An official website of the United States government
Fire plays an important role in shaping forested ecosystems around the globe. Unlike many other fire-driven forest types, our understanding of pre-settlement fire behavior in quaking aspen (Populus tremuloides) systems is limited. To better understand the frequency and severity of fires in a putatively stable quaking aspen forest, a small, key watershed was selected for sediment coring to reconstruct fire history, vegetation change, and climatic variability. The study aim was to explore the fire–climate–vegetation linkages in an aspen-dominated catchment. For the past ~4000 years this basin has been dominated by quaking aspen but also subalpine fir (Abies lasiocarpa), and their relative composition has shifted inversely over this period. Large, stand-replacing fires occurred, on average, every ~178 years, with individual fire-free intervals ranging from 132 to 323 years. The occurrence of fire was not related to climatic conditions as characterized by either cool-season or warm-season moisture availability (drought proxies). Rather, fire occurrence was most strongly related to fuel accumulation associated with the predictable successional shift in species dominance from quaking aspen to subalpine fir. Unlike in climate-limited systems where managers have little control over fire occurrence due to climatic conditions (e.g., drought), fuel-limited systems are controlled from the bottom up, where the explicit reduction or redistribution of long-term fuel buildup is an effective approach to reducing the likelihood and/or effects of fire in the short-term.
more »
« less
This content will become publicly available on April 1, 2027
Fire lines adjacent to aspen are unlikely to hold during extreme burning conditions in southern Rocky Mountain forests
Abstract Increases in area of extent, severity, and frequency of wildfires across the western United States are presenting challenges to socio‐ecological systems, including shifts to alternative ecological states, loss of homes, and compromising human health. Wildfire suppression operations, such as constructing hand lines to limit the spread of fire, are an important part of wildland fire management, particularly in the wildland urban interface. Like other attributes of wildland fire activity and effects, suppression strategies and their effectiveness vary with ecological, topographic, climatological, and sociopolitical factors. However, there has been little research that examines the efficacy of suppression operations, specifically as they relate to forest composition. Here, we ask about the effectiveness of fire line construction based on adjacent stand composition. Specifically, we ask: (1) Are wildfire suppression lines preferentially constructed in stands with specific tree species? (2) How does species identity influence the probability that suppression lines hold when also considering differences in topography, climate, and extreme fire weather? We anticipated that suppression operations will be biased towards—and more effective in—stands with quaking aspen because they are often associated with less extreme fire behavior than many conifer species. We conducted our study in the southern Rocky Mountain ecoregion using fires (n = 36) that burned during 2019–2023 and included records of fire suppression operations (n = 4295). We used nonparametric statistical models to elucidate biases in the construction of fire lines and the effects of stand composition. We found quaking aspen was the least common tree species to be within fire footprints, yet fire lines were placed near quaking aspen 1.68–5.30 times more than commonly co‐occurring tree species. Fire growth, independent of stand composition, was the most important predictor for whether fire suppression lines were likely to hold but the percentage of fire lines that held differed between fires >40,500 ha and smaller events (65% vs. 82%, respectively). This research suggests that wildland firefighters preferentially located fire lines near aspen stands, perhaps due to the long‐held notion that aspen stands are less flammable. However, during extreme burning conditions fire lines are unlikely to hold regardless of stand composition.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2153040
- PAR ID:
- 10696294
- Publisher / Repository:
- Wiley
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Ecological Applications
- Volume:
- 36
- Issue:
- 3
- ISSN:
- 1051-0761
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Abstract Climate change has increased the frequency and severity of drought and large wildfire events across western North America. Despite the increasing concurrence of drought and wildfire events and the importance of forests as a global carbon sink, the impacts of fire on tree drought and carbon acquisition traits are not well understood, particularly on multi‐year time‐scales.In 2022–2024, we leveraged a natural experiment at a large 2018 wildfire in southwestern Colorado, comparing leaf and xylem functional traits related to drought resistance and carbon acquisition in burned and unburned ponderosa pine, quaking aspen, subalpine fir, and Engelmann spruce trees.Relative to unburned trees of the same species, we found reduced xylem vulnerability to embolism (P50) in burned ponderosa pine and subalpine fir; decreased leaf heat tolerance (T50) in burned quaking aspen and ponderosa pine; and increased investment in leaf structural over photosynthetic components (leaf C:N isotopic ratio) in burned quaking aspen, subalpine fir, and Engelmann spruce.In contrast to previous studies, our results suggest that wildfire positively impacts functional traits related to drought resistance and water movement in surviving burned trees. However, generally negative impacts of wildfire were found with respect to leaf physiological and photosynthetic traits, suggesting divergent water and carbon responses to fire. Read the freePlain Language Summaryfor this article on the Journal blog.more » « less
-
Spectral indices are widely used to assess vegetation fire severity following wildland fires. Although essential, ground-based assessments of how such indices change due to varying fire intensities remain limited, especially with deciduous tree species that exhibit resprouting. In this paper, we evaluate the efficacy of detecting post-fire physiological change and top kill in quaking aspen (Populus tremuloides) saplings using differenced spectral indices. Saplings (n = 64) were burned under controlled conditions over a range of discrete fire intensity levels from 0 to 4.0 MJ m−2, and reflectance was collected pre-fire and at six post-fire intervals up to 16 weeks. Ten spectral indices (CCI, CSI, MIRBI, NDVIL8, NBR, NBRL8, PRI, SAVI, SW-NIRratio, and SW-SWratio) were calculated, differenced from pre-fire, and related to the change in net photosynthesis and top kill. Fire intensity most strongly influenced the observed spectral changes at weeks 1–2 post-fire, especially for ΔCSI, ΔCCI, and ΔPRI. Pre- to post-fire change in net photosynthesis was strongly related (Tjur’s R2 > 0.5) with ΔCCI, ΔCSI, ΔNBRL8, and the ΔSW–NIR ratio at one week post-fire. Of the spectral indices assessed, ΔCCI and ΔPRI were most effective at predicting top kill. This study illustrates the potential of spectral indices for monitoring vegetation fire severity in deciduous tree species.more » « less
-
Abstract Climate change driven extreme droughts have major impacts on forest ecosystems, including large‐scale mortality and reduced primary production, which feedback to affect the global carbon cycle. The long‐term impacts of extreme drought events on forest mortality, ecosystem responses, and recovery/post‐drought trajectories are poorly understood. In this study, we combine annual tree ring widths of five major species occurring in the southwestern United States and data obtained from long‐term forest inventory and monitoring plots to study the effect of an extreme drought event in 2002 on subsequent tree growth. We quantified the extent to which trees that survived the drought had increased growth due to potential increases in resources from reduced stand density or reduced growth due to lingering impacts of drought stress. We found diverse patterns of post‐drought growth trajectories across species, with drastic increases in growth in some species such as trembling aspen (Populus tremuloides) and clear growth suppression in other species such as ponderosa pine (Pinus ponderosa), reflecting notable drought legacy effects. Total basal area was the best predictor of post‐drought growth responses, though the regression effect (positive or negative) varied by species; for example, ponderosa pine showed less growth than predicted in higher density stands while spruce had greater growth than expected in the higher density stands. Climatic water deficit and stand age also emerged as important drivers of post‐drought growth trajectories for multiple species. The results of this study can help to elucidate how different forest types in the southwestern United States will respond to future drought events and the ramifications for carbon cycling in this region.more » « less
-
Abstract With climate warming and drying, fire activity is increasing in Cajander larch (Larix cajanderiMayr.) forests underlain by continuous permafrost in northeastern Siberia, and initial post-fire tree demographic processes could unfold to determine long-term forest carbon (C) dynamics through impacts on tree density. Here, we evaluated above- and belowground C pools across 25 even-aged larch stands of varying tree densities that established following a wildfire in ~ 1940 near Cherskiy, Russia. Total C pools increased with increased larch tree density, from ~ 9,000 g C m−2in low-density stands to ~ 11,000 g C m−2in high and very high-density stands, with increases most pronounced at tree densities < 1 stem m−2and driven by increased above- and belowground (that is, coarse roots) and live and dead (that is, woody debris and snags) larch biomass. Total understory vegetation and non-larch coarse root C pools declined with increased tree density due to decreased shrub C pools, but these pools were relatively small compared to larch biomass. Fine root, soil organic matter (OM), and near surface (0–30 cm) mineral soil (MS) C pools varied little with tree density, although soil C pools held most (18–28% in OM and 44–51% in MS) C stored in these stands. Thus, if changing fire regimes promote denser stands, C storage will likely increase, but whether this increase offsets C lost during fires remains unknown. Our findings highlight how post-fire tree demographic processes impact C pool distribution and stability in larch forests of Siberian permafrost regions.more » « less
