IntroductionOpen educational resources (OERs) provide instructors access to no-cost lesson materials they can incorporate into their courses. OER lessons can promote the use of innovative and evidence-based educational practices in biology education. Prior research suggests that teaching strategies are often implemented in different ways which can impact student learning. However, few studies have explored how OER lessons are modified to fit their local context. MethodsWe used the teacher-curriculum framework to understand how and why instructors modify these materials. Additionally, we explored how these materials supported instructors in enacting national priorities from Vision and Change. We surveyed 139 instructors who implemented lessons published inCourseSource, a peer-reviewed journal specifically designed to share OERs. ResultsWe found that the majority of instructors who used the lesson materials (e.g., slides, worksheets, assessments, protocols) did so without making substantial modifications, in contrast with prior research. Furthermore, we found that these materials were particularly helpful in incorporating student-centered teaching practices, like group work or discussions, sometimes for the first time. DiscussionThese insights into what instructors value in lesson materials can inform OER publishing guidelines so that these materials best meet instructional needs.
more »
« less
This content will become publicly available on May 29, 2027
Assessment, feedback, and grading practices and philosophies of introductory biology instructors
ABSTRACT While pedagogical research often focuses on assessment, feedback, and grading (AFG) practices, we lack a clear understanding of how instructors both conceptualize and implement these elements of teaching in their courses. To explore on-the-ground interpretations of AFG in college courses, we conducted one-on-one Zoom interviews with 27 undergraduate introductory biology instructors at 2- and 4-year institutions in the United States. Participants were asked to describe the purpose of AFG and to share examples of their AFG practices. Using a dialogic, reflexive coding process, we found that instructors’ goals for AFG were multidimensional and sometimes contradictory. For instance, some viewed grading as a motivational tool, while others saw it as discouraging motivation. Additionally, the boundaries between assessment, feedback, and grading were often blurred: grading was sometimes described as feedback, and vice versa. In some cases, instructors’ AFG philosophies were not clearly translated into AFG practices. These findings underscore the need to better distinguish and articulate the roles of AFG in undergraduate biology instruction (and beyond). Clarifying these concepts can enhance communication between instructors, students, and pedagogical researchers, which could help lead to supporting more effective learning strategies.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2417992
- PAR ID:
- 10701146
- Editor(s):
- Wang, Jack
- Publisher / Repository:
- ASM journals
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Journal of Microbiology & Biology Education
- ISSN:
- 1935-7877
- Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Scientific investigation is a core competency in undergraduate chemistry programs, yet instructors often do not explicitly assess students’ engagement with the full range of investigative practices in laboratory courses. Students are more likely to develop these skills when there are opportunities to engage with these practices and when assessments provide constructive feedback for improvement. Rubrics assessing investigative practices can help achieve this by creating a shared understanding of the practices between instructors and students. It also enables instructors to reflect on their teaching and make necessary changes to increase alignment between instruction and learning objectives. Here, we present rubrics designed to assess multiple dimensions of scientific investigation, such as generating investigable questions, planning and carrying out investigations, and applying mathematical and computational thinking, within undergraduate chemistry laboratories. Instructors and graduate teaching assistants who used these rubrics in their laboratory courses reported that they were useful for assessing student performance and generally viewed the resulting scores as reflective of students’ proficiency with the targeted science practices. These rubrics offer a resource for instructors to better align assessment with learning objectives and to intentionally design laboratory experiences that foster comprehensive engagement with scientific investigation.more » « less
-
IntroductionAdvances in our understanding of the immune system have contributed to important progress in the medical field, however gaps in immunology education and training persist. MethodsWe surveyed 76 immunology instructors housed in a range of institutions in the United States regarding challenges they face, as well as the solutions they employ using an adapted form of the K-12 conceptual framework of teaching challenges for higher education. Using a mixed method approach, we categorized challenges as extrinsic (outside or under instructor control) or as intrinsic (student cognitive factors). ResultsWe found that immunology instructors faced challenges that, when compounded or lacking in support, became barriers. We found that immunology was taught in varied formats and contexts, primarily to undergraduate biology majors, with class sizes ranging from under 50 to over 200 students. Interestingly, we found that a large number of instructors did not report having formal training in immunology, highlighting a critical need for professional development in the field. Patterns also emerged suggesting that instructors at smaller institutions encounter additional constraints. Despite these challenges, educators demonstrate creativity and resilience in adapting their teaching practices, which we share. Still, many noted that administrative support could further ease these barriers and assist with instructor retention. We also found that programs and courses have yet to integrate immunology curricula as a result of these challenges. DiscussionThis study provides valuable insights for immunology education researchers and offers practical recommendations for instructors and administrators. It also highlights the potential to adapt existing resources from other biology subdisciplines to better support immunology educators—whether they are seasoned experts or new to the field. As the AAASVision and Changereport emphasizes, evidence-based teaching practices are essential for the future of biology education, and immunology education is only beginning to develop its pedagogical foundation.more » « less
-
Synopsis Advanced biology courses, particularly terminology-heavy organismal biology courses, pose unique challenges, which were further compounded by the Covid-19 pandemic. While attending to instructional strategies is one evident way to address these challenges, grading schemes can also be modified or completely restructured to accomplish this goal. What if the grading expectations could be aligned to how students learn in a way that supports their agency and empowers them? What if our grading schemes facilitate learning in students and provide opportunities for students to further study the material, even after they performed poorly in those areas? This paper unpacks the perspectives, course procedures, and thinking in two advanced biology courses that led the instructor to move away from traditional grading procedures and to adopt a more open grading schematic that facilitated student change and learning. The resulting grading model aligns with applied cognitive theories on knowledge acquisition and would be of interest to instructors interested in focusing on student learning progression and student improvement and retention in biology and other STEM subjects.more » « less
-
Quantitative reasoning (QR) is the ability to apply mathematics and statistics in the context of real-life situations and scientific problems. It is an important skill that students require to make sense of complex biological phenomena and handle large datasets in biology courses and research as well as in professional contexts. Biology educators and researchers are responding to the increasing need for QR through curricular reforms and research into biology education. This qualitative study investigates how undergraduate biology instructors implement QR into their teaching. The study used pedagogical content knowledge (PCK) and a QR framework to explore instructors’ instructional goals, strategies, and perceived challenges and affordances in undergraduate biology instruction. The participants included 21 biology faculty across various institutions in the United States, who intentionally integrated QR in their instruction. Semi-structured interviews were used to collect data focusing on participants’ beliefs, experiences, and classroom practices. Findings indicated that instructors adapt their QR instruction based on course level and student preparedness. In lower-division courses, strategies emphasized building foundational skills, reducing math anxiety, and using scaffolded instruction to promote confidence. In upper-division courses, instructors expected greater math fluency but still encountered a wide range of student abilities, prompting a focus on correcting misconceptions in integrating math knowledge and fostering deeper conceptual understanding in biology. Many instructors reported that their personal and educational experiences, especially struggles with math, often shaped their inclusive and empathetic teaching practices. Additionally, instructors’ research backgrounds influenced instructional design, particularly in the use of authentic data, statistical tools, and real-world applications. Instructors’ teaching experiences led to refinement in lesson planning, pacing, and active learning strategies. Despite their efforts, instructors faced both internal and external challenges in implementing QR, including discomfort with teaching math, time limitations, student resistance, and institutional barriers. However, affordances such as departmental support, interdisciplinary collaboration, and curricular flexibility helped to overcome some of these challenges. This study highlights the complex relationships between instructors’ experiences, beliefs, and contextual factors in shaping QR instruction. This calls for professional development that supports reflective practice, builds interdisciplinary competence, and promotes instructional strategies that bridge biology and mathematics and will help instructors design a learning environment that better support students’ development of QR skills. These findings offer valuable guidance for professional development aimed at helping biology instructors incorporate quantitative reasoning into their teaching. Such efforts can better equip students to meet the quantitative demands of modern biology and promote their continued engagement in STEM fields through more inclusive and integrated instructional approaches.more » « less
An official website of the United States government
