skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Explore Research Products in the PAR
It may take a few hours for recently added research products to appear in PAR search results.


  • NSF Public Access
  • Search Results
  • A meta inspiral–merger–ringdown consistency test of general relativity with gravitational wave signals from compact binaries
Title: A meta inspiral–merger–ringdown consistency test of general relativity with gravitational wave signals from compact binaries
Abstract The observation of gravitational waves from compact binary coalescences is a promising tool to test the validity of general relativity (GR) in a highly dynamical strong-field regime. There are now a variety of tests of GR performed on the observed compact binary signals. In this paper, we propose a new test of GR that compares the results of these individual tests. This meta inspiral–merger–ringdown consistency test (IMRCT) involves inferring the final mass and spin of the remnant black hole obtained from the analyses of two different tests of GR and checking for consistency. If there is a deviation from GR, we expect that different tests of GR will recover different values for the final mass and spin, in general. We check the performance of the meta IMRCT using a standard set of null tests used in various gravitational-wave analyses: the original IMRCT, the test infrastructure for GR, the flexible-theory-independent test, and the modified dispersion test. However, the meta IMRCT is applicable to any tests of GR that infer the initial masses and spins or the final mass and spin, including ones that are applied to binary neutron star or neutron star–black hole signals. We apply the meta IMRCT to simulated quasi-circular GR and non-GR binary black hole (BBH) signals as well as to eccentric BBH signals in GR (analysed with quasicircular waveforms). We find that the meta IMRCT gives consistency with GR for the quasi-circular GR signals and picks up a deviation from GR in the other cases, as do other tests. In some cases, the meta IMRCT finds a significant GR deviation for a given pair of tests (and specific testing parameters) while the individual tests do not, showing that it is more sensitive than the individual tests to certain types of deviations. In addition, we also apply this test to a few selected real compact binary signals and find them consistent with GR.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2205920 2308887
PAR ID:
10631671
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
Classical and Quantum Gravity
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Classical and Quantum Gravity
Volume:
42
Issue:
16
ISSN:
0264-9381
Page Range / eLocation ID:
165011
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. ; ; ; (, Classical and Quantum Gravity)
    Abstract Recent gravitational wave (GW) observations include possible detections of black hole—neutron star binary mergers. As with binary black hole mergers, numerical simulations help characterize the sources. For binary systems with neutron star components, the simulations help to predict the imprint of tidal deformations and disruptions on the GW signals. In a previous study, we investigated how the mass of the black hole has an impact on the disruption of the neutron star and, as a consequence, on the shape of the GWs emitted. We extend these results to study the effects of varying the compactness of the neutron star. We consider neutron star compactness in the 0.113–0.2 range for binaries with mass ratios of 3 and 5. As the compactness and the mass ratio increase, the binary system behaves during the late inspiral and merger more like a black hole binary. For the cases with the least compact neutron star, the GWs emitted, in terms of mismatches, are the most distinguishable from those by a binary black hole. The disruption of the star significantly suppresses the kicks on the final black hole. The disruption also affects, although not dramatically, the spin of the final black hole. Lastly, for neutron stars with low compactness, the quasi-normal ringing of the black hole after the merger does not show a clean quasi-normal ringing because of the late accretion of debris from the neutron star. 
    more » « less
  2. ; ; (, Physical Review D)
    Detections of gravitational waves emitted from binary black hole coalescences allow us to probe the strong-field dynamics of general relativity (GR). One can compare the observed gravitational-wave signals with theoretical waveform models to constrain possible deviations from GR. Any physics that is not included in these waveform models might show up as apparent GR deviations. The waveform models used in current tests of GR describe binaries on quasicircular orbits, since most of the binaries detected by ground-based gravitational-wave detectors are expected to have negligible eccentricities. Thus, a signal from an eccentric binary in GR is likely to show up as a deviation from GR in the current implementation of these tests. We study the response of four standard tests of GR to eccentric binary black hole signals with the forecast O4 sensitivity of the LIGO-Virgo network. Specifically, we consider two parametrized tests (TIGER and FTI), the modified dispersion relation test, and the inspiral-merger-ringdown consistency test. To model eccentric signals, we use nonspinning numerical relativity simulations from the SXS catalog with three mass ratios (1, 2, 3), which we scale to a redshifted total mass of 80M⊙ and luminosity distance of 400 Mpc. For each of these mass ratios, we consider signals with eccentricities of ∼0.05 and ∼0.1 at 17 Hz. We find that signals with larger eccentricity lead to very significant false GR deviations in most tests while signals having smaller eccentricity lead to significant deviations in some tests. For the larger eccentricity cases, one would even get a deviation from GR with TIGER at ∼90% credibility at a distance of ≳1.5 Gpc. Thus, it will be necessary to exclude the possibility of an eccentric binary in order to make any claim about detecting a deviation from GR. 
    more » « less
  3. (, Zenodo)
    This dataset contains the compact binary populations that were used in the Cosmic Explorer MPSAC White paper1 (submitted to the NSF MPSAC ngGW Subcommittee) and the accompanying technical paper2. Contents: 1. 1-year populations for binary black hole (BBH), binary neutron star (BNS), neutron star-black hole (NSBH), intermediate mass binary black hole (IMBBH), Population III (Pop 3) binary black holes and primordial black hole (PBH) mergers. It also contains the SNRs and measurement errors on intrinsic and extrinsic parameters calculated using gwbench3. 2. 1/4-year sub-population of BNS mergers for which errors on tidal parameters were calculated. 3. An ipython notebook (instructions.ipynb) that shows how the data can be used. References: 1. Evans, Matthew et al. Cosmic Explorer: A Submission to the NSF MPSAC ngGW Subcommittee (2023). arXiv: 2306.13745 [gr-qc]. 2. Gupta, Ish et al. Characterizing Gravitational Wave Detector Networks: From A# to Cosmic Explorer (2023). In preparation. 3. Borhanian, Ssohrab. GWBENCH: a novel Fisher information package for gravitational-wave benchmarking. Class. Quant. Grav. 38, 175014 (2021). arXiv: 2010.15202 [gr-qc]. 
    more » « less
  4. ; ; ; (, Physical Review D)
    The inspiral-merger-ringdown (IMR) consistency test checks the consistency of the final mass and final spin of a binary black hole merger remnant, independently inferred via the inspiral and merger-ringdown parts of the waveform. As binaries are expected to be nearly circularized when entering the frequency band of ground-based detectors, tests of general relativity (GR) currently employ quasicircular waveforms. We quantify the effect of residual orbital eccentricity on the IMR consistency test. We find that eccentricity causes a significant systematic bias in the inferred final mass and spin of the remnant black hole at an orbital eccentricity (defined at 10 Hz) of e0≳0.1 in the LIGO band (for a total binary mass in the range 65-200M⊙). For binary black holes observed by Cosmic Explorer (CE), the systematic bias becomes significant for e0≳0.015 (for 200-600M⊙ systems). This eccentricity-induced bias on the final mass and spin leads to an apparent inconsistency in the IMR consistency test, manifesting as a false violation of GR. Hence, eccentric corrections to waveform models are important for constructing a robust test of GR, especially for third-generation detectors. We also estimate the eccentric corrections to the relationship between the inspiral parameters and the final mass and final spin; they are shown to be quite small. 
    more » « less
  5. ; ; ; ; (, Physical Review D)
    Compact objects observed via gravitational waves are classified as black holes or neutron stars primarily based on their inferred mass with respect to stellar evolution expectations. However, astrophysical expectations for the lowest mass range, ≲1.2⁢𝑀⊙, are uncertain. If such low-mass compact objects exist, ground-based gravitational wave detectors may observe them in binary mergers. Lacking astrophysical expectations for classifying such observations, we go beyond the mass and explore the role of tidal effects. We evaluate how combined mass and tidal inference can inform whether each binary component is a black hole or a neutron star based on consistency with the supranuclear-density equation of state. Low-mass neutron stars experience a large tidal deformation; its observational identification (or lack thereof) can therefore aid in determining the nature of the binary components. Using simulated data, we find that the presence of a sub-solar mass neutron star (black hole) can be established with odds ∼100∶1 when two neutron stars (black holes) merge and emit gravitational waves at signal-to-noise ratio ∼20. For the same systems, the absence of a black hole (neutron star) can be established with odds ∼10∶1. For mixed neutron star-black hole binaries, we can establish that the system contains a neutron star with odds ≳5∶1. Establishing the presence of a black hole in mixed neutron star-black hole binaries is more challenging, except for the case of a ≲1⁢𝑀⊙ black hole with a ≳1⁢𝑀⊙ neutron star companion. On the other hand, classifying each individual binary component suffers from an inherent labeling ambiguity. 
    more » « less
  • Citation Formats
  • MLA
  • APA
  • Chicago
  • BibTeX
  • Text Encoded Conversion
  • XML
  • Save / Share this Record
  • Send to Email