Title: Revisiting the Early Late Cretaceous Equable Climate Problem Through a Model‐Data Perspective
Abstract Early Late Cretaceous (∼90–100 Ma) Sea surface temperatures (SST) records suggest extremely warm Southern Hemisphere high latitudes and a meridional gradient as low as 5°C, attributed to elevated atmospheric CO2. Climate models have been unable to reproduce such extreme warmth, questioning model performance and/or the validity of SSTs reconstructions. Indeed, the latter partly rely on the measurement of oxygen isotopic composition of marine organisms (δ18Oc), a proxy that requires knowledge of the δ18O of past seawater (δ18Osw). Here we use the water isotope‐enabled Community Earth System Model (iCESM1.2) to investigate how paleogeography and pCO2affect δ18Oswdistribution and our understanding of Cenomanian‐Turonian SSTs. Our simulations suggest that the semi‐isolation of southern South Atlantic‐Indian Ocean resulted in locally very negative δ18Oswexplaining low δ18Ocmeasured on planktonic foraminifera. Accounting for this δ18Oswspatio‐temporal variability increases the estimated meridional temperature gradient by 5°C and narrows the gap between model and proxy‐based reconstructions.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2309580
PAR ID:
10642285
Author(s) / Creator(s):
 ;  ;  
Publisher / Repository:
AGU Publications
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Paleoceanography and Paleoclimatology
Volume:
40
Issue:
4
ISSN:
2572-4517
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract Stable isotope‐based reconstructions of past ocean salinity and hydroclimate depend on accurate, regionally constrained relationships between the stable oxygen isotopic composition of seawater (δ18Osw) and salinity in the surface ocean. An increasing number of δ18Oswobservations suggest greater spatial variability in this relationship than previously considered, highlighting the need to reassess these relationships on a global scale. Here, we use available, paired δ18Oswand salinity data (N = 11,119) to create global interpolations of each variable. We then use a self‐organizing map, a specialized form of machine learning, to define 19 regions with unique δ18Osw‐salinity relationships in the surface (<50 m) ocean. Inclusion of atmospheric moisture‐related variables and oceanic tracer data in additional self‐organizing map experiments indicates global surface δ18Osw‐salinity spatial patterns are strongly forced by the atmosphere, as the SOM spatial output is highly similar despite no overlapping input data. Our approach is a useful update to the previously delimited regions, and highlights the utility of neural network pattern extraction in spatiotemporally sparse data sets. 
    more » « less
  2. Abstract The carbon isotopic composition of pedogenic carbonate (δ13Cc) is a widely used proxy for paleoatmospheric CO2levels. However, the estimated CO2is often highly uncertain due to the lack of constraints on other variables that influence this system. To improve paleosol‐based CO2reconstructions, here we propose the Joint Proxy Inversion (JPI) of a paleosol‐based proxy system model, which integrates various proxies (e.g., pedogenic carbonate δ13C and δ18O) that share sensitivities to common environmental parameters (e.g., CO2, precipitation) via a forward proxy model in a Bayesian hierarchical framework. JPI generates self‐consistent posterior distributions of environmental parameters conditioned on multi‐proxy data sets while accounting for proxy and model uncertainties. The JPI was applied to data from Quaternary loess deposits from the Chinese Loess Plateau to test its performance. Sensitivity tests and posterior CO2estimates suggest insensitivity of proxy values to CO2when the analysis integrates δ13C, δ18Oc, and clumped isotope values of pedogenic carbonates only. Improved results were achieved after incorporating a precipitation‐sensitive proxy, a model component representing environmental variation as a function of time, and a parameterized relationship between global temperature and CO2. The improved model performance is indicated by agreement between posteriors of environmental parameters (i.e., CO2, temperature, precipitation) and other independent records. Compared to the traditional proxy interpretation approach, the paleosol‐JPI offers a more holistic and rigorous way to interpret multi‐proxy records with shared environmental sensitivities, provides additional information on climate and environmental systems, and is capable of reconstructing paleo‐CO2levels with higher precision and fidelity. 
    more » « less
  3. Abstract Tropical Pacific seawater and precipitation stable oxygen isotope data aid in understanding modern oceanic and atmospheric interactions, and these data are particularly valuable as they are archived in isotope‐based paleoclimate records. However, the absence of modern seawater isotope time series limits the ability to identify the atmospheric influences on these data, precluding robust paleoclimate interpretations. We present a new 10 year sub‐monthly record of seawater and precipitation stable oxygen isotope values (δ18Oswand δ18Op) from Koror, Palau. Our dataset indicates that temporally, δ18Oswis strongly influenced by local δ18Op.Both monthly δ18Oswand δ18Opare highly correlated with outgoing longwave radiation across the tropical Pacific, reflecting a Walker Circulation imprint on the surface ocean. Changes in the Palau δ18Osw—salinity relationship correspond to NINO3.4 variability, indicating a difference in how these variables record El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO) information, but demonstrating the utility of δ18Oswto reconstruct ENSO variability in the western tropical Pacific. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract The Paleocene‐Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM, ∼56 million years ago) is among the best‐studied climatic warming events in Earth history and is often compared to projected anthropogenic climate change. The PETM is characterized by a rapid negative carbon isotope excursion and global temperature increase of 4–5°C, accompanied by changes in spatial patterns of evaporation and precipitation in the global hydrologic cycle. Recent climate model reconstructions suggest a regionally complex and non‐linear response of one important aspect of global hydrology: enhanced moisture flux from the low‐latitude ocean. In this study, we use the elemental and stable isotope geochemistry of surface‐dwelling planktic foraminifera from a low‐latitude Atlantic deep‐sea sedimentary record (IODP Site 1258) to quantify changes in sea‐surface temperature (SST) and salinity. Foraminiferal Mg/Ca and δ18O values are interpreted with a Bayesian forward proxy system model to reconstruct how SST and salinity changed over the PETM at this site. These temperature and salinity reconstructions are then compared to recent climate model simulations of Eocene warming. Our reconstructions indicate °C of warming, in excellent agreement with estimates from other tropical locations and modeled PETM warmth. The regional change in salinity is not as straightforward, demonstrating a slight decrease at extremepCO2forcing (a reversal of the modeled sense of change under moderatepCO2forcing) in both model and proxy reconstructions. The cause of this non‐linear response is unclear but may relate to increased South American continental runoff or shifts in the Inter‐Tropical Convergence Zone. 
    more » « less
  5. Marine sediments, speleothems, paleo-lake elevations, and ice core methane and δ18O of O2 (δ18Oatm) records provide ample evidence for repeated abrupt meridional shifts in tropical rainfall belts throughout the last glacial cycle. To improve understanding of the impact of abrupt events on the global terrestrial biosphere, we present composite records of δ18Oatm and inferred changes in fractionation by the global terrestrial biosphere (ΔεLAND) from discrete gas measurements in the WAIS Divide (WD) and Siple Dome (SD) Antarctic ice cores. On the common WD timescale, it is evident that maxima in ΔεLAND are synchronous with or shortly follow small-amplitude WD CH4 peaks that occur within Heinrich stadials 1, 2, 4, and 5 – periods of low atmospheric CH4 concentrations. These local CH4 maxima have been suggested as markers of abrupt climate responses to Heinrich events. Based on our analysis of the modern seasonal cycle of gross primary productivity (GPP)-weighted δ18O of terrestrial precipitation (the source water for atmospheric O2 production), we propose a simple mechanism by which ΔεLAND tracks the centroid latitude of terrestrial oxygen production. As intense rainfall and oxygen production migrate northward, ΔεLAND should decrease due to the underlying meridional gradient in rainfall δ18O. A southward shift should increase ΔεLAND. Monsoon intensity also influences δ18O of precipitation, and although we cannot determine the relative contributions of the two mechanisms, both act in the same direction. Therefore, we suggest that abrupt increases in ΔεLAND unambiguously imply a southward shift of tropical rainfall. The exact magnitude of this shift, however, remains under-constrained by ΔεLAND. 
    more » « less