ABSTRACT Theory and observations reveal that the circumgalactic medium (CGM) and the cosmic web at high redshifts are multiphase, with small clouds of cold gas embedded in a hot, diffuse medium. We study the ‘shattering’ of large, thermally unstable clouds into tiny cloudlets of size $$\ell _{\rm shatter}\sim {\rm min}(c_{\rm s}t_{\rm cool})$$ using idealized numerical simulations. We expand upon previous works by exploring the effects of cloud geometry (spheres, streams, and sheets), metallicity, and an ionizing ultraviolet background. We find that ‘shattering’ is mainly triggered by clouds losing sonic contact and rapidly imploding, leading to a reflected shock that causes the cloud to re-expand and induces Richtmyer–Meshkov instabilities at its interface. The fragmented cloudlets experience a drag force from the surrounding hot gas, leading to recoagulation into larger clouds. We distinguish between ‘fast’ and ‘slow’ coagulation regimes. Sheets are always in the ‘fast’ coagulation regime, while streams and spheres transition to ‘slow’ coagulation above a critical overdensity, which is smallest for spheres. Surprisingly, $$\ell _\mathrm{shatter}$$ does not appear to be a characteristic clump size even if it is well resolved. Rather, fragmentation continues until the grid scale with a mass distribution of $$N(\gt m)\propto m^{-1}$$. We apply our results to cold streams feeding massive ($$M_{\rm v}\lower.5ex\rm{\,\, \buildrel\gt \over \sim \,\,}10^{12}\, {\rm M}_\odot$$) galaxies at $$z\lower.5ex\rm{\,\, \buildrel\gt \over \sim \,\,}2$$ from the cosmic web, finding that streams likely shatter upon entering the hot CGM through the virial shock. This could explain the large clumping factors and covering fractions of cold gas around such galaxies, and may be related to galaxy quenching by preventing cold streams from reaching the central galaxy.
more »
« less
This content will become publicly available on November 24, 2026
Eppur Si Muove : self-sustained streaming motions in multiphase MHD
ABSTRACT Radiative cooling can drive dynamics in multiphase gas. A dramatic example is hydrodynamic ‘shattering’, the violent pressure-driven fragmentation of a cooling cloud that falls drastically out of pressure balance with its surroundings. We run magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulations to understand how shattering is influenced by magnetic fields. In MHD, clouds do not ‘shatter’ chaotically. Instead, after initial fragmentation, both hot and cold phases coherently ‘stream’ in long-lived field-aligned self-sustaining gas flows, at high speed ($$\sim 100 \, {\rm km \, s^{-1}}$$). MHD thermal instability also produces such flows. They are due to the anisotropic nature of MHD pressure support, which only operates perpendicular to B-fields. Thus, even when $$P_{\rm B} + P_{\rm gas} \approx$$const, pressure balance only holds perpendicular to B-fields. Field-aligned gas pressure variations are unopposed, and results in gas velocities $$v \sim (2 \Delta P/\rho)^{1/2}$$ from Bernoulli’s principle. Strikingly, gas in adjacent flux tubes counter-stream in opposite directions. We show this arises from a cooling-induced MHD version of the thin shell instability. Magnetic tension is important both in enabling corrugational instability and modifying its non-linear evolution. Even in high $$\beta$$ hot gas, streaming can arise, since magnetic pressure support grows as gas cools and compresses. Thermal conduction increases the sizes and velocities of streaming cloudlets, but does not qualitatively modify dynamics. These results are relevant to the counter-streaming gas flows observed in solar coronal rain, as well as multiphase gas cooling and condensation in the interstellar medium, circumgalactic medium, and intracluster medium.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2407521
- PAR ID:
- 10678458
- Publisher / Repository:
- MNRAS
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
- Volume:
- 544
- Issue:
- 4
- ISSN:
- 0035-8711
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 4119 to 4145
- Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
ABSTRACT The circumgalactic medium (CGM) in $$\gtrsim 10^{12}\ \mathrm{M}_{\odot }$$ haloes is dominated by a hot phase ($$T \gtrsim 10^{6}$$ K). While many models exist for the hot gas structure, there is as yet no consensus. We compare cooling flow models, in which the hot CGM flows inwards due to radiative cooling, to the CGM of $$\sim 10^{12}{\,\rm to\,}10^{13}\ \mathrm{M}_{\odot }$$ haloes in galaxy formation simulations from the Feedback in Realistic Environments (FIRE) project at $$z\sim 0$$. The simulations include realistic cosmological evolution and feedback from stars but neglect AGN feedback. At both mass scales, CGM inflows are typically dominated by the hot phase rather than by the ‘precipitation’ of cold gas. Despite being highly idealized, we find that cooling flows describe $$\sim 10^{13}\ \mathrm{M}_{\odot }$$ haloes very well, with median agreement in the density and temperature profiles of $$\sim 20{{\ \rm per\ cent}}$$ and $$\sim 10{{\ \rm per\ cent}}$$, respectively. This indicates that stellar feedback has little impact on CGM scales in those haloes. For $$\sim 10^{12}\ \mathrm{M}_{\odot }$$ haloes, the thermodynamic profiles are also accurately reproduced in the outer CGM. For some of these lower-mass haloes, cooling flows significantly overpredict the hot gas density in the inner CGM. This could be due to multidimensional angular momentum effects not well captured by our one-dimensional cooling flow models and/or to the larger cold gas fractions in these regions. Turbulence, which contributes $$\sim 10{\!-\!}40{{\ \rm per\ cent}}$$ of the total pressure, must be included to accurately reproduce the temperature profiles. Overall, cooling flows predict entropy profiles in better agreement with the FIRE simulations than other idealized models in the literature.more » « less
-
ABSTRACT Observed accretion rates onto the Milky Way and other local spirals fall short of that required to sustain star formation for cosmological timescales. A potential avenue for this unseen accretion is a rotating inflow in the volume-filling hot phase ($$\sim 10^6\, {\rm K}$$) of the circumgalactic medium (CGM), as suggested by some cosmological simulations. Using hydrodynamic simulations and a new analytic solution valid in the slow-rotation limit, we show that a hot inflow spins up as it approaches the galaxy, while remaining hot, subsonic, and quasi-spherical. Within the radius of angular momentum support ($$\sim 15\, {\rm kpc}$$ for the Milky Way) the hot flow flattens into a disc geometry and then cools from $$\sim 10^6$$ to $$\sim 10^4\, {\rm K}$$ at the disc–halo interface. Cooling affects all hot gas, rather than just a subset of individual gas clouds, implying that accretion via hot inflows does not rely on local thermal instability in contrast with ‘precipitation’ models for galaxy accretion. Prior to cooling and accretion the inflow completes ≈tcool/tff radians of rotation, where tcool/tff is the cooling time to free-fall time ratio in hot gas immediately outside the galaxy. The ratio tcool/tff may thus govern the development of turbulence and enhancement of magnetic fields in gas accreting onto low-redshift spirals. We show that if rotating hot inflows are common in Milky-Way-size disc galaxies, as predicted, then signatures of the expected hot gas rotation profile should be observable with X-ray telescopes and fast radio burst surveys.more » « less
-
Abstract We investigate how cosmic rays (CRs) affect thermal and hydrostatic stability of circumgalactic (CGM) gas, in simulations with both CR streaming and diffusion. Local thermal instability can be suppressed by CR-driven entropy mode propagation, in accordance with previous analytic work. However, there is only a narrow parameter regime where this operates, before CRs overheat the background gas. As mass dropout from thermal instability causes the background density and hence plasma β ≡ Pg/PB to fall, the CGM becomes globally unstable. At the cool disk to hot halo interface, a sharp drop in density boosts Alfven speeds and CR gradients, driving a transition from diffusive to streaming transport. CR forces and heating strengthen, while countervailing gravitational forces and radiative cooling weaken, resulting in a loss of both hydrostatic and thermal equilibrium. In lower β halos, CR heating drives a hot, single-phase diffuse wind with velocities v∝(theat/tff)−1, which exceeds the escape velocity when theat/tff ≲ 0.4. In higher β halos, where the Alfven Mach number is higher, CR forces drive multi-phase winds with cool, dense fountain flows and significant turbulence. These flows are CR dominated due to ‘trapping’ of CRs by weak transverse B-fields, and have the highest mass loading factors. Thus, local thermal instability can result in winds or fountain flows where either the heat or momentum input of CRs dominates.more » « less
-
ABSTRACT We study the properties of cosmic-ray (CR) driven galactic winds from the warm interstellar medium using idealized spherically symmetric time-dependent simulations. The key ingredients in the model are radiative cooling and CR-streaming-mediated heating of the gas. Cooling and CR heating balance near the base of the wind, but this equilibrium is thermally unstable, leading to a multiphase wind with large fluctuations in density and temperature. In most of our simulations, the heating eventually overwhelms cooling, leading to a rapid increase in temperature and a thermally driven wind; the exception to this is in galaxies with the shallowest potentials, which produce nearly isothermal $$T \approx 10^4\,$$ K winds driven by CR pressure. Many of the time-averaged wind solutions found here have a remarkable critical point structure, with two critical points. Scaled to real galaxies, we find mass outflow rates $$\dot{M}$$ somewhat larger than the observed star-formation rate in low-mass galaxies, and an approximately ‘energy-like’ scaling $$\dot{M} \propto v_{\rm esc}^{-2}$$. The winds accelerate slowly and reach asymptotic wind speeds of only ∼0.4vesc. The total wind power is $$\sim 1~{{\ \rm per\ cent}}$$ of the power from supernovae, suggesting inefficient preventive CR feedback for the physical conditions modelled here. We predict significant spatially extended emission and absorption lines from 104–105.5 K gas; this may correspond to extraplanar diffuse ionized gas seen in star-forming galaxies.more » « less
An official website of the United States government
