An official website of the United States government
Recently there has been significant interest in using machine learning to improve the accuracy of cardinality estimation. This work has focused on improving average estimation error, but not all estimates matter equally for downstream tasks like query optimization. Since learned models inevitably make mistakes, the goal should be to improve the estimates that make the biggest difference to an optimizer. We introduce a new loss function, Flow-Loss, for learning cardinality estimation models. Flow-Loss approximates the optimizer's cost model and search algorithm with analytical functions, which it uses to optimize explicitly for better query plans. At the heart of Flow-Loss is a reduction of query optimization to a flow routing problem on a certain "plan graph", in which different paths correspond to different query plans. To evaluate our approach, we introduce the Cardinality Estimation Benchmark (CEB) which contains the ground truth cardinalities for sub-plans of over 16 K queries from 21 templates with up to 15 joins. We show that across different architectures and databases, a model trained with Flow-Loss improves the plan costs and query runtimes despite having worse estimation accuracy than a model trained with Q-Error. When the test set queries closely match the training queries, models trained with both loss functions perform well. However, the Q-Error-trained model degrades significantly when evaluated on slightly different queries (e.g., similar but unseen query templates), while the Flow-Loss-trained model generalizes better to such situations, achieving 4 -- 8× better 99th percentile runtimes on unseen templates with the same model architecture and training data.
more »
« less
This content will become publicly available on July 1, 2027
BaCon: Efficient Batch Processing of Counting Queries
Counting queries are ubiquitous in database systems, particularly for driving internal system optimization. Learned models for cardinality estimation rely heavily on large-scale training data, yet generating such data by executing massive batches of counting queries is expensive. We propose BaCon, an efficient algorithm for batch evaluation of counting queries on top of a database system, without modifying its internals. BaCon integrates the idea of factorized databases with a workload-aware domain quantization strategy, allowing it to evaluate batches of counting queries using compact data structures rather than materializing massive join results. BaCon’s design is compatible with most database management system, and we have implemented it as a client-side application on PostgreSQL with a lightweight C-language UDF (user-defined function). This implementation delivers speedups between 2× and 178× over baselines and good performance across various workloads, making training and maintenance of learned cardinality estimation models significantly more practical.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2402823
- PAR ID:
- 10690364
- Publisher / Repository:
- VLDB Endowment
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Proceedings of the VLDB Endowment
- Volume:
- 19
- Issue:
- 9
- ISSN:
- 2150-8097
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Recent work has reemphasized the importance of cardinality estimates for query optimization. While new techniques have continuously improved in accuracy over time, they still generally allow for under-estimates which often lead optimizers to make overly optimistic decisions. This can be very costly for expensive queries. An alternative approach to estimation is cardinality bounding, also called pessimistic cardinality estimation, where the cardinality estimator provides guaranteed upper bounds of the true cardinality. By never underestimating, this approach allows the optimizer to avoid potentially inefficient plans. However, existing pessimistic cardinality estimators are not yet practical: they use very limited statistics on the data, and cannot handle predicates. In this paper, we introduce SafeBound, the first practical system for generating cardinality bounds. SafeBound builds on a recent theoretical work that uses degree sequences on join attributes to compute cardinality bounds, extends this framework with predicates, introduces a practical compression method for the degree sequences, and implements an efficient inference algorithm. Across four workloads, SafeBound achieves up to 80% lower end-to-end runtimes than PostgreSQL, and is on par or better than state of the art ML-based estimators and pessimistic cardinality estimators, by improving the runtime of the expensive queries. It also saves up to 500x in query planning time, and uses up to 6.8x less space compared to state of the art cardinality estimation methods.more » « less
-
Cardinality estimation is the problem of estimating the size of the output of a query, without actually evaluating the query. The cardinality estimator is a critical piece of a query optimizer, and is often the main culprit when the optimizer chooses a poor plan. This paper introduces LpBound, a pessimistic cardinality estimator for multi-join queries (acyclic or cyclic) with selection predicates and group-by clauses.LpBoundcomputes a guaranteed upper bound on the size of the query output using simple statistics on the input relations, consisting of ℓp-norms of degree sequences. The bound is the optimal solution of a linear program whose constraints encode data statistics and Shannon inequalities. We introduce two optimizations that exploit the structure of the query in order to speed up the estimation time and makeLpBoundpractical. We experimentally evaluateLpBoundagainst a range of traditional, pessimistic, and machine learning-based estimators on the JOB, STATS, and subgraph matching benchmarks. Our main finding is thatLpBoundcan be orders of magnitude more accurate than traditional estimators used in mainstream open-source and commercial database systems. Yet it has comparable low estimation time and space requirements. When injected the estimates ofLpBound, Postgres derives query plans at least as good as those derived using the true cardinalities.more » « less
-
Lehalle, Henri; Tijus, Charles (Ed.)The purpose of the present research was to evaluate two different theo- retical perspectives of cardinality and counting development. According to one perspective, the cardinality concept underlying meaningful 1-to- 1-counting (“How many...?”) provides the basis for the later develop- ment of a more advanced cardinality concept that underlies meaningful counting-out (“Give n...”). According to another, a single cardinality concept underlies the development of both meaningful 1-to-1 counting and counting out a specified number of items. Thirty preschoolers 38- to 51-months-olds were pretested. Seven children who were develop- mentally ready for cardinality training were individually trained and re- tested. Overall, the evidence of the pre- and post-testing was more consistent with stepwise cardinality and counting development. For example, some children constructed the basic cardinality concept and achieved meaningful counting without understanding the more advanced cardinality concept and achieving meaningful counting out.more » « less
-
Sketches are single-pass small-space data summaries that can quickly estimate the cardinality of join queries. However, sketches are not directly applicable to join queries with dynamic filter conditions --- where arbitrary selection predicate(s) are applied --- since a sketch is limited to a fixed selection. While multiple sketches for various selections can be used in combination, they each incur individual storage and maintenance costs. Alternatively, exact sketches can be built during runtime for every selection. To make this process scale, a high-degree of parallelism --- available in hardware accelerators such as GPUs --- is required. Therefore, sketch usage for cardinality estimation in query optimization is limited. Following recent work that applies transformers to cardinality estimation, we design a novel learning-based method to approximate the sketch of any arbitrary selection, enabling sketches for join queries with filter conditions. We train a transformer on each table to estimate the sketch of any subset of the table, i.e., any arbitrary selection. Transformers achieve this by learning the joint distribution amongst table attributes, which is equivalent to a multidimensional sketch. Subsequently, transformers can approximate any sketch, enabling sketches for join cardinality estimation. In turn, estimating joins via approximate sketches allows tables to be modeled individually and thus scales linearly with the number of tables. We evaluate the accuracy and efficacy of approximate sketches on queries with selection predicates consisting of conjunctions of point and range conditions. Approximate sketches achieve similar accuracy to exact sketches with at least one order of magnitude less overhead.more » « less
