This content will become publicly available on June 22, 2027

Title: Metacognitive development through structured reflection: A case study in Biological and Agricultural Engineering
Developing students’ metacognitive regulation and effective use of learning strategies is central to supporting adaptive learning in engineering education. This qualitative single-case study examined one undergraduate engineering student’s metacognitive regulation and use of learning strategies across four semesters that incorporated structured written reflection. The student’s 19 reflections were deductively coded at the element level of the three metacognitive regulation dimensions: Monitoring, Evaluating, and Planning. The students’ texts for each element were classified for level of detail (None, Vague, or Sufficiently Detailed), and each dimension assigned an overall proficiency level. In parallel, the student’s knowledge and use of learning strategies, as communicated through their reflections and pre-post surveys, were analyzed. Results indicated overall movement from Emerging toward Developing and, in some cases, Proficient engagement across the three dimensions, though growth was uneven across semesters. Improvements were most evident in elements that required concrete descriptions, while elements requiring abstract thinking remained more inconsistently articulated. The student’s level of detail was lowest for Planning. Across semesters, growth in knowledge of learning strategies reflected increased frequency of Consolidating-Surface and Acquiring-Deep strategies. These findings suggest that sustained instructional support plays a critical role in developing metacognitive regulation. Instructors should continue supporting students with clear feedback and instructions from the reflection activities, especially for elements that require sensemaking.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2235227
PAR ID:
10682869
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
Proceedings of the 133rd ASEE Annual Conference and Exposition
Date Published:
Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
reflection metacognition undergraduate biological engineering agricultural engineering
Location:
Charlotte, NC
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Self-regulation, a skillset involving taking charge of one’s own learning processes, is crucial for workplace success. Learners develop self-regulation skills through reflection where they recognize weaknesses and strengths by employing metacognitive strategies: planning, monitoring, and evaluating. Use of anchors assists learners’ engagement in reflection. The purpose of this work was to gain insight into students’ use of anchors when reflecting on their learning. The two research questions were: (1) To what extent do students link their self-evaluation and learning objective (LO) self-ratings to their reflections? and (2) What dimensions and level of metacognitive strategies do students use in their self-evaluation of and reflections on weekly problem-solving assignments? Data were upper-division engineering students’ anchors (self- evaluations, LO self-ratings) and reflection responses for one assignment. Self-evaluations and reflections were analyzed for the presence of references to LOs. The number of students who linked the anchors to their reflection were tabulated. Additionally, a revised a priori coding scheme was applied to students’ written work to determine type and level of metacognitive strategies employed. Few students linked both anchors to their reflections. Students employed low to medium levels of the metacognitive strategies in their self-evaluations and reflections, even when they linked their anchors and reflections. The evaluating strategy dominated in the self- evaluations, while planning and monitoring dominated in the reflections. Students have limited understanding of the use of anchors to guide their reflection responses. Students overall level of engagement in the metacognitive strategies indicates a need for formal instruction on reflection. 
    more » « less
  2. The world is constantly changing, and the practice of engineering, therefore, requires that professionals and students continuously learn and critically think to persist in solving complex societal problems. For students, this requirement calls for an ability to use appropriate strategies to acquire and apply new knowledge as needed. However, undergraduate engineering curricula rarely directly develop students’ ability to reflect - assess their skill/knowledge gaps and plan for their learning. In civil engineering core coursework, the use of theory-grounded reflection exercises that emphasize metacognitive regulation strategies (MRSs) may aid instructors in developing students’ reflexivity and ability to be self-directed learners. The purpose of this single-case design research study was to examine a student’s progression in their application of MRSs while engaged in structured reflections in four core courses in their civil engineering program. Data were collected between Fall 2023 and Fall 2025 at an R1 Midwestern US university. The participant used reflections to identify a difficulty encountered while completing an assignment, assess actions taken, and plan further actions to improve learning. Qualitative methods were used to analyze the participant's reflections for the use of MRSs. Results showed that the participant demonstrated increased ability to engage in multiple elements of MRSs. By increasing student’s abilities with MRSs, critical thinking skills may be improved and that will be useful for solving new and unfamiliar problems in the future. 
    more » « less
  3. Lifelong learning plays an important role in achieving success in one’s professional life. Engaging students in metacognition assists in the development of their lifelong learning abilities. Instructors can integrate reflection activities in their courses to provide multiple opportunities to students for metacognitive engagement. During reflection, students regulate their cognition by engaging themselves in three dimensions of metacognition: Planning, Monitoring, and Evaluating. Reflection is a complex process, and it takes time to reach the level of critical reflection. The purpose of the study was to investigate the change in students' level of engagement in three dimensions of metacognition when reflecting on the third and tenth-week assignments of the environmental engineering course. Data collection took place in the Fall of 2023 at a large Midwest University. Students’ responses to the assigned reflection prompts for each dimension were coded for their level of engagement in each element of the three dimensions using a revised prior coding scheme. Results showed that for both assignments, students' responses were mainly at the vague level for all elements of the three dimensions, indicating students' superficial engagement in the reflection activity. Recommendations for instructors are provided to improve students' understanding of the reflection activity and their level of engagement in the three dimensions of metacognition. 
    more » « less
  4. This Research-to-Practice work-in-progress (WIP) paper describes the development of an AI tool for grading and providing metacognition theory-aligned feedback on engineering students’ reflections. Students with strong reflection skills are better able to overcome learning difficulties in academic settings and task challenges in professional contexts. However, a key barrier to implementing reflection in core engineering courses is the knowledge and time required for instructors to provide high-quality, theory-aligned feedback. The goal of this work was to develop an AI tool that delivers instructor-like feedback aligned with best practices and explicitly targets the constructs of metacognitive regulation (i.e., Monitoring, Evaluating, Planning). An LLM-based AI tool for assessing students’ reflections on their engineering assignments was developed by training and fine-tuning a model using a dataset of informed-grader feedback on sample student reflections. Overall, this work seeks to understand the quantity and quality of feedback provided by the instructor versus the AI tool as well as students’ and instructors’ perceptions. Preliminary finds for the Monitoring construct are presented. Future work is outlined. 
    more » « less
  5. College students differ widely in their awareness and use of effective learning strategies, despite strong evidence linking such strategies to academic success. To address these differences in an engineering context, a semester-long metacognitive intervention was embedded in a chemical engineering Fluid Flow course. This intervention consisted of 10 structured written activities implemented over 16 weeks, each designed to promote core metacognitive processes: planning, monitoring, and evaluating. Students completed the Metacognitive Awareness Inventory (MAI) at the beginning and end of the semester to quantify metacognitive awareness and track change over the semester, completed a reflection on their MAI results and prior semester difficulty, engaged in exam-specific “exam preps” to plan and assess their study approaches, and completed “exam wrappers” to reflect on performance and identify areas for improvement. This study had two aims: (1) to evaluate the effectiveness of the intervention in the course, and (2) to examine associations between student engagement, student confidence, and course performance. Primary outcomes included course grades and changes in learning strategy use over time. Qualitative and quantitative findings indicated that sustained engagement in metacognitive activities was associated with improved student learning. Students who completed more activities earned higher course grades and increases in MAI across the semester were associated with stronger final grades. Total study hours were negatively related to exam performance, whereas spending a greater percentage of study time with peers was positively associated with performance, underscoring the importance of study quality over quantity. Student confidence in the course material remained stable across the semester and was not related to exam performance; however, students who perceived their prior semester as harder than expected performed worse on multiple exams and overall. These preliminary results suggest that structured, embedded metacognitive interventions can support metacognitive growth and are associated with improved academic performance in an undergraduate chemical engineering course, with within-semester increases in metacognitive awareness emerging as a key correlate of success. The approach offers a practical avenue for STEM instructors seeking to integrate metacognitive development into their curricula to better support student success. 
    more » « less