skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.
Attention:The NSF Public Access Repository (NSF-PAR) system and access will be unavailable from 7:00 AM ET to 7:30 AM ET on Friday, April 24 due to maintenance. We apologize for the inconvenience.


Title: Evaluating uncertainty in North American plate-tectonic reconstructions from lower-mantle slabs
ABSTRACT Tomographic images hold key constraints for North American Cordillera plate-tectonic histories, but models that prioritize surface geology (i.e., top-down) or mantle tomographic slabs (i.e., bottom-up) show disparate conclusions. Here, we highlight five key questions regarding assumptions and uncertainties for building North American Cordillera plate reconstructions from tomography: (1) Which seismic anomalies under North America should be interpreted as subducted slabs? (2) How should paleo–subduction zone absolute locations be determined from mantle constraints? (3) How should paleo–subduction zone polarities be determined from tomography? (4) How should slab constraints be integrated into absolute plate motion models? (5) How do inferences from lower-mantle slabs compare to surface geologic remnants of accreted terranes along western North America? The lower mantle under North America shows five main slab-like, faster-than-average seismic anomalies; of these, four anomalies are generally interpreted as subducted slabs, and the other anomaly is possibly a geophysical artifact. Comparison of interpreted subducted slabs from published tomography shows the interpreted slabs generally occupy similar mantle locations, but slab dips may be highly variable between tomographic data sets. Thus, caution is needed when inferring paleo–subduction zone polarity or absolute locations directly from slab dips. Absolute plate motion models of areas offshore western North America during the Jurassic–Cretaceous imply a relatively fast, northeast-moving Farallon oceanic plate that precludes a stationary, long-lived (>40 m.y.), west-dipping intra-oceanic subduction zone. However, long-lived east-dipping or bivergent (east- and west-dipping) intra-oceanic subduction zones are permissible. Alternative conclusions about North American Cordillera paleo–subduction zone polarities and terrane-slab correlations stem from slab reconstruction approaches based on “vertical slab sinking” and “nonvertical slab sinking” hypotheses; future tests of these hypotheses will improve our understanding of Earth’s mantle and its convective processes.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2422671 1848327
PAR ID:
10668893
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ;
Publisher / Repository:
Geological Society of America
Date Published:
Page Range / eLocation ID:
57 to 79
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. ABSTRACT The North American Cordillera is an archetypal terrane collage formed by collisional tectonics, yet a margin-wide plate-tectonic reconstruction that unifies surface geology with the subducted oceanic lithosphere observed in Earth’s mantle by tomographic imaging does not exist. Surface geology–based regional tectonic models are not easily reconciled with each other or existing mantle-based reconstructions, which demand broad reinterpretation of robust geologic observations. Here, we applied a novel workflow by structurally unfolding subducted Farallon lithosphere using mantle tomography to constrain the tectonic history of the North American Cordillera. We reconstructed long-lived, east-dipping subduction below North America and an east-dipping intra-oceanic subduction zone above the offshore Insular superterrane prior to Late Cretaceous time (100–80 Ma). We propose recognition of a “Bridge River” oceanic plate that subducted eastward below western North America prior to Late Cretaceous time. We implemented our slab unfolding–derived plate reconstructions into tomographically filtered mantle convection forward models and found that Late Cretaceous Insular superterrane–North America collision reproduces observed mantle structure, whereas models involving Jurassic Insular superterrane collision do not. We compared our reconstructions against independent upper-plate constraints such as a new restoration of Cordilleran strike-slip faults, surface geology, and Insular superterrane paleomagnetic data and found reasonable correspondence. Insular superterrane collision and northward translation in our reconstructions coincide with transpressional shear zones in southern California through SE Alaska. Our results suggest that westward lateral slab movement after subduction below North America played a crucial role in mantle dynamics that potentially reconciles the geologic record with the deep mantle. 
    more » « less
  2. H Thybo (Ed.)
    The link between surface tectonic plates and mantle slabs is fundamental for paleo-tectonic reconstructions and for our understanding of mantle dynamics. Many seismic tomography-based studies have assumed vertical slab sinking and projected mantle features to the surface to reconstruct paleo-trench locations or explain tectonic features. Here, we used a slab-unfolding approach that does not require assumptions about sinking paths or rates to re-interpret the seismic structure of the Lesser Antilles slab underneath the Caribbean. A recent study invoked mainly vertical slab sinking and a highly folded and deformed slab to explain seismic Caribbean mantle structures. However, our results show that the upper-mantle Lesser Antilles slab structure can be better explained by limited intra-slab deformation and up to ~900 km lateral slab transport towards the northwest after subduction. Our results indicate that such lateral slab transport can occur even with probable weaknesses in the slab that originate from a subducted fossil ridge-transform system. We ascribe the lateral slab transport in the mantle to a kinematic connection with the North American plate, which has migrated northwestward since the Eocene. 
    more » « less
  3. null (Ed.)
    The configuration of mid-ocean ridges subducted below North America prior to Oligocene time is unconstrained by seafloor isochrons and has been primarily inferred from upper-plate geology, including near-trench magmatism. However, many tectonic models are permitted from these constraints. We present a fully kinematic, plate tectonic reconstruction of the NW Cordillera since 60 Ma built by structurally unfolding subducted slabs, imaged by mantle tomography, back to Earth’s surface. We map in three-dimensions the attached Alaska and Cascadia slabs, and a detached slab below western Yukon (Canada) at 400−600 km depth that we call the “Yukon Slab.” Our restoration of these lower plates within a global plate model indicates the Alaska slab accounts for Pacific-Kula subduction since ca. 60 Ma below the Aleutian Islands whereas the Cascadia slab accounts for Farallon subduction since at least ca. 75 Ma below southern California, USA. However, intermediate areas show two reconstruction gaps that persist until 40 Ma. We show that these reconstruction gaps correlate spatiotemporally to published NW Cordillera near-trench magmatism, even considering possible terrane translation. We attribute these gaps to thermal erosion related to ridge subduction and model mid-ocean ridges within these reconstruction gap mid-points. Our reconstructions show two coeval ridge-trench intersections that bound an additional “Resurrection”-like plate along the NW Cordillera prior to 40 Ma. In this model, the Yukon slab represents a thermally eroded remnant of the Resurrection plate. Our reconstructions support a “northern option” Farallon ridge geometry and allow up to ∼1200 km Chugach terrane translation since Paleocene time, providing a new “tomographic piercing point” for the Baja-British Columbia debate. 
    more » « less
  4. A typical subduction of an oceanic plate beneath a continent is expected to be accompanied by arc volcanoes along the convergent margin. However, subduction of the Cocos plate at the Middle American subduction system has resulted in an uneven distribution of magmatism/volcanism along strike. Here we construct a new three-dimensional shear-wave velocity model of the entire Middle American subduction system, using full-wave ambient noise tomography. Our model reveals significant variations of the oceanic plates along strike and down dip, in correspondence with either weakened or broken slabs after subduction. The northern and southern segments of the Cocos plate, including the Mexican flat slab subduction, are well imaged as high-velocity features, where a low-velocity mantle wedge exists and demonstrate a strong correlation with the arc volcanoes. Subduction of the central Cocos plate encounters a thick high-velocity feature beneath North America, which hinders the formation of a typical low-velocity mantle wedge and arc volcanoes. We suggest that the presence of slab tearing at both edges of the Mexican flat slab has been modifying the mantle flows, resulting in the unusual arc volcanism. 
    more » « less
  5. Mantle slabs imaged by seismic tomography provide complementary subsurface information that could improve global plate reconstructions because they are indications of ancient tectonic plates. Linking mantle slabs to the surface plates requires approaches that follow geodynamic principles in a highly vigorous mantle. Here, we propose a new workflow that couples a slab unfolding approach and a mantle circulation model (MCM) through which tomotectonic reconstructions can be performed, evaluated and improved in a closed-loop experiment. We publish the most recent version of our unfolded-slab constrained, geodynamically self-consistent plate reconstruction, Tomopac2, in which comprehensive intra-oceanic subductions within the Pacific-Panthalassa realms are implemented. These intra-oceanic subductions are crucial for understanding the evolution of the mantle and surface tectonics in the central Pacific, western North America and East Asia since the Mesozoic. Our model also incorporates subduction along western South America. Our closed-loop experiment allows us to reinterpret published tomotectonic reconstructions based on the vertical sinking slabs hypothesis. We conclude that highly vigorous mantle flow that allows lateral slab transport up to 4000 km and non-constant sinking rates that deviate by up to 10 mm yr 1 locally within an approximately 1000  km area must be accounted for in tomotectonic reconstructions. 
    more » « less