Sustainable Open Source Software (OSS) forms much of the fabric of our digital society, especially successful and sustainable ones. But many OSS projects do not become sustainable, resulting in abandonment and even risks for the world's digital infrastructure. Prior work has looked at the reasons for this mainly from two very different perspectives. In software engineering, the focus has been on understanding success and sustainability from the socio-technical perspective: the OSS programmers' day-to-day activities and the artifacts they create. In institutional analysis, on the other hand, emphasis has been on institutional designs (e.g., policies, rules, and norms) that structure project governance. Even though each is necessary for a comprehensive understanding of OSS projects, the connection and interaction between the two approaches have been barely explored. In this paper, we make the first effort toward understanding OSS project sustainability using a dual-view analysis, by combining institutional analysis with socio-technical systems analysis. In particular, we (i) use linguistic approaches to extract institutional rules and norms from OSS contributors' communications to represent the evolution of their governance systems, and (ii) construct socio-technical networks based on longitudinal collaboration records to represent each project's organizational structure. We combined the two methods and applied them to a dataset of developer digital traces from 253 nascent OSS projects within the Apache Software Foundation (ASF) incubator. We find that the socio-technical and institutional features relate to each other, and provide complimentary views into the progress of the ASF's OSS projects. Refining these combined analyses can help provide a more precise understanding of the synchronization between the evolution of institutional governance and organizational structure.
more »
« less
This content will become publicly available on August 1, 2027
Diagnosing Institutional Design‐Implementation Gaps: A Dual‐Layer Systems Modeling Language Protocol for Visualizing Institutional Change Mechanisms
ABSTRACT This study introduces a dual‐layer protocol for diagnosing how formal institutional designs are implemented in practice in complex governance systems. The protocol builds two linked process maps; one for the formal rules and procedures (rules‐in‐form) and one for the routines actors actually follow in practice (rules‐in‐use). We adapt Systems Modeling Language (SysML), a graphical notation from systems engineering for specifying and analyzing complex socio‐technical systems, to represent both formal workflows and observed rules‐in‐use, and then overlay the two maps to identify divergence nodes where practice bypasses, supplements, or otherwise alters formally prescribed processes. Using Chesapeake Bay watershed governance as an illustrative case, the method shows how drift, layering, conversion, and displacement become visible through recurring divergences in data submission, model review, and approval routines, including socio‐technical artifacts such as data schemas, model parameters, and verification procedures. By producing transparent, empirically checkable visualizations linked to qualitative and documentary evidence, the protocol supports comparative institutional diagnostics and more targeted inquiry into where formal–informal gaps emerge and how they operate in collaborative governance. The study contributes to institutional analysis and policy process research by making visible the mechanisms through which gradual institutional change unfolds in collaborative governance and by offering a replicable way to represent implementation architecture and make socio‐technical dependencies more readily inspectable through an open systems‐engineering notation.
more »
« less
- PAR ID:
- 10708702
- Publisher / Repository:
- Wiley Periodicals LLC
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Policy Studies Journal
- Volume:
- 54
- Issue:
- 3
- ISSN:
- 0190-292X
- Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Open source software (OSS) now underpins critical digital infrastructure, yet many projects struggle to sustain the volunteer effort, technical maintenance, and governance work required to persist over time. This paper develops a Socio-Technical-Governance (STG) framework to explain OSS sustainability as a digital commons problem in which social dynamics, technical production, and rule-based governance jointly shape outcomes. Building on socio-technical systems scholarship in Software Engineering and Ostrom’s Institutional Analysis and Development (IAD) tradition in the social sciences, the framework conceptualizes OSS communities as nested action situations governed by working rules that allocate decision authority, distribute costs and benefits, and structure participation. We illustrate the framework’s utility through an integrative synthesis of previously published evidence from the Apache Software Foundation (ASF) Incubator, leveraging an ecosystem of digital trace data (e.g., version control, issue tracking, and mailing-list discussions) and five previously published studies of the ASF Incubator: a shared longitudinal dataset covering 269 incubator projects, and four empirical analyses that draw overlapping subsets from it. Across technical, social, and governance dimensions, the four source studies report (1) early and sustained growth in technical activity as a distinguishing feature of projects that graduate, alongside code-quality signals associated with retirement; (2) mentorship configuration as a meaningful social correlate of outcomes; (3) governance patterns consistent with cost–benefit balancing at the program level in ASF’s Incubator context; and (4) measurable differences in institutional discourse and sociotechnical network trajectories that emerge months before final outcomes. The STG Framework offers a theory-grounded approach for comparing governance arrangements across OSS contexts and for developing candidate indicators to support earlier diagnosis and intervention in at-risk projects.more » « less
-
Building a successful community means governing active populations and limited resources. This challenge often requires communities to design formal governance systems from scratch. But the characteristics of successful institutional designs are unclear. Communities that are more mature and established may have more elaborate formal policy systems. Alternatively, they may require less formalization precisely because of their maturity. Indeed, scholars often downplay the role that formal rules relative to unwritten rules, norms, and values. But in a community with formal rules, decisions are more consistent, transparent, and legitimate. To understand the relationship of formal institutions to community maturity and governance style, we conduct a large-scale quantitative analysis applying institutional analysis frameworks of self-governance scholar Elinor Ostrom to 80,000 communities across 3 platforms: the sandbox game Minecraft, the MMO game World of Warcraft, and Reddit. We classify communities' written rules to test predictors of institutional formalization. From this analysis we extract two major findings. First, institutional formalization, the size and complexity of an online community's governance system, is generally positively associated with maturity, as measured by age, population size, or degree of user engagement. Second, we find that online communities employ similar governance styles across platforms, strongly favoring "weak" norms to "strong" requirements. These findings suggest that designers and founders of online communities converge on styles of governance practice that are correlated with successful self-governance. With deeper insights into the patterns of successful self-governance, we can help more communities overcome the challenges of self-governance and create for their members powerful experiences of shared meaning and collective empowerment.more » « less
-
Building a successful community means governing active populations and limited resources. This challenge often requires communities to design formal governance systems from scratch. But the characteristics of successful institutional designs are unclear. Communities that are more mature and established may have more elaborate formal policy systems (as cause or effect of their success). Alternatively, they may require less formalization precisely because of their maturity: because they have more latitude and capacity to select and acculturate new members, or because their reputations encourage greater self-selection. Indeed, scholars often downplay the role that formal rules relative to unwritten rules, norms, and values. But in a community with formal rules, decisions are more consistent, transparent, and legitimate. To understand the relationship of formal institutions to community maturity and governance style, we conduct a large-scale quantitative analysis applying institutional analysis frameworks of self-governance scholar Elinor Ostrom to 80,000 communities across 3 platforms: the sandbox game Minecraft, the MMO game World of Warcraft, and Reddit. We classify communities' written rules according to several institutional taxonomies in order to test predictors of institutional formalization. From this analysis we extract two major findings. First, institutional formalization, the size and complexity of an online community's governance system, is generally positively associated with maturity, as measured by age, population size, or degree of user engagement. Second, we find that online communities employ similar governance styles across platforms, strongly favoring weak norms to strong requirements. These findings suggest that designers and founders of online communities converge, to some extent independently, on styles of governance practice that are correlated with successful self-governance. With deeper insights into the patterns of successful self-governance, we can help more communities overcome the challenges of self-governance and create for their members powerful experiences of shared meaning and collective empowerment.?more » « less
-
This paper addresses a gap in the AI governance literature in understanding collaboration between national governments and tribal nations in governing AI systems for emergency management. This conceptual work develops and presents a governance design framework for accountable AI systems to fill the knowledge gap by drawing from the fields of public administration, information systems, indigenous studies, and emergency management. This framework situates the governance framework in a cross-sovereignty historical, legal, and policy contexts. It captures the multi-level features and embeddedness of governance structures, including the levels of collaborative governance structure, software system governance rules, and technical software system design. The focal governance dynamics involve the collaborative process in the bi-directional relationship between governance rules and technical design for accountability and the feedback loop. The framework highlights the importance of multi-level and process considerations in designing accountable AI systems. Productive future research avenues include empirical investigation and resulting refinement of the framework and analytical rigor employing institutional grammar.more » « less
An official website of the United States government
