpentinite) and basaltic magmas. Felsic melts (SiO2 ≥ 55 wt%) can be generated at a maximum melt fraction of 0.4 when starting serpentinite:basalt mass ratio is high (i.e., higher than 1.5:1). Here we show that felsic melts obtained in our experimental runs can account for the Hf isotope evolutionary array displayed by Hadean detrital zircons worldwide. We propose that open system interactions between serpentinite and basaltic melts at the end of the magma ocean stage after magma degassing and water ocean precipitation allowed the formation of extensive early Hadean felsic crust (4.4 - 4.5 Gy ago). Our calculations indicate that this felsic crust accounts for up to 50% of present-day continental crust mass. The abundant production of primordial felsic crust throughout the Hadean could be due to the impact-induced melting owing to frequent impacts. A similar process could have also occurred on Mars, and other rocky planets, provided that water was abundant at shallow and surficial levels, which would account for the existence of a thick felsic crust. The serpentinised protocrust had a dual role in the primitive planetary environment: to provide the first and most abundant felsic crust and to facilitate the emergence of life in the shallow hydrothermal environments of water-bearing terrestrial planets. 

   more » « less
2. Trace elements in zircon record changing magmatic processes and the multi-stage build-up of Archean proto-continental crust

   https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gca.2024.03.014  

   Drabon, Nadja; Kirkpatrick, Heather M; Byerly, Gary R; Wooden, Joseph L (May 2024, Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta)

   Iizuka, Tsuyoshi (Ed.)

   Zircon trace element geochemistry has become an increasingly popular tool to track crustal evolution through time. This has been especially important in early-Earth settings where most of the crust has been lost, but in some fortuitous instances detrital zircons derived from that lost crust have been preserved in younger sediments. To study the formation and geochemical evolution of continental crust from the Hadean to the Paleoarchean, the 3.6 to 3.2 Ga Barberton Greenstone Belt in southern Africa is an excellent target due to its outstanding preservation and presence of detrital zircons that span almost a billion years. Here, we use trace elements, in combination with hafnium and oxygen isotopes, of 3.65 to 3.22 Ga detrital and tuffaceous zircons of the Moodies and Fig Tree groups and compare their geochemistry to previously studied 4.2 to 3.3 Ga detrital zircons from the Green Sandstone Bed of the Onverwacht Group. The major detrital zircon age clusters in the former at 3.55 Ga, 3.46 Ga, and 3.26–3.23 Ga overlap with episodes of TTG emplacement and felsic volcanism in the Barberton area, suggesting a local provenance. In contrast, age clusters at 3.65 Ga and 3.29 Ga of the Moodies and Fig Tree groups as well as 4.2 to 3.3 Ga detrital zircons from the Green Sandstone Bed do not have known intrusive sources and were likely derived from outside the present-day Barberton belt. This indicates that more than half of the felsic igneous events in the detrital zircon record do not have a whole-rock representation that can be directly studied. The similar compositions and inferred crustal evolution histories recorded in zircons from the Fig Tree and Moodies groups, as well as from the Green Sandstone Bed, suggest that they were derived from connected terranes experiencing similar crustal processes diachronously. Together, they show three phases of felsic continent formation, reflecting different crustal processes: (1) long-lived protocrust formed in the Hadean from undepleted mantle sources. These zircons are vastly different from younger zircons and, hence, Barberton TTGs are not good analogues of Hadean crust formation. (2) At 3.8 Ga, onset of significant crustal growth though cyclic juvenile additions and hydrous melting, possibly within a volcanic plateau setting but an arc-like setting cannot be excluded based on this data. (3) Between 3.4 and 3.3 Ga, felsic crust is generated through a previously unrecognized episode of crustal growth by shallow melting of mafic, mantle-derived sources. This is immediately followed by the onset of crustal thickening through the transport of surface-altered, hydrated materials to deep crustal levels. Since there is geological evidence for extension and shortening at that time this may reflect the onset of horizontal movement. Whether this last geodynamic setting reflects modern-style plate tectonics or not, continent formation and the onset of plate tectonics in the Barberton area occurred through complex multi-stage processes spanning almost a billion years, most of which is only accessible through the detrital zircon record. 

   more » « less
3. Destabilization of Long‐Lived Hadean Protocrust and the Onset of Pervasive Hydrous Melting at 3.8 Ga

   https://doi.org/10.1029/2021AV000520  

   Drabon, Nadja; Byerly, Benjamin_L; Byerly, Gary_R; Wooden, Joseph_L; Wiedenbeck, Michael; Valley, John_W; Kitajima, Kouki; Bauer, Ann_M; Lowe, Donald_R (April 2022, AGU Advances)

   Abstract The nature of Earth's earliest crust and crustal processes remain unresolved questions in Precambrian geology. While some hypotheses suggest that plate tectonics began in the Hadean, others suggest that the Hadean was characterized by long‐lived protocrust and an absence of significant plate tectonic processes. Recently proposed trace‐element proxies for the tectono‐magmatic settings in which zircons formed are a relatively novel tool to understand crustal processes in the past. Here, we present high‐spatial resolution zircon trace and rare earth element geochemical data along with Hf and O isotope data of a new location with Hadean materials, 4.1–3.3 Ga detrital zircons from the 3.31 Ga Green Sandstone Bed, Barberton Greenstone Belt. Together, the hafnium isotope and trace element geochemistry of the detrital zircons record a major transition in crustal processes. Zircons older than 3.8 Ga show evidence for isolated, long‐lived protocrust derived by reworking of relatively undepleted mantle sources with limited remelting of surface‐altered material. After 3.8 Ga, Hf isotopic evidence for this protocrust is muted while relatively juvenile source components for the zircon's parental magmas and flux‐like melting signatures become more prominent. This shift mirrors changes in Hf isotopes and trace element geochemistry in other Archean terranes between ∼3.8 and 3.6 Ga and supports the notion that the global onset of pervasive crustal instability and recycling—A possible sign for mobile‐lid tectonics—Occurred in that time period. 

   more » « less
4. Eoarchean and Hadean melts reveal arc-like trace element and isotopic signatures

   https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-023-36538-5  

   Chowdhury, Wriju; Trail, Dustin; Miller, Martha; Savage, Paul (February 2023, Nature Communications)

   Abstract Constraining the lithological diversity and tectonics of the earliest Earth is critical to understanding our planet’s evolution. Here we use detrital Jack Hills zircon (3.7 − 4.2 Ga) analyses coupled with new experimental partitioning data to model the silica content, Si+O isotopic composition, and trace element contents of their parent melts. Comparing our derived Jack Hills zircons’ parent melt Si+O isotopic compositions (−1.92 ≤ δ³⁰Si_NBS28 ≤ 0.53 ‰; 5.23 ≤ δ¹⁸O_VSMOW ≤ 9.00 ‰) to younger crustal lithologies, we conclude that the chemistry of the parent melts was influenced by the assimilation of terrigenous sediments, serpentinites, cherts, and silicified basalts, followed by igneous differentiation, leading to the formation of intermediate to felsic melts in the early Earth. Trace element measurements also show that the formational regime had an arc-like chemistry, implying the presence of mobile-lid tectonics in the Hadean. Finally, we propose that these continental-crust forming processes operated uniformly from 4.2 to at least 3.7 Ga. 

   more » « less
5. Zircon geochemistry from early evolved terranes records coeval stagnant- and mobile-lid tectonic regimes

   https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2405378121  

   Mixon, Emily E; Bauer, Ann M; Blum, Tyler B; Valley, John W; Rizo, Hanika; O’Neil, Jonathan; Kitajima, Kouki (September 2024, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences)

   Determining the mechanisms by which the earliest continental crust was generated and reworked is important for constraining the evolution of Earth’s geodynamic, surface, and atmospheric conditions. However, the details of early plate tectonic settings often remain obscured by the intervening ~4 Ga of crustal recycling. Covariations of U, Nb, Sc, and Yb in zircon have been shown to faithfully reflect Phanerozoic whole-rock-based plate-tectonic discriminators and are therefore useful in distinguishing zircons crystallized in ridge, plume, and arc-like environments, both in the present and in deep time. However, application of these proxies to deciphering tectonic settings on the early Earth has thus far been limited to select portions of the detrital zircon record. Here, we present in situ trace-element and oxygen isotope compositions for magmatic zircons from crystalline crustal rocks of the Acasta Gneiss Complex and the Saglek-Hebron Complex, Canada. Integrated with information from whole-rock geochemistry and zircon U-Pb, Hf, and O isotopes, our zircon U-Nb-Sc-Yb results reveal that melting of hydrated basalt was not restricted to a single tectonomagmatic process during the Archean but was operative during the reworking of Hadean protocrust and the generation of juvenile crust within two cratons, as early as 3.9 Ga. We observe zircon trace-element compositions indicative of hydrous melting in settings that otherwise host seemingly differing whole-rock geochemistry, zircon Hf, and zircon O isotopes, suggesting contemporaneous operation of stagnant-lid (oceanic plateau) and mobile-lid (arc-like) regimes in the early Archean. 

   more » « less