An official website of the United States government
Abstract PremiseEvolutionary theory predicts polymorphism should be rare; however, intraspecific variation in floral color is common and can be attributed to genetic drift, plasticity, or variable selection. Examining floral color polymorphism both within contact zones and across a species' range can reveal the mechanisms maintaining this variation. Here, we used a multistep approach to investigate spatially heterogeneous variation in floral bract color inCastilleja coccinea. MethodsWe compared frequencies of color morphs, floral morphology, fitness, and genetic structure in regional populations and in a common garden. Next, we examined habitat differences, including edaphic factors, as potential drivers of variation. Lastly, we leveraged herbarium and iNaturalist occurrence data to investigate whether patterns were consistent at the landscape scale. ResultsBract color inC. coccineais genetically heritable, with yellow dominant over red, and is under selection. Populations are predominantly monomorphic, with color distance showing no correlation to genetic or geographic distance, despite significant genetic isolation by distance. Yellow morphs were associated with open wetlands, while red morphs occurred at drier sites with nearby tree cover. Red morphs demonstrated lower fitness in a common garden, suggesting trade‐offs associated with pleiotropic effects of floral color. ConclusionsDifferences in floral color between morphs are consistent with diversification associated with a shift in ecological niche. We identified variation in edaphic and habitat conditions as probable drivers of divergence in floral color. Additionally, variation in other floral traits suggests a combined role of pollinators and habitat differences acting in concert to maintain distinct floral color morphs.
more »
« less
This content will become publicly available on January 1, 2027
The genetics, evolution, and maintenance of a biological rock-paper-scissors game
Side-blotched lizards (Uta stansburiana) play a biological rock-paper-scissors game in which three differently colored male morphs utilize alternative mating strategies. We identified the genetic basis of this polymorphism, which was previously posited to arise from three alleles at one locus. Orange usurper and blue mate-guarder morphs are associated with two divergent haplotypes in the regulatory region of the sepiapterin reductase gene, but yellow sneaker morphs appear to arise through phenotypic plasticity from the same genetic background as blue morphs. Our simulations show that rock-paper-scissors dynamics can better maintain a polymorphism with a genetic system of two alleles plus plasticity than with a three-allele system. This form of balancing selection that combines genetic determination with phenotypic plasticity expands the possibilities for how stable polymorphisms arise in nature.
more »
« less
- PAR ID:
- 10664691
- Publisher / Repository:
- American Association for the Advancement of Science
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Science
- Volume:
- 391
- Issue:
- 6780
- ISSN:
- 0036-8075
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 69 to 74
- Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
- Color polymorphism genomics game theory mating system alternative mating strategies
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
ABSTRACT Male alternative reproductive tactics are taxonomically widespread, with many species showing males with distinctly different phenotypic characters such as body size or weaponry. Several mechanisms can drive the expression of these male morphs, including genetic polymorphism or environmental interactions during development. In insects, multiple male morphs are common in several orders, including Coleoptera, Odonata, and Hymenoptera, but are rare in Orthoptera. This study establishes the presence of two male phenotypic morphs in the bush cricketSatizabalus jorgevargasi, a species in which the males display mandibular weaponry, and tests the effects of diet on the expression of male dimorphic characters. Male nymphs were raised under standard conditions until adulthood, whereupon morphological measurements were taken. Males raised under standard conditions showed two male phenotypes on the basis of head size and body colouration—a major morph with larger heads and more colouration, and a smaller and duller minor morph. A second group of male nymphs were housed individually and fed either a high‐protein diet or a high‐carbohydrate diet. Body weight and pronotum length were measured on a weekly basis as the nymphs developed, and once the males had matured, morphological and bioacoustic characters were measured. Diet had a significant impact on these male dimorphic characters, with protein‐fed males having significantly larger heads and mandibles. Additionally, males reared on the high‐protein diet had significantly more regions with colour when compared to carbohydrate‐fed males. Our data parallel that seen in other invertebrate groups, where higher levels of protein during maturation are key to the production of larger male morphs.more » « less
-
Many organisms facultatively produce different phenotypes depending on their environment, yet relatively little is known about the genetic bases of such plasticity in natural populations. In this study, we describe the genetic variation underlying an extreme form of plasticity––resource polyphenism––in Mexican spadefoot toad tadpoles, Spea multiplicata. Depending on their environment, these tadpoles develop into one of two drastically different forms: a carnivore morph or an omnivore morph. We collected both morphs from two ponds that differed in which morph had an adaptive advantage and performed genome-wide association studies of phenotype (carnivore vs. omnivore) and adaptive plasticity (adaptive vs. maladaptive environmental assessment). We identified four quantitative trait loci associated with phenotype and nine with adaptive plasticity, two of which exhibited signatures of minor allele dominance and two of which (one phenotype locus and one adaptive plasticity locus) did not occur as minor allele homozygotes. Investigations into the genetics of plastic traits in natural populations promise to provide novel insights into how such complex, adaptive traits arise and evolve.more » « less
-
Abstract Two decades of widespread drought-induced forest mortality events on every forested continent have raised the specter of future unpredictable, rapid ecosystem changes in 21stcentury forests. Yet our ability to predict drought stress, much less drought-induced mortality across the landscape remains limited. This uncertainty stems at least in part from an incomplete understanding of within-species variation in hydraulic physiology, which reflects the interaction of genetic differentiation among populations (ecotypic variation) and phenotypic plasticity in response to growth environment. We examined among-population genetic differentiation in a number of morphological and hydraulic traits in California blue oak (Quercus douglasii) using a 30 year old common garden. We then compared this genetic trait differentiation and trait-trait integration to wild phenotypes in the field from the original source populations. We found remarkably limited among-population genetic differentiation in all traits in the common garden, but considerable site-to-site variation in the field. However, it was difficult to explain trait variation in the field using site climate variables, suggesting that gridded climate data does not capture the drivers of plasticity in drought physiology in this species. Trait-trait relationships were also considerably stronger in the field than in the garden, particularly links between leaf morphology, leaf hydraulic efficiency and stem hydraulic efficiency. Indeed, while twelve of 45 potential trait-trait relationships showed significant wild phenotypic correlations, only four relationships showed both genetic and phenotypic correlations, and five relationships showed significantly different genetic and phenotypic correlations. Collectively, our results demonstrate limited ecotypic variation in drought-related physiology but considerable geographic variation in physiology and phenotypic integration in the wild, both driven largely by plasticity.more » « less
-
TBD (Ed.)ABSTRACT Natural selection shapes traits during evolution including animal coloration known to be important for concealment and communication and color has been particularly salient in the explosive radiation of cichlid fish species in the rift valley lakes of East Africa. Though selection can produce variation in color via genetic substrates during early development, plasticity in coloration can occur through endocrine, neural and transcriptional cues in response to various environmental stimuli. It is well known that some animals often change color to match their visual ecology. Adult male cichlid fish (Astatotilapia burtoni, Lake Tanganyika) can switch between blue and yellow body colors. Different colors result from the expression of pigment-bearing cells, which differ in density and function between these two color morphs. We show thatA. burtoniswitches from yellow to blue depending on their visual environment by downregulating endothelin receptor B (EdnRB) mRNA via DNA hypermethylation at a single cytosine residue within its promoter. EdnRB functions in yellow chromatophores to signal the aggregation of yellow pigments, making yellow less visible. Taken together, the regulation ofEdnRBthrough DNA methylation in yellow chromatophores, in part, contributes to pigmentation changes from blue to yellow, depending on visual environment.more » « less
