Devising models that reliably recognize player goals is a key challenge in creating player-adaptive games. Player goal recognition is the task of automatically recognizing the intent of a player from a sequence of observed player actions in a game environment. In open-world digital games, players often undertake suboptimal and varied sequences of actions to achieve goals, and the high degree of freedom afforded to players makes it challenging to identify sequential patterns that lead toward specific goals. To address these issues, we present a player goal recognition framework that utilizes a fine-tuned T5 language model, which incorporates our novel attention mechanism called Temporal Contrary Attention (TCA). The T5 language model enables the framework to exploit correlations between observations through non-sequential self-attention within input sequences, while TCA enables the framework to learn to eliminate goal hypotheses by considering counterevidence within a temporal window. We evaluate our approach using game trace data collected from 144 players' interactions with an open-world educational game. Specifically, we investigate the predictive capacity of our approach to recognize player goals as well as player plans represented as abstract actions. Results show that our approach outperforms non-linguistic machine learning approaches as well as T5 without TCA. We discuss the implications of these findings for the design and development of player goal recognition models to create player-adaptive games.
more »
« less
This content will become publicly available on January 30, 2027
Exploring Player Archetypes in a Minecraft-Based Learning Environment
Games are recognized as valuable tools for learning and interest development. However, the association between behavioral player archetypes and these important outcomes is still underexplored. This study explores the relationship between learning, interest development, and player archetypes (Roamers, Explorers, and Scientists) identified within the WHIMC project, a game-based learning environment where students engage with scientifically accurate hypothetical astronomy scenarios in Minecraft. Grounded in human-computer interaction and player typologies frameworks, we analyze data from 57 participants across four summer camps using Ordered Network Analysis (ONA) and k-means clustering to identify player archetypes emerging from student actions. We then examine how these archetypes relate to learning outcomes and motivational factors. Statistical tests reveal significant differences in in-game actions across archetypes and correlations between player behaviors and learning outcomes. These findings contribute to the design of serious educational games by increasing understanding of how to optimize experiences and enhance science engagement for learners with differing playing styles.
more »
« less
- PAR ID:
- 10691494
- Publisher / Repository:
- Serious Games Society
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- International Journal of Serious Games
- ISSN:
- 2384-8766
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 19 to 40
- Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Abstract This study investigates student learning and interest within the context of a single-player, open-world game designed for microbiology inquiry. The game immerses players in the role of investigative scientists tasked with diagnosing a mysterious illness on a remote island. Ordered Network Analysis (ONA) was combined with clustering techniques to analyze in-game actions (i.e., interactions with non-playable characters, exploration, and utilization of in-game educational tools) allowing us to construct student archetypes based on the behavioral patterns of 122 middle schoolers. The analysis identified four distinct clusters of students with varying engagement patterns—two showing apparent patterns of engagement and two showing apparent patterns of disengagement. The study contributes insights into tailoring educational game designs to address disengaged or ineffective behaviors, enhancing the efficacy of game-based learning experiences.more » « less
-
Pandey, Sumali (Ed.)ABSTRACT Gamification has gained momentum in STEM education as a way to boost student engagement, motivation, and conceptual learning. A wide variety of games, from short in-class activities to long-format student-built projects, are used across disciplines. However, few studies have examined why different game formats succeed or fail across varying contexts. In this perspective piece, we examine how games have been used in higher education STEM classrooms and highlight key contrasts between game types, implementation goals, and learning outcomes. Building from this foundation, we explore the added value of combining game-based learning (GBL) with design-based learning (DBL), particularly through student-led game design. We suggest that student-led game design, which incorporates both GBL and DBL principles, provides instructors with a flexible way to align games with course content, promote systems thinking, and encourage collaboration. Student-led game design is also highly adaptable to online learning environments, offering a way to enhance community and communication, which are typically challenged in this instructional format. Overall, we found that gamification in STEM is most effective when instructors consider both the diversity of game structures and how these support specific learning outcomes. Student-led game design is a flexible, underused strategy that can engage and motivate college-level students across scientific disciplines.more » « less
-
Prior research has shown that digital games can enhance STEM education by providing learners with immersive and authentic scientific experiences. However, optimizing the learning outcomes of students engaged in game-based environments requires aligning the game design with diverse student needs. Therefore, an in-depth understanding of player behavior is crucial for identifying students who need additional support or modifications to the game design. This study applies an Ordered Network Analysis (ONA)—a specific kind of Epistemic Network Analysis (ENA)—to examine the game trace log data of student interactions, to gain insights into how learning gains relate to the different ways that students move through an open-ended virtual world for learning microbiology. Our findings reveal that differences between students with high and low learning gains are mediated by their prior knowledge. Specifically, level of prior knowledge is related to behaviors that resemble wheel-spinning, which warrant the development of future interventions. Results also have implications for discovery with modeling approaches and for enhancing in-game support for learners and improving game design.more » « less
-
rior research has shown that digital games can enhance STEM education by providing learners with immersive and authentic scientific experiences. However, optimizing the learning outcomes of students engaged in game-based environments requires aligning the game design with diverse student needs. Therefore, an in-depth understanding of player behavior is crucial for identifying students who need additional support or modifications to the game design. This study applies an Ordered Network Analysis (ONA)—a specific kind of Epistemic Network Analysis (ENA)—to examine the game trace log data of student interactions, to gain insights into how learning gains relate to the different ways that students move through an open-ended virtual world for learning microbiology. Our findings reveal that differences between students with high and low learning gains are mediated by their prior knowledge. Specifically, level of prior knowledge is related to behaviors that resemble wheel-spinning, which warrant the development of future interventions. Results also have implications for discovery with modeling approaches and for enhancing in-game support for learners and improving game design.more » « less
An official website of the United States government
